England Lions v Australia A, Edgbaston, 1st day August 14, 2012

Cowan and Harris share honours in even battle

Paul Edwards at Edgbaston
21

Australia A 308 for 9 (Cowan 73, Paine 59, Hughes 51, Harris 6-102) v England Lions
Scorecard

Two cricketers dominated the evenly-balanced opening day of the second unofficial Test match between England Lions and Australia A at Edgbaston. One of them, Glamorgan's James Harris, has been badly hampered by injury over the last year and is not mentioned too often when the full England side's seam bowling requirements are discussed; yet he proved the timeless value of accuracy to take six wickets, two of them lbw and two bowled, as the Lions attack enjoyed success, but also conceded runs too freely, on a pitch which had been trimmed since it offered the seamers plenty of help in Monday's CB40 game.

The other player to catch the eye was Australia A captain Ed Cowan, who made 73 when the Birmingham wicket was at its liveliest and the England bowlers fresh. Cowan did not seem to be the obvious candidate to open his country's batting early last November until hundreds in four successive matches won him a place in the team for the Boxing Day Test. So if the players have a moment to relax with a beer after this game, maybe Harris can compare notes on the virtues of persistence with a man who is nearly eight years his senior and who has paid his dues to make it.

For the moment, they are on opposite sides in a short series which has been well contested throughout. And no one has fought harder than Cowan, whose 186-ball monument to patience on the opening day of the second match followed his 99 in last week's encounter at Old Trafford. The Australia A captain has worked hard to fashion a successful technique in which every stroke seems carefully calibrated; even favoured shots, like the cover drive, are removed from his repertoire if they carry unacceptable levels of risk.

It was in this manner that Cowan proceeded carefully to his 116-ball fifty, hitting four boundaries and, somewhat incongruously, lifting a bouncer from Harris over fine-leg for six. He seemed set for a century too, until James Tredwell won an lbw decision from Neil Mallender when Cowan attempted a sweep. The batsman had almost to drag himself from the crease and appeared less than enamoured with the decision. He may have had a point.

By the time Cowan was fourth out, the total was 186 and Harris had started his good day's work. That had begun with his twelfth ball of the morning when Liam Davis shouldered arms and was lbw for a 15-ball 24. Four overs later, Michael Klinger was also lbw although on this occasion the batsman was on the front foot, not that it saved him from Tim Robinson's finger.

Cowan and Phillip Hughes saw Australia A through to lunch on 106 for 2, although they did so in contrasting styles: Hughes was adventurous, cover-driving Matt Coles for two fours and clipping Ben Stokes' final ball before the break though midwicket for another boundary; Cowan stuck to the method he knew and it served him well.

Ten overs after the break, Hughes gave Harris his third wicket when he drove all too loosely and was caught by Joe Root at short cover for a 51 which had been filled with fine strokes, yet had exhibited an all too fallible method. The afternoon might have gone even better for the Lions had not Joe Burns been dropped by Samit Patel off Chris Woakes, who was in the middle of a fine nine-over spell which cost just 12 runs.

Either side of Cowan's dismissal, Burns steadied the ship for the tourists, reaching tea on 27 in one of those innings where one looks up at the scoreboard and wonders quite how the batsman has acquired his runs.

The final session of play at Edgbaston was the most attractive of the day. Australia scored 110 runs for the loss of five wickets, three of them to Harris, who bowled Burns for 29 immediately after the resumption when the batsman played across the line. At the other end, the Kent offspinner James Tredwell epitomised the parsimonious spinner and he too got his reward, first when Tom Cooper edged his arm-ball to Kieswetter, and then ten overs later when Mitchell Johnson also snicked a ball to the keeper, though this delivery did turn.

By the end of the day Tredwell's figures were 19-7-35-3 and he has been the Lions best bowler in the series, albeit that he seems fated to be the supporting actor rather than the leading man.

