New Zealand v England, 2nd T20, Hamilton

Brendon McCullum blitz draws New Zealand level

The Report by David Hopps

February 12, 2013

Comments: 80 | Text size: A | A

New Zealand 192 for 6 (B McCullum 74, Guptill 47, Rutherford 40) beat England 137 (J Buttler 54, Franklin 4-15) by 55 runs
Scorecard and ball-by-ball details

Hamish Rutherford helped New Zealand to a quick start, New Zealand v England, 2nd T20, Hamilton, February 12, 2013
Hamish Rutherford hauled one into the sponsors' area and almost felled a couple of stilt walkers © Getty Images
Related Links

England have never successfully chased a target of such magnitude to win a Twenty20 international and they certainly did not chase this one. They foundered from the start under the lights at Seddon Park, enabling New Zealand to inflict a 55-run trouncing. After all the talk of small boundaries, for England they seemed to be expanding by the moment.

The ICC rankings system certainly knows how to lose faith with a side after a bad night's cricket. England, third at the start of the night, were sixth by the end of it. T20 is a volatile business. The series will be settled in Wellington on Friday.

Brendon McCullum had carried the fight for New Zealand, striking 74 from 38 balls and manfully thrusting a daunting total into English faces after they had gained control in mid-innings. England conceded 38 off the last two overs, Stuart Broad and Jade Dernbach the bowlers to suffer, and even though Dernbach silenced McCullum's belligerence at deep cover on the penultimate ball of the innings, England had nothing to show for some tigerish fielding.

Just as striking was the degree to which New Zealand's fast bowlers outdid their England counterparts. They found movement under the lights never imagined by England earlier in the innings as they preferred the back-of-a-length approach that had served them so well in the opening T20I in Auckland.

England, victors in the opening T20I in Auckland when they batted first and made their highest total in this format, opted to chase when Stuart Broad won the toss on a dry, lightly cloudy evening in Hamilton. "Probably should have batted first," Broad accepted.

Ian Butler stood out with an impeccable spell of 2 for 9 in four overs as England's innings never found any impetus. Butler has had some discouraging times in a career and almost abandoned New Zealand cricket to play county cricket in England but he has had a good season with Otago Volts and this was a night that told of a bowler with appetite restored. James Franklin bowled well, but his four-for largely fell upon him.

England never recovered from losing three wickets for 24 by the fifth over. Alex Hales was bowled by Mitchell McClenaghan as he tried to work to leg, Luke Wright edged his sighter to gully, and Jonny Bairstow, cramped as he pulled Butler, got it no further than short-fine leg. When Michael Lumb was bowled off his pads, charging Nathan McCullum's off spin, England limped to the mid-point at 47 for 4.

It all left Morgan facing circumstances that he did not naturally relish, a batsman with too much time on his hands. Morgan likes games to be set up for him, but this one felt more like a set up favoured in American gangster movies.

It is not often that Morgan seems overpowered by a situation, but it was the case here. He reached 13 from 22 before he fell to Butler. He needed good fortune to get that far, surviving a stumping chance - a McCullum brotherly combination that went amiss - and was badly dropped off Butler at deep midwicket when Hamish Rutherford battered one to the floor off his chest.

By the time Samit Patel was run out by yards, failing to negotiate a single to Trent Boult who hit direct from mid off, England's innings had entered the realms of black comedy. The only consolation came from Jos Buttler's maiden T20I fifty. Buttler has been favoured with the gloves ahead of Bairstow as a statement that England wish to keep him in the side. His reputation is built on short, explosive innings, and his 54 from 30 balls in a hopeless task did him no harm.

After the somewhat unnatural six-hitting extravaganza in Eden Park, Seddon Park had a more satisfying cricketing feel. It is another compact ground, with straight boundaries around 65m, but a few extra metres and a more logical shape provided a more gratifying setting for another packed house. Even so, after England gave the first over to the offspinner, James Tredwell, it took all of four balls before Martin Guptill smashed him for six into the sightscreen. There were ten sixes in all for New Zealand, five of them to McCullum, their jaw-jutting captain. England, so supreme in Auckland, managed two in reply.

Finn had placed a marker a few paces from the stumps in an effort to control his occasional habit of colliding with them. Stay left of that, and you will be okay, seemed to be the message. His thoughts soon strayed elsewhere as Rutherford hauled him into the sponsors' area and almost felled a couple of stilt walkers.

New Zealand rattled along at around ten an over from the outset. Jade Dernbach was wearing a strapping on his heavily-tattooed left arm after being accidentally spiked in practice, presumably denying onlookers the chance to read several ancient Tibetan dictums.

