The Surfer

Decision time for Aleem Dar?

Osman Samiuddin in the National contemplates whether Aleem Dar, whose consistency as an international umpire has been freakish and his reputation impeccable, making glaring errors - as during the recent India-Australia series - is a sign of an ending

Osman Samiuddin in the National contemplates whether Aleem Dar, whose consistency as an international umpire has been freakish and his reputation impeccable, making glaring errors - as during the recent India-Australia series - is a sign of an ending.

Loading ...

..when Dar stood face to face with Ricky Ponting at the Melbourne Cricket Ground in the fourth Ashes Test in 2010 - Ponting rabid, angry, mouthy; Dar dignified, impassive, calm and right - it was not hard to think back to the infamous and seismic photograph of Shakoor Rana and Mike Gatting, wagging fingers at each other in Faisalabad in 1988, and feel a little closure. So it has been a little jarring to see him get a few decisions wrong lately. Actually, I will be honest: it has hurt.