The Surfer
Ramachandra Guha questions the choice of Pune and Kochi for the two new franchises in the IPL, arguing in the Kolkata-based Telegraph that neither city has a cricketing reason to get a spot in the Twenty20 tournament
... this tournament both reflects and further intensifies a deep divide between the India of wealth and entitlement and the India — or Bharat — of poverty and disenfranchisement. Writing about the dangerous growth of inequality in India, the economist, Amartya Sen, warned some years ago that if present trends continued, half of India would look like the American state of California, the other half like sub-Saharan Africa. Since he made this comment, California has been beset with an acute — and apparently irreversible — fiscal crisis. Perhaps we might then substitute the state of Massachusetts for it. But the point remains; there are indeed two Indias, the one which is awarded IPL franchises, and the other which is not.
The Observer says the mad dash for Twenty20 riches by the game's administrators is serving neither spectators nor players
It is time for a coherent plan to be formulated by the ECB alongside its international partners that provides a balance between all forms of the game, which allows our players the time and space to improve, which will last more than one season and which does not necessarily kowtow to the largest cheque.
Peter Roebuck asks in the Hindu whether Twenty20 players can achieve greatness, though the stage is smaller
Cricket has been as good as any other sport at enticing greatness from the recesses of the mind. Now, though, greatness faces an unprecedented challenge. It needs to cut its teeth in a format that does not require its existence.
Youngsters can become stars, millionaires and celebrities without so much as trying to make greatness's acquaintance. But a game dies without greatness.
In the Guardian , Mike Selvey is highly critical of the ECB's move to stretch the county season at both ends, which he believes has compromised the championship's integrity.
So disrespectful is the schedule to the integrity of the County Championship – for which the winners will receive £500,000... – that some will have completed four matches before the daffs are over, with all the impact of the weather, and half the programme by the time the football World Cup kicks off. It is as if the County Championship, which should provide the breeding ground for future England Test cricketers, has become the stale bread surrounding a cash-cow filling of Twenty20.
The sheer presence of the IPL is such that it demands to be watched
The IPL pursues revenues at the expense of other valuable resources: Test cricket, but also domestic cricket, the inevitable breeding grounds for young talent. In its grubbing for money, in fact, the IPL is dismissive of anything old-fashioned, anything aesthetic; even the four seconds between one ball and the next, held sacrosanct through more than a century of cricket, have been sold for inconsequential advertisements. Meanwhile, owners buy teams for staggering quantities of money and with the fuzziest possibilities of recovering their investment; they desire only to dice up the risk and sell it in parts to sponsors and other companies, a practice that should surely sound familiar to us today.
In the Wisden Cricketer , Lawrence Booth lists five things he would like to see in the new county season which is about to begin
Fingers crossed for Simon Jones. Hampshire are the latest county to take a gamble, but his career has long since lapsed into a nostalgic gaze at 2005 and the fear must be that his fragile body will break down again. Even so, a dream: Jones – whenever he makes it back on the field – holds it together for just long enough to have one more tilt at the Aussies and put the Brisbane 2002-03 nightmare behind him.
Altus Momberg writes in supersport.com that the South African playerspoor form in the IPL is jeopardising the national side's preparations for the World Twenty20 tournament.
It was hoped beforehand that the majority of the national players would get regular game time in the IPL so that it would serve as ideal preparation for the World tournament. However, the opposite has transpired, with the likes of AB de Villiers, Mark Boucher and JP Duminy spectators in the IPL.
He may have been dropped by the England and Yorkshire selectors, but Matthew Hoggard, in his new role as captain of Leicestershire, tells the Guardian that he has a lot to offer to his new county.
Coming to Leicestershire as captain gives me a clean slate. I've come here to do a job which I'm more than capable of doing. I'm going to prove that to myself and my team and become a good leader. The key will be to judge the situation right. Is it time for me to put a hand around their shoulders or give them a rocket up the arse? I need to get that right but I'll still tell the truth. I'll call a shovel a shovel and a pick a pick.
Sir Alec Bedser's death has triggered a series of tributes
Gathering himself at the start of his run-in with three walking steps, he would approach the wicket with nine mastodontic strides. Arrived at the crease, his left arm would be flung up high, while his body — pivoting on a firmly braced left leg — adopted the classical sideways-on position. The right arm, high at the point of delivery, would follow through to describe almost a full circle.
In a sporting era where materialistic rewards were few, his playing career was the very epitome of service, a foreign word to most modern players. His 236 Test wickets were the most ever taken by the time he played the last of his 51 Tests in 1955.
Stephen Brenkley writes in the Independent , that the selection of the England side for the World Twenty20 tournament, including three new-faces, is a shot in the dark and is not based on detailed planning.
Michael Lumb is the latest to be called up as a catch-all opener, in the footsteps of such discards as Vikram Solanki, Darren Maddy, Joe Denly, Matt Prior and Luke Wright to name but a handful. It's possible they have landed on a correct combination, but impossible that this has come about through careful planning rather than blind panic.