England in New Zealand 2007-08 March 26, 2008

Sidebottom makes the difference

Stats review of the three-Test series between New Zealand and England


Ryan Sidebottom won his personal battles against Stephen Fleming, and became the first England bowler in nearly 30 years to take 24 wickets in a three-Test series © Getty Images
 

By winning the three-Test series after losing the first game, Michael Vaughan's team emulated a feat achieved by only three other England teams. In 2000-01, they edged Sri Lanka in the last two Tests after losing the first, but the two other instances were way back in the 1880s. (Click here for the full list of come-from-behind series wins.)

Like you'd expect in such a close, there wasn't much to choose between the two teams - the batting for both teams was less than convincing, though England redeemed themselves in the last Test, while the onus of taking wickets was largely on the fast bowlers. The difference between the runs per wicket for the two teams was just two runs, but where New Zealand lost out was in their inability to convert starts into centuries: 14 times their batsmen topped 50, but apart from Ross Taylor's 120 in Hamilton, none went on to a hundred. England's lack of centuries had been a talking point of late, but here they rediscovered that habit, scoring four hundreds, three of which came in the crucial last Test.

Runs per wkt for both teams
Team Runs Wickets Average Runs/ over 100s/ 50s
England 1813 57 31.80 2.74 4/ 7
New Zealand 1755 59 29.74 3.37 1/ 13

New Zealand's biggest problem was their top-order batting. Matthew Bell was woeful in five out of six innings, while Mathew Sinclair was even worse. Their six opening stands in the series produced 44, 1, 4, 18, 1, and 48 - 116 runs at an average of 19.33. The average partnerships for the third and fifth wickets were even worse. Among the partnerships for the top five wickets, the only one which consistently produced the runs was the second-wicket stand, thanks largely to Stephen Fleming's presence at No. 3. His associations with Jamie How were the most profitable for New Zealand - the two added 269 runs in four innings at an average of 67.25. The sixth and seventh wickets also helped them beef up their total, with Daniel Vettori and Brendon McCullum contributing consistently in every game.

England's top order, on the other hand, was relatively more prolific. The biggest disappointment was their captain - Michael Vaughan finished with a disappointing 123 runs in six innings - but the rest of the batsmen all averaged more than 30. The partnerships for each of the top-order wickets were more significant as well; the only exception was the third-wicket stand, which averaged a meagre 20.33.

Average partnerships per wicket
Wicket Eng - ave stand 100s/ 50s NZ - ave stand 100s/ 50s
First 35.33 0/ 2 19.33 0/ 0
Second 31.33 1/ 1 69.83 1/ 4
Third 20.33 0/ 1 12.67 0/ 0
Fourth 52.67 1/ 0 34.50 0/ 2
Fifth 44.16 0/ 2 10.83 0/ 0
Sixth 50.67 1/ 1 46.16 1/ 2
Seventh 30.83 0/ 2 35.67 1/ 1
Eighth 24.80 0/ 0 24.16 0/ 0
Ninth 9.40 0/ 0 21.00 0/ 0
Tenth 10.00 0/ 0 22.00 0/ 1

England's biggest strength throughout the series was Ryan Sidebottom. He was easily the outstanding bowler from either side, with 24 wickets at 17.08. His haul is among the highest for England in a three-Test series. Only three times has a bowler taken more than 24 - George Lohmann took 35 against South Africa in 1895-96, while the same team suffered on two other occasions as well, as Sydney Barnes took 34 during the Triangular Tournament in 1912, and Colin Blythe nailed 26 in 1907. The last time an England bowler took 24 in a three-Test series was nearly 30 years back, when Ian Botham destroyed New Zealand.

Sidebottom took more than 50% of the wickets that fell to the England seamers. Remove him from the equation, and the rest gave away 40 runs per wicket, which was largely due to the disappointing performances of Steve Harmison and Matthew Hoggard in the first Test.

New Zealand's seam attack was in splendid form too, with Jacob Oram and Kyle Mills the outstanding performers, while Tim Southee had a debut to remember. Overall, the New Zealand pace attack was slightly more effective than their England counterparts.

Fast bowlers from both teams
Team Wickets Average 5WI/ 10WM Strike rate Econ rate
New Zealand 41 26.60 1/ 0 58.6 2.72
England 47 28.51 4/ 1 49.8 3.42
England minus Sidebottom 23 40.43 1/ 0 65.2 3.72

The battle of the left-arm spinners, though, was won quite convincingly by Panesar, who sealed the series with his six-wicket haul in the last innings. Vettori was tidy throughout, but struggled for wickets - his strike rate was a poor 134.5, which is more than 22 overs per wicket.

Battle of the left-arm spinners
Bowler Wickets Average 5WI/ 10WM Strike rate Econ rate
Monty Panesar 11 30.18 1/ 0 66.8 2.71
Daniel Vettori 7 54.71 0/ 0 134.5 2.43

Player v player stats

The one New Zealand batsman who handled Sidebottom successfully was Ross Taylor: in 154 deliveries, he scored 88 runs and was dismissed just once. Fleming clearly came out second-best in his battle against Sidebottom, falling to him three times in 112 deliveries.

Taylor was far more circumspect against Panesar, who, in turn, failed to dismiss his opposite number even once in 83 deliveries. Mills was New Zealand's best bowler against England's top three; though Southee was superb in Napier as his replacement, Mills' absence clearly hurt New Zealand in the last match.

Player v player stats from the series
Batsman Bowler Runs Balls Dismissals Average
Stephen Fleming Ryan Sidebottom 50 112 3 16.67
Jacob Oram Ryan Sidebottom 19 51 3 6.33
Ross Taylor Ryan Sidebottom 88 154 1 88.00
Ross Taylor Monty Panesar 41 139 2 20.50
Daniel Vettori Monty Panesar 51 83 0 -
Andrew Strauss Kyle Mills 24 67 2 12.00
Michael Vaughan Kyle Mills 31 92 2 15.50
Alastair Cook Kyle Mills 39 87 2 19.50

S Rajesh is stats editor of Cricinfo