| 1 | Andre Fletcher † top-order batter | Lendl Simmons top-order batter |
| 2 | Johnson Charles wicketkeeper batter | Tillakaratne Dilshan  allrounder |
| 3 | Kyle Mayers batting allrounder | Shivnarine Chanderpaul batter |
| 4 | Kevin Pietersen top-order batter | Denesh Ramdin † (c) wicketkeeper batter |
| 5 | Ross Taylor middle-order batter | Brad Hodge top-order batter |
| 6 | Henry Davids top-order batter | Chris Barnwell allrounder |
| 7 | Daren Sammy (c) allrounder | Sunil Narine bowling allrounder |
| 8 | Kemar Roach bowler | Paul Wintz bowler |
| 9 | Shannon Gabriel bowler | Veerasammy Permaul bowler |
| 10 | Fidel Edwards bowler | Marchant de Lange bowler |
| 11 | Eddie Leie bowler | Ronsford Beaton bowler |
