Matches (18)
IPL (3)
PAK v WI [W] (1)
BAN v IND [W] (1)
SL vs AFG [A-Team] (1)
NEP vs WI [A-Team] (1)
County DIV1 (4)
County DIV2 (3)
WT20 Qualifier (4)
Ian Chappell

Get Root higher up at No. 3

England should look to make the most of his potential because unlike Gary Ballance, he does not get bogged down against pace or spin

Ian Chappell
Ian Chappell
12-Jul-2015
Root would be better off swapping places with Ballance in the XI  •  Getty Images

Root would be better off swapping places with Ballance in the XI  •  Getty Images

There are still sceptics among the flat-earth mob but there's no doubt climate change has hit English cricket.
Their rapid progression from a timid, attritional team to an aggressively fearless batting line-up, backed by a skilled attack bowling with discipline, has been a revelation. Two months ago England, purely on the basis of being a participant, had a 10% chance of winning back the Ashes; on their early showing in the series, they're (at worst) a fifty-fifty bet.
The question is whether they can retain their entertaining but practical approach through the tough periods as well as when they're on top. If they can hold their nerve, it's a style that affords them their best chance of wresting back the Ashes.
Joe Root is the symbol of the new England. He's not a gung-ho strokemaker like Ben Stokes or Jos Buttler, or even Moeen Ali, but there's never any doubt about his intent when on strike; he's looking to score at every opportunity. It's an intent that marks the difference between the average batsman and the best international players.
Just as importantly, he has displayed this approach when the team is in trouble. He did it against New Zealand and repeated the dose against Australia in Cardiff. This prompts the question whether, like his young Australian counterpart Steven Smith, he should agitate for a rise in the batting order.
Smith has bucked a modern trend to languish in the middle order as cover for early setbacks, by adopting the cricketing equivalent of the Welsh rugby adage: "Get your retaliation in first."
In addition to being a potential England captain, Root has the ingredients to be a successful No. 3 batsman. He's technically efficient, plays pace and spin well, and can mount a counter-attack. This makes him a better option than the incumbent, Gary Ballance, a dogged but stodgy wicket-preserver who is easily bogged down.
If England want further improvement they should swap these two in the batting order. Ballance's regular periods of inactivity against both pace and spin will bog England down and frustrate the strokemakers at the other end. He needs to devise a method of scoring singles more regularly so he doesn't keep the faster scorers on edge while waiting to face a delivery.
Also, his method against Mitchell Johnson's short deliveries - a prod and a prayer - are a confidence booster for a bowler who has struggled in English conditions but whose success is closely allied to Australia's fortunes. England dented Johnson's confidence in the first innings in Cardiff; they shouldn't then act as benevolent panel-beaters.
The tour began with Australia's attack supposedly the more penetrative. After the early going it's evident Australia have the faster attack, but they also tend to be profligate. If they're not taking wickets regularly, the two Mitchells dilute Michael Clarke's captaincy advantage because they make it difficult for him to attack as he'd wish.
Then there's the possible domino effect of Ryan Harris' departure. Compounded by Starc's injury, it probably means an opportunity for Peter Siddle, who could offer Clarke more control. The domino effect is often precipitous among older teams and Australia will be concerned that Harris' injury sets off the toppling.
On the other hand, England's disciplined bowling enabled Alastair Cook to face down a considerable demon - the inability to erase the pesky lower half of Australia's batting order cheaply. Cardiff was a big improvement on England's last Ashes series and the bowling perfectly complemented Root's substantial contribution.
The rise to stardom of players like Root and Smith is a reminder of how the game keeps regenerating. Like with Virat Kohli for India, the maturing of skilful young players may not cause fans to forget a retired superstar but it gives them reason for continued interest in the game.
Just as the game regenerates through its players it also evolves as a spectacle. Two months ago no one could have predicted a drastic change of philosophy by England; now no one can doubt they're a legitimate challenger for the urn.

Former Australia captain Ian Chappell is now a cricket commentator for Channel 9, and a columnist