Rewind to Rewind toRSS FeedFeeds


Death on a summer's day

In a week where a county moaned about the state of the pitch at Lord's, we look back to the day a batsman was killed on the same ground

Martin Williamson

April 21, 2012

Text size: A | A

George Summers
Wisden on George Summers: "No professional cricketer ever left us who in life was more highly respected and whose death was more deeply deplored" © 'Cricket' magazine
Related Links
Players/Officials: Richard Daft | John Platts | George Summers

Despite its standing in the game as the Mecca of cricket, Lord's has not always managed to produce high-quality pitches. Earlier this week, Surrey's three-run defeat by Middlesex triggered a somewhat predictable outpouring of moans from the losing side about an underprepared track. At least the pain was only mental. In 1870 a poor pitch cost Nottinghamshire's George Summers his life. Cricket's history is dotted with low-scoring matches where the Lord's pitch has been to blame.

In the 1860s, by which time Lord's was established as the most prestigious venue in the land, it nevertheless had a reputation for poor and at times dangerous wickets. Overuse was allied to primitive groundsmanship; sheep still kept the outfield grass trimmed, and the pitches themselves were cut with rudimentary tools. The first "grass-cutting machine" had been patented in 1830 and horse-drawn mowers came a decade later. By the 1850s mechanical mowers started to appear but Lord's was slow to embrace the new technology and these were not used at the ground until the 1880s.

In 1864, Sussex refused to play a match there because the conditions were so poor. The MCC returfed the entire ground but things did not improve. In 1868, Lord Harris said he expected "three shooters every eight balls" when playing at Lord's. In 1869 and 1870 only two of the scheduled first-class matches went into a third day, both against Nottinghamshire.

But not everyone thought this was necessarily a bad thing. A number of cricketers - almost exclusively amateurs whose livelihoods did not depend on performances - believed a bad surface provided a test of courage and virility. If you could take blows on the body, so the thinking went, then it showed you were a real man. And this in an era where protection was almost non-existent.

Work continued on trying to improve conditions, although annual reports showed far more time and money was spent on making the lives of spectators, especially members, better than on the playing facilities. At the start of 1870 the MCC finally purchased a heavy roller, which was brought into use for that season. Wisden went so far as to describe the resulting wickets as "excellent". However, the main bugbear remained small pebbles on the pitch that rose to the surface with frustrating regularity.

In June 1870, Nottinghamshire travelled to London by train for two games, their first major matches of the summer. They started at The Oval, where they beat Surrey by 108 runs, remaining in the city for a two-day break before heading to Lord's to face a strong MCC side.

The three days were played out under a hot sun. Nottinghamshire made 267 and MCC replied with 187 and, following on under the laws of the day, 240, leaving the visitors a target of 155. When they lost their first wicket, Summers came out to bat.

Summers was a 25-year-old Nottingham-born professional batsman who had been in the side for three seasons without really stamping his mark although he was considered a bright prospect and an outstanding cover fielder. Usually an opener, he had dropped down the order for these two matches. While his performances had been adequate, he was still good enough to have played in four prestigious Gentlemen v Players contests.

The first delivery Summers faced was from John Platts, a young fast bowler making his first-class debut; the ball hit one of the loose pebbles and reared up, striking Summers between the cheek and the temple. He "reeled like a teetotum and fell" at the crease. WG Grace, a 22-year-old medical student at the time, gave what assistance he could and Summers, although conscious, was deemed unfit to continue and headed off.

Richard Daft, Nottinghamshire's captain and a renowned player who had made 117 in the first innings (as had Grace for MCC) emerged from the pavilion to bat at No. 4 with his head swathed in a towel. He later recalled he was mocked by the fielders for donning this rudimentary protection.

Charles Thornton, who at the time refused to wear pads when batting, let alone gloves, said Daft "had a towel round his head covered with a scarf tied under his chin". Another MCC player, Charles Green, was openly disgusted by Daft's actions, claiming he looked "ridiculous". But neither of them relied on cricket for an income, whereas if Daft got injured he would be out of pocket.

