India v West Indies, 1st Test, Kolkata, 1st day November 6, 2013

Shami's swing the revelation

N Hunter
Mohammed Shami relied on his strength - swing - to fetch four wickets on debut. His contest against the best West Indies batsman was the most compelling
24

Marlon Samuels had only just arrived at the crease when he faced against Mohammed Shami. He pitched it on a good length on the off stump. The ball was moving at a good pace and Samuels was lured into playing it, but was completely squared up as the ball moved away from him late. Samuels had decided to withdraw his bat at the very last instant. He hopped on his toes, raising an appreciative glance at Shami.

In the one-on-one contests drawn up on the eve of the Test, Shami v Samuels was never one of them. One big reason was, as MS Dhoni had pointed out on Tuesday afternoon, India had not worked out their bowling combination. Bhuvneshwar Kumar had booked his berth considering he has shown the consistency to move the new ball early and he proved his worth when he quickly sent back his bunny Chris Gayle.

The choice of the second fast bowler was a fight between Umesh Yadav and Shami, considering Ishant Sharma's shoddy form in the seven-match ODI series against Australia. If pace was the sole criterion, Yadav would have clinched the spot, but Shami can also swing the ball both ways. Also, there was the X-factor in his favour - West Indies had not seen much of Shami other than his bowling in the ODIs since his debut in January this year.

Two days before the Test, he had teamed up with Bhuvneshwar and troubled the batsmen in the nets with his movement. Having earned his debut, he had to transport that same momentum in a Test match. Playing in front of home fans is never easy as the expectations are more. Sachin Tendulkar's farewell drawing all the attention may have helped Shami to quietly get on with his job without many nerves.

Shami's biggest impact came when India changed the ball in the 41st over. Immediately, Dhoni brought Shami the next over. Before the ball change, Shami's figures were 7-1-39-1. After the change it was an impressive 10-1-49-3.

Even before the ball change, Shami was smart to detect Kieran Powell's urgency to step on the gas too early. Powell had scored a couple of boundaries in Bhuvneshwar's previous over. So on the second delivery of his second spell, Shami produced a shoulder-high bouncer that climbed fast on Powell, who had decided to pull it, which only proved fatal.

However, Shami reserved his best for the best West Indies batsman on the day: Samuels. The Jamaican had raced to a half-century with powerful drives and lofts against both fast and slow bowling. But as soon as Shami started to reverse swing the ball, he instantly looked dangerous. Even Samuels, one of Wisden's Cricketers of the Year in 2012, was finding it hard to guess which way the ball was going to move. Before the ball change, Samuels had scored 19 runs from 13 balls from Shami. After the change he managed just five runs off 11 deliveries.

Shami learned the art of working on the ball in his native Moradabad in Uttar Pradesh where he would request coaches to hand him used balls, which he would take home and shine and then get it to reverse. Having honed the art from his Under-16 days, Shami reversed the ball at will effortlessly today.

Every performance has a signature. Shami's was to keep things simple, in addition to utilising the experience of playing on his home ground. The Eden Gardens pitch, even the re-laid one, has not favoured the fast bowlers too much. So Shami has had to rely on other factors to get his wickets in the time he has been playing for Bengal in the last three years.

Accuracy, allied with movement and good pace can be a lethal combination in a fast bowler. Shami added control to that today. He maintained an off-stump line as far as possible and that exact length, which is not too full, not too short, was too tempting for the batsmen.

Shami said that he had mentally prepared himself on Tuesday evening for the big day. Reflecting on his various spells, Shami said the new ball swung less for him the morning. "The first ball before the change was swinging a little less, and it was a bit soft. After it was changed, it was swinging and reversing well," Shami said.

According to Shami, most of the West Indies batsmen did not show the right mindset to play out time and that helped him settle down and bowl to his strengths. "They just didn't care about Test cricket. In my view, they played their strokes continuously. So it becomes easy for me, that I'd get them if they play strokes against me," he said.

Shami's figures of 4 for 71 are the third-best by an Indian fast bowler in his debut innings, after Mohammad Nissar and Venkatesh Prasad. But you cannot forecast a future on 17 overs. At tea, as the Indians walked towards the dressing room, everyone looked towards Tendulkar to cross the ropes first. But Tendulkar insisted Shami lead the team back.

