July 8, 2012

Wanted: education for players on ethics

Why the BCCI needs to invest in systems to let players know when they may be going astray

In May, when India TV released tapes of its sting operation uncovering potential black-money transactions, players openly flouting IPL rules, and possible spot-fixing, the BCCI needed to act fast to restore credibility. They did, conducting an enquiry that reached its conclusion in quick time. As important as it is to conduct a fair trial, it's equally important the process is quick and a conclusion is arrived at while the issue is still fresh in public memory. The punishments handed out to the guilty cricketers were also severe, and it can be said that the BCCI succeeded in setting the right precedent.

One can argue that while TP Sudhindra's crime of taking money to bowl a no-ball in a local league game deserved a life ban, the others were not guilty of much more than talking through their hats. The income tax department has given a clean chit to these cricketers because it found no evidence of ill-gotten monetary gain, so banning them might seem a bit harsh. While three of them will be serving one-year bans from competitive cricket, which theoretically means that they can return to represent their Ranji Trophy teams in 2013, in reality it could be the end of their careers, for states rarely reinstate tainted cricketers. If the BCCI has taken a tough stance, the state associations are also likely to follow suit.

I have spent enough time with cricketers to say with authority that bragging is an intrinsic part of most casual cricket conversations. There are always a couple of players in every team who like to talk big. Perhaps that's just what Abhinav Bali and Mohnish Mishra were doing. Unfortunately they were talking to strangers and were caught on camera. While banning players for bragging may be a little harsh, this article isn't about defending the guilty or criticising the punishments. It was important for the BCCI to take action because a strong message had to be sent across to every player in the country. Hopefully these sentences will work as a deterrent in the future.

While handing out severe punishments might be a logical end to an enquiry, it cannot stem the rot completely. If severe punishments could prevent players from indulging in match/spot-fixing, the likes of Salman Butt wouldn't have gone to jail in 2011 after several cricketers were banned for life in 2000. The most important lesson to be learnt from the Lord's spot-fixing was that you could go to jail for bowling an innocuous-looking no-ball. Unfortunately Sudhindra perhaps chose to learn something else: that there was money to be made by overstepping the line.

If severe punishments could prevent players from indulging in match/spot-fixing, the likes of Salman Butt wouldn't have gone to jail in 2011 after several cricketers were banned for life in 2000

Banning these five cricketers was relatively easy, and it shouldn't be considered as an end or a "solution". It addresses the outcome of the act, not the reasons for it. In fact, it should be seen as only the beginning of a tough process - that of creating an environment that discourages foul play, encourages awareness among players, and makes franchisees equally responsible when it comes to preventing corruption.

It's common knowledge that since the advent of the IPL, there has been a spike in the number of player-agents on the circuit. They not only promise players IPL deals (taking a hefty cut for their services) but also get lucrative deals for bat-stickers etc. Some of them even lure young cricketers with gifts, in cash and kind. There is an urgent need for the IPL, in association with the franchisees, to regularise this sector, which will make the processes involved transparent.

The BCCI has already put a system in place that educates every cricketer in the country about anti-doping laws and practices. There's also a 24-hour helpline that deals with day-to-day problems with regards to medicines prescribed by local doctors. There should be a similar structure in place to impart ethical education to players with regards to spot/match-fixing, the code of conduct, and so on. Also, a helpline, easily accessible to all players, for help on issues regarding signing an agent or discussing an offer made by a random sponsor, must be made available.

All IPL teams should also be instructed to lay down and enforce stringent rules of player conduct. Since the IPL, quite rightly, claims to be at par with international cricket, it must also follow the same discipline. The hotels the teams stay in should be sanitised, the events that the players attend should be monitored, and every player must be made aware of the consequences of falling out of line.

It may be an expensive and exhausting exercise to sanitise a tournament of the IPL's magnitude but if it enhances the credibility of the IPL, and of Indian cricket as a whole, it's worth every dollar spent. Not to mention the careers of young cricketers saved from the perils of modern cricket.

Former India opener Aakash Chopra is the author of Out of the Blue, an account of Rajasthan's 2010-11 Ranji Trophy victory. His website is here and his Twitter feed here

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Pranab on July 9, 2012, 10:20 GMT

    One major step in this regard could be to bring in complete professionalization in the area of player management. That all agents and agencies should be licensed by the BCCI and all authorized agencies to be allowed to manage players contract. The more we allow things to be unorganized the more they will remain murky.

  • Dummy4 on July 9, 2012, 7:59 GMT

    Totally agree. Sharad Pawar and N Srinivasan are indeed the right people to talk about ethics to young cricketers.

  • Ashok on July 9, 2012, 0:59 GMT

    Cricket now has opened the doors for every one to reach the top & play for India. However, India needs to start a compulsory passing of exam for all Cricketers playing in IPL, State level & National level regarding the code of conduct min Cricket including the rules of cricket. It should be more on the lines for passing the Driving exams in the Western countries like Canada & USA. This will make the potential top class cricketers aware of how to behave on & off the field & what cricket - a gentleman's Game - expects of them at any level. Some of the top Cricketers like Kohli are still short of the acceptable target regarding their temper & blue language. It is amazing that Kohli has been named India's vice captain with his current attitude. This where BCCI needs to step up. This will also answer Aakash's concern about corruption & Bribery in Cricket.

  • Dummy4 on July 8, 2012, 15:05 GMT

    It is a good idea to put such a system in practice, but the ideal place where the teaching of ethics should begin is at home and school. These are the shortcoming of our current education practices where value is not given to self development but money. We cannot expect BCCI to educate lakhs and lahks of upcoming cricketers every year. There is a saying in tamil that,what you cannot develop in someone at the age of five cannot be developed at the age of 50. Anyways it is better late than never too...

  • Anil on July 8, 2012, 14:55 GMT

    Akash, this time I do not quite agree with you. Taking money for doing wrong (like, bowling no-balls for money etc.) is wrong, every kid knows that. Do you suggest that we need to teach these 20-22yr olds this simple truth of life? Bragging too big for yourself is wrong too. Kids/people know it and still do it; that is human folly. Education cannot change that; punishment can. If someone did not learn anything from recent Asif-Amir episode, I doubt any educationing can do any good. The bigger problem is our national mentality and attitude. From poor to rich, educated to illeterate, bribing is so rampant in our country that we are basically a nation of bribes. It is both shameless and painful that we expect cricketers to be honest, while we ourselves are not.

  • No featured comments at the moment.