Australia v India, Champions Trophy, Group A, Centurion

Spin could be India's weapon

India have been compelled to abandon their preferred formula and reinforce their bowling at the cost of their batting. It is a risk, but one worth taking

Sambit Bal in Centurion

September 27, 2009

Comments: 45 | Text size: A | A
Harbhajan Singh is pumped up after sending back Tillakaratne Dilshan, Sri Lanka v India, Compaq Cup, final, Colombo, September 14, 2009
Harbhajan Singh has an important role to play against Australia © Associated Press
Enlarge
Related Links
Series/Tournaments: ICC Champions Trophy
Teams: Australia | India

This tournament doesn't have a pause and that's the beauty of it. Only five days have passed, and it feels dizzy, and I mean that in the positive sense. The pitches have been interesting; after South Africa's unexpected loss and England's unexpected win, both matches involving Sri Lanka, there are no clear favourites any more.

And the West Indians, so derided before the tournament, have hardly been pushovers. Incredibly, with a little luck, they could have even been heading their group. And, even more incredibly, there remains a possibility - if only theoretical - of them making it through to the semi-finals still. For that this needs to happen: India must thrash Australia tomorrow, Pakistan must then beat Australia and top the group; and West Indies must beat India by a huge margin in the final group match.

But for any of this to happen of course, India have to turn up tomorrow. They came to the tournament as the number one team in the rankings - though that's not always synonymous with the best team - and, after only one game, they are one game away from elimination. It's a fate that has befallen them in two out three previous ICC events, yet they have a frighteningly simple task ahead of them: keep winning.

Their rivals are the defending champions. A lot has changed since Australia won the Champions Trophy in 2006, and then the World Cup in 2007, but they will bring to this match an 8-1 winning record since the start of this season, and a desire to set a couple of things straight against a team with which they have shared an interesting and piquant recent history. It was Dhoni's team that precipitated Australia's one-day slide by blanking them out of the tri-series final in 2008.

But those were different times. Australia were slipping from their lofty perch and India, perky, young, energetic and confident, were on the upswing. Ishant Sharma was sensational, RP Singh was swinging it, and Praveen Kumar was the surprising bowling hero. And of course Sachin Tendulkar was batting like a champion.

He still is. But it was the pace bowlers who won India the series then, and today they present Dhoni his biggest worry. Dhoni is a remarkably candid man. Yesterday, he minced no words in admitting that his bowlers had let the team down, today, he went a step further by conceding that they were low on confidence. Consquently, India have been compelled to abandon their preferred formula and reinforce their bowling at the cost of their batting. It is a risk, but one worth taking. In fact, they are one match late.

It is easy to understand why Dhoni has been wary of going down that path. None of his quick men can bat, and No. 8 is a spot too high for Harbhajan. Australia recovered from 171 for 7 to 275 through Mitchell Johnson and Brett Lee yesterday. Once Rahul Dravid was seventh out against Pakistan, India added ten. Admittedly, the quality of bowling and match situations were different but with Amit Mishra, who is certain to come in tomorrow, the tail will be lengthened. Yet Mishra, a legspinner in the classical mould and was a surprising success in the IPL, could hold the key.

As a one-day side, Australia are just about in the same place as India were in 2008. Ricky Ponting is batting majestically; Lee has recovered his zest and fitness, Johnson has grown as a bowler, and in Callum Ferguson, they have found a batsman with poise and skill and in Tim Paine, a young wicketkeeper batsman of unpredictable, and to the Indians, unknown quantity.

But if this side has a known weakness, it is against spin. The familiar theme in most of their one-day defeats this year has been a mid-innings struggle against spin. From Johan Botha to Shahid Afridi to Graeme Swann, they have all prospered against the Australian middle order. Expectedly Michael Clarke, who is unlikely to play tomorrow, has been their most prolific batsman against the spinners, but his runs have come at 4.11 per over; James Hopes and Brad Haddin, their two big strikers have scored at less than 4.00 and no batsman managed more than 5.00. Theoretically, Mishra and Harbhajan Singh, if he can find his mojo, could keep them under 80 runs off their 20 overs. Dhoni will miss the handy fillers from Yuvraj Singh and Virender Sehwag, but expect Suresh Raina to wheel away a few.

