Corruption in the IPL June 2, 2013

The day through contradicting quotes

ESPNcricinfo staff
What the people present in the meeting had to say about what took place
17

After the working-committee meeting of the BCCI, N Srinivasan stepped aside while the commission probes the charges of betting and spot-fixing in the IPL. Jagmohan Dalmiya was charged with day-to-day activities of the board. Here is what the people present in the meeting had to say about what took place.

On the outcome of the meeting

"I have taken an extraordinarily fair step of not discharging my duties till the probe is completed. What have I done wrong? There is no charge laid against me. Nothing."
N Srinivasan, the president, has no doubts regarding the fairness of it all

"It seemed like a pre-planned drama. I said it was a sham that will not satisfy the public."
IS Bindra, former BCCI president and now the Punjab Cricket Board chief, doesn't quite agree

"I am not only unhappy. I am extremely sad. I am at the same time extremely concerned about the future. We need a more credible explanation rather than just putting old wine in new bottles."
Ajay Shirke, the Maharashtra Cricket Association boss who resigned as the BCCI treasurer two nights ago, is not impressed

"What hurt me during the meeting is we should have discussed the system and not just individuals. How to cleanse the system. And what wrong things have entered the game of cricket."
Sanjay Jagdale, who resigned as the BCCI secretary along with Shirke, talks of what the real issue is

"Under this arrangement, you must have a board with some credibility. Since the board has taken this decision, I am sure it must be given a chance."
Arun Jaitley, a BJP MP and a BCCI vice-president, believes credibility has been restored

"It was the most uncharitable and unreasonable comment you have made."
Jagmohan Dalmiya, former BCCI chief and now interim in-charge, rules out this being an eyewash

On how the arrangement with Jagmohan Dalmiya will work

"Mr Dalmiya will look after the responsibilities. He will get decisions ratified by the board. The entire administration will be done by the working committee of the board. Whatever Mr Dalmiya decides will have to be ratified by the board."
Jaitley maps out the immediate plan

"This is an internal matter on how the board arranges itself. Mr Dalmiya is very experienced. Within the framework of the rules of the board, it can be managed."
Srinivasan is confident the confusing situation can be managed

"I have no problem with Mr Dalmiya coming in. He is an experienced administrator, but I don't like the way he has been brought in."
Bindra

"I cannot see how this kind of arrangement work."
Shirke

On who all asked Srinivasan to resign unconditionally

"Nobody except Mr Bindra and myself and a couple of others questioned this arrangement. At the end of the day, this has been carried through."
Shirke didn't have much support in the meeting

"At the meeting, Mr Bindra didn't ask me to resign. The meeting was very smooth. There was no acrimony. The members appreciated what were the tasks ahead of the BCCI. This announcement I made after all members had expressed their views. This was well received. Then Mr Dalmiya was appointed."
Srinivasan sticks with the unanimity theme

"I have the minutes and the notes of the meeting. I categorically asked for his resignation. I said this sham will not satisfy the public. I said he should resign and come back if exonerated."
Bindra doesn't quite agree

"Nobody had asked for his resignation. I can say nobody came forward. It was unnecessary, like going after a punching bag."
Dalmiya has another view

On what happens to the resignations of Shirke and Jagdale

"All of us requested Mr Jagdale and Mr Shirke to continue so that there is continuity. Ajay Shirke is my best friend. He said he will come back tomorrow. Even Sanjay Jagdale will get back to us tomorrow."
Srinivasan hopes the resignations will be taken back

"They were unanimous in asking us to take back the resignation, but I feel bad that I cannot respond in a positive manner."
Jagdale says thanks but no thanks

"No question of me taking back the resignation unless there is a creditable route ahead of us."
Doesn't seem Shirke is taking a u-turn anytime soon

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • AjaySridharan on June 3, 2013, 17:10 GMT

    Are Ajay Shirke and Sanjay Jagdale shirking their responsibilities? Resignation doesn't make negligence pardonable. If things were so bad all along, why were they not making noises? Also, why can't this BCCI meetings be held on camera, like Parliamentary sessions? Why should it be behind closed doors, and everyone having their version of "notes" and "minutes"?! Are we living in 1800s?!

  • Leggie on June 3, 2013, 13:41 GMT

    Complete sham and waste of cricket fan's time. The fans are euqally to blame for this situation. They have the power to boycott matches that they think are farcical - but those that bring money & thereby "power" to the board. If they didn't do it, they better take the blame too.

  • Fogu on June 3, 2013, 13:23 GMT

    Fans can get upset all they want but if they do not take action, nothing will happen. Fans should stop buying merchandise and TV programming as well as boycott some games to send the message. Cricket is a cash cow in India and as long as the money is rolling in, BCCI will not give a hoot about the fans being upset.

  • Clyde on June 3, 2013, 9:49 GMT

    'Jagmohan Dalmiya was charged with day-to-day activities of the board'? That is a very serious charge.

