Brydon Coverdale
Assistant editor, ESPNcricinfo

Australia in South Africa 2011-12

What to do with Watson?

While his bowling remains important to Australia, consideration must be given to him moving down the batting order

Brydon Coverdale

November 12, 2011

Comments: 81 | Text size: A | A

Shane Watson is pumped up after his five-for, South Africa v Australia, 1st Test, Cape Town, 2nd day, November 10, 2011
Shane Watson: "After getting five wickets, you don't have any time to soak it in and re-approach your batting" © Getty Images

Shane Watson is unfailingly honest. On Australia's disastrous second day in Cape Town, he took five wickets and then was dismissed in the first over of Australia's innings. When asked after the game if his bowling work affects his mindset when he walks out to open the batting, he was frank.

"After getting five wickets, you don't have any time to soak it in and re-approach your batting," he said. "Before I knew it I was back in the pavilion. It's a balancing act to mentally switch off my bowling and wait to enjoy it until after the day's play. That's something I need to do better because when I have got wickets or bowled quite a bit, I haven't scored any runs."

Watson does not want to give up opening, but Australia's problem is that he has taken too many wickets in recent times. Or rather, Watson has had to take too many wickets, because the rest of the bowlers haven't. In suitable conditions, he swings the ball more than any of his colleagues. He bowls full enough and curves the ball late enough to trouble top-class batsmen. At times he looks like he is running in treacle as he approaches his delivery stride. But he gets the job done.

Over the past 18 months, only Mitchell Johnson has collected more victims for Australia than Watson, who during that period has taken more five-wicket hauls - three - than any other Australia bowler.

He has just entered the top 10 on the ICC's Test bowling rankings, a career high. He has become, whether Australia realises it or not, a bowling allrounder. It is illogical for a bowling allrounder to open the batting. Of course, his place in the team is inextricably linked to the success or failure of the other bowlers, notably Johnson.

Johnson may have more taken wickets than Watson over the last 18 months, but his average is nearly twice as high. His place in the team must be questioned, and if he makes way for another fast man who more consistently threatens the opposition batsmen, Watson's bowling workload might decrease.

His work ethic is not in question. On Saturday, on what should have been the fourth day of the Test, the Australians scheduled an optional training session back at Newlands. Watson was one of five players who turned up, along with Phillip Hughes, Ricky Ponting, Trent Copeland and Nathan Lyon. Watson was the last man remaining in the nets, facing throwdowns after the others had left.

But besides his bowling work, and despite his desire to open, there are other arguments for him to move down the order. He has not scored a Test century since October last year, and has made only two in 43 innings as a Test opener. There have been plenty of fifties, but openers must bat long more often.

By pairing Watson and Hughes, Australia are trusting two aggressive stroke-makers to see off the new ball. It is a fraught approach. The most successful opening partnerships have been based on a balance between defence and attack. Matthew Hayden's power was offset by Justin Langer's fight; Mark Taylor's stubbornness at the crease allowed Michael Slater to flourish. Sometimes two accumulators can form a fine partnership - Jack Fingleton and Bill Brown, for example, or Taylor and Geoff Marsh - but rarely do two dashers thrive at the top of a Test order.

The journalist Ray Robinson once wrote of Bill Lawry that if not actually wedded to his wicket, they were at least going steady. It is not clear that either Watson or Hughes are quite as attached to theirs.

Even if Hughes is eventually dropped, perhaps for David Warner, the imbalance will remain. The man in Australia's side who is temperamentally most suited to partnering a strokeplaying opener is Shaun Marsh. There is no reason that Marsh could not be promoted to open. He has the skill and the composure to succeed against the new ball. Watson could complete his bowling duties, rest, and then bat anywhere from No. 4 to No. 6.

The change might not be made for the second Test in Johannesburg. Other factors - Marsh's back injury and Ricky Ponting's poor form key among them - will come into play. But for the long-term good of Australia's Test side, consideration must be given to Watson moving down the order.

Brydon Coverdale is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Brydon Coverdale

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by lugujaga on (November 15, 2011, 14:36 GMT)

the aussies should admit they made a and bring simon kattich as the opener who can bring a great sense of balance to the side .come on australia let common sense and reason prevail.

Posted by Kikkidu on (November 15, 2011, 11:24 GMT)

Dont give my Watson much workload even though he accept it with pleasure. Suchan hard working and committed sportsman

Posted by RandyOZ on (November 15, 2011, 10:05 GMT)

@Jeremy, you are right I must've been looking at Cooper or someone, whoops! Anyway I am a redback supporter and have watched Dan a lot and think he's got the stuff!

Posted by   on (November 15, 2011, 0:04 GMT)

RandyOZ, Dan Christian averages a tick over 28 in first class cricket, which is a lot lower than the 53 you claimed.

Meanwhile, I'm still struggling to get my head around the number of people who think Watson doesn't make sense as an opener. He batted most of his shield career at number 3, without anyone worrying about his bowling workload, because he was never relied on as a chief wickettaker for QLD, TAS or NSW.

What's changed is that his bowling has really developed, while much of the rest of the AUS bowling attack has generally been poor. Fix the bowling attack, let Watson bowl shorter stints and generally not to the tail, and then let him bat where he's naturally suited - the top order.

