Jayaditya Gupta
Executive editor of ESPNcricinfo in India

BCCI bitten by its own buzzword

The BCCI under Sharad Pawar's presidency has made a mockery of the vision document it released in 2005

Jayaditya Gupta

April 25, 2010

Comments: 16 | Text size: A | A

Sharad Pawar and Shashank Manohar chat after a formal meeting, New Delhi, April 20, 2010
Will Shashank Manohar's BCCI be more transparent than Sharad Pawar's? © AFP
Enlarge
Related Links
Gideon Haigh : Put the game before the brand
Gideon Haigh : Why so surprised?
In Focus: The IPL Mess
Series/Tournaments: Indian Premier League
Teams: India

In December 2005, the BCCI circulated a vision paper titled "The cricket board in the 21st century". It covered topics such as "quality of grounds and pitches", "infrastructure development", "marketing and merchandising" and "National Cricket Academy". Though presumably shelved immediately after and forgotten since, it was a bold statement of intent, one befitting the occasion - the first working committee meeting under Sharad Pawar's presidency in an entity that was already assuming its current leviathan proportions.

The most important point, though, was the preamble. Written in the aftermath of the board election that ended the much-vilified Jagmohan Dalmiya regime and began the Pawar era, it spoke of the fans' expectations of the new dispensation whose buzzword, it said, would be transparency. Just over four years later those expectations have been rudely shattered, and Pawar and his associates stand discredited. The future looks bleak but if Shashank Manohar - who finally has a chance to run Indian cricket as his own man - needs a plan to revive the board's credibility, he need look no further than that eerily prescient vision document.

Read now, though, that preamble is a mockery of whatever Sharad Pawar and his colleagues have done in their time at the helm. In fact their prescription for the board in 2005 is needed, now more than ever, in the wake of the worst scandal by far to engulf Indian cricket. The saddest part of the vision document is that, though four years old, it has not dated, instead it has become even more relevant.

"Some of the happenings during the last few years have grievously dented the board's image," the vision document says. "Our first priority should be to restore its pristine glory by creating confidence among the followers of the game that the board is indeed a sincere custodian of Indian cricket. Frankly the question being asked is, as the richest body in world cricket, has it fulfilled its obligations towards the players and paying public? For that we all need to introspect and touch our hearts before saying 'yes, we have'."

That time for introspection has come, with the Board's credibility at an all-time low - and with the pendulum of public sympathy swinging dangerously, if improbably, towards Modi. Perhaps the only fact in this whole stew of allegations is that not a single charge against Modi has yet been proved - he is as innocent or as guilty as anyone else. Public perception shouldn't matter too much to the BCCI - things would not have come to such a pass if it did - but it does matter to a senior politician like Pawar, who faces elections in his home state of Maharashtra next year. Pawar also takes up the ICC presidency two months from now and his immense clout would be undermined by any mud sticking to him.

Over the past few days there has been much talk of who could set this right - the government, the judiciary, a collegium of corporate leaders. The Army, that go-to for all India's problems, has presumably been ruled out because of a conflict of interest - there's a Services team in the Ranji Trophy. None of that will work, though, without corrective measures from within.

Can it be done? Back to that preamble: "As a premier national sports body, the board had been a model for all others sports organizations, but of late it has invited scorn from the public. In a fast paced world driven by market forces, we have to gear up to meet the ever increasing challenges and aspirations of a cricket-crazy nation. When the country is getting excited about the Right to Information Act, the Board is being ridiculed for its lack of transparency. Unless we believe in the free flow of information, particularly when millions and millions of rupees are involved, we are bound to be misunderstood. There can't be a better start to the new-look board than resolve that everything we do from hereon will be transparent and in the game's and public interest, be it election or allotting television rights or the team selection.

"The buzz word should be "Transparency.'"

Later, the document deals specifically with the issue of television rights. "The Board wants to end speculation over the selling of television rights. It would like to come up with a transparent method which will not only benefit the Board financially but will also help in restoring its image as an organisation which has become the epicenter of international cricket."

No one will hold the BCCI to every word in this document. But if they can, over the next few days, weeks and months, stay true to this buzzword, there may be some chance of the mess being resolved. Otherwise let's hope they find the world's biggest carpet under which to shovel the dirt.

Jayaditya Gupta is executive editor of Cricinfo in India

RSS Feeds: Jayaditya Gupta

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by Alburger2000 on (April 27, 2010, 7:52 GMT)

Congratulations Mr Jayaditya on a very well written article. i normally like all your work, but this was especially good. keep up the good work. the BCCI will never be transparent because they are not working with the ICC but are rather working against it! there is no advantage for the BCCI to show what they are doing because we all know they are ruining cricket once and for all!

Posted by Hiteshdevilliers on (April 27, 2010, 2:02 GMT)

Right now it's only the BCCI. Once Mr. Pawar gets to the helm at the ICC, expect transparency to become a thing of the past. Cricket's headquarters have elected a man with a shady past and present to take over. The same issues on transparency and corruption have been raised in domestic politics as well regarding his honesty. As you said, not one charge against Lalit Modi has been proven as of yet and unless there is no substantial evidence against him, then Mr. Modi has been wrongfully evicted and I would express deep sympathy for him.