  • on June 3, 2013, 7:19 GMT

    @vj_gooner. We - the public - are fools. We can only be fools since we're always out there in the light and we can't see what happens in the dark, where the machinations of power are at work. It's a bit like when you're in a car and are about to enter a tunnel. You can't see what's in there because your eyes are adjusted to the light.

  • jaikishan_k on June 3, 2013, 7:09 GMT

    A complete eye wash ... extremely sad and angry. They do not realise that they are what they are because of the fans of this country. And the fans are not stupid to buy in their eyewashes. Their credibility is on a very thin thread at the moment and if they keep doing these kind of eye washes, sooner or later you will have empty stadiums and sponsors running out.

    Looks like only then will BCCI learn a lesson. I hope that day doesnt come and that they realise the gravity of the situation and take some immediate and genuine steps to cleanup the sport rather than taking steps in vested interest to safegaurd the president.

  • vj_gooner on June 3, 2013, 5:57 GMT

    At the end of the day, we (the public) are being made to look like fools!!!

  • ThatsJustCricket on June 3, 2013, 3:27 GMT

    In stead of everybody shooting conflicting comments about what actually happened, why not publish the minutes of the meeting for the public? That way we can all see what really happened in there.

  • ZDNH on June 2, 2013, 20:27 GMT

    I never thought I would say this, but it seems cricket was better served when it was under the thump of Australia and England!

  • esmile on June 2, 2013, 19:26 GMT

    Nobody is bigger than game.... But what happened today is complete eyewash...we all should stop watching cricket.... Sponsors should withdraw themselves.. Then only something will happen ... Otherwise show will go on and on like this for decades.... Feels shame on being an Indian cricket fan... Where are the so called cricket legends???? Why aren't they coming out and protest ?

  • AjaySridharan on June 3, 2013, 17:10 GMT

    Are Ajay Shirke and Sanjay Jagdale shirking their responsibilities? Resignation doesn't make negligence pardonable. If things were so bad all along, why were they not making noises? Also, why can't this BCCI meetings be held on camera, like Parliamentary sessions? Why should it be behind closed doors, and everyone having their version of "notes" and "minutes"?! Are we living in 1800s?!

  • Leggie on June 3, 2013, 13:41 GMT

    Complete sham and waste of cricket fan's time. The fans are euqally to blame for this situation. They have the power to boycott matches that they think are farcical - but those that bring money & thereby "power" to the board. If they didn't do it, they better take the blame too.

  • Fogu on June 3, 2013, 13:23 GMT

    Fans can get upset all they want but if they do not take action, nothing will happen. Fans should stop buying merchandise and TV programming as well as boycott some games to send the message. Cricket is a cash cow in India and as long as the money is rolling in, BCCI will not give a hoot about the fans being upset.

  • Clyde on June 3, 2013, 9:49 GMT

    'Jagmohan Dalmiya was charged with day-to-day activities of the board'? That is a very serious charge.

  • on June 3, 2013, 7:19 GMT

    @vj_gooner. We - the public - are fools. We can only be fools since we're always out there in the light and we can't see what happens in the dark, where the machinations of power are at work. It's a bit like when you're in a car and are about to enter a tunnel. You can't see what's in there because your eyes are adjusted to the light.

  • jaikishan_k on June 3, 2013, 7:09 GMT

    A complete eye wash ... extremely sad and angry. They do not realise that they are what they are because of the fans of this country. And the fans are not stupid to buy in their eyewashes. Their credibility is on a very thin thread at the moment and if they keep doing these kind of eye washes, sooner or later you will have empty stadiums and sponsors running out.

    Looks like only then will BCCI learn a lesson. I hope that day doesnt come and that they realise the gravity of the situation and take some immediate and genuine steps to cleanup the sport rather than taking steps in vested interest to safegaurd the president.

  • vj_gooner on June 3, 2013, 5:57 GMT

    At the end of the day, we (the public) are being made to look like fools!!!

  • ThatsJustCricket on June 3, 2013, 3:27 GMT

    In stead of everybody shooting conflicting comments about what actually happened, why not publish the minutes of the meeting for the public? That way we can all see what really happened in there.

  • ZDNH on June 2, 2013, 20:27 GMT

    I never thought I would say this, but it seems cricket was better served when it was under the thump of Australia and England!

  • esmile on June 2, 2013, 19:26 GMT

    Nobody is bigger than game.... But what happened today is complete eyewash...we all should stop watching cricket.... Sponsors should withdraw themselves.. Then only something will happen ... Otherwise show will go on and on like this for decades.... Feels shame on being an Indian cricket fan... Where are the so called cricket legends???? Why aren't they coming out and protest ?

  • on June 2, 2013, 18:23 GMT

    What is Gurunath Meiyappan's role for Chennai Super Kings? If he is just a cricket enthusiastic as suggested by N.Srinivasan, then why was he present in the ground and why all official email communications are addressed to him? If he is the owner of Chennai Super Kings, then because he is arrested in spot fixing scandal, Chennai Super Kings should be terminated from IPL according to guidelines and rules of IPL?

