Steven Lynch
Ask Steven Ask StevenRSS FeedFeeds  | Archives
The Tuesday column in which Steven Lynch answers your questions on all things cricket. Challenge him on Facebook

Mumbai masala

Level scores, six half-centuries, a hundred with a five-for, and another Tendulkar record - it all happened at the Wankhede

Steven Lynch

December 6, 2011

Text size: A | A

R Ashwin appeals successfully for an lbw against Kieran Powell, India v West Indies, 3rd Test, Mumbai, 5th day, November 26, 2011
It was a busy Test for R Ashwin, who scored his maiden Test hundred, took a five-for, conceding 150 runs in an innings, and levelled the scores in the end © AFP

The Mumbai Test was drawn with the scores level. Has this ever happened before? asked Dennis Morgan from Australia
The exciting third Test between India and West Indies in Mumbai was actually the fifth instance of a Test match ending with both sides having scored the same number of runs. The two most famous instances are the two tied Tests - Australia v West Indies in Brisbane in 1960-61, and India v Australia in Madras (now Chennai) in 1986-87 - when the last wicket went down with the batting side one short of victory. In Bulawayo in 1996-97 England finished one short of victory against Zimbabwe, but that wasn't a tie as England had not lost all their wickets in the second innings. And at Old Trafford in 1998 England's two totals of 183 and 369 for 9 added up exactly to what South Africa scored in just one innings - 552 for 5. That looks one-sided, and it was - but there was an exciting end to the match as England inched closer to avoiding the innings defeat, which they did with a few minutes left, ensuring there would not be time for South Africa to bat again.

The first six West Indies batsmen all scored over 60 in the first innings at Mumbai - is that a first? asked Alastair from Australia
West Indies' first innings in Mumbai was the seventh in all Tests to contain six scores of 60-plus - but only the second time the top six had all managed it. At Kolkata in 1997-98, VVS Laxman made 95, Navjot Sidhu 97, Rahul Dravid 86, Sachin Tendulkar 79, Mohammad Azharuddin 163 and Sourav Ganguly 65, against Australia (the only other batsman used in India's total of 633 for 5 declared was Nayan Mongia, who finished with 30 not out). The first instance of six sixties in an innings was at Old Trafford in 1934, when six England players - including Gubby Allen at No. 9 and Hedley Verity at 10 - managed it. The most recent case before Mumbai was in Bridgetown in 2003, when six of Australia's top seven passed 60 - but opener Matthew Hayden missed out with 27.

Ravichandran Ashwin apparently became only the third Indian player to score a hundred and take a five-for in the same Test at Mumbai - who are the others? And who is the only player to score a double-century and take a five-for in the same Test? asked Richard Webb from England
The other Indian players to echo Ashwin's feat in Mumbai were Vinoo Mankad and Polly Umrigar. Mankad had an astonishing match against England at Lord's in 1952: in between innings of 72 and 184 he bowled 73 overs and took 5 for 196. In England's second innings he bowled 24 more overs, finishing with 0 for 35. Umrigar achieved a similar tour de force against West Indies in Port-of-Spain in 1961-62, in a match India ended up losing: after taking 5 for 107 in West Indies' first innings of 444 he top-scored with 56 then, in the follow-on, made 172 not out. Finally Umrigar bowled 16 overs for 17 runs as West Indies made heavy weather of chasing down the 176 they needed for victory (it took them 101 overs). For the full list of people who have done this, click here. Two men (not one) have managed a double-century and a five-for in the same Test: Denis Atkinson, for West Indies against Australia in Bridgetown in 1955, and Mushtaq Mohammad, for Pakistan against New Zealand in Dunedin in 1972-73.

Ashwin acheived the double of a hundred and a five-wicket haul in his third Test match. Has anyone done this in their first Test? asked Aby Siby Kalappurayil from India
The only man to have achieved this double on Test debut was Bruce Taylor, for New Zealand v India in Calcutta (now Kolkata) in 1964-65. Taylor came in at No. 8 and hit 105 - his maiden century in first-class cricket - and later took 5 for 86. Jack Gregory, the Australian allrounder, achieved the feat in his second Test, against England in Melbourne in 1920-21.

