Worcestershire v Warwickshire, New Road, 1st day

Warwicks take Bear hug on the title

George Dobell at New Road

September 4, 2012

Comments: 4 | Text size: A | A

Warwickshire 215 for 2 (Chopra 115*) lead Worcestershire 60 (Wright 5-24, Barker 5-36) by 155 runs
Scorecard


Chris Wright took 5 for 24 before lunch, Worcestershire v Warwickshire, County Championship, Division One, New Road, September, 4, 2012
Chris Wright picked up his second five-for of the season © PA Photos
Enlarge

Like a wrestling bout between a seal and a polar bear, this has been a disturbingly unequal contest between local rivals with little in common other than geography.

Warwickshire treated Worcestershire not as an obstacle to the Championship title, but as a road. Worcestershire, who recorded their lowest first-class total since 1971 and their lowest ever against Warwickshire, were brushed away with an ease quite unbecoming of this level of cricket. Having chosen to bat first on a blameless wicket, a total of 60 was not just woefully inadequate, it was embarrassing. Tellingly, their senior pro, Alan Richardson, tweeted an apology to supporters at the close of play. "That's about as bad as it gets," he admitted. "It can't be easy watching us sometimes."

This was a depressing day for Worcestershire. Not only did their distant hopes of salvation recede to the point of invisibility, but it was hard to conclude that the future was very bright, either.

Lacking the budget of most of their Division One rivals, Worcestershire have had to recruit more through the address book than the cheque book. Some of the players they have brought in are decent cricketers and may well shine in the Birmingham League. But, in arguably the toughest first-class domestic competition in world cricket, they look some way off the pace.

The underlying issue is not just a lack of quality at the club - though that is one issue - but also the failure to coax the best out of the talent they do have. The likes of Moeen Ali, Vikram Solanki, Ben Scott, Alexei Kervezee, Richard Jones, Gareth Andrew, Daryl Mitchell and Aneesh Kapil all have the ability to prosper at this level. Yet all have endured disappointing seasons. Failure as widespread as that suggests something in the environment at the club is wrong.

The fact is that only two men in this team - overseas batsman Phil Hughes and captain Daryl Mitchell - average over 25 in first-class cricket this season - that they have failed to score 350 in a Championship innings this season (they have passed 300 only twice) and that, in this game, their first and second change bowlers were men with 12 first-class wickets between them. One - Joe Leach - barely gets a bowl in the Birmingham League and the other - Nick Harrison - gained selection after a List A performance where he conceded 83 in seven overs against Lancashire including 30 in one over. His first ball at this level was a wide and his second a long-hop that was cut for four. Aged only 20, he has the time and the talent to develop into a decent cricketer. Right now, however, he looked somewhat out of his depth.

Some will call for Steve Rhodes, the director of cricket at New Road, to be sacked. But even if Worcestershire was that sort of club - and it really is not - there is no chance of that. Not only will the club remain loyal to a man who has, in the last two or three years, achieved rather a lot with rather a little, but they can scarcely afford the cost of jettisoning a long-term employee. Besides, the club know they will not find a more passionate, hard-working coach. In the long-term, it is anticipated that the development that will see the start of construction of a hotel on this ground within a few weeks will allow more money to be invested into cricket at the club. In the shorter-term, many of these players will have a chance to develop in the lower division. It may not be such a bad thing.

Some changes have taken place already. Solanki has been dropped - not an encouraging scenario for Surrey supporters who will welcome him as their replacement for Mark Ramprakash next season - while Scott is pursuing opportunities outside cricket having been told that he will not be offered a contract extension. Scott remains a keeper of the highest class, but his failure to score runs consistently has undermined his career.

"I feel quite embarrassed by our batting," Rhodes admitted afterwards. "It was a terrific wicket, but either technically or tactically, we batted very poorly. They bowled exceedingly well. But some of those dismissals…Well, it was men against boys. If I had played like that as a youngster in the Yorkshire leagues, I'd have had my backside kicked. But they are young and when you are young you make mistakes. It's been a disappointing day."

Cricket is a wonderfully unpredictable game, of course, and Worcestershire might yet stage a remarkable recovery. But on the evidence to date, the gulf between these sides is vast. Warwickshire, it should be remembered, are without several first choice players. Not only are Ian Bell, Jonathan Trott, Chris Woakes and Jeetan Patel absent on international duty (Woakes could yet be drafted into this game in place of Tom Milnes), but Tim Ambrose is absent with a thigh injury that may well keep him out of the CB40 final. Trott, too, may struggle to return for that game.

