Zimbabwe v South Africa, 2nd ODI, Bulawayo August 18, 2014

Can Zimbabwe stay competitive for longer?

15

Match facts

Tuesday, August 19, 2014
Start time 0930 local (0730 GMT)

Big Picture

The hypothesis is, the shorter the format the smaller the gulf between teams, but it has not applied in Zimbabwe's case. They had the spirit to spar with South Africa's seamers in the one-off Test, when their bowlers were disciplined and their batsmen determined, but were blown away in the first ODI, when they lacked bite and basics. The realisation they lost that game in the space of 23 overs is what will hurt the hosts most.

Zimbabwe conceded 120 in the last 11 overs, which allowed South Africa to exceed the par score of around 280, and then crumbled to 35 for 3 in the first 12 overs of the chase. That period apart, Zimbabwe managed to drag South Africa's run-rate back after Quinton de Kock's striking start, and then Hamilton Masakadza and Sean Williams showed what could be achieved with a little application.

The next step for the hosts will be to try and increase the length of the good period and shrink those 23 overs in which they got almost everything wrong. That will require effort from every member of the side, particularly Elton Chigumbura, who will have to be more assertive as captain.

South Africa captain AB de Villiers' tour could also do with livening up but he has none of the worries of his counterpart. His top order did one half of the job in the first ODI and his bowling attack the other. Though some areas - like spin bowling - needed tightening, the chief thought on de Villiers' mind will be that the series can be sealed and South Africa could have earned a trophy before Tuesday ends.

Form guide

(last five completed games, most recent first)

Zimbabwe LLLWW
South Africa WWLWW

In the spotlight

Brendan Taylor will no longer be keeping wicket because the coach Stephen Mangongo would like a "specialist" in the job. Because Taylor is no longer the ODI captain, he has been completely unburdened to concentrate on his batting. He got himself out in the first match against South Africa and also had an inconsistent run against Afghanistan, when he made one half-century and three middling scores. Taylor will be Zimbabwe's key batsman at the World Cup and there is no better time for him to find form than against a team like South Africa.

The strength of South Africa's top order did not allow David Miller an opportunity to play a part in the first match. Miller had similar issues in Sri Lanka and is facing the reality that the better the top four get the less time he may have at the crease. He will have to make an impact in short and sharp bursts while finishing an innings. If Miller gets it right, South Africa could mount totals far too large for Zimbabwe to scale.

Team news

The questions regarding Zimbabwe's line-up start at the top. Vusi Sibanda was dropped during the series against Afghanistan and if Sikandar Raza is fully recovered from his broken thumb, he may open with Richmond Mutumbami. In the pace department, Shingi Masakadza may sit out after being both expensive and wicketless. Brian Vitori would be the automatic choice if his ankle niggle has healed.

Zimbabwe (likely) 1 Vusi Sibanda/Sikandar Raza, 2 Richmond Mutumbami (wk), 3 Hamilton Masakadza, 4 Brendan Taylor, 5 Sean Williams, 6 Elton Chigumbura (capt), 7 Luke Jongwe 8 Neville Madziva, 9 John Nyumbu, 10 Prosper Utseya, 11 Brian Vitori

AB de Villiers indicated he would prefer to use an unchanged XI to win the series and save experimentation for the final ODI.

South Africa: (likely) 1 Hashim Amla, 2 Quinton de Kock (wk), 3 Faf du Plessis, 4 JP Duminy, 5 AB de Villiers (capt), 6 David Miller, 7 Ryan McLaren, 8 Wayne Parnell, 9 Kyle Abbott, 10 Aaron Phangiso, 11 Imran Tahir

Pitch an conditions

The Bulawayo surface was sluggish for the first ODI and spinners were able to slow the run rate for large swathes of it. Though the second game will be played on a different pitch, a similar pattern can be expected, with scoring laboured but far from impossible against substantial turn. The weather is expected to be warmer, with clear skies and a high of 24 degrees.

Stats and trivia

  • Of the batsmen Hashim Amla has had at least 15 partnerships with, his second-highest average is with Quinton de Kock. Amla and de Kock have put on 963 runs - with four century and three fifty partnerships - in 15 innings at 64.20, an average that is only behind his 81.77 with de Villiers.

  • The stats are overwhelmingly in favour of bowling first at Queens Sports Club. Teams have bowled 35 times after winning the toss and won 22 of those games, while sides that chose to bat have won nine out of 24 games.

Quotes

"This is a 300 wicket. If we can restrict South Africa to less than 300, we would have done a good job."Zimbabwe captain Elton Chigumbura predicts another high-scoring game

"300 was above par. There were thoughts of 250 at one time and even Hashim said he didn't think we would get to 300. If the wicket looks similar, we will bat first again."AB de Villiers is not sure there are big scores in the Bulawayo pitch

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • sohanpandey578 on August 19, 2014, 6:52 GMT

    FAF shouldn't be in ODIs. Better Killer Miller bat at 4, ABD at 3.

