Zimbabwe Twenty20 triangular series 2012 June 18, 2012

SA struggle to find value in tri-series

28

You would be forgiven for thinking it strange that Hashim Amla sounded like a man going to war when South Africa departed for Harare. For one, Amla rarely sounds like anything but a man coming from an ashram. Then of course, there are the facts to consider. South Africa's Twenty20 squad are going to play in an unofficial tri-series in Harare, involving two sides they have beaten soundly in the past and will likely continue to beat in various formats almost all of the time.

Nothing to get too excited about, except that only victory will justify their inclusion in this competition. "We are kind of expecting that [to win]," Amla said. "But in the T20 format, teams that are not so well known can perform really well too. But, we are expecting to perform well."

It is almost unnaturally bullish talk from the stand-in skipper ahead of what is increasingly looking like a meaningless contest. There's certainly no prize at stake - Zimbabwe Cricket could barely afford to host the event - neither is there much recognition for the team who wins, no rankings points and surely no bragging rights to take into the World T20.

The only benefit it could have is that of preparation but even that is starting to look dubious from a South African perspective. Their players will spend two months in England before the ICC tournament even crosses their minds and will have far more pressing issues at hand. The Test squad will be concerned with wresting the No.1 ranking from England, the ODI squad with not fading as dramatically as they did after the Test series victory four years ago and only then will twenty-over cricket become an issue worth pondering.

From a timing perspective, this week probably comes too early for it to be called a camp for the World T20. Johan Botha alluded to it when he said he thought it was "too far out" for him to be worried about missing out through injury, because he will play enough cricket between now and September to be ready.

When South Africa requested the fixtures, they asked for five matches in five days, a schedule that would create intensity. The inclusion of Bangladesh in the event changed it to four matches in six days, with the additional possibility of a final. While that is not drastically different to what South Arica initially wanted, their attitude seems to have changed.

Instead of using the week to fine-tune tactics and strategies with a squad that closely matches to the men who will travel to Sri Lanka, South Africa have opted to rest captain AB de Villiers and their frontline pace bowlers Morne Morkel and Dale Steyn. Given these players workloads, it made sense to leave them out, although it does mean South Africa will field teams in Zimbabwe that do not look like the XIs who will play in Sri Lanka, particularly not on the bowling front.

It's a concern that Amla hinted at when he said ultimate specialisation is not the way to go. "It does seem that that's the trend these days, to have specialised players but I guess the ideal would be to find a good balance; where the team doesn't change a lot and there's a good core of players and other guys just fit in," he said.

This series will be more of a case of the latter. Opportunity will be present for a relatively unknown bowler like Chris Morris to make an impact, for Wayne Parnell to come full circle after his comeback from injury over a year ago and for Marchant de Lange to show his last over heroics in New Zealand were no fluke.

Of greater concern though will be the batting. South Africa's 14-man squad is loaded with middle-order batsmen, none of him have nailed down a spot as their own. Colin Ingram, Justin Ontong, Farhaan Behardien and Dane Vilas will all have the chance to perform but given the experimentation that is likely to take place, none of them can count on a sustained run in Harare.

The player who may be particularly concerned about where he will fit in is Faf du Plessis. Although considered an integral part of the ODI squad, du Plessis has yet to play in T20 for South Africa but forced his way into the squad through his showings in the IPL. Du Plessis was asked to open the batting by Chennai Super Kings coach Stephen Fleming and did so with some success, scoring three half-centuries and ending the tournament as his franchise's second highest run-getter.

Du Plessis' promising form led to speculation that he may open the batting with Richard Levi, a position currently held by Amla, who has not had much to show for the eight T20s he has played. Amla left space for juggling the batting order, which should give Du Plessis at least one look in. "We know in T20 format, very seldom does a team get bowled out. So you can afford to have guys opening the batting who don't normally open the batting to get them in as quickly as possible."

Du Plessis could also challenge Amla on the captaincy front. Having been named captain of the A side, du Plessis may have to step in if Amla is left out for a game for the sake of testing combinations. Amla was a reluctant leader during last year's ODI and T20 series against Australia and was only named captain for this week when Botha was ruled out. For him, this series will also be an opportunity to have another shot at the task. "I always understood as vice-captain that sometimes AB [de Villiers] won't be around and I will have to do it."

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on June 20, 2012, 15:28 GMT

    at least after loosing to Zimbabwe they will learn humility

  • RyanHarrisGreatCricketer on June 19, 2012, 11:06 GMT

    In t20 wc south africa should include:

    Amla , Du Plessis , Kallis , AB de Villiers , David Miller , Duminy , Van der Merwe , Albie Morkel , Steyn , Parnell , Tahir

  • Abaa on June 19, 2012, 10:04 GMT

    @ Third_Gear - SAF have continuously been one of the top teams in all forms of international cricket since 1992 (which was when they were re-admitted) and have been the epitome of consistency. When you try to ridicule them the way you just did, you come out looking absurdly silly!