But of course, stats, history and theories are often of little use. If anything, this tournament has made rubbish of conventional wisdom almost every day. Common sense suggests Australia should win. India go in to the match low on talent and confidence, and the knowledge that they can not afford to blink. What they need to find is some inspiration and a couple of saviours.

Sambit Bal is the editor of Cricinfo

RSS Feeds: Sambit Bal

© ESPN EMEA Ltd.

Comments: 45 
Posted by varunjohn on (September 28 2009, 16:36 PM GMT)

Problem with Indian selectors and management is that they go for the big names rather than the ones who actually perform! Looking at Ishant Sharma's form today and (in recent times) he really doesn't deserve to be in the playing 11 as of now! He just cannot get his line and length right. Even the bowl to which he got Hussey out was very short and wide. I'm sure there are many more talented youngsters who should be given the opportunity as they have the hunger to perform. Even Karthik and Nayar should have been given a chance. Really do not understand Dhoni and co.'s tactics here! Maybe the problem lies with the fact that they don't have many options to start with. Indian team really needs some specialist pace bowlers like the likes of Shane Bond, Johnson, Lee, Steyn etc. We are a country of more than a billion people and I find it hard to believe that we can't produce a single front-line fast bowler who can consistently bowl at over 90 mph..

Posted by varunjohn on (September 28 2009, 12:35 PM GMT)

Totally agree with "nicric" here. Either the Indian selectors need to be changed or its just politics! They are making the same mistakes over and over again. Raina is a good bowler who has always bowled tidy spells under a pressure match. Don't understand why is not being used at all. Virat Kohli has been given too many chances to which he hasn't proved himself so why not give AM Nayar a chance??!! He can bowl too and is a good allrounder. If i remember correctly he played well in the practise match. I don't see a point in playing Sharma also again and again. I think his form is questionable and is just deteriorating since a while now. Sad being an Indian supporter but I wouldn't be surprised if we loose this one and are out of the tournament. I think Mr. Kris Srikanth needs a new job!

Posted by Jacz on (September 28 2009, 12:03 PM GMT)

Its a dream for every Indian to see India victorious tonight. This is a crunch match and the pressure is on Team India. If India make a score around 300+ always stand a chance to win tonight. Playing an additional spinner is also good. MS shouldn't repeat the mistake he has done in last match (not giving Suresh Raina a bowl and not taking the batting power play when Pathan came to bat) Indian Management should also think about some Rookie pacer when they go to countries like South Africa/Australia and West Indies. I was very impressed with the bowling and fielding of West Indies even though they are considered as 2nd or 3rd strings in this tournament. I wish all the best to Team India, If they apply themselves and put maximum effort in the field still have a chance in Champion's Trophy 2009

Posted by thealmighty on (September 28 2009, 11:57 AM GMT)

whatever the case guys we have to win today..the last 4 series have been won by india but have been either bilateral or triangular..If we want to be no 1 in the actual sense we have to win a icc event and its starts with champions trophy. I was disapointed with our performance against pakistan but it was a off day..sachin has to step up and lead us today as he has done for so many years. i hope bhaaji has the aura and the performance to indimidate pointing and his lads..lets just hope we win today after all its dussera..lol

Posted by cjscanada on (September 28 2009, 11:51 AM GMT)

Congrats to Younis and Pakistan. Younis is a thorough gentleman and a pleasant personality. Dhoni on the other hand is a good leader and has a good sense of the game but that is when the going is good for India. In order to be a successfull captain, let's wait amd see how he copes with failure.That is the time to test how good you are. Indians, mainly the media, over-reacts to short term result - take a cue from Peter Roebuck. Ishant and RP are good. They need some guidance. With Zaheer around that is missing. You cannot win each and every game - you can only try to. Having said that it amazes me how fickle minded some of the comments are. India is not a great team though they may have acheived the number one status. It's a good team. Remember this Indian team is a slow starter. I hope Yusuf is played and we retain the same team but change our strategy for the Aussies by having Pathan/Kohli open with Sachin as he is always there to provide valuable tips and calm. Have a go India.