Wright, who looks too perky to sit down in a tattoo parlour, came up trumps for the second successive match, his medium pace bringing 2 for 24 to follow his 2 for 29 in Auckland. He arrested an opening stand of 75 in 8.2 overs when Rutherford tried to fiddle one to third man and was caught at the wicket. There was the wicket of Ross Taylor, too, who hauled him to Bairstow at deep midwicket. Acclaimed as the returning hero since ending his self-imposed exile, Taylor has so far amassed more ovations than runs.

When Dernbach's slower balls began to make an impact - Colin Munro hauling to Bairstow at deep midwicket and Grant Elliott having his bails trimmed by a back-of-the-hand delivery, the judder in New Zealand's innings had become pronounced. But it was nothing like the judder England were about to experience.

David Hopps is the UK editor of ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: David Hopps

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by A_Vacant_Slip on (February 15, 2013, 8:21 GMT)

Fast track bully. In that case India are no better than England at t20 in India. So if England's bench strength is poor then so is Indias. And this only in game in India. Unfortunately India also play away from their home from time to time. I notice that you won't talk about India away record. Now why is that fast track bull?

Posted by Fast_Track_Bully on (February 15, 2013, 7:20 GMT)

@A_Vacant_Slip. Funny to see your explanation. 2012 India played 3 matches against Eng and India won 2 of them. You are trying to hide that 90 run victory in T20 WC! OK, in that case, England lost 29 out of 45 ODI matches in India and won only 13 out of 55 tests in India. Do you have anything to say??

Posted by A_Vacant_Slip on (February 14, 2013, 19:01 GMT)

@fast track bully. In the last 3 t20 game played in India between India and England the score is England 2 India 1. I say played in India because as everyone know - the only game of cricket that count is one played in India so I won't count any game other than one played in India. Now, let me explain this to you - in games of t20 played in India England lead 2-1. So fast track bully it is India, not England who have the weak bench strength. If you want talk about any game cricket in any format played by India but outside of India then we can talk about that if you like. But it would be very short conversation which would include the word lost quite a few times.

Posted by Fast_Track_Bully on (February 14, 2013, 10:42 GMT)

England do not have bench strength and thats proved yet again!

Posted by The_bowlers_Holding on (February 14, 2013, 2:51 GMT)

Bring_Back_Warnie on (February 12, 2013, 15:32 GMT) I agree with what you say about Bird, to me of the new batch of Aussie quicks he looks the business, the top order of the batting and the loss of Huss is the big differnce to me. RandyUK as original and amusing as ever, GSinge7 have you always been obsessed with England or is it since 2011, I am honestly curious as to your infatuation with good ole England it humors me.

Posted by Front-Foot-Lunge on (February 13, 2013, 20:17 GMT)

With such an incredible depth of squad, England have talent knocking on the door for all positions. If one thinks back to the whitewash they gave Australia last year, England have a absolute quality batting line up that pummels any opposition on it's day. T20 cricket is a good place to tweak things in a team, whilst giving fresh talent a chance. England should use the talented Jos Buttler higher up the order, he is an incredible bat.

Posted by RandyOZ on (February 13, 2013, 14:09 GMT)

With the Lions losing for a third time against Victoria, there is no depth so England better hope no one goes down.

Posted by dabhand on (February 13, 2013, 12:51 GMT)

@Arshad Siddiqui - quite right - but there are plenty of fools on here - those who predicted England would be whitewashed in the series before this and those like RandyOz who have incredibly selective memories (74 ALL OUT) and especially those who just don't understand T20 is incredibly unpredictable.

Great result for the Kiwis, but in the grand scheme of cricket not a particularly meaningful result for either team.

Posted by Energetic. on (February 13, 2013, 11:29 GMT)

Ranking tables can be a bit of a joke, just look at the left hand side of the column and see how unevenly distributed the matches are so really they don't tell the whole story whether we like it or not :)

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
David HoppsClose
David Hopps David Hopps joined ESPNcricinfo as UK editor early in 2012. For the previous 20 years he was a senior cricket writer for the Guardian and covered England extensively during that time in all Test-playing nations. He also covered four Olympic Games and has written several cricket books, including collections of cricket quotations. He has been an avid amateur cricketer since he was 12, and so knows the pain of repeated failure only too well. The pile of untouched novels he plans to read, but rarely gets around to, is now almost touching the ceiling. He divides his time between the ESPNcricinfo office in Hammersmith and his beloved Yorkshire.
Tour Results
New Zealand v England at Auckland - Mar 22-26, 2013
Match drawn
New Zealand v England at Wellington - Mar 14-18, 2013
Match drawn
New Zealand v England at Dunedin - Mar 6-10, 2013
Match drawn
NZ XI v England XI at Queenstown - Feb 27-Mar 2, 2013
NZ XI won by 3 wickets
New Zealand v England at Auckland - Feb 23, 2013
England won by 5 wickets (with 75 balls remaining)
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days