    As for the guy comparing West Indies' loss to England (an English team which everyone including West Indian fans will accept is better than WI) by 114 runs in an ODI to Bangladesh's loss to Zimbabwe (who the Bangladesh fans were boasting about whitewashing a couple of days ago) by 11 runs in a T20! How can you compare the two? Do you catch the point? In that case, how badly has Bangladesh lost in ODIs in recent times? How many times by 150+ runs and how many times by 8+ wickets?

    Seriously the way you guys put down any other team you can get your hands on to conveniently forget the failure of your team is really frustrating.Honestly its the aweful attitude of Bangladesh fans that is ridiculously disgusting!

  • britishcricketfan on June 19, 2012, 10:03 GMT

    i dont see the problem with this series... all 3 teams are giving their players the opportunity to play20/20 cricket in a tournament format prior to the world cup, due to take place in about 3 months time. More practise = better results... what's the issue???

  • on June 19, 2012, 9:45 GMT

    As Zimbabwe that's how we like it, we have been known to cause upsets especially to sides that are over confident. We have a feel big scalps in our T20 closet. Such statement can just be described as mouthing off , Zimbabwe just need to execute their game plan ,not drop catches and tight fielding .Who knows ??

  • Sehwag_Is_Ordinary on June 19, 2012, 9:43 GMT

    Bd will win today no doubt

  • Open-Eyed on June 19, 2012, 9:23 GMT

    I disagree with this report and the guys who cannot see the positives from this series especially for the SA team. This kind of tournament will give them an opportunity to try new players and will find alternatives before the big tournament, what they are going to do anyway. As with new players the team can have different result especially in T20 format and that could be one of the reason Amla is talking like that. I think there are some other issues also involved SA to join this series as they could not host BD earlier, so they have some obligations. we should remember if big team not playing with small team now and then they cannot grow and cricket will not expand. we should see the bigger picture and the media does have same responsibilities.

  • satish619chandar on June 19, 2012, 8:49 GMT

    I think by including SA in this series, they have robbed a upcoming team to have pride of a winning a series.. It would have been a good series with equal teams like Zimbabwe, BD, Ireland clash and the best of them win the tournament..

  • Third_Gear on June 19, 2012, 8:38 GMT

    kushaman@ I did'nt even know last 3 or 5 series SA played against who,what was the result and how they played. Bcoz we dont care about them.

  • Baundele on June 19, 2012, 8:37 GMT

    Ah! Amla has started talking even before becoming a real captain!

  • on June 20, 2012, 15:28 GMT

    at least after loosing to Zimbabwe they will learn humility

  • RyanHarrisGreatCricketer on June 19, 2012, 11:06 GMT

    In t20 wc south africa should include:

    Amla , Du Plessis , Kallis , AB de Villiers , David Miller , Duminy , Van der Merwe , Albie Morkel , Steyn , Parnell , Tahir

  • Abaa on June 19, 2012, 10:04 GMT

    @ Third_Gear - SAF have continuously been one of the top teams in all forms of international cricket since 1992 (which was when they were re-admitted) and have been the epitome of consistency. When you try to ridicule them the way you just did, you come out looking absurdly silly!

    As for the guy comparing West Indies' loss to England (an English team which everyone including West Indian fans will accept is better than WI) by 114 runs in an ODI to Bangladesh's loss to Zimbabwe (who the Bangladesh fans were boasting about whitewashing a couple of days ago) by 11 runs in a T20! How can you compare the two? Do you catch the point? In that case, how badly has Bangladesh lost in ODIs in recent times? How many times by 150+ runs and how many times by 8+ wickets?

    Seriously the way you guys put down any other team you can get your hands on to conveniently forget the failure of your team is really frustrating.Honestly its the aweful attitude of Bangladesh fans that is ridiculously disgusting!

  • britishcricketfan on June 19, 2012, 10:03 GMT

    i dont see the problem with this series... all 3 teams are giving their players the opportunity to play20/20 cricket in a tournament format prior to the world cup, due to take place in about 3 months time. More practise = better results... what's the issue???

  • on June 19, 2012, 9:45 GMT

    As Zimbabwe that's how we like it, we have been known to cause upsets especially to sides that are over confident. We have a feel big scalps in our T20 closet. Such statement can just be described as mouthing off , Zimbabwe just need to execute their game plan ,not drop catches and tight fielding .Who knows ??