    If ICC let BCCI knew about Spot Fixing prior to IPL, then who did ICC contacted? Was it Srinivasan directly and if not why ICC did not contacted N.Srinivasan? If Srinivasan was contacted then he is directly involved with Spot Fixing, because he was aware of the Spot Fixing prior to IPL began and he decided not to took any action. If Srinivasan was not aware, then why was not he aware as he is the President of BCCI and

  • on June 2, 2013, 17:24 GMT

    Sigh, politician types running the show. Srinivasan, Dalmiya, Jaitley and probably even Bindra. Hope BCCI actually bring some change into administration because of all the hue and cry, and cleans up the game at least to some extent.

  • ODI_BestFormOfCricket on June 2, 2013, 17:21 GMT

    ajay shirke at ndtv discussion said 'no one including bindra, categorically asked srinivisan to resign. But bindra and srinivasan contradicts about who asks what in meeting. Mudiyila..

  • Rahul_Kayal on June 2, 2013, 16:51 GMT

    Its a strategic time-out for Mr. Srinivasan.

  • on June 2, 2013, 16:49 GMT

    we cannot comment on what happened,. may be we should stop watching cricket,.. Sad but true,.. lots all the interest coz Dravid and Sachin retirement,.. whatever left,.. thts also gone today.....

  • cricketoverkill on June 2, 2013, 16:32 GMT

    When there's tonnes of money at stake, this is what happens!

  • Rahul_Kayal on June 2, 2013, 16:25 GMT

    Mr. Srinivasan got changed the rule itself to suit him. He is the owner of Chennai team and president of BCCI. This kind of conflict of interest is rarely legalized. We know how family members of a powerful man exploit the power in their favor. Gurunath is Srinivasan's son-in-law, not someone distant relative. Gurunath is the team principal of the Chennai team. In this situation, how can Srinivasan continue as the BCCI president. Appointing Dalmiya is one of his master-stroke. Its like a Dalmiya 'lock' in BCCI room but the 'key' is still with Mr. Srinivasan.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • Rahul_Kayal on June 2, 2013, 16:25 GMT

    Mr. Srinivasan got changed the rule itself to suit him. He is the owner of Chennai team and president of BCCI. This kind of conflict of interest is rarely legalized. We know how family members of a powerful man exploit the power in their favor. Gurunath is Srinivasan's son-in-law, not someone distant relative. Gurunath is the team principal of the Chennai team. In this situation, how can Srinivasan continue as the BCCI president. Appointing Dalmiya is one of his master-stroke. Its like a Dalmiya 'lock' in BCCI room but the 'key' is still with Mr. Srinivasan.

  • cricketoverkill on June 2, 2013, 16:32 GMT

    When there's tonnes of money at stake, this is what happens!

  • on June 2, 2013, 16:49 GMT

    we cannot comment on what happened,. may be we should stop watching cricket,.. Sad but true,.. lots all the interest coz Dravid and Sachin retirement,.. whatever left,.. thts also gone today.....

  • Rahul_Kayal on June 2, 2013, 16:51 GMT

    Its a strategic time-out for Mr. Srinivasan.

  • ODI_BestFormOfCricket on June 2, 2013, 17:21 GMT

    ajay shirke at ndtv discussion said 'no one including bindra, categorically asked srinivisan to resign. But bindra and srinivasan contradicts about who asks what in meeting. Mudiyila..

  • on June 2, 2013, 17:24 GMT

    Sigh, politician types running the show. Srinivasan, Dalmiya, Jaitley and probably even Bindra. Hope BCCI actually bring some change into administration because of all the hue and cry, and cleans up the game at least to some extent.

  • on June 2, 2013, 18:23 GMT

    What is Gurunath Meiyappan's role for Chennai Super Kings? If he is just a cricket enthusiastic as suggested by N.Srinivasan, then why was he present in the ground and why all official email communications are addressed to him? If he is the owner of Chennai Super Kings, then because he is arrested in spot fixing scandal, Chennai Super Kings should be terminated from IPL according to guidelines and rules of IPL?

    If ICC let BCCI knew about Spot Fixing prior to IPL, then who did ICC contacted? Was it Srinivasan directly and if not why ICC did not contacted N.Srinivasan? If Srinivasan was contacted then he is directly involved with Spot Fixing, because he was aware of the Spot Fixing prior to IPL began and he decided not to took any action. If Srinivasan was not aware, then why was not he aware as he is the President of BCCI and

  • esmile on June 2, 2013, 19:26 GMT

    Nobody is bigger than game.... But what happened today is complete eyewash...we all should stop watching cricket.... Sponsors should withdraw themselves.. Then only something will happen ... Otherwise show will go on and on like this for decades.... Feels shame on being an Indian cricket fan... Where are the so called cricket legends???? Why aren't they coming out and protest ?

  • ZDNH on June 2, 2013, 20:27 GMT

    I never thought I would say this, but it seems cricket was better served when it was under the thump of Australia and England!

  • ThatsJustCricket on June 3, 2013, 3:27 GMT

    In stead of everybody shooting conflicting comments about what actually happened, why not publish the minutes of the meeting for the public? That way we can all see what really happened in there.