WICB President's XI v Australians, Bridgetown, 2nd day April 3, 2012

Tourists suspect against spin - Baugh


Carlton Baugh, the West Indies wicketkeeper, has openly questioned Australia's readiness to battle the spin of Devendra Bishoo after the tourists were made to look ordinary by a modest pair of local slow bowlers in their only warm-up for the Caribbean Test series.

Having struggled to read and play the offbreaks and variations of the IPL-bound Sunil Narine in the limited-overs matches, Australia's batsmen will soon be pitted against Bishoo, winner of the ICC's Emerging Player of the Year award for 2011 after a series of wily performances against India's spin-conversant batsmen at home and away.

Bishoo's four most recent appearances for Guyana in the regional first-class competition have reaped 24 wickets, and his skills are far in advance of those used by Ryan Austin and the part-time wrist-spinner Nkrumah Bonner at the Three Ws Oval. Baugh had little hesitation pointing this out, and also Australia's periodic difficulties against quality slow bowlers down the decades.

"To be honest, over the years Australia doesn't play spin that well," Baugh said. "Not taking away anything from them, they're pretty good players, but tradition follows on from the years that they're not the best players of spin.

"It is pretty interesting because Austin is a natural offspin bowler and Bonner is pretty much a part-time legspin bowler, so it was pretty interesting to see what others can do, especially Devendra Bishoo and other spin bowlers."

Bishoo was hidden from Australia's view during the ODIs and Twenty20s, and Baugh said this sleight of hand "could be [an advantage], and on Bishoo's day you never know what can happen".

Watching from behind the stumps as captain of the WICB President's XI, Baugh saw Michael Clarke make a smooth 30 and Ricky Ponting a brief 13. He reasoned that