Posted by rkp2106 on (September 28 2009, 11:46 AM GMT)

Is anyone reading or editing this drivel? I understand that given the pace of online publishing mistakes will be made. However, is it too much to ask for a carefully constructed sentence from a writer once in a while??? We can't all be Neville Cardus but Mr. Bal short, simple sentences would not hurt.

Posted by P44njv on (September 28 2009, 11:46 AM GMT)

well i think team india will perform to win today no matter yuvi and sehwag are missing and y ishant still in team and sreesanth in india doing nutting if any one seen him playing for warwick sreesanth was in v good form and they call him back to india.........anyway GOOD LUCK india

Posted by rkp2106 on (September 28 2009, 11:44 AM GMT)

Dear Editor, I write this in an effort to offer some constructive criticism to a website that I frequent as a avid cricket fan. My complaint relates to the frequent massacre of the English language by several of your "journalist's" that often render's their reportage on this most beautiful game almost unbearable. For an example of what I mean I refer you to an article entitled "Spin could be India's weapon" by a Mr. Bal. I have extracted the first two paragraphs of the delightful prose in question below. My comments appear in brackets.

Posted by Dcc823 on (September 28 2009, 11:42 AM GMT)

In response to Mrgupta: Sir, with due respect, i would say tht according to your observations, one like you should only pray tht India winning toss and batting first and they would win the match easily like other teams did. My dear, it is not only the case, someone has to stand up and make efforts like of Dilshan (116) Malik (128) etc.

Posted by nicric on (September 28 2009, 11:40 AM GMT)

One thing india and dhoni are miscalculatuing, i have followed raina as a cricketer since his under 19 days and he is a decent bowler, he is not a part-time bowler and certainly bowls better than yusuf pathan. he bowls quick flat off spin that is not easy to get away on any track. This has been poroved in the ipl and the compaq cup also. he bowled some 7 overs and went for around 25 odd runs. dhoni missed a easy trick and did not even try him for a single over against pakistan. raina has real potential to be an all-rounder and anyway he is a terrific fielder. He will only get better by bowling more overs in internationals and perfectly compliments harbhajans loopy off-spin. We should not be negitive and not bluntly get an extra bowler since depleting indias batting strength against australia is dangerous especially if we are chasing. Same goes with nayar. he could also bowl some good skiddy medium pacers. his bowling reminds me of guy whittal the former zimbabwe all rounder.

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Sambit BalClose
Sambit Bal Editor Sambit Bal took to journalism at the age of 19 after realising that he wasn't fit for anything else, and to cricket journalism 14 years later when it dawned on him that it provided the perfect excuse to watch cricket in the office. Among other things he has bowled legspin, occasionally landing the ball in front of the batsman; laid out the comics page of a newspaper; covered crime, urban development and politics; and edited Gentleman, a monthly features magazine. He joined Wisden in 2001 and edited Wisden Asia Cricket and Cricinfo Magazine. He still spends his spare time watching cricket.
Tournament Results
Australia v New Zealand at Centurion - Oct 5, 2009
Australia won by 6 wickets (with 28 balls remaining)
New Zealand v Pakistan at Johannesburg - Oct 3, 2009
New Zealand won by 5 wickets (with 13 balls remaining)
Australia v England at Centurion - Oct 2, 2009
Australia won by 9 wickets (with 49 balls remaining)
India v West Indies at Johannesburg - Sep 30, 2009
India won by 7 wickets (with 107 balls remaining)
Australia v Pakistan at Centurion - Sep 30, 2009
Australia won by 2 wickets (with 0 balls remaining)
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days
  • Cricinfo Widgets
Sponsored Links

Access your Indian Rupee earnings from anywhere in the world.

on registering and transfer of USD 250 and above.

At Cricshop.com