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • woodstock1969 on November 6, 2013, 16:57 GMT

    Good to see a genuine fast bowler who can also swing. Now let us hope that he can withstand the test of longevity. If he can at least perform as consistently as Srinath or even Zaheer did, that will be great. We certainly do not want to see him go from good to bad to worse to ridiculous like several others such as Irfan Pathan, Munaf Patel, RP Singh, Praveen Kumar, and need I even mention Ishant.

  • on November 11, 2013, 9:09 GMT

    Well done Sami and all de the best for the future.Keep up the good working and please maintain the same consistency .

  • ferngully on November 8, 2013, 9:53 GMT

    too early to know what Shami will look like in a couple of years or down the road, but the way he is swinging it he is a must for selectors in SA. Bhuvi Shami Yadav not looking like a bad pace trio

  • on November 7, 2013, 10:40 GMT

    @Zusa94: " some random guy took 4 wickets on his home ground against one of the worst Test batting line ups made of mostly T20 players" - you got to be kidding me...right? Chanderpaul is a 150 test exp, Gayle has scored two triple centuries in tests and only the third batsman to do so. Samuels and Bravo are very talented and dangerous batsmen, i don't know on which planet you are living and which brand of cricket you are following, u people just can't digest any Indian doing good in any field sports.

  • Sandt on November 7, 2013, 8:12 GMT

    @Zusa94-which team in international cricket now have full of test players.All teams use players for T2o and ODI along with test.And westindies in not a bad team and have some of the dangerous batsmen in the world with them who plays all format.You think Gayle,chanderpaul,Samuels and bravo are third class batsmen.Then you don't understand cricket.When india does well all have execuses to say.

  • on November 7, 2013, 8:07 GMT

    give shami another year or two and will see if he bowls at the same pace or not indian bowlers drop 10 kph within a year and become dibbly dobbly bowlers get the best of him while u can

  • Zusa94 on November 7, 2013, 3:43 GMT

    We can expect this from the media every time an Indian sportsman does anything close to decent You will go to his house, interview his mother, father, future bride, nephews, and neighbors and essentially create such an aura around him that even if this player had any potential, it will be submerged in a sea of hyped up expectations and unnecessary pressure.

    Here is the reality: some random guy took 4 wickets on his home ground against one of the worst Test batting line ups made of mostly T20 players. So let's not make a big deal. Leave him alone to develop and mature, please. Put it on the "Plays of the day" page, and let's move on.

  • on November 7, 2013, 3:08 GMT

    Good to see an Indian bowler under domestic conditions meets the WI team with their own medicine - pace and swing. But let this not be a "ek dhin" performance like Ishant's spell to Punter. Happy for Sami. let him gain mental and physical strength and learn from a maestro who is at the other end of his career when this boy is playing his first.

  • on November 7, 2013, 2:54 GMT

    Shammi has bowled beautifully and got valuable wickets for India. He has been the cause for winning the ODI series against Aussies. A brilliant piece of bowling from him. He aims at the wicket all the time and swings the ball tirelessly. Very good effort of bowling. Wish him all the best.

  • rajkirp on November 7, 2013, 2:44 GMT

    Let's not be so overjoyed by his performance. Remember Munaf Patel and his wickets in his debut match. Remember Irfan Pathan and his hattrick against Pakistan. Even Ishant Sharma in Australia. All performances that led us to believe that our pace attack is in good hands. Not to happen. Fame coupled with ramp shows, ads can give you a swollen head. Follow this up with injuries. All leading to performing just to maintain place in the Indian team. I only hope he does not go the way of others before him. Best of wishes to him.

  • woodstock1969 on November 6, 2013, 16:57 GMT

    Good to see a genuine fast bowler who can also swing. Now let us hope that he can withstand the test of longevity. If he can at least perform as consistently as Srinath or even Zaheer did, that will be great. We certainly do not want to see him go from good to bad to worse to ridiculous like several others such as Irfan Pathan, Munaf Patel, RP Singh, Praveen Kumar, and need I even mention Ishant.

  • on November 11, 2013, 9:09 GMT

    Well done Sami and all de the best for the future.Keep up the good working and please maintain the same consistency .