Dominating the stage in the last hour were Tim Paine and, inevitably perhaps, Harris. The Australian wicketkeeper-batsman restored the game to some sort of balance with a well-judged innings of 59 and a sensible eighth-wicket partnership of 51 with Nathan Coulter-Nile, who made 24. Both batsmen fell to Harris, though, Coulter-Nile hitting across the line and Paine caught down the leg side.

These dismissals proved once and for all that it was to be the Welsh seamer's day and he was honest enough to admit in the aftermath of success that other bowlers had deserved success too. Probably he was thinking of Woakes, who had Nathan Lyon dropped by Tredwell at slip in the last significant action of the evening session.

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • R_U_4_REAL_NICK on August 15, 2012, 20:54 GMT

    Shame about the rain... looking forward to Coulter-Nile and Lyon bowling. Relax Jonesy, at least it shows he's still in the running and they're not considering Doherty/Beer as the only hope.

  • thebrotherswaugh on August 15, 2012, 20:21 GMT

    Great to see Cowan & Hughes in the runs, but still no hundred's being scored? I'd be a little concerned if it were anywhere else bar ENG. After all, you have to take into account the level of umpiring in ENG at the moment is on a par with their cricketing talent - very poor indeed. Most of them must have a cyclops or two in their family trees, that's how one-eyed they are! The same applies with our bowlers also, blatant decisions going against them, no doubt. And what wouldn't the Poms give for some of our bowling stocks - best be on the lookout for poachers from the infamous ECB, otherwise known as the Ecb Trading & Import Co. No home-grown talent there, the last quality players ENG itself actually produced were Gower & Botham - a hell of a long time between drinks. Should get a win out of this one, even with the Cyclops squad in charge. Go AUS!!

  • hhillbumper on August 15, 2012, 17:57 GMT

    Who is the top 3 spinner playing for Aus.Not done a south Africa and got a pakistani spinner in your team have you?

  • jonesy2 on August 15, 2012, 12:43 GMT

    cant understand how a top 3 spinner in the world is playing for australia a. great to see paine get some runs on return, what a comeback. cowan dominating as expected, what a man. hard to measure the performances though against an ordinary attack at best

  • RandyOZ on August 15, 2012, 12:38 GMT

    Great to see Paine and Hughes in the runs, as well as Cowan, although for me personally he is still on notice. Amazing depth coming through at the moment with Hughes, Khawaja, Burns, Cooper (who would make any other national side). Great to see England keeping the United XI spirit alive and giving the Kiwi, South African and Welshman a bowl.

  • Wozza-CY on August 15, 2012, 7:00 GMT

    @matty1979- "Cowan is hated by so many Aussies"......really? Too much hate in the world if that is the case. I think us Ozi fans are being a little unrealistic in our expectations of our cricketers at this stage. The chap has only played 7 tests! Ok, an average of under 30 isn't ideal but he has come into a very unsettled side playing some ordinary cricket. I feel as though he has handled the pressure well and deserves further opportunities. Agreed he is limited but as you say, he 'takes the shine off the ball' as all good openers do. It's just that we got used to Matty Hayden who used to belt it off where as Cowan works it.

  • jmcilhinney on August 15, 2012, 6:41 GMT

    @Terry Wise on (August 15 2012, 06:06 AM GMT), he was probably included in the first game because it was his home ground and expected to turn. Not so much need for two specialist spinners at Edgbaston. While this is a 4-day game, I'm guessing that Tredwell is in contention for limited-overs games on the subcontinent.

  • on August 15, 2012, 6:06 GMT

    Where's Kerrigan? Injured?

  • MattyP1979 on August 15, 2012, 2:51 GMT

    Peter. Aus have a difficult year coming, and although you can never remove the Aus spirit, they certainly don't instill fear into the opponents now. Cowan probably wont make you 100's but the first job as an opener is to protect the middle order (and usually better) batsman. He does this very often. I fear the next ashes contest may not be even that. I suppose we will have to wait and see. Aus have some good old players and some youngsters coming through but it seems there is no talent in the middle.