Ashwin conceded 150 runs and scored a century at Mumbai. How often has this happened in Tests? asked Nandan Lokare from India
Ashwin (5 for 156 and 103) was the fifth player to achieve this particular all-round double in a Test. Another Indian, Vinoo Mankad, did it in the match at Lord's in 1952 referred to above. The first to do it was the tireless Australian, George Giffen, who scored 161 and later took 4 for 164 against England in Sydney in 1894-95 (three years previously Giffen had scored 271 and took 16 wickets for South Australia against Victoria in Adelaide, so this might have felt like a light workout!). Tony Greig followed an innings of 148 with 6 for 164 for England against West Indies in Bridgetown in 1973-74, while in Sheikhupura in 1996-97 (in the match in which Wasim Akram clouted 257 not out from No. 8 for Pakistan) Zimbabwe's Paul Strang followed 106 not out with 5 for 212 from 69 overs.

Sachin Tendulkar was dismissed in the nineties for the tenth time in a Test at Mumbai. Is that a record? asked Mauro Freitas from the United Arab Emirates
Yes, Sachin Tendulkar is indeed the first batsman to be dismissed 10 times in the nineties in Tests, to go with 17 dismissals in the nineties in one-day internationals. Rahul Dravid and Steve Waugh have also made 10 scores in the nineties, but one of Dravid's and two of Waugh's were not out. Michael Slater of Australia was also out nine times in the nineties in only 74 Tests, less than half the matches played by the other three.

Steven Lynch is the editor of the Wisden Guide to International Cricket 2011. Ask Steven is now on Facebook

RSS Feeds: Steven Lynch

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Email Feedback Print
Steven LynchClose
Steven Lynch Steven Lynch won the Wisden Cricket Monthly Christmas Quiz three years running before the then-editor said "I can't let you win it again, but would you like a job?" That lasted for 15 years, before he moved across to the Wisden website when that was set up in 2000. Following the merger of the two sites early in 2003 he was appointed as the global editor of Wisden Cricinfo. In June 2005 he became the deputy editor of Wisden Cricketers' Almanack. He continues to contribute the popular weekly "Ask Steven" question-and-answer column on ESPNcricinfo, and edits the Wisden Guide to International Cricket.

    'The key to Ishant's success will be length'

Ajit Agarkar and Aakash Chopra assess: Ishant Sharma and
Peter Siddle

The best commentator on TV

The Cricket Monthly: Cricket brings the drama through its narrators' tones. Our panelists pick five of their favourites
Download the app: for iPads | for Android tablets

    Love before first sight

My Favourite Cricketer: First-class batsman Yere Goud caught a 13-year-old's attention with his unusual name and news-making runs. By Karthik Krishnaswamy

    Every innings is an act of courage

Simon Barnes: Phillip Hughes' death was desperately unlucky, and it came in the courageous pursuit of sporting excellence

Player Ball Difference: An interesting new concept

Anantha Narayanan: A look at the fastest and the slowest innings in cricket using a new concept. And, another Bradman surprise

News | Features Last 7 days

Phillip Hughes: Gone too soon

The cricket world reacts to the passing away of Phillip Hughes

Phillip Hughes: Country kid who moved a nation

Likeable, hard-working and skilful, it was a matter of time before Phillip Hughes cemented his spot in the Australian Test team. Then, improbably and inconsolably, his time ran out

Hope for Hughes, feel for Abbott

It is impossible to imagine how Sean Abbott must feel after sending down that bouncer to Phillip Hughes. While the cricket world hopes for Hughes' recovery, it should also ensure Abbott is supported

November games need November prices

An early start to the international season, coupled with costly tickets, have kept the Australian public away from the cricket


People across the world paid tribute to Australian cricketer Phillip Hughes, who died on November 27, by putting out their bats

News | Features Last 7 days