  • ForeverProtea on August 19, 2014, 6:11 GMT

    I don't understand Faf. He knows the two extremes and nothing in between. He either only blocks (what he does is tests) or only smashes (what he does is T20s).

    Great to see QdK&Hash give SA another great platform. Really hope Rilee gets at least one game this series. He is such an exciting player who has been the backbone of the Knights and SA A teams.

  • on August 19, 2014, 4:40 GMT

    No, plain and simple, no explanation needed

  • on August 19, 2014, 4:30 GMT

    i smell a century ...might be 16th one ...its hash ...would be harsh if i say its hashtag....atlest 5 centuries in this series and tri series...hashim has not scored a ton in odi against aussies...

  • on August 19, 2014, 4:11 GMT

    ziM best of luck vitori chatara and panyangara back plz

  • on August 19, 2014, 2:12 GMT

    If they win this match, they'll probably give Rossouw a go in the dead rubber. Though Shezi could be given a shot this time around.

  • Greatest_Game on August 18, 2014, 23:13 GMT

    The grind wins tests, but ODIs need an attacking mindset. de Kock is by nature attacking, but needs guidance & Hash must give it with word AND with bat, pacing the innings with him! Hash was a little slow in the 1st ODI, & must not allow QdK to push too hard. He must attack in balance & rhythm with QdK, & not let him race off. Consistent strike rotation is key. Bowlers & field rushing to adjust to left/right batting are always disadvantaged.

    Less than 300 is not dominating! A player carrying his bat needs SR 100+, or someone else has to score those runs. 100+ cannot realistically be expected in the last 10 overs every match. Chasing is SA's Achilles heel, & SA needs to practice it, even batting 1st. The lineup needs to develop a calm, confident 'chasing mindset.' SA must set themselves bigger & bigger targets. We have the batting strength to dominate from ball 1. Now we must focus on & develop the rhythm, the 'feel' of walking out & taking control immediately, & keeping control.

  • chinthak99 on August 18, 2014, 19:47 GMT

    any guess who will be the man of the match

  • TommytuckerSaffa on August 18, 2014, 19:02 GMT

    Same team? Thats madness, I would like Shezi and Rilee Roussouw to have a go.

  • Tapcan19 on August 18, 2014, 17:58 GMT

    As much as im not enjoying Vusi's form,i still want him to prove to me how much he can Bat because he surely can and im so mad at the guy that as much as i want him in the team,i want him rested or given a spot down the order so that he wont dissapoint me again and again...Zim should not be experimenting at this point, we got our best 11 lets field for practice sake the worldcup is so near.... 1)Vusi/Taylor 2)Raza 3)Hamilton 4)Taylor/Vusi 5)Chigumbura 6)Williams 7)Mutumbami 8)Utseya 9)Panyangara 10)Chatara 11)Vittori

  • sohanpandey578 on August 19, 2014, 6:52 GMT

    FAF shouldn't be in ODIs. Better Killer Miller bat at 4, ABD at 3.

  • ForeverProtea on August 19, 2014, 6:11 GMT

    I don't understand Faf. He knows the two extremes and nothing in between. He either only blocks (what he does is tests) or only smashes (what he does is T20s).

    Great to see QdK&Hash give SA another great platform. Really hope Rilee gets at least one game this series. He is such an exciting player who has been the backbone of the Knights and SA A teams.

  • on August 19, 2014, 4:40 GMT

    No, plain and simple, no explanation needed

  • on August 19, 2014, 4:30 GMT

    i smell a century ...might be 16th one ...its hash ...would be harsh if i say its hashtag....atlest 5 centuries in this series and tri series...hashim has not scored a ton in odi against aussies...

  • on August 19, 2014, 4:11 GMT

    ziM best of luck vitori chatara and panyangara back plz

  • on August 19, 2014, 2:12 GMT

    If they win this match, they'll probably give Rossouw a go in the dead rubber. Though Shezi could be given a shot this time around.

  • Greatest_Game on August 18, 2014, 23:13 GMT

    The grind wins tests, but ODIs need an attacking mindset. de Kock is by nature attacking, but needs guidance & Hash must give it with word AND with bat, pacing the innings with him! Hash was a little slow in the 1st ODI, & must not allow QdK to push too hard. He must attack in balance & rhythm with QdK, & not let him race off. Consistent strike rotation is key. Bowlers & field rushing to adjust to left/right batting are always disadvantaged.

    Less than 300 is not dominating! A player carrying his bat needs SR 100+, or someone else has to score those runs. 100+ cannot realistically be expected in the last 10 overs every match. Chasing is SA's Achilles heel, & SA needs to practice it, even batting 1st. The lineup needs to develop a calm, confident 'chasing mindset.' SA must set themselves bigger & bigger targets. We have the batting strength to dominate from ball 1. Now we must focus on & develop the rhythm, the 'feel' of walking out & taking control immediately, & keeping control.

