Ian Chappell
Ian Chappell Ian ChappellRSS FeedFeeds  | Archives
Former Australia captain, now a cricket commentator and columnist

Spin could be Australia's Achilles heel in India

Picking a second spinner to partner Nathan Lyon, and how to bat on turning tracks will be the big questions for the side

Ian Chappell

February 10, 2013

Comments: 59 | Text size: A | A

Michael Clarke has a light moment during training, Sydney, January 25, 2012
If Shane Watson opens with David Warner, Michael Clarke can bat at No. 4, the position he's best suited to © Getty Images

The clash between India and Australia promises to be a classic battle between spin and pace and experience and youth.

Australia's great strength is their hit-man squad of fast bowlers, who will be confronted by an experienced Indian batting line-up. How the young quicks cope with the conditions will play a big part in deciding the series, and it could also shape Sachin Tendulkar's immediate future. A good series might see him carry on in Test cricket, but another poor showing like the one he had against England may prompt him to retire.

Australia will be comforted by the success Jimmy Anderson had in India, and they will prefer to play three fast bowlers: Peter Siddle and Mitchell Starc will be the first picks, and James Pattinson, if he is deemed ready, is likely to be preferred over Mitchell Johnson as the third. But that means Australia will be going in with two bowlers - Siddle and Pattinson - who haven't played any long-form cricket in over a month.

This summer Starc has had consistent success with late movement into right-hand batsmen at a lively pace - a delivery that the highly dangerous Virender Sehwag is most uncomfortable against. His opening partner Gautam Gambhir is, like most batsmen, vulnerable to the away-swinger early on.

Gambhir will be a prized early wicket, because he can attack spinners. Australia will be flustered if he gets on top of Nathan Lyon, who is a steady offspinner - no Graeme Swann, but tidy nonetheless.

However, none of Australia's other spinners has made a mark so far. Choosing the second spinner will be crucial. They may look to cover two bases by using Glenn Maxwell as a second spinner who can add some valuable middle-order runs. India should look to attack him from the outset to dent one of his great strengths - confidence.

If the Indian pitches for the series are raging turners, the other option would be to use medium-fast allrounder Moises Henriques as a third seamer and Xavier Doherty as the second frontline spinner.

Other than not having top-class spinners, Australia's most glaring weakness is batting against quality spin. If their batsmen were facing a traditional Indian side, full of wily spinners, it would have spelt trouble for them, but against this team, which is still trying to decide on its best attack, they will feel they have a chance.

The Australian batting order contains two areas of contention: who will open and where will Michael Clarke bat?

Shane Watson's return to top form in ODIs suggests he'll open with the ultra-aggressive David Warner. That is Australia's best opening combination and it lines up the batting order correctly, with Clarke at No. 4, where he's best suited. Clarke is the best player of spin in the Australian side, so he can't afford to bat any lower than No. 4, otherwise the Indian spinners could have the upper hand by the time he arrives at the crease. With Watson opening, it's likely Australia will have some runs on the board before Clarke has to face the spinners. That makes him a much more dangerous proposition.

That leaves the ungainly but highly effective Phil Hughes at No. 3 and opens up a spot for Usman Khawaja at No. 5. This will be a big test for Khawaja, as he is a bit leaden-footed to start with against spinners, but Australia have to unearth some young batsmen, especially in the middle order. Matthew Wade will bat at No. 6, with Maxwell coming at 7.

The make-up of India's attack will give a clue to how they propose to dismantle the Australian batting. As Australians traditionally play legspin better than the left-arm orthodox variety, I suspect India will choose two left-arm spinners to partner offspinner R Ashwin.

The type of surfaces the four Tests will be played on will have a big part in shaping the result. I expect the pitches to favour spin rather than pace. If that's the case, India will be favourites to win, but only if they have mentally recovered from being beaten by England.

Former Australia captain Ian Chappell is now a cricket commentator for Channel 9, and a columnist

RSS Feeds: Ian Chappell

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by Kaze on (February 13, 2013, 23:03 GMT)

I prefer to look to past series to judge strength. In the last series OZ gave the indians a hell of a run in the first 2 tests. That was an indian side with much more experienced batting than the current one. The key for me is Starc, if he gets his swing going at pace then the pitch becomes irrelevant. It will be a torrid time for an indian side whose younger players are notoriously terrible against pace bowling. My money is on OZ to thrash india , they might struggle at times against the spin but I will back them to do the job.

Posted by   on (February 12, 2013, 2:51 GMT)

Aussie's are really going to miss Steve O'keefe and he is far better spinner/bat compared to Lyon or Doherty... India would be really happy with Mike Hussey just announcing his retirement just before this series...