  • Dashgar on August 15, 2012, 2:18 GMT

    Cowan again tops the runs. He's been excellent this tour and I'm looking forward to him really breaking out this summer. Good to see Paine get some runs too. Hopefully he stays fit and puts in a big shield season. I wouldnt be unhappy to see him play as a specialist batsman alongside Wade.

  • R_U_4_REAL_NICK on August 15, 2012, 20:54 GMT

    Shame about the rain... looking forward to Coulter-Nile and Lyon bowling. Relax Jonesy, at least it shows he's still in the running and they're not considering Doherty/Beer as the only hope.

  • thebrotherswaugh on August 15, 2012, 20:21 GMT

    Great to see Cowan & Hughes in the runs, but still no hundred's being scored? I'd be a little concerned if it were anywhere else bar ENG. After all, you have to take into account the level of umpiring in ENG at the moment is on a par with their cricketing talent - very poor indeed. Most of them must have a cyclops or two in their family trees, that's how one-eyed they are! The same applies with our bowlers also, blatant decisions going against them, no doubt. And what wouldn't the Poms give for some of our bowling stocks - best be on the lookout for poachers from the infamous ECB, otherwise known as the Ecb Trading & Import Co. No home-grown talent there, the last quality players ENG itself actually produced were Gower & Botham - a hell of a long time between drinks. Should get a win out of this one, even with the Cyclops squad in charge. Go AUS!!

  • hhillbumper on August 15, 2012, 17:57 GMT

    Who is the top 3 spinner playing for Aus.Not done a south Africa and got a pakistani spinner in your team have you?

  • jonesy2 on August 15, 2012, 12:43 GMT

    cant understand how a top 3 spinner in the world is playing for australia a. great to see paine get some runs on return, what a comeback. cowan dominating as expected, what a man. hard to measure the performances though against an ordinary attack at best

  • RandyOZ on August 15, 2012, 12:38 GMT

    Great to see Paine and Hughes in the runs, as well as Cowan, although for me personally he is still on notice. Amazing depth coming through at the moment with Hughes, Khawaja, Burns, Cooper (who would make any other national side). Great to see England keeping the United XI spirit alive and giving the Kiwi, South African and Welshman a bowl.

  • Wozza-CY on August 15, 2012, 7:00 GMT

    @matty1979- "Cowan is hated by so many Aussies"......really? Too much hate in the world if that is the case. I think us Ozi fans are being a little unrealistic in our expectations of our cricketers at this stage. The chap has only played 7 tests! Ok, an average of under 30 isn't ideal but he has come into a very unsettled side playing some ordinary cricket. I feel as though he has handled the pressure well and deserves further opportunities. Agreed he is limited but as you say, he 'takes the shine off the ball' as all good openers do. It's just that we got used to Matty Hayden who used to belt it off where as Cowan works it.

  • jmcilhinney on August 15, 2012, 6:41 GMT

    @Terry Wise on (August 15 2012, 06:06 AM GMT), he was probably included in the first game because it was his home ground and expected to turn. Not so much need for two specialist spinners at Edgbaston. While this is a 4-day game, I'm guessing that Tredwell is in contention for limited-overs games on the subcontinent.

  • on August 15, 2012, 6:06 GMT

    Where's Kerrigan? Injured?

  • MattyP1979 on August 15, 2012, 2:51 GMT

    Peter. Aus have a difficult year coming, and although you can never remove the Aus spirit, they certainly don't instill fear into the opponents now. Cowan probably wont make you 100's but the first job as an opener is to protect the middle order (and usually better) batsman. He does this very often. I fear the next ashes contest may not be even that. I suppose we will have to wait and see. Aus have some good old players and some youngsters coming through but it seems there is no talent in the middle.

  • Dashgar on August 15, 2012, 2:18 GMT

    Cowan again tops the runs. He's been excellent this tour and I'm looking forward to him really breaking out this summer. Good to see Paine get some runs too. Hopefully he stays fit and puts in a big shield season. I wouldnt be unhappy to see him play as a specialist batsman alongside Wade.