  • ferngully on November 8, 2013, 9:53 GMT

    too early to know what Shami will look like in a couple of years or down the road, but the way he is swinging it he is a must for selectors in SA. Bhuvi Shami Yadav not looking like a bad pace trio

  • on November 7, 2013, 10:40 GMT

    @Zusa94: " some random guy took 4 wickets on his home ground against one of the worst Test batting line ups made of mostly T20 players" - you got to be kidding me...right? Chanderpaul is a 150 test exp, Gayle has scored two triple centuries in tests and only the third batsman to do so. Samuels and Bravo are very talented and dangerous batsmen, i don't know on which planet you are living and which brand of cricket you are following, u people just can't digest any Indian doing good in any field sports.

  • Sandt on November 7, 2013, 8:12 GMT

    @Zusa94-which team in international cricket now have full of test players.All teams use players for T2o and ODI along with test.And westindies in not a bad team and have some of the dangerous batsmen in the world with them who plays all format.You think Gayle,chanderpaul,Samuels and bravo are third class batsmen.Then you don't understand cricket.When india does well all have execuses to say.

  • on November 7, 2013, 8:07 GMT

    give shami another year or two and will see if he bowls at the same pace or not indian bowlers drop 10 kph within a year and become dibbly dobbly bowlers get the best of him while u can

  • Zusa94 on November 7, 2013, 3:43 GMT

    We can expect this from the media every time an Indian sportsman does anything close to decent You will go to his house, interview his mother, father, future bride, nephews, and neighbors and essentially create such an aura around him that even if this player had any potential, it will be submerged in a sea of hyped up expectations and unnecessary pressure.

    Here is the reality: some random guy took 4 wickets on his home ground against one of the worst Test batting line ups made of mostly T20 players. So let's not make a big deal. Leave him alone to develop and mature, please. Put it on the "Plays of the day" page, and let's move on.

  • on November 7, 2013, 3:08 GMT

    Good to see an Indian bowler under domestic conditions meets the WI team with their own medicine - pace and swing. But let this not be a "ek dhin" performance like Ishant's spell to Punter. Happy for Sami. let him gain mental and physical strength and learn from a maestro who is at the other end of his career when this boy is playing his first.

  • on November 7, 2013, 2:54 GMT

    Shammi has bowled beautifully and got valuable wickets for India. He has been the cause for winning the ODI series against Aussies. A brilliant piece of bowling from him. He aims at the wicket all the time and swings the ball tirelessly. Very good effort of bowling. Wish him all the best.

  • rajkirp on November 7, 2013, 2:44 GMT

    Let's not be so overjoyed by his performance. Remember Munaf Patel and his wickets in his debut match. Remember Irfan Pathan and his hattrick against Pakistan. Even Ishant Sharma in Australia. All performances that led us to believe that our pace attack is in good hands. Not to happen. Fame coupled with ramp shows, ads can give you a swollen head. Follow this up with injuries. All leading to performing just to maintain place in the Indian team. I only hope he does not go the way of others before him. Best of wishes to him.

  • getgopi on November 7, 2013, 2:20 GMT

    I remember a similar article came out for Ishant Sharma when he did that "thing" in Australia against Ricky Ponting several years ago...

  • sray23 on November 7, 2013, 2:04 GMT

    Well done Shami, but remember, this is after all the West Indies post 1990s. Much harder tests lie ahead. Longevity is definitely his biggest test. Question for BCCI - why can't Kapil Dev be used to mentor these young fast bowlers? We worry about Indian bowlers losing pace & getting injured but here is a guy who played for 10 years continuously in the '80s with no professional structure, hardly ever missed a match from injury, but we have him sitting on the sidelines just watching. Rather than importing foreign full-time bowling coaches with no knowledge of Indian physiques, wouldn't a very successful Indian who has been there & done it all be better, even if as a part-time mentor??

  • CricketFanIndUS on November 7, 2013, 0:53 GMT

    Mohammed Shami, a new hope!