Aussie XI against 1st Test: Warner, Ed Cowan, Hughes, Clarke, Watson, Wade, Maxwell, Johnson, Pattison, Starc, Lyon

Posted by wellrounded87 on (February 12, 2013, 2:44 GMT)

Not many people giving Lyon a chance here. He's proved a solid spinner and lumping him in with Doherty Maxwell and Smith is unfair. He's a much better spinner than these guys. He might not be a future great but he's good enough to take wickets when needed and also apply some pressure with good flight and drift. Has everyone forgot how he dismantled SL in SL? I hope he does really well this series to shut up the naysayers. I also hope Johnson can put in a good performance he's been bowling very well lately, much more consistent than he used to be. Still waiting for the next destructive spell from him.

As far as India is concerned i'm interested to see how Pujara and Kohli go. Both show plenty of potential and i think will be the hardest men for us to dispose of. I'm of course assuming Tendulkar and Sehwag continue slipping into senility and don't rediscover their youth in this series.

Posted by krishna_cricketfan on (February 11, 2013, 21:13 GMT)

Time and again, it has been proved that good pace attack and/or spin attack can defeat India. I am not sure why spin is always highlighted. Good bowlers depend on their skills and to an extent on the pitch. Legend like McGrath have shown that. Aussies won a test series in India with pace attack. Even the 2001 series was a nail biter. That again was due to McGrath and others. If the Australian bowlers bowl to their potential, Indians will have tough time. The batting lineup is not what it used to be. Is anyone in form? Did not the England bowlers show where we stand? So this is going to be a tough series for India. Indian bowling the less said the better.

Posted by Raki99 on (February 11, 2013, 14:46 GMT)

Neither team is capable of taking 20 wickets, Australia have good pace attack thats it but they don't have even a avarage spinners, England won beacuse of their spin attack in india, But again India is a hopelless team when it comes to Test cricket. Their batsman and bowlers are all mediocore. Tendulkar is just playing to get to 200 test matches. He is done and dusted same can be said about sehwag. Dhoni as a captain in test cricket is joke. i see a tie or a aus win in this series. BCCI thanks for droping Ghambir as he was a giving nice slip cathing practice to the opposition... India's bolwing is mess too the spinners are horrible and pacers don't have enough pace. 5 years from now we will only have three nations playing test cricket. England Australia and south africa.

Posted by NP_NY on (February 11, 2013, 13:14 GMT)

Not to worry Ian. Looks like spin is going to be India's achilles heel too. Actually India's bowling is going to be India's achilles heel....and India's opening batsmen....and India's middle order. I'd love for the Indian team to prove me wrong though. I strongly doubt they will.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Ian ChappellClose
Ian Chappell Widely regarded as the best Australian captain of the last 50 years, Ian Chappell moulded a team in his image: tough, positive, and fearless. Even though Chappell sometimes risked defeat playing for a win, Australia did not lose a Test series under him between 1971 and 1975. He was an aggressive batsman himself, always ready to hook a bouncer and unafraid to use his feet against the spinners. In 1977 he played a lead role in the defection of a number of Australian players to Kerry Packer's World Series Cricket, which did not endear him to the administrators, who he regarded with contempt in any case. After retirement, he made an easy switch to television, where he has come to be known as a trenchant and fiercely independent voice.

    'I have what it takes to be a great Test batsman'

Couch Talk: West Indies batsman Kraigg Brathwaite on his mental approach, and his captaincy ambitions

What to expect from this World Cup

Jarrod Kimber: A random list of things that you may or may not see at the 2015 mega-event

Forever young

The Cricket Monthly: In pictures, famous players at the age of 25
Download the app: for iPads | for Android tablets

    Ronchi's blitz, and remarkable ODI recoveries

Ask Steven: Also, the fastest ODI 150s, and the highest Test totals without a half-century

The many crickets of an Indian boyhood

Sankaran Krishna: Growing up in India, you play a number of varieties of the game, each developing a certain skill

News | Features Last 7 days

Kohli at No. 4 - defensive or practical?

It seems Virat Kohli is to not bat before the 12th or 13th over to strengthen the middle and the lower middle order. It suggests a lack of confidence in what was supposed to be India's strength in their title defence: their batting

Open with Rohit and Binny, with Kohli at No. 3

India's batting is going the way of their bowling in Australia, and they need get their order sorted before the World Cup

Off-stump blues leave Dhawan flailing

The out-of-form Shikhar Dhawan still has the backing of his captain, but there's no denying his slump has arrived at an inconvenient time for India and his technical issues have to be sorted out before they attempt to defend the World Cup

On TV it looks uglier than it actually is

Often reasonable arguments on the field look nasty beyond the boundary and on camera

Ronchi smashes highest score by a No. 7

Stats highlights from the fifth ODI between New Zealand and Sri Lanka at Dunedin

News | Features Last 7 days