  • chinthak99 on August 18, 2014, 19:47 GMT

    any guess who will be the man of the match

  • TommytuckerSaffa on August 18, 2014, 19:02 GMT

    Same team? Thats madness, I would like Shezi and Rilee Roussouw to have a go.

  • Tapcan19 on August 18, 2014, 17:58 GMT

    As much as im not enjoying Vusi's form,i still want him to prove to me how much he can Bat because he surely can and im so mad at the guy that as much as i want him in the team,i want him rested or given a spot down the order so that he wont dissapoint me again and again...Zim should not be experimenting at this point, we got our best 11 lets field for practice sake the worldcup is so near.... 1)Vusi/Taylor 2)Raza 3)Hamilton 4)Taylor/Vusi 5)Chigumbura 6)Williams 7)Mutumbami 8)Utseya 9)Panyangara 10)Chatara 11)Vittori

  • ZCFOutkast on August 18, 2014, 16:36 GMT

    Yeah push everyone up except AB! He should really be batting in the top 3, but golden boy won't be moved now will he! I don't see why Faf should be batting ahead of JP either, or in the first team at all when van Zyl&Rossouw ar ebreaking the door down(clearly helps being AB's buddy). When you're ranked #1 but are never domainant yet conduct yourself a a follower, you can't blame people for never noticing you are #1. It seems selectors are intent on copying England - Trott at 3 inn ODIs&Tests, we throw Faf in. In ODIs Root at 4 post KP, AB at 4 post Kallis! Split coaching, split captaincy etc. Only difference is with bowling allrounders with Broad&Philander going opposite directions out&in the team respectively. No wonder Cook's now mad enough to compare Steyn&Jimmy!

    Parnell, Abott&Tahir were underwhelming. ZIM collapse through throwing their wickets away rescued Tahir's stats. Queue Marchant&Shezi for two of those 3.

  • SamWintson92 on August 18, 2014, 16:15 GMT

    I don't get why Zim axed Chatara !

    ZIM XI for 2nd ODI: (Taylor should open, Waller in for Jongwe, Panyangara in for S Masakadza, Vitori in for Madziva) 1 Taylor 2 Raza 3 H Masakadza 4 Williams 5 Waller 6 Chigumbura (C) 7 Mutumbami (WK) 8 Utseya 9 Nyumbu 10 Panyangara 11 Vitori.

  • on August 18, 2014, 16:11 GMT

    The team should be Vusi,raza,hami,taylor,williams,mutumbami,chigumbura,utseya,panyangara,chatara,vittori. I dont think zim can afford to experiment too much given that they play too few international cricket in a year. They need to put their best eleven in the park and look to make the most of the games they play in this year as world cup is approaching.

  • RoyRulez on August 18, 2014, 15:01 GMT

    Same XI is fine but SA could push JP and Miller at No. 3 or 4 in the second and third games... It will give them some practice before the tri-series...

    They did something similar in New Zealand in 2012 and AB is known to slide down the order against weaker opponents!!!

    Miller hardly ever gets a chance to bat in this SA team... In the last 12 matches, he has played more than 25 balls only ONCE!!!

  • ZCFOutkast on August 18, 2014, 14:24 GMT

    Taylor is an opener. Unburdened with everything (captaincy, keeping, poor fielder) maybe it makes sense for him to go back to doing that job of opening. If Chigumbura won't be bowling much then he must bat above Williams out of whom 10 overs are expected.

    I know these 3 ODIs are being used to experiment ahead of the TriSeries with Australia, but we've seen enough to know that international cricket is a bit too soon for Jongwe&Madziva, plus they don't have enough quality to lenghten the tail anyway. Nyumbu is good, but LOIs are not for him. Very easy to get on top of. We were surpised when Shingi was left out of many sides recently but the selectors were clearly spot on there. Assuming they are fit, Zimbabwe need their best four bowlers to compete against the Proteas. ZIMBABWE CRICKET, please show some respect and field the BEST batsmen&bowlers to make the series competitive!

    Taylor, Raza, Hami, Vusi, Chigumbura(c), Williams, Mutumbami(wk), Utseya, Panyangara, Chatara, Vitori.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • ZCFOutkast on August 18, 2014, 14:24 GMT

    Taylor is an opener. Unburdened with everything (captaincy, keeping, poor fielder) maybe it makes sense for him to go back to doing that job of opening. If Chigumbura won't be bowling much then he must bat above Williams out of whom 10 overs are expected.