  • Sehwag_Is_Ordinary on June 19, 2012, 9:43 GMT

    Bd will win today no doubt

  • Open-Eyed on June 19, 2012, 9:23 GMT

    I disagree with this report and the guys who cannot see the positives from this series especially for the SA team. This kind of tournament will give them an opportunity to try new players and will find alternatives before the big tournament, what they are going to do anyway. As with new players the team can have different result especially in T20 format and that could be one of the reason Amla is talking like that. I think there are some other issues also involved SA to join this series as they could not host BD earlier, so they have some obligations. we should remember if big team not playing with small team now and then they cannot grow and cricket will not expand. we should see the bigger picture and the media does have same responsibilities.

  • satish619chandar on June 19, 2012, 8:49 GMT

    I think by including SA in this series, they have robbed a upcoming team to have pride of a winning a series.. It would have been a good series with equal teams like Zimbabwe, BD, Ireland clash and the best of them win the tournament..

  • Third_Gear on June 19, 2012, 8:38 GMT

    kushaman@ I did'nt even know last 3 or 5 series SA played against who,what was the result and how they played. Bcoz we dont care about them.

  • Baundele on June 19, 2012, 8:37 GMT

    Ah! Amla has started talking even before becoming a real captain!

  • kushaman on June 19, 2012, 7:54 GMT

    I m a die heart fan of SA..... I dint even knew about this series before today when i just turnaround this site.... I dont think this series will help SA they will win lyk Lions and others teams may not even compete them........ Go SA GO.......

  • realist1 on June 19, 2012, 7:02 GMT

    It's very disheartening to see the way bigger teams treat Zimbabwe and Bangladesh and Ireland to some extent. These are emerging teams and very exciting watch. Still FTP don't allow them as many games against bigger teams as they should. People talk about one sided match. But how often we see one sided matches between higher ranked teams (India vs Aus or SAF). One sided matches are part of the game. If ICC gives more chances to BD and Zim then only thing will happen is these two team will improve. Otherwise we will see the same team play against each other again and again.... Boring.

  • ziggy500 on June 19, 2012, 6:57 GMT

    i fail to see the value it has on any of the 3 teams, let alone south africa. these are just like friendlies in football

  • ParOChiaL on June 19, 2012, 6:13 GMT

    Whether you like it or not, it is extremely unlikely that SA will lose to either zim or bang. SA have not been disrespectful in the slightest, if they thought they were too good to bother playing with teams at the bottom of the rankings then they wouldn't have played. As Amla said they expect to win, as they should, however "teams that are not so well known can perform too" shows he isn't entering the game with a "who cares we will win easily" attitude. The fact that they are letting key players such as Steyn rest is common sense, why would you risk injury and fatigue to players that are necessary if SA are to take the #1 test position from eng in the upcoming series. As for Amla's attitude towards captaincy, not everyone enjoys captaining a side, doesn't mean he isn't good at it and shouldn't be doing it. Same situation as Sangakkara, he no longer wants to captain SL however when Dilshan was injured during the eng tour he stepped up, however reluctantly, and did the job.

  • 9ST9 on June 19, 2012, 3:33 GMT

    @wibblewibble - If teams only played against competitive teams, England may have even entirely given up ODI's halfway into the last decade.

  • joynal693 on June 19, 2012, 2:38 GMT

    Wish a pretty good contest with SA. Probably we will have to expect another Defeat.

  • zimbos_05 on June 19, 2012, 2:26 GMT

    Its highly disrspectful to Zim and Bangladesh that SA see the series this way. It doesnt bode well that teams thik the minnows are undeserving or dont have a right to be considered a challenge. One should be chomping at the big to play in every match and want to win it. Zim and Bangladesh fans will be smiling if they could upset SA and to think SA will just be going, 'meh' is downright disrespectful and not professional. Amla is my favourite player at the moment, but i sometimes question the mental state. How can we ever expect cricket to grow if we continue to undermine the minnows and not give them enough competition. Was not long ago Zim and Bangladesh were beating SA, Aus, Pak, Eng, NZ etc etc in ODIS and becoming strong. Time for the ICC to be more serious with their jobs.

  • on June 19, 2012, 1:10 GMT

    if SA starts to think like this they may not even win; one should not be too much over confident.

  • wiseshah on June 19, 2012, 0:56 GMT

    zimbabwe has brendan taylor, ray price, masakadza, taibu, utseya--they can break into any team in the world. watch out south africa.

  • teo. on June 18, 2012, 22:23 GMT

    SA Fan.... and I wont even bother checking the results of this "series"... most people in SA arent even aware of it. So, who honestly cares if Bang or Zim win....pffff.... As some of the comments here state: Disrespectful, and poor planning from CSA.

  • Lord_Dravid on June 18, 2012, 20:26 GMT

    LOL the article made me laugh 'SA struggle to find value'..also SA shouldn't take this to heart that the series is unofficial, but rather think of it as some practice because after all its bangladesh and zimbabwe!