  • tassietiger85 on August 15, 2012, 1:57 GMT

    Great to see Tim Paine back in the game and doing well, if not for injury he would have walked right into the side last summer instead of Wade, no doubt. Wade will be the T20 and ODI keeper over the next few years, but I reckon Paine will be put back into the Test side pretty quickly. I would say he would be the ODI keeper too if we didn't already have a middle order full of very slow scorers...

  • jmcilhinney on August 15, 2012, 1:02 GMT

    @MattyP1979 on (August 14 2012, 19:35 PM GMT), Australian fans seem to have got so used to their openers scoring quickly that they've forgotten what a traditional Test opener's job is. That said, if Cowan had been scoring slowly but making decent scores then I'm sure the public would be a bit more patient but with a relatively low strike rate and average, he hasn't really done much to endear himself. He's done well on this tour but if he can't translate that into runs at the top level then he won't be winning to many more friends any time soon.

  • jmcilhinney on August 15, 2012, 0:58 GMT

    Seems like a rather even day in the end. Aus A looked in a fairly strong position for a while but the Lions came back in that last session. I'm sure they're ruing dropping Lyon as I'm sure that they'd like to start the day batting rather than have to think about going out into the field to take that one more wicket.

  • Meety on August 15, 2012, 0:14 GMT

    @Peterincanada - I hadn't felt that Cowan had made the test opening position his own, with a string of par performances. I think this tour has been great for him, as it pretty much proves that he has the technique/strategy to survive in England, although the BIG innings is eluding him. A string of 100s & 50s in England, means he can pretty well cancel any social plans he had in June next year. I probably would NOT take him to India though. I don't think he is all that good against spinners, (as seen in the WIndies). I don't think playing a test series in India prior to an Ashes series (again), will be great practise for English conditions!

  • Guernica on August 14, 2012, 21:54 GMT

    @Ian Johnson - the immediate concern is a second spinner for the tour of India. Tredwell may not be the future, but he needs looking at for that.

  • Peterincanada on August 14, 2012, 20:36 GMT

    @MattyP1979 - I agree with you that the Aus batting is poor. People have been calling for younger players to replace Punter and Hussey but nobody has raised their hand. I initially did not think much of Cowan against India and WI. He could occupy the crease but seemed to lack strokes. He has come good on this tour which is timely because a solid opener a la Bill Lawry is essential for the Ashes in England to protect the middle order. I was happy to see they brought Hughes in and that he made some runs. Too bad he played loosely after getting to 50. Maybe the middle order is where he belongs. He certainly can score runs if he gets a start which the other "A" batters have failed to do thus far.

  • on August 14, 2012, 20:32 GMT

    Cowan bringing runs again, but you'd feel that the Aussies would be dissappointed in that once again we see a string of fifties with no-one going on. This is the absolute problem with Australian batting right now and I just can't see anything improving. Hopefully Bird and NCN can make some early inroads on day 2.

  • maddinson on August 14, 2012, 20:10 GMT

    It will be great if Ali McDermott got a chance instead of MJ. Cooper missed very good chances to come close of selection. I always like Cowan's style, he looked compact and give some assurance at the top of order and good to see Paine getting some good runs.

  • MattyP1979 on August 14, 2012, 19:35 GMT

    Cowan is hated by so many Aussies but I feel he is a must for the frankly limp batting card. Aus have some difficlut games ahead and I look forward to seeing more of the young players coming through (by young I mean mid 30's). With Hussy/Punter qualifying for their bus pass next year they might need some of the young players to help them off the coach. At least CA can take some some comfort in the fact their cricket team will have a hard time doing worse than their atheletes. Can't wait to see Ind attack vs Aus Batsman, which is worse we will find out.

  • hhillbumper on August 14, 2012, 19:21 GMT

    Harris has been around for ages and always gets results but seems to lack that last bit of pace that would put him into the top tier.i hope he does get picked as he has always been accurate and incisive.

