The experts review the action

Ian Chappell: No point in having Ponting in a new-look team

If the selectors are looking to build a team for the future then Ponting must go, but the problem is that it's not great time to appoint Clarke. (00:00)

December 27, 2010

Posted by   on (December 28, 2010, 7:02 GMT)

Misleading headline "Ian Chappell: No point in having Ponting in a new-look team". Chappell never said Ponting shouldn't be in the new look team. He is just suggesting that Ricky shouldn't be the captain of a new look team.

Posted by Ramkunic on (December 28, 2010, 6:19 GMT)

The penalty must have been heavier. Imagine if the batsman had been given out and he stands there arguing.You cannot have an captain who wants all decision in his favour. Ponting acts as if he is only correct be it in any disputed catches or in third umpire referrals.It should have been a match ban which would have been the case if lesser known nation were involved

Posted by   on (December 28, 2010, 6:03 GMT)

ian is right !! it's time for the aussies to have a new skipper. point failed to lead from the front. moreover, his act with umpire aleem dar was totally unbecoming.

Posted by   on (December 27, 2010, 19:04 GMT)

Chappell's correct for a change! The ICC and the governing bodies should never have allowed such behavior but then that always happens with players from certain countries. Now if a Harbhajan or a Sangakkara would've argued like that I'm sure they'd ve got 3 matches minimum!! Also, commentators like Chappell himself are guilty of elevating the level of players like Ponting, who was never the great batsman or captain he was made out to be. He just made hay while the sun was shining, it aint shining now is it Ricky? :-)

Posted by   on (December 27, 2010, 17:52 GMT)

I totally agree.. Ponting is bad example and role model for younger generation.

Posted by jupiterlaw on (December 27, 2010, 16:39 GMT)

This must be a tough series for Chappell to take as he had predicted a series win for Australia and a Ponting masterpiece, both of which will prove to have been wishful thinking. I hate to see him out there like that.

Comments have now been closed for this article


Play Video
Arnold: An awesome victory for Sri Lanka

Jun 24, 2014 Russel Arnold speaks to Andrew Fernando at the end of a pulsating Test match at Headingley to review the significance of the Sri Lanka series victory in England. (06:05)

Play Video
Arnold: Sri Lanka have shown a lot of heart

Jun 23, 2014 Russel Arnold assesses Sri Lanka's performance over the opening three days at Headingley and says there is much they can be proud of (05:41)


Play Video
#politeenquiries: Who is your favourite Stuart?

Features: Jarrod Kimber and George Dobell answers your tweets and questions from the final day of the first Test between England and India including who is their favourite Stuart and England and India's selection for Lord's (05:15) | Jul 13, 2014

Play Video
Cook: 'Simon is a tough kid'

Press Conference: England captain Alastair Cook believes Simon Kerrigan has proved his merit by earning a recall to the Test squad for the second match against India at Lord's. (00:46) | Jul 13, 2014

Play Video
Extraordinary match, unique pitch - Cook

Press Conference: England captain Alastair Cook says that it was a strange opening Test at Trent Bridge, which ended in a draw against India, and hoped that the pitches would improve for the rest of the series (01:49) | Jul 13, 2014