  • on November 6, 2013, 23:26 GMT

    Great we dont have to see Ishant Sharma anymore. God bless Shami

  • Nampally on November 6, 2013, 22:03 GMT

    Shami finally made his Test debut after being benched in 5 ODI's vs. the Aussies & showing his true class in the last ODI vs. the OZ. Today he again showed that he is miles ahead of Ishant Sharma & Vinay Kumar- the 2 Guys Dhoni consistently preferred over Shami. Yadev may be slightly faster than Shami but less skilled - very little swing or movement of the pitch. Ishant & Vinay have lost their spot in Indian squad permanently. B.Kumar & Shami are both superior in this respect to Ishant, Vinay & may be Yadev too. Aaron has fitness problems & all his initial talent is now a wasted one - lost in injuries! India need to look towards Shukla, Pandey, Kulkarni & Yadev as back up for B.Kumar & Shami for SA Tour. In batting there is sufficient talent to carry India forward. In Spin bowling Ashwin, Ojha, Mishra & Jadeja will do an acceptable job. I still feel that for the all rounder spot , A.Nayar is an excellent choice for SA. He has performed well in Ranji + in limited India A matches.

  • the_blue_android on November 6, 2013, 19:20 GMT

    Hopefully, this is good riddance, Ishant Sharma. With all the spare time he's gonna have, hopefully he can find time to get a haircut.

  • on November 6, 2013, 17:57 GMT

    Indian bowling coaches need to live him alone because everyone they work on after goes bad with there coaching all Indian bowler are unique when they come in the team but after they are like Ishant So if he know what he is doing don't teach him anything else

  • on November 6, 2013, 17:18 GMT

    Todays play also highlights that the new ODI rule of 2 new balls has effectively taken away the potent weapon of reverse swing from the bowlers, specially in the sub continent where the ball tends to get rough faster as compared to other countries....reverse swing if used skilfully, can be very handy on flat sub continent pitches as Shami showed today....ICC needs to revisit the 2 new ball rule in ODIs very soon

  • on November 6, 2013, 17:13 GMT

    This is a lesson for indian selectors to pick players doing well in four day cricket...Shami was good in Ranji trophy but made to debut in ODI...there r others like Pankaj Singh from RAJASthan RANJI Winning squad coaced by M Pringle from South Africa, Ishwar Pandey from Madhya Pradesh who both shd make test debut as soon as possible as these guys had a stellar domestic season recently...Injustice was done to Ashok Dinda...dropped on IPL performance where Dhoni, Rohit hit him for too many runs....now this has gone Agarkar like situation...bowlers bowling to u in national team net set up n then u go after him bcz u know his A to Z mindset.....Ashok Dinda deserved a test debut ahead of Shami...Ishant needs to go back to domestic cricket n learn the art to pick wickets as International cricket is not the place to experiment as he has been doing....Well done Shami....but lets see if ur pace goes down within this year or u add a yard or two to it...gdluck

  • Dhanno on November 6, 2013, 16:50 GMT

    How much time do we give him ? 2 years - 3 years ? They toil on these surfaces for 8-10 years before bursting ( at 127 K not 155 k mind you) on international scene. then disappear in 6 months time. None of his fault but the system which favors batsmen only.

  • on November 6, 2013, 16:50 GMT

    it appears that, the bloke has got all the prerequisites to become a great or at least carry it forward from where Zaheer left.

  • devil_in_details on November 6, 2013, 15:37 GMT

    I hope Shami shares the art of reverse swing with other bowlers as well. Given that there is no senior leader of the pack among pace bowlers, they have to share the knowledge among themselves to improve. A good bowling coach should hone their skills further and is probably the one addition to coaching staff which is needed.

  • Vilander on November 6, 2013, 15:17 GMT

    At average of 140k's he is geneuin fast, and he swings it both ways and reverses it in one way. This is just awesome, cant wait for his time in SA him yadav and Bhuv will make a good new ball combination in SA. But only for 2 tests...why so little please BCCI please let us have 4 tests with SA.

  • Al_Bundy1 on November 6, 2013, 15:13 GMT

    Way to go, Shami !! I have been shouting on this board for last few years that we have no shortage of talent in India. Why do our selectors keep selecting the same old Ishant Sharma, in spite of the fact that he hasn't done anything in past 2 years ?? Ishwar Pandey is a great prospect for India. He deserves a chance ASAP. There are others like Imtiaz Ahmed, Sandeep Sharma, etc. All of them can do better than the club level bowling of Ishant, Vinay and Unadkat.