    I know these 3 ODIs are being used to experiment ahead of the TriSeries with Australia, but we've seen enough to know that international cricket is a bit too soon for Jongwe&Madziva, plus they don't have enough quality to lenghten the tail anyway. Nyumbu is good, but LOIs are not for him. Very easy to get on top of. We were surpised when Shingi was left out of many sides recently but the selectors were clearly spot on there. Assuming they are fit, Zimbabwe need their best four bowlers to compete against the Proteas. ZIMBABWE CRICKET, please show some respect and field the BEST batsmen&bowlers to make the series competitive!

    Taylor, Raza, Hami, Vusi, Chigumbura(c), Williams, Mutumbami(wk), Utseya, Panyangara, Chatara, Vitori.

  • RoyRulez on August 18, 2014, 15:01 GMT

    Same XI is fine but SA could push JP and Miller at No. 3 or 4 in the second and third games... It will give them some practice before the tri-series...

    They did something similar in New Zealand in 2012 and AB is known to slide down the order against weaker opponents!!!

    Miller hardly ever gets a chance to bat in this SA team... In the last 12 matches, he has played more than 25 balls only ONCE!!!

  • on August 18, 2014, 16:11 GMT

    The team should be Vusi,raza,hami,taylor,williams,mutumbami,chigumbura,utseya,panyangara,chatara,vittori. I dont think zim can afford to experiment too much given that they play too few international cricket in a year. They need to put their best eleven in the park and look to make the most of the games they play in this year as world cup is approaching.

  • SamWintson92 on August 18, 2014, 16:15 GMT

    I don't get why Zim axed Chatara !

    ZIM XI for 2nd ODI: (Taylor should open, Waller in for Jongwe, Panyangara in for S Masakadza, Vitori in for Madziva) 1 Taylor 2 Raza 3 H Masakadza 4 Williams 5 Waller 6 Chigumbura (C) 7 Mutumbami (WK) 8 Utseya 9 Nyumbu 10 Panyangara 11 Vitori.

  • ZCFOutkast on August 18, 2014, 16:36 GMT

    Yeah push everyone up except AB! He should really be batting in the top 3, but golden boy won't be moved now will he! I don't see why Faf should be batting ahead of JP either, or in the first team at all when van Zyl&Rossouw ar ebreaking the door down(clearly helps being AB's buddy). When you're ranked #1 but are never domainant yet conduct yourself a a follower, you can't blame people for never noticing you are #1. It seems selectors are intent on copying England - Trott at 3 inn ODIs&Tests, we throw Faf in. In ODIs Root at 4 post KP, AB at 4 post Kallis! Split coaching, split captaincy etc. Only difference is with bowling allrounders with Broad&Philander going opposite directions out&in the team respectively. No wonder Cook's now mad enough to compare Steyn&Jimmy!

    Parnell, Abott&Tahir were underwhelming. ZIM collapse through throwing their wickets away rescued Tahir's stats. Queue Marchant&Shezi for two of those 3.

  • Tapcan19 on August 18, 2014, 17:58 GMT

    As much as im not enjoying Vusi's form,i still want him to prove to me how much he can Bat because he surely can and im so mad at the guy that as much as i want him in the team,i want him rested or given a spot down the order so that he wont dissapoint me again and again...Zim should not be experimenting at this point, we got our best 11 lets field for practice sake the worldcup is so near.... 1)Vusi/Taylor 2)Raza 3)Hamilton 4)Taylor/Vusi 5)Chigumbura 6)Williams 7)Mutumbami 8)Utseya 9)Panyangara 10)Chatara 11)Vittori

  • TommytuckerSaffa on August 18, 2014, 19:02 GMT

    Same team? Thats madness, I would like Shezi and Rilee Roussouw to have a go.

  • chinthak99 on August 18, 2014, 19:47 GMT

    any guess who will be the man of the match

  • Greatest_Game on August 18, 2014, 23:13 GMT

    The grind wins tests, but ODIs need an attacking mindset. de Kock is by nature attacking, but needs guidance & Hash must give it with word AND with bat, pacing the innings with him! Hash was a little slow in the 1st ODI, & must not allow QdK to push too hard. He must attack in balance & rhythm with QdK, & not let him race off. Consistent strike rotation is key. Bowlers & field rushing to adjust to left/right batting are always disadvantaged.

    Less than 300 is not dominating! A player carrying his bat needs SR 100+, or someone else has to score those runs. 100+ cannot realistically be expected in the last 10 overs every match. Chasing is SA's Achilles heel, & SA needs to practice it, even batting 1st. The lineup needs to develop a calm, confident 'chasing mindset.' SA must set themselves bigger & bigger targets. We have the batting strength to dominate from ball 1. Now we must focus on & develop the rhythm, the 'feel' of walking out & taking control immediately, & keeping control.

  • on August 19, 2014, 2:12 GMT

    If they win this match, they'll probably give Rossouw a go in the dead rubber. Though Shezi could be given a shot this time around.