'India formidable, but not invincible yet'

Aakash Chopra and Russel Arnold join Raunak Kapoor to discuss India's victory in the recently concluded try-nation series in the West Indies

Producer: Suketu Mehta

July 12, 2013

Posted by Naresh28 on (July 19, 2013, 10:57 GMT)

@nampally - agree with you on the bowling. Sandeep sharma is a player that needs to be tested out at a higher level. He did so well at U19 and even in domestic games. Mohit is good because he holds the ball close to his neck when delivering and although it looks strange it has worked for him. Pujara will blossom for India once given a chance at ODI (there is no doubt) Rayudu and Rahane are other options and have been given a chance on Zim/SA tours.

Posted by   on (July 16, 2013, 9:33 GMT)

I don't know why Ishant Sharma keeps long hair like a woman's in the terrible heat and also it blocks his vision while bowling. If I were a selecto or a captain, I wouldn't select him unless he cuts his hair. Dhoni has never been a good captain and it is due to the credit of other cricketers that India won and has been winning despite his poor captaincy.

Posted by Ranchi_Lad on (July 15, 2013, 13:09 GMT)

People tend to forget that Sanga was dropped on 22 and Thirimanne on 2, India should have been chasing 108 and not 201...one was obviously by the worst fielder in the Indian side, Ashwin. But the other was by Raina. Had he taken the chance, and that too of the Great Sanga, off his own bowling, Dhoni's decision to bowl him would become a masterstroke!

Posted by Nampally on (July 15, 2013, 12:50 GMT)

Indian team is good but it still is missing some really good players who are available but not included. To start with Ishant Sharma & Yadev need to be told to improve their length & direction or replaced with alternate talent. Playing these 2 expensive bowlers is hurting India in ODI's. Alternate seamers are Mohit Sharma, Sandeep Sharma, Kaul & P.Kumar. They are all economical but @ 130 KPH zone not in 140 KPH. A quick leg spinner like Karan Sharma& Rasool are other valuable spinners. In batting Pujara has been by passed repeatedly under the excuse of him being a Test batsmen & not suited to ODI's. His ODI record proves otherwise. A S/R of 60 is good average for ODI's & Pujara is in that range while he scored his double century or a Test century. India needs a sheet anchor in batting with correct technique in the weak middle order. Pujara answers that need totally. Samson, Zol & Chand are other young batting talent. Luckily in the SA & Zimbabwe squads these guys finally get a break.

Posted by kumarcoolbuddy on (July 15, 2013, 6:18 GMT)

@mark2011, I still don't understand that if 240 would have given match to SL then why was SL all out for 201? Even Angelo Mathews in Post Match ceremony said that "If we had batted for 50 overs we would have scored 240-250 and that would have been enough to win".

Posted by premendrasinghal on (July 13, 2013, 14:21 GMT)

During the match when Sri Lanka were two down and feeling pressure and Dhoni let the pressure released by giving ball to Kohli and Raina I was also having the same feeling as Akash Chopra had, that Dhoni did a mistake here. But later i realize that he wanted more options in death overs after all it a 50 over game. I know some would say Dhoni was lucky. My answer is Luck plays an important role in Cricket as the game stats with a TOSS its a matter of luck, no one can deny that. Every captain has different plans and strategies and I found Dhoni is different from all others. I dont think he is successful just by luck. Credit must be given to him and the team. We must understand that most of the pundits dont have any experience but they say anything about anybody.

Posted by mark2011 on (July 13, 2013, 13:18 GMT)

too much boasting...its only 2 bowls remained in the end.. so there's nothing much great of Indi winning this, its pure poor batting by SL players.. 240 wud hav easily given tha matvh to SL.. but still it was there, but luck of MSD favoured as its been for some time now...

Posted by vsssarma on (July 13, 2013, 12:39 GMT)

There is a need for India to strengthen its ODI bowling. Ishant Sharma, Umesh Yadav, Vinay Kumar are getting more chances than they deserve and this is bringing down India's bowling strength. The best ODI bowling team of India would be: Rahul Sharma; B Kumar; Ashwin; Jadeja; IK Pathan. Reserves should be Zaheer Khan and Praveen Kumar.