Here it was the bowling of Chris Wright and Keith Barker that gave Warwickshire the initiative. The pair bowled unchanged throughout the slightly extended first session - extended so as to include the entire Worcestershire first innings - and both achieved not just five-wicket hauls (Barker's fifth of the season; Wright's second) but surpassed 50 Championship wickets in a season for the first time in their careers.

Huge credit for their emergence must go to Warwickshire's bowling coach, Graeme Welch. Jim Troughton, the Warwickshire captain, referred to them as "unpolished diamonds" when they arrived at the club but, through the skills and belief instilled by Welch, they have developed into high-class bowlers that would find a place in many international sides. It is worth noting that both men went unwanted elsewhere: Barker first offered his services to Lancashire, while Wright has passed through the hands of Hampshire, Middlesex and Essex. Welch, in identifying and nurturing their talent, will have played as big a part in Warwickshire's success this season as anyone.

"We wanted to have a bowl anyway," Jim Troughton, the Warwickshire captain said afterwards. "And then neither bowler would give the ball back."

They complemented each other nicely: Barker, left-arm and persistent, found late swing, while Wright, right arm and a bit sharper, found seam and swing movement. The pitch had a hint of green and the conditions were overcast, but there were no terrors in either. Rhodes rated it as "one of our better wickets".

The truth is that the batting was painfully thin. Mitchell, perhaps deceived by Wright going wide on the crease, played across a straight one; Hughes, Matt Pardoe and Brett D'Oliveria pushed unnecessarily at ones that left them; Kervezee prodded at one he could have left and Ben Cox pulled obligingly to a deep fielder. Leach was beaten by inswing and Moeen Ali, feet in concrete, by outswing.

Later Varun Chopra, in registering his third Championship century of the campaign, provided not only a nudge to the England selectors but surpassed the Worcestershire total on his own. Alan Richardson demanded respect and, on 44, Chopra survived an edge off the admirable Chris Russell that flew through the slips for four. On the whole, however, Chopra eased to a century characterised by some elegant drives and dismissive cuts with ease.

It all means that, if Warwickshire score 350 and win this game, the Championship title will be theirs. Warwickshire do not have one hand on the County Championship trophy. They have it in a Bear hug.

George Dobell is a senior correspondent at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: George Dobell

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by Nomad73 on (September 5, 2012, 10:58 GMT)

Carpathian, I take your point (I too have seen the posts suggesting Hughes is sweeping all before him) but for me he is an interesting case. He is clearly very talented but see really see him as an opener, except maybe in 1 day cricket (in which, somewhat bizarrely, to my mind at least, he normally bats at 3 for Worcs).

If I were the Aussie selectors I'd get him to move down the order in FC cricket to about number 5 where the flaws in his technique would be less exposed. I'll also be looking to bring him into the 1 day squad and wait for him to deliver there before considering him for tests. Given the type of player that he is, I find it very odd that he has only ever represented Australia in tests.

Well done to The Bears though. Worthy champions elect.

Posted by CricketingStargazer on (September 5, 2012, 9:50 GMT)

It looks like that defeat to Middlesex last week has knocked the stuffing out of Worcestershire. One fears that Warwickshire could declare now on their overnight total and still win by an innings and a few. Congratulations to the side that has proved over the course of a difficult season to be, undoubtedly, the best all-round unit.

Posted by Carpathian on (September 5, 2012, 3:28 GMT)

Is see Phil Hughes' first-class batting average for the northern winter has now slipped below 40. Just thought I'd note this in case there's anyone still claiming he's dominated county cricket.

Posted by jackiethepen on (September 4, 2012, 22:28 GMT)

A lot of credit has to go to Ashley Giles who has backed players to come good after a lean spell. Ambrose and Troughton have both benefitted from this approach. Clarke had the same backing last year. When Bell went back to Warwickshire to improve his form, Giles spent 2 hours before a match advising him in the nets. Bell went on to get his first ton and pull Warks out of a hole of 14-4. Giles is a decent thoughtful coach who gets results. Other teams drop players who don't perform. Giles likes to coax the best out of them. Reminds me of Strauss. What a loss he will be to England.

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
George DobellClose
County Results
Hampshire v Warwickshire at Lord's - Sep 15, 2012
Hampshire won (lost fewer wickets)
Derbyshire v Hampshire at Derby - Sep 11-14, 2012
Derbyshire won by 6 wickets
Essex v Yorkshire at Chelmsford - Sep 11-14, 2012
Yorkshire won by 239 runs
Lancashire v Surrey at Liverpool - Sep 11-14, 2012
Match drawn
Leics v Gloucs at Leicester - Sep 11-14, 2012
Leics won by 2 wickets
Notts v Warwickshire at Nottingham - Sep 11-14, 2012
Match drawn
All recent results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days