Irani Cup 2011 September 24, 2011

Selectors make embarrassing errors in Irani Cup squad

ESPNcricinfo staff
  shares 12

The Indian selectors have picked an injured player to represent Rest of India in the Irani Cup, and left out another on fitness grounds after having originally selected him. The state association of the player who's been left out claims he is fit. The concerned players are Delhi and Mumbai Indians left-arm seamer Pawan Suyal and Jharkhand and Deccan Chargers batsman Ishank Jaggi.

On September 23 the Champions League Twenty20 technical committee allowed Mumbai Indians to field five foreign payers because of an unprecedented count of injuries in the squad. One of the injured players was Suyal. A day after the Champions league made the announcement through a release that went to media houses around the world, the BCCI selected Suyal, and also mis-spelt his name as B Suval, for the Irani Cup. Suyal confirmed to ESPNcricinfo that he underwent a knee surgery two-and-a-half months ago and was aiming at a return in December.

However, a hurried corrigendum from BCCI only corrected the spelling. It also mentioned that the selectors had just discovered that Jaggi was injured and would be replaced by Karnataka's C Gautam. Later in the day the Jharkhand Cricket Association (JCA) told Indian Express that Jaggi was fit and was part of Jharkhand's Ranji Trophy preparatory camp.

"As far as Pawan Suyal is concerned, we didn't know about his injury," the new BCCI secretary and convenor of selectors Sanjay Jagdale told the Indian Express. "We have the main players on our database but we are not aware of injuries to every single first-class cricketer in the country." R Vinay Kumar, the Karnataka seamer, has replaced Suyal in the squad.

Jaggi found support from his state association. The JCA claimed that Jaggi, who had suffered a knee injury during the fourth edition of the IPL while playing for Deccan Chargers, was back to full fitness and training with the state team. "As far as the JCA is concerned, I can tell you that he is fit and presently is even taking part in our Ranji camp," JCA secretary Rajesh Verma told the Indian Express. "We consulted BCCI's authorised doctor Anant Joshi a month ago and he had told us that Ishank did not require any surgery.

"They should have conducted his fitness test if they wanted to pick him for Irani Cup. Jaggi was never called to Bangalore [to the National Cricket Academy] for a test. There is no point in dropping a player when you have not conducted any test."

When asked about Jaggi, Jagdale said: "In Ishank Jaggi's case we went by the National Cricket Academy (NCA) physio's report, which had suggested a surgery but now we will see what can be done."

According to JCA, Jaggi had approached the NCA after his injury, and was advised by the BCCI physio Nitin Patel to undergo surgery in England. Verma further told the paper that Patel failed to acquire an appointment with orthopedic surgeon Andrew Wallace in London whereupon Jaggi was asked by Deccan Chargers and the JCA to meet Joshi.

This fiasco comes days after the BCCI announced a new Under-19 captain for the upcoming quadrangular only to later discover that his date of birth in the BCCI records didn't match the one on his passport.

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • POSTED BY on | September 26, 2011, 16:33 GMT

    The incident tells you that how much BCCI & the selectors give importance to the first class cricket in India ... Ranji trophy perfomance should be the top criteria for any team selection rather than IPL .. The incident tells you that how much BCCI & the selectors give importance to the first class cricket in India ... Ranji trophy perfomance should be the top criteria for any team selection rather than IPL ..

  • POSTED BY arun_nva on | September 26, 2011, 12:33 GMT

    if Shikanth need to be dismissed then the whole group of selectors also resign their job. what are they doing in the meeting if each and evrything is done by Kris. the selectors of the respective zones need to be more careful and look into each players of his zone more closely.

  • POSTED BY on | September 26, 2011, 10:07 GMT

    erm, if my memory serves right, india was the top test team for almost three years and won the last world cup.. so blaming the selectors now is a joke.. and if this is the talent pool in our country, the selectors can only do so much..

  • POSTED BY rsurya on | September 26, 2011, 5:18 GMT

    when will this curse end for India?????

  • POSTED BY howizzat on | September 26, 2011, 4:23 GMT

    Ample of times Mr Srikkanth has shown that he is a CHEAP Selector. By the way if Suyal and Jaggi are among the top 40 or so then god only can save TEAMINDIA in future.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 18:24 GMT

    Sreekanth shoul not be the chief selector anymore

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 16:31 GMT

    Like his careless batting style Shreekant has selected the team for the Irani team without minding the fitness of the players. Shree should step down or get a sack. But with Srinivas at the helm will it happen?

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 13:55 GMT

    The man who made comment on selectors 'Bunch of Jokers' is at the helm of the affairs.This is not REST OF INDIA team it is WASTE OF INDIA team.

  • POSTED BY atuljain1969 on | September 24, 2011, 13:10 GMT

    Indian selectors need to look at unique acheivements by domestic players in last season and give them proper exposure in coming Irani Trophy and Challenger series, rather then trying out the players on basis of IPL performances. One such player who has been ignored is "RISHI DHAWAN" of Himachal Pradesh. He has done enough in last Ranji season to be given a fair chance to prove himself at the next level.