Batting should be from: Dhawan, Kohli, Tiwary, Dhoni, Gambhir and Raina. RG Sharma and Yuvraj Singh should be in the reserves.

Posted by ramli on (July 13, 2013, 7:56 GMT)

Aarkay Chandru ... very uncharitable comment on Ashwin ... man he was the one who bailed India out of Aus test series not so in distant past ... he was the one who bowled well to restore both control and wickets in CT final ... he is such a good bowler that batsmen worldwide want to see him off by taking very minimal risks ... just because Herath bowled well in this match does not make Ashwin a lesser bowler ...

Posted by Naresh28 on (July 13, 2013, 7:53 GMT)

India needs to find a good left armer for Khans spot or could he make a comeback!!! To be a complete team. Karthik shopuld be replaced by Rayudu or Pujara.

Posted by   on (July 13, 2013, 6:51 GMT)

You comment is baseless.If you remember all the matches have been low scoring and Indian team has done well without MSD. Look how Rohit has matured.He is now fighting every ball for his wicket instead of throwing it away.Kohli contribution as a captain is almost forgotten he fought to give India a Chance in the final.

Dhawan played good in patches but was unlucky a few times to get out.

India have done very well in CT .They hardly required the services of MSD. Karthik and Raina have flopped for a while but i feel India are still formidable.Time to give chance to Rayudu or bring back yuvraj

Bowling the less the better.Ishant Sharma need to be dropped.He can hardly produce that seam movement ,Its time to give chance to youngsters like Mohit Sharma.

The pitches were erratic and definetly not international standard. You could say which ball you are going to get out.

Posted by   on (July 13, 2013, 5:33 GMT)

With the comfort of having won the tri-series, let us not forget some serious issues with the team. No doubt, MSD is the best finisher on earth and has bailed out the team on numerous occasions. What the other top and middle order batsmen are doing in the team? Why is it left to poor MSD time and again to earn the team a win out of hopeless situations? Why can't the any of the top or middle order batsmen hold one end and play a longer innings? Why are they content making some 30, 40 runs which is enough to safeguard their career? Instead of showering praises on their captain, let them play their role to perfection first!

Having chosen cricket as a career, isn't it wise for Ashwin to workout on his fitness? He needs to shed at least a 10 kgs now or quit from the game and choose a career in engineering. Again, on that day he hasn't bowled even 1/10th of how Herath bowled and yet, what stature he's bestowed upon! Does he deserve it? Is he a strike bowler for us really taking 1 Wkt/match?

Posted by rajhe1 on (July 13, 2013, 3:57 GMT)

Can we please please get back the original huddlers like Nitin back ?

Comments have now been closed for this article


Play Video
Captivated by Cage Cricket

Aug 2, 2014 A hybrid version of the game takes place in the background at Ageas Bowl, inside a cage, with its unique rules and scoring zones. The twist - if a batsman's out, he's 'not out' (05:34)

Play Video
'We were determined to prove we were not an average team'

Aug 1, 2014 Former South Africa keeper Dave Richardson remembers the favourite moment from the win at Lord's in 1994: the Wessels-Kirsten partnership, Atherton being caught with dirt in his pocket, and celebrating late into the night (03:40)


Play Audio
'Women's team missing exposure'

News and Analysis: Former India women captain Anjum Chopra talks to Gaurav Kalra about the BCCI's decision to not field Indian teams in the cricket event at the Asian Games (04:19) | Aug 1, 2014

Play Video
'Anderson must question his behaviour'

News and Analysis: David Hopps on the not-guilty verdict for James Anderson and Ravindra Jadeja, and the need for ICC to re-assess acceptable standards of on-field behaviour (04:18) | Aug 1, 2014

Play Video
Moores defends Anderson's 'hard' brand of cricket

Press Conference: England coach Peter Moores says that people enjoying playing with, and against James Anderson because he gives his all (00:30) | Aug 1, 2014