  • on August 14, 2012, 19:16 GMT

    With respect, why Tredwell?? He's hardly the future with Kerigan, Parry, Rafiq, Briggs, Borthwick, Beer, Waller, etc etc

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • on August 14, 2012, 19:16 GMT

    With respect, why Tredwell?? He's hardly the future with Kerigan, Parry, Rafiq, Briggs, Borthwick, Beer, Waller, etc etc

  • hhillbumper on August 14, 2012, 19:21 GMT

    Harris has been around for ages and always gets results but seems to lack that last bit of pace that would put him into the top tier.i hope he does get picked as he has always been accurate and incisive.

  • MattyP1979 on August 14, 2012, 19:35 GMT

    Cowan is hated by so many Aussies but I feel he is a must for the frankly limp batting card. Aus have some difficlut games ahead and I look forward to seeing more of the young players coming through (by young I mean mid 30's). With Hussy/Punter qualifying for their bus pass next year they might need some of the young players to help them off the coach. At least CA can take some some comfort in the fact their cricket team will have a hard time doing worse than their atheletes. Can't wait to see Ind attack vs Aus Batsman, which is worse we will find out.

  • maddinson on August 14, 2012, 20:10 GMT

    It will be great if Ali McDermott got a chance instead of MJ. Cooper missed very good chances to come close of selection. I always like Cowan's style, he looked compact and give some assurance at the top of order and good to see Paine getting some good runs.

  • on August 14, 2012, 20:32 GMT

    Cowan bringing runs again, but you'd feel that the Aussies would be dissappointed in that once again we see a string of fifties with no-one going on. This is the absolute problem with Australian batting right now and I just can't see anything improving. Hopefully Bird and NCN can make some early inroads on day 2.

  • Peterincanada on August 14, 2012, 20:36 GMT

    @MattyP1979 - I agree with you that the Aus batting is poor. People have been calling for younger players to replace Punter and Hussey but nobody has raised their hand. I initially did not think much of Cowan against India and WI. He could occupy the crease but seemed to lack strokes. He has come good on this tour which is timely because a solid opener a la Bill Lawry is essential for the Ashes in England to protect the middle order. I was happy to see they brought Hughes in and that he made some runs. Too bad he played loosely after getting to 50. Maybe the middle order is where he belongs. He certainly can score runs if he gets a start which the other "A" batters have failed to do thus far.

  • Guernica on August 14, 2012, 21:54 GMT

    @Ian Johnson - the immediate concern is a second spinner for the tour of India. Tredwell may not be the future, but he needs looking at for that.

  • Meety on August 15, 2012, 0:14 GMT

    @Peterincanada - I hadn't felt that Cowan had made the test opening position his own, with a string of par performances. I think this tour has been great for him, as it pretty much proves that he has the technique/strategy to survive in England, although the BIG innings is eluding him. A string of 100s & 50s in England, means he can pretty well cancel any social plans he had in June next year. I probably would NOT take him to India though. I don't think he is all that good against spinners, (as seen in the WIndies). I don't think playing a test series in India prior to an Ashes series (again), will be great practise for English conditions!

  • jmcilhinney on August 15, 2012, 0:58 GMT

    Seems like a rather even day in the end. Aus A looked in a fairly strong position for a while but the Lions came back in that last session. I'm sure they're ruing dropping Lyon as I'm sure that they'd like to start the day batting rather than have to think about going out into the field to take that one more wicket.

  • jmcilhinney on August 15, 2012, 1:02 GMT

    @MattyP1979 on (August 14 2012, 19:35 PM GMT), Australian fans seem to have got so used to their openers scoring quickly that they've forgotten what a traditional Test opener's job is. That said, if Cowan had been scoring slowly but making decent scores then I'm sure the public would be a bit more patient but with a relatively low strike rate and average, he hasn't really done much to endear himself. He's done well on this tour but if he can't translate that into runs at the top level then he won't be winning to many more friends any time soon.