Somerset v Nottinghamshire, Taunton, 1st day

Rose resigned to Lions losses

Alex Winter at Taunton

August 7, 2012

Comments: 6 | Text size: A | A

Nottinghamshire 18 for 1 v Somerset
Scorecard


Nick Compton drives during his innings of 46, England Lions v Australia A, 1st unofficial Test, Old Trafford, 1st day, August 7, 2012
The man who wasn't there: Nick Compton in action for England Lions, rather than Somerset © Getty Images
Enlarge

The County Championship has been marginalised by many things this summer, not least the weather, with the "reserve Ashes" between England Lions and Australia A at Old Trafford the latest event to take the limelight away from the competition just as it moves towards the business end.

Two of the best sides in England are at Taunton in a crucial match that could have significant impact on the title. But country before club has long been the emphasis in English cricket and clearly the ECB sees more value in the second-best players in the land playing an unofficial Test than helping their counties try to win the Championship.

Somerset are most disadvantaged. Nick Compton has made 1,036 Championship runs at 86.33 this season - outperforming by a distance every other player - and helped Somerset maintain their push for a first title. But with such a historic milestone within reach, England have put their needs above Somerset's.

"We're where we are in the table mainly because Nick Compton has played so well in adverse conditions," Brian Rose, Somerset's director of cricket, told ESPNcricinfo. "It's frustrating to get towards the end of the season and have a clash of fixtures. It's coming to a crucial time in the Championship, we're just a win behind the two leaders and if we have a good game here it will set up an exciting time for the club.

"But I'm a great supporter of England Lions games because it's a precursor to Test cricket. Nick deserves to play and all credit to him, he's played tremendously well. Don't forget you put so much into development you want players to play for England, that's part of our job to get players into the England team so there's no way Somerset or Nottinghamshire are going to be complaining about that."

So perhaps the counties are now more inclined to measure success by their contribution to the England team than to their trophy cabinets? Maybe that can be understood given the level of financial support now offered by the ECB to promote young players in the county game. But an entire west country XI for England could not usurp a first Championship title for Somerset.

Victory for them here would see Somerset join Warwickshire, Nottinghamshire and Sussex on four wins but Rose was philosophical about the impact of losing players to the Lions. "At the end of the day, the sides that are going to win the Championship are going to be good enough to stay at the top," he said. "The weather has been the biggest factor this year, which has compressed the competition, but I think at the end of the day the best team should still win it."

Weather certainly owned day one. All credit was due to the umpires for refusing to call off play with showers falling in the early afternoon. The weather cleared long enough for Somerset to win the toss and ask Notts to bat at 4.40pm. But eight overs in and the heavens gathered again. One more ball was possible and Peter Trego found the outside edge of Riki Wessels' bat. It was entirely expected on a very green wicket that offered plenty to Trego and Steve Kirby.

So far in this match, it hasn't particularly mattered who is playing. "Swings and roundabouts" was Rose's summing up of the situation. Notts are without Samit Patel - 329 runs and 14 wickets in nine matches this season - and would have been without James Taylor too had he not earned a last-minute call-up for the second Test at Headingley. Somerset are also missing wicketkeeper Craig Kieswetter. Jos Buttler is behind the stumps in this match.

"I've mentioned to the ECB that these fixtures don't clash so players can play at both ends," Rose said, who was keen on the idea of a window for Lions' games if space could be found. "The best thing if you're coming towards the end of the Championship would be to have the fixture list represented in a slightly better fashion. But it all depends on future tours and how the Championship and T20s are composed as well. The authorities are looking at it."

Alex Winter is an editorial assistant at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Alex Winter

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by JG2704 on (August 8, 2012, 19:32 GMT)

@HipposRule /Neil Dyer - Guys , I was trying to come across as balanced and not a biased Somerset fan but sod it. We have had loss of players through various reasons throughout the season but the weather has really hampered our chances of winning the title. We were well on top of Notts in the 1st fixture and have them 48-3 in this one but have somehow lost best part of 2 days cricket. I like in Devon (next county down) and it's been dry all day and another commenter on the Lancs match said there was 5 mins of rain in Liverpool on the day which was all but truncated by the rain. Ba Humbug

Posted by   on (August 8, 2012, 12:02 GMT)

England first and the Counties second and this is the way it should be.

Posted by   on (August 8, 2012, 11:18 GMT)

@JG2704 Notts don't pay wages for Broad and Swann, nor Warks for Bell and Trott (central contracts), so it's not quite the same issue.

Posted by HipposRule on (August 8, 2012, 8:32 GMT)

@JG2704 - remember we're also without both Overtons and Dockrell in Australia for the U19s.

Posted by zenboomerang on (August 8, 2012, 3:17 GMT)

@Alex Winter... One of the oddest articles I have ever read - most cricketers want to play for their country first & foremost, as does the ECB want to develop them... The whole reason of having a FC comp is for players to get experience & those performing well these days get to play "A" matches before getting their "caps"... Going by Winter's logic the IPL should take precedence over other countries seasons or perhaps for Englands next tour down under they shouldn't get the 4 warm up matches against Oz State & Aust A squads like last time... Sounds too "closed shop" for my liking...

Posted by JG2704 on (August 7, 2012, 20:00 GMT)

Personally I wouldn't moan about the loss of Craig and Nick. Notts have been without Broad and Swann practically all season as have Warwicks with Bell and Trott. What does annoy me is that Somerset have had so many rain interupted games when we've been on top (inc the 1st match vs Notts) and have only lost 1 match by 2 wickets to Warwicks who we beat last week and we're 3rd. I do think that the CC table does not always reflect who the best side is. Sometimes it's the side who has best weather as losing a game - unless it is to a championship rival or relegation rival - does not lose you so much ground but drawing games because of weather does. As it happens I think Warwicks have played the best cricket this year and deserve to be top

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Alex WinterClose
County Results
Hampshire v Warwickshire at Lord's - Sep 15, 2012
Hampshire won (lost fewer wickets)
Derbyshire v Hampshire at Derby - Sep 11-14, 2012
Derbyshire won by 6 wickets
Essex v Yorkshire at Chelmsford - Sep 11-14, 2012
Yorkshire won by 239 runs
Lancashire v Surrey at Liverpool - Sep 11-14, 2012
Match drawn
Leics v Gloucs at Leicester - Sep 11-14, 2012
Leics won by 2 wickets
Notts v Warwickshire at Nottingham - Sep 11-14, 2012
Match drawn
All recent results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days