Summers, meanwhile, although groggy, was given a brandy and then sat in the sun at the front of the pavilion to watch the remainder of the match, which Nottinghamshire won by two wickets. From Lord's the team went back to their hotel before heading to the station to catch the return train to Nottingham. It was suggested to Summers he remain in London to rest and seek medical help, but he declined as he had been away from home for more than a week and was keen to return.

Summers' condition worsened during the journey and cannot have been helped by the shaking of the carriage he was in, often violently. On some parts of the line between London and Nottingham the rails at that time were reported as being so bad as to induce dizziness in the most fit of passengers.

He arrived back at his father's Nottingham house but was still not well. Three days later he collapsed and died. He was two days shy of his 26th birthday.

Almost immediately blame was laid on senior Nottinghamshire players, who, it was claimed, had not looked after the injured Summers properly. Grace, who played in the game, was one of the most outspoken. The accusations were naturally and vigorously denied by those involved.

Within days the MCC had paid £30 for a gravestone with an inscription "to mark their sense of his qualities as a cricketer and to testify their regret at the untimely accident at Lord's Ground, which cut short a short career full of promise". Wisden's report in 1871 stated that "no professional cricketer ever left us who in life was more highly respected and whose death was more deeply deplored".

As for Platts, the incident took a heavy toll on him. He lessened his pace and the catastrophe made such a painful impression it is said he never in subsequent years could play, with any pleasure, at Lord's.

Is there an incident from the past you would like to know more about? Email with your comments and suggestions.

WG Grace: A Life by Simon Rae (Faber and Faber, 1998)
A Social History of English Cricket by Derek Birley (Aurum, 2000)
More Than A Game by John Major (Harper Press, 2007)
Wisden's Cricketers' Almanack 1871

Martin Williamson is executive editor of ESPNcricinfo and managing editor of ESPN Digital Media in Europe, the Middle East and Africa

RSS Feeds: Martin Williamson

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Email Feedback Print
Martin WilliamsonClose
Martin Williamson Executive editor Martin Williamson joined the Wisden website in its planning stages in 2001 after failing to make his millions in the internet boom when managing editor of Sportal. Before that he was in charge of Sky Sports Online and helped launch and run Sky News Online. With a preference for all things old (except his wife and children), he has recently confounded colleagues by displaying an uncharacteristic fondness for Twenty20 cricket. His enthusiasm for the game is sadly not matched by his ability, but he remains convinced that he might be a late developer and perseveres in the hope of an England call-up with his middle-order batting and non-spinning offbreaks. He is now managing editor of ESPN EMEA Digital Group as well as his Cricinfo responsibilities.

    'When I became an umpire, I didn't realise how complicated this game was'

Peter Willey on suiting upo against '80s West Indies, and umpiring in England

    'Saqlain was like an English spinner with a subcontinental touch'

My XI: Erapalli Prasanna on a spinner whom even Sachin Tendulkar found hard to bat against

Hitting Warnie for six, and Test stumpings

Think You Know Yourself: Do administrators have their numbers at their fingertips? Not Dave Richardson

    Last ball, last wicket, and Northants' parched spell

Ask Steven: Also, Vijay Manjrekar's nickname, Abid Ali's no-ball, oldest double-centurions, and this decade's leading players

Cricket: complex, unknowable cricket

Jon Hotten: We, as players and spectators, are finite, but cricket, utterly brilliant in its design, is not

News | Features Last 7 days

How India weeds out its suspect actions

The BCCI set up a three-man committee to tackle the problem of chucking at age-group and domestic cricket, and it has produced significant results in five years

A rock, a hard place and the WICB

The board's latest standoff with its players has had embarrassing consequences internationally, so any resolution now needs to be approached thoughtfully

Kohli back to old habits

Stats highlights from the fourth ODI between India and West Indies in Dharamsala

West Indies go AWOL

West Indies may have formally played the fourth ODI in Dharamsala but their fielding suggested their minds were already on the flight back home

KP and the green-eyed monster

Individual rivalries in team sports can be productive or destructive. Jealousy may have spurred Pietersen the batsman, but at the cost of the team's image

News | Features Last 7 days