Posted by RandyOZ on (November 14, 2011, 22:34 GMT)

@Steve Gregory, one of the few, along with myself, actually noticing Dan Christian as a gun. This bloke averages 53 but because he plays for SA gets ignored.

Posted by   on (November 14, 2011, 15:06 GMT)

I agree with Beertije i believe Warner should open the batting with Marshy and watto should come before Haddin,Punter should bat where he is at his best at number 3 and i personally believe tht Dougy should come back into the test side as he has proven good form in place of Johnson.Haddins days are over so he should pack his bags and leave,on the other hand if Punter doesn't perform till the end of the India series he should also retire

Posted by choo_for_twenty_choo on (November 14, 2011, 13:36 GMT)

Watson with his aggression, beefy strength and need for post-bowling rest would be better suited to middle order batting, where he could develop into a destroyer a-la Bevan or Symonds. Watson as a Test opener never made any sense except in his own mind and the deluded minds of the Aussie selectors. I can't fault his hope and training application. But the figures do the necessary talking; it can't work. Won't work. Don't work.

Posted by   on (November 14, 2011, 13:17 GMT)

I think they need to bring katich as a opener and make watson bat at the middle

Posted by Beertjie on (November 14, 2011, 9:50 GMT)

Players get comfortable in their roles and a re reluctant to change, e.g., Hussey started as an opener in 2005, but soon moved down the order. Pup probably won't want to bat at three. However Watto would welcome dropping to 4, so that leaves Pup and Huss where they currently are. As Brydon says, one needs a stolid Alfie type to complement a dasher, so Marsh and Warner seem like a logical combination, even if a right-left combo would have helped. That just leaves Khawaja and Punter. Give the latter what he deserves: forced retirement in the form of a final home game (Hobart vs Kiwis) and then bring in Usman. All of the above are logical and sensible, so the sooner they get implemented the better for our future. The bowling options are a lot less clear, and specific conditions will play a part. Cummins can be given a try at Wanderers, but MJ's time is rapidly coming to an end (we all hope!). It's not short-term success but proper planning with people being given a fair go that's required

Posted by wix99 on (November 14, 2011, 9:02 GMT)

I think there are two ways the selectors might handle the move. One is a direct swap with M. Hussey to open and Watson to bat at No. 6. The other is for S Marsh to move up to open and Watson down to No. 5 or 6.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Brydon CoverdaleClose
Brydon Coverdale Assistant Editor Possibly the only person to win a headline-writing award for a title with the word "heifers" in it, Brydon decided agricultural journalism wasn't for him when he took up his position with ESPNcricinfo in Melbourne. His cricketing career peaked with an unbeaten 85 in the seconds for a small team in rural Victoria on a day when they could not scrounge up 11 players and Brydon, tragically, ran out of partners to help him reach his century. He is also a compulsive TV game-show contestant and has appeared on half a dozen shows in Australia.

    The return of Bob Simpson

Rewind: When the 41-year-old former captain came out of retirement to lead Australia against India

    Ranji in Ireland, Hazare in Mumbai

Subash Jayaraman's cricket world tour takes in Dublin, Mumbai, Pune, Bangalore and Chennai

    A year of triumph and disaster

Martin Crowe: Misbah, McCullum, and the ICC's efforts against chucking were the positive highlights in a year that ended with the tragedy of Phillip Hughes' death

    Two fortresses called Brisbane and Centurion

Numbers Game: Australia haven't lost at the Gabba since 1988, while South Africa have a 14-2 record in Centurion

Why Steven Smith's here to stay

Russell Jackson: He has experienced captaincy at every level. Most admirably, he has managed to reinvent his game to succeed at the highest level

News | Features Last 7 days

The perfect Test

After the tragedy of Phillip Hughes' death, this match showed that cricket and life will continue to go on. This time Test cricket dug in and got through to tea.

Kohli attains batting nirvana

Virat Kohli's innings on the final day transcended the conditions, the bowlers and his batting partners, and when it was all in vain, he displayed remarkable grace in defeat

What ails Rohit and Watson?

Both batsmen seemingly have buckets of talent at their disposal and the backing of their captains, but soft dismissals relentlessly follow both around the Test arena

Hazlewood completes quartet of promise

Josh Hazlewood has been on Australian cricket's radar since he was a teenager. The player that made a Test debut at the Gabba was a much-improved version of the tearaway from 2010

Australia in good hands under proactive Smith

The new stand-in captain has the makings of a long-term leader, given his ability to stay ahead of the game

News | Features Last 7 days

    BCCI's argument against DRS not 100% (164)

    Turning your back on a system that the whole cricketing world wants a discussion on, refusing to discuss it because it is not 100%, is not good enough

    Karn struggles to stay afloat (114)

    The failed gamble of handing Karn Sharma a Test debut despite him having a moderate first-class record means India have to rethink who their spinner will be

    Kohli attains batting nirvana (110)

    Virat Kohli's innings on the final day transcended the conditions, the bowlers and his batting partners, and when it was all in vain, he displayed remarkable grace in defeat

    When defeat isn't depressing (57)

    After a long time we have seen an Indian team and captain enjoy the challenge of trying to overcome stronger opposition in an overseas Test

    What ails Rohit and Watson? (52)

    Both batsmen seemingly have buckets of talent at their disposal and the backing of their captains, but soft dismissals relentlessly follow both around the Test arena