  • Nadeem1976 on June 18, 2012, 18:23 GMT

    Unofficial tournament and you are inviting world #2 team in all formats to play with you. That is shame. SA deserves an official series, this is as bad as Misbah captaincy in T2020 and ODI. Just boring and disrespectful.

  • on June 18, 2012, 17:44 GMT

    Be careful what you say South Africa although you are strong favourites to win against Bangladesh I most certainly won't underestimate them and if I recall it was back at 07 World Cup where South Africa got thrashed by Bangladesh simply because of lack carelessness. You have to remember Bangladesh who did deservedly lose the other day only lost by 11 runs which according to some is such a big defeat but I wonder how you can describe West Indies 114 run defeat? :)

  • wibblewibble on June 18, 2012, 17:39 GMT

    If teams only ever played against other competitive teams, England would have had a 20 year gap of playing most sides. It's not always just about the 'better' team, the 'minnows' have a right to play series too.

    "I always understood as vice-captain that sometimes AB [de Villiers] won't be around and I will have to do it." - not the attitude you really want from your VC, you should be champing at the bit to do the job, not 'have' to do it.

  • wiseshah on June 18, 2012, 17:36 GMT

    i wonder what would be SAF main XI. my guess 1. amla 2. levy 3. du plessis 4. duminy 5. farhaan7. colin ingram 7.vilas 8. albie9.robin petersen 10.tsotsobe 11. merchant de lange. extra: morris, parnell,ontong

  • wiseshah on June 18, 2012, 17:31 GMT

    BD team should be: 1.anamul 2. ashraful 3. jahurul 4.mushfiq 5.junaid 6.ziaur rahman 7.nasir 8.elias sunny 9.abdur razzaq 10. mashrafe 11.abul hasan/najmul hossain. plz no mahmudullah in main XI. he is not good or T20

  • banglafan on June 18, 2012, 17:15 GMT

    Will be real sad if BD exits the tournament without any win.Highly possible, but sad.

  • on June 18, 2012, 16:59 GMT

    Hope BD will WIN . Pray for best .

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • on June 18, 2012, 16:59 GMT

    Hope BD will WIN . Pray for best .

  • banglafan on June 18, 2012, 17:15 GMT

    Will be real sad if BD exits the tournament without any win.Highly possible, but sad.

  • wiseshah on June 18, 2012, 17:31 GMT

    BD team should be: 1.anamul 2. ashraful 3. jahurul 4.mushfiq 5.junaid 6.ziaur rahman 7.nasir 8.elias sunny 9.abdur razzaq 10. mashrafe 11.abul hasan/najmul hossain. plz no mahmudullah in main XI. he is not good or T20

  • wiseshah on June 18, 2012, 17:36 GMT

    i wonder what would be SAF main XI. my guess 1. amla 2. levy 3. du plessis 4. duminy 5. farhaan7. colin ingram 7.vilas 8. albie9.robin petersen 10.tsotsobe 11. merchant de lange. extra: morris, parnell,ontong

  • wibblewibble on June 18, 2012, 17:39 GMT

    If teams only ever played against other competitive teams, England would have had a 20 year gap of playing most sides. It's not always just about the 'better' team, the 'minnows' have a right to play series too.

    "I always understood as vice-captain that sometimes AB [de Villiers] won't be around and I will have to do it." - not the attitude you really want from your VC, you should be champing at the bit to do the job, not 'have' to do it.

  • on June 18, 2012, 17:44 GMT

    Be careful what you say South Africa although you are strong favourites to win against Bangladesh I most certainly won't underestimate them and if I recall it was back at 07 World Cup where South Africa got thrashed by Bangladesh simply because of lack carelessness. You have to remember Bangladesh who did deservedly lose the other day only lost by 11 runs which according to some is such a big defeat but I wonder how you can describe West Indies 114 run defeat? :)

  • Nadeem1976 on June 18, 2012, 18:23 GMT

    Unofficial tournament and you are inviting world #2 team in all formats to play with you. That is shame. SA deserves an official series, this is as bad as Misbah captaincy in T2020 and ODI. Just boring and disrespectful.

  • Lord_Dravid on June 18, 2012, 20:26 GMT

    LOL the article made me laugh 'SA struggle to find value'..also SA shouldn't take this to heart that the series is unofficial, but rather think of it as some practice because after all its bangladesh and zimbabwe!

  • teo. on June 18, 2012, 22:23 GMT

    SA Fan.... and I wont even bother checking the results of this "series"... most people in SA arent even aware of it. So, who honestly cares if Bang or Zim win....pffff.... As some of the comments here state: Disrespectful, and poor planning from CSA.

  • wiseshah on June 19, 2012, 0:56 GMT

    zimbabwe has brendan taylor, ray price, masakadza, taibu, utseya--they can break into any team in the world. watch out south africa.