  • Al_Bundy1 on November 6, 2013, 15:13 GMT

    Way to go, Shami !! I have been shouting on this board for last few years that we have no shortage of talent in India. Why do our selectors keep selecting the same old Ishant Sharma, in spite of the fact that he hasn't done anything in past 2 years ?? Ishwar Pandey is a great prospect for India. He deserves a chance ASAP. There are others like Imtiaz Ahmed, Sandeep Sharma, etc. All of them can do better than the club level bowling of Ishant, Vinay and Unadkat.

  • Vilander on November 6, 2013, 15:17 GMT

    At average of 140k's he is geneuin fast, and he swings it both ways and reverses it in one way. This is just awesome, cant wait for his time in SA him yadav and Bhuv will make a good new ball combination in SA. But only for 2 tests...why so little please BCCI please let us have 4 tests with SA.

  • devil_in_details on November 6, 2013, 15:37 GMT

    I hope Shami shares the art of reverse swing with other bowlers as well. Given that there is no senior leader of the pack among pace bowlers, they have to share the knowledge among themselves to improve. A good bowling coach should hone their skills further and is probably the one addition to coaching staff which is needed.

  • on November 6, 2013, 16:50 GMT

    it appears that, the bloke has got all the prerequisites to become a great or at least carry it forward from where Zaheer left.

  • Dhanno on November 6, 2013, 16:50 GMT

    How much time do we give him ? 2 years - 3 years ? They toil on these surfaces for 8-10 years before bursting ( at 127 K not 155 k mind you) on international scene. then disappear in 6 months time. None of his fault but the system which favors batsmen only.

  • on November 6, 2013, 17:13 GMT

    This is a lesson for indian selectors to pick players doing well in four day cricket...Shami was good in Ranji trophy but made to debut in ODI...there r others like Pankaj Singh from RAJASthan RANJI Winning squad coaced by M Pringle from South Africa, Ishwar Pandey from Madhya Pradesh who both shd make test debut as soon as possible as these guys had a stellar domestic season recently...Injustice was done to Ashok Dinda...dropped on IPL performance where Dhoni, Rohit hit him for too many runs....now this has gone Agarkar like situation...bowlers bowling to u in national team net set up n then u go after him bcz u know his A to Z mindset.....Ashok Dinda deserved a test debut ahead of Shami...Ishant needs to go back to domestic cricket n learn the art to pick wickets as International cricket is not the place to experiment as he has been doing....Well done Shami....but lets see if ur pace goes down within this year or u add a yard or two to it...gdluck

  • on November 6, 2013, 17:18 GMT

    Todays play also highlights that the new ODI rule of 2 new balls has effectively taken away the potent weapon of reverse swing from the bowlers, specially in the sub continent where the ball tends to get rough faster as compared to other countries....reverse swing if used skilfully, can be very handy on flat sub continent pitches as Shami showed today....ICC needs to revisit the 2 new ball rule in ODIs very soon

  • on November 6, 2013, 17:57 GMT

    Indian bowling coaches need to live him alone because everyone they work on after goes bad with there coaching all Indian bowler are unique when they come in the team but after they are like Ishant So if he know what he is doing don't teach him anything else

  • the_blue_android on November 6, 2013, 19:20 GMT

    Hopefully, this is good riddance, Ishant Sharma. With all the spare time he's gonna have, hopefully he can find time to get a haircut.

  • Nampally on November 6, 2013, 22:03 GMT

    Shami finally made his Test debut after being benched in 5 ODI's vs. the Aussies & showing his true class in the last ODI vs. the OZ. Today he again showed that he is miles ahead of Ishant Sharma & Vinay Kumar- the 2 Guys Dhoni consistently preferred over Shami. Yadev may be slightly faster than Shami but less skilled - very little swing or movement of the pitch. Ishant & Vinay have lost their spot in Indian squad permanently. B.Kumar & Shami are both superior in this respect to Ishant, Vinay & may be Yadev too. Aaron has fitness problems & all his initial talent is now a wasted one - lost in injuries! India need to look towards Shukla, Pandey, Kulkarni & Yadev as back up for B.Kumar & Shami for SA Tour. In batting there is sufficient talent to carry India forward. In Spin bowling Ashwin, Ojha, Mishra & Jadeja will do an acceptable job. I still feel that for the all rounder spot , A.Nayar is an excellent choice for SA. He has performed well in Ranji + in limited India A matches.