Mumbai A v England XI, Mumbai, 3rd day November 5, 2012

Compton states case with half-century

43

England XI 345 for 9 dec (Bairstow 118, Morgan 76, Patel 60) and 149 for 2 (Compton 64*) drew with Mumbai A 286 (Pujara 87, Shah 92)
Scorecard

As is the case with most three-day first-class games in India, there wasn't much at stake in terms of the result between the visiting England XI and Mumbai A at the Dr DY Patil Sports Stadium. But winning or losing was the last thing on everyone's mind in the England camp, for this game anyway, and they made full use of their last day in Mumbai on all counts.

After Graham Onions - just like James Anderson the previous evening - struck in his first over with the second new ball, the left-arm spin duo of Monty Panesar and Samit Patel didn't take long to dislodge the lower order; opener Nick Compton finally managed to occupy the crease for well over three ours - albeit against mediocre bowling; and, most importantly, Stuart Broad, who needed a scan on his heel on Sunday, was not just back on the field in the morning but also was cleared of a serious injury.

So, as the England camp wrapped up the first of their three Mumbai legs on the India tour, they would have been feeling slightly better than they were coming in to the game. Compton, who remained unbeaten on 64 when the teams shook hands, said there had been "a number of good performances" over the last week.

"[Alastair] Cook has got a hundred, [Jonny] Bairstow has got a hundred, Samit has batted consistently well," he said. "Panesar's bowling was accurate, exceptional. I do feel that some batsmen have played well and that does bode well."

After dismissing the remaining six Mumbai batsmen for 46 runs, England scored 149 for 2 in 52 overs - 22 of which were bowled by part-time bowlers. Compton, who was dismissed for 0 and 1 in his first two innings on tour, finally managed to get it right and helped raise England's highest opening partnership so far. Joe Root, who started off as impressively as in the first innings, fell shouldering arms to a Shardul Thakur delivery that came in and rapped him on the pads with the score on 38 but Compton carried on to get a more substantial feel of batting in Indian conditions.

And he was candid in admitting how difficult it is to concentrate on a day when there's nothing much at stake.

"Mentally it's quite challenging. It was a bit of a challenge when they brought on a couple of spinners who probably don't bowl that much in first-class cricket," Compton said. "But it's about having the right attitude in these situations, every single ball, every single minute is important. Especially for me, having missed out in the first game. It's more of a mental battle, getting back to run-scoring mode. The opposition wasn't brilliant at the end, but they bowled quite accurately in the first hour."

In the morning, Mumbai A's Hiken Shah, who started the day 16 runs shy of a deserved century, started off with two well-timed boundaries off Onions. However, the left-hander was then caught in two minds about whether to play at a ball that was going down leg and edged it to wicketkeeper Jonny Bairstow. Naturally, he was disappointed to have missed out on a hundred and stood his ground in disbelief before taking the long walk back. Panesar and Patel then made short work of the tail, picking off the last five Mumbai A wickets for 22 runs off 41 balls.

Amol Karhadkar is a correspondent at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Sarfin on November 6, 2012, 12:50 GMT

    India will be 50 times stronger than Mumbai A simply because Mumbai A is the 'second' team of a state which is playing in Ranji trophy with 23 other teams. So, 24*2 = 48. I want England to win. They did well against India A. But for me, they were not up to the mark against Mumbai A. And for Compton, one fifty in 4 innings against some less than medium pacers did not convince me. I still wish England top order will do better in Tests

  • Selassie-I on November 6, 2012, 11:29 GMT

    Sarfin - 50 times stronger? so by your reckoning India will score 14,300 runs before being bowled out by England and be able to bowl England out for less than 7 runs? Interesting statement...

    Personally, I'm happy with how the warm ups have gone, really ready for the test series now after all this T20 of late.

  • gsingh7 on November 6, 2012, 11:16 GMT

    4-0 WHITE WASH WAITING FOR ENGLAND , DHONI WUD DEFINATELY BEAT THEM INTO HIDING

  • Valavan on November 6, 2012, 9:43 GMT

    @maddy20, cooldown mate, first of all you mostly dig out with your comments like thrashing, preparing square turners and blah blah. I have never seen any unbiased comment, you just blow the trumpet - How India is this and that? JG make always good unbiased statements, the rest of English whine you and your friends to test your mental toughness, at the end as Hammond said, indian camp and fans are more nervous than england. cricinfo please publish.

  • Hammond on November 6, 2012, 8:54 GMT

    I think India will have the more nervous camp at the moment.

  • DINESHCC on November 6, 2012, 8:41 GMT

    SARFIN: "50 times stronger". WHO, WHERE, WHEN, HOW, AGAINST WHOM, WHY, WHAT?

  • maddy20 on November 6, 2012, 8:03 GMT

    @JG2704 I would suggest that you look at some other comments(such as the one made by subbass) before taking a dig at the Indian posters!

  • jmcilhinney on November 6, 2012, 5:16 GMT

    @Patchmaster on (November 06 2012, 04:01 AM GMT), I didn't/don't blame the poor WT20 performance on Pietersen or Broad. It was a collectively mediocre performance.

  • Patchmaster on November 6, 2012, 4:01 GMT

    Broad should be dropped, he's not fit enough, fast enough, and his batting certainly doesn't hold water. The fact they made him VC, is another giant blunder by management. Broad got away with awful captaincy in the T20 World Cup, because everyone blamed the terrible performance on Peiterson. In reality, Broad was as much at fault as anyone.

  • Akshita29 on November 6, 2012, 3:26 GMT

    There were many spelling mistakes in my previous comment . I mean to say that England's bowling was very good both in UAE and SL . And I feel the test series is going to be exciting .

  • No featured comments at the moment.