Posted by dilipm on (April 27, 2010, 0:57 GMT)

Sharad Pawar should concentrate on his portfolio in the central cabinet more seriously and leave cricket management to people more qualified than him. With food inflation at unexpected high levels, his attention (if he takes his job seriously) should be to bring down prices througha series of proactive measures -such as better/effective productivity;increased supplies; improved storage;reduction of food wastage and more efficient PDS etc. However this mundane work does not suit his style! There is far more money and power in the glamorous world of national and international cricket! With his advent Indian cricket has been reduced from a dignified sport to a loud,glitzy entertainment with all its accompanying downsides! RIP cricket!

Posted by khansa06 on (April 26, 2010, 21:54 GMT)

People may come and people may go..... power of the "POWAR-PLAY" remains unchecked.

Posted by Scopey123 on (April 26, 2010, 19:32 GMT)

The BCCI has been discrediting cricket for sometime. Their power struggle turned to arrogance which then turned to greed. The IPL seems to be just an arm of the BCCI and ICC. None care about Test cricket - too much emphasis is put on too many games and TV revenue.

The game has been effected beyond anything Hansie Cronje achieved.

Shame on you IPL and BCCI.

Posted by kommuri on (April 26, 2010, 15:57 GMT)

Amazing jugglery of words with assumption that IPL is fraudulent which isn't proved yet. Little premature stuff. One thing is for sure, the credibility has gone south because of internal conflicts before it has any chance to prove. Just like any form of media, cricinfo had to have a pie at the mud.

Posted by sunildabre on (April 26, 2010, 14:18 GMT)

Mr. Gupta, the joke is on you for even expecting anything to improve during Mr. Pawar's tenure. If you have followed his career you would have expected this reign of total incompetence and financial irregularities.

Posted by ram5160 on (April 26, 2010, 12:27 GMT)

Because of the huge public interest involved, maybe a special case can be made for applying the Right to Information Act to the BCCI. Even though it is a private body, cricket lies in the public domain and we have a right to KNOW.

Posted by mjrvasu on (April 26, 2010, 11:19 GMT)

We should realize IPL is a private enterprise and business; why there is such a hue and cry about 'transparency'? Except Government's expectations of taxes, it is not anyone's business how a private enterprise is run. The 8 or 10 team owners are investing for return, it is their problem. Whether Modi has overgrown his shoes or not is an irrelevant issue for the public. When the man had the genious to sell 'cricketainment', why should anyone grudge his paycheck? It is up to the investors into IPL to handle matters related to it.

BCCI may have given its blessings to IPL, and don't forget they did it for the money it brought to BCCI itself. This does not mean BCCI 'owns' IPL. The real owners are the team owners, and BCCI should step back. Otherwise one day BCCI will face the same fate as ICC, having no voice on a sport it is said to control. Who can stop a new private entity getting into the act of running a parallel IPL?

Posted by RHARKI on (April 26, 2010, 8:36 GMT)

Agree with @paamkssr here. The entire fight is for control over IPL. Lets not forget that the success of IPL needs to be given to Modi (and probably a very capable team working behind the scenes). Personally, I can't even imagine Sharad Pawar as ICC chief - I am afraid the ICC might also go down the drain now (if it already isn't there). Why can't we have a lot more professionalism here? A fair trial, democratic elections with a much bigger electorate and a constitution for decision making and powers held.

But alas, no one is listening. Bureaucrats busy with politics and the common man waiting for the WC T20 to start so that he can cheer for India once again. Well, that is important too after all!

Comments have now been closed for this article

FeedbackTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Jayaditya GuptaClose
Jayaditya Gupta Executive editor, India A football lover and a veteran of the print media, Jayaditya sold out on both to join the crazy gang at ESPNcricinfo. It's a decision that often left him wondering whether he'd stumbled into the wrong room by mistake, till he realised that many of his colleagues switch the TV channel from cricket to football when they think nobody's watching. He does have cricketing heroes: Viv Richards and Steve Waugh share space with Steve Coppell (the player and manager) and Bryan Robson (the player!). Having covered two world cups (the football version) and a Champions League final, he can now set his sights on fulfilling other ambitions - including the launch of "Footinfo". Watch this space for more details...

    Still plenty of ifs for Butt

Rob Steen: Salman Butt insists players should refrain from "wrongdoing" but that shouldn't gain him back the trust of those he duped

Outside the Grace Gate

Shot Selection: You think MCC members have it easy when it comes to watching a Test at Lord's? Think again

Drowned out by the hype machine

Sharda Ugra: A lot has gone wrong with the Indian T20 league but as its seventh season begins, everything will be brushed everything aside like nothing is amiss

    Notes from a Dutch adventure

Netherlands coach Anton Roux looks back on their incredible wins in the World T20, late-night bonding, and pizza intake

A measure for batting and bowling effectiveness in T20

Kartikeya Date: Strike rates and economy rates do not quite tell the whole story. Here's a new standard

News | Features Last 7 days

UAE all set to host lavish welcoming party

The controversy surrounding the IPL has done little to deter fans in UAE from flocking the stadiums, as they gear up to watch the Indian stars in action for the first time since 2006

Attention on Yuvraj, Gambhir in IPL 2014

ESPNcricinfo picks five players for whom this IPL is of bigger significance

India: cricket's Brazil

It's difficult to beat a huge talent base exposed to good facilities, and possessed of a long history of competing as a nation

Fifty for the pantheon

What if you had to narrow all of cricket greatness down to 50 names?

'I love to take batsmen on'

Wahab Riaz, the Pakistan left-arm quick, on the pain of missing out on a ten-for, and his love for numbers and batting

News | Features Last 7 days