    Whatever was seen of him in last season, is worth watching and could be a good investment for future.

    HOPE SELECTORS READ THIS.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 13:06 GMT

    This is a farce.Please remove this Srikkanth as the chief selector.

  • POSTED BY on | September 26, 2011, 16:33 GMT

    The incident tells you that how much BCCI & the selectors give importance to the first class cricket in India ... Ranji trophy perfomance should be the top criteria for any team selection rather than IPL .. The incident tells you that how much BCCI & the selectors give importance to the first class cricket in India ... Ranji trophy perfomance should be the top criteria for any team selection rather than IPL ..

  • POSTED BY arun_nva on | September 26, 2011, 12:33 GMT

    if Shikanth need to be dismissed then the whole group of selectors also resign their job. what are they doing in the meeting if each and evrything is done by Kris. the selectors of the respective zones need to be more careful and look into each players of his zone more closely.

  • POSTED BY on | September 26, 2011, 10:07 GMT

    erm, if my memory serves right, india was the top test team for almost three years and won the last world cup.. so blaming the selectors now is a joke.. and if this is the talent pool in our country, the selectors can only do so much..

  • POSTED BY rsurya on | September 26, 2011, 5:18 GMT

    when will this curse end for India?????

  • POSTED BY howizzat on | September 26, 2011, 4:23 GMT

    Ample of times Mr Srikkanth has shown that he is a CHEAP Selector. By the way if Suyal and Jaggi are among the top 40 or so then god only can save TEAMINDIA in future.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 18:24 GMT

    Sreekanth shoul not be the chief selector anymore

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 16:31 GMT

    Like his careless batting style Shreekant has selected the team for the Irani team without minding the fitness of the players. Shree should step down or get a sack. But with Srinivas at the helm will it happen?

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 13:55 GMT

    The man who made comment on selectors 'Bunch of Jokers' is at the helm of the affairs.This is not REST OF INDIA team it is WASTE OF INDIA team.

  • POSTED BY atuljain1969 on | September 24, 2011, 13:10 GMT

    Indian selectors need to look at unique acheivements by domestic players in last season and give them proper exposure in coming Irani Trophy and Challenger series, rather then trying out the players on basis of IPL performances. One such player who has been ignored is "RISHI DHAWAN" of Himachal Pradesh. He has done enough in last Ranji season to be given a fair chance to prove himself at the next level.

    Whatever was seen of him in last season, is worth watching and could be a good investment for future.

    HOPE SELECTORS READ THIS.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 13:06 GMT

    This is a farce.Please remove this Srikkanth as the chief selector.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 10:00 GMT

    Farcical ! We fans are fools to expect the BCCI to come up clean in such issues. Anyways, All the very best to these cricketers who dream to be the future of Indian cricket.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 9:55 GMT

    When Pawan Suyal had surgery before 2.5 months back, why he has named in Mumbai Internationals squad ?

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 9:55 GMT

    When Pawan Suyal had surgery before 2.5 months back, why he has named in Mumbai Internationals squad ?

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 10:00 GMT

    Farcical ! We fans are fools to expect the BCCI to come up clean in such issues. Anyways, All the very best to these cricketers who dream to be the future of Indian cricket.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 13:06 GMT

    This is a farce.Please remove this Srikkanth as the chief selector.

  • POSTED BY atuljain1969 on | September 24, 2011, 13:10 GMT

    Indian selectors need to look at unique acheivements by domestic players in last season and give them proper exposure in coming Irani Trophy and Challenger series, rather then trying out the players on basis of IPL performances. One such player who has been ignored is "RISHI DHAWAN" of Himachal Pradesh. He has done enough in last Ranji season to be given a fair chance to prove himself at the next level.

    Whatever was seen of him in last season, is worth watching and could be a good investment for future.

    HOPE SELECTORS READ THIS.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 13:55 GMT

    The man who made comment on selectors 'Bunch of Jokers' is at the helm of the affairs.This is not REST OF INDIA team it is WASTE OF INDIA team.

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 16:31 GMT

    Like his careless batting style Shreekant has selected the team for the Irani team without minding the fitness of the players. Shree should step down or get a sack. But with Srinivas at the helm will it happen?

  • POSTED BY on | September 24, 2011, 18:24 GMT

    Sreekanth shoul not be the chief selector anymore

  • POSTED BY howizzat on | September 26, 2011, 4:23 GMT

    Ample of times Mr Srikkanth has shown that he is a CHEAP Selector. By the way if Suyal and Jaggi are among the top 40 or so then god only can save TEAMINDIA in future.

  • POSTED BY rsurya on | September 26, 2011, 5:18 GMT

    when will this curse end for India?????

  • POSTED BY on | September 26, 2011, 10:07 GMT

    erm, if my memory serves right, india was the top test team for almost three years and won the last world cup.. so blaming the selectors now is a joke.. and if this is the talent pool in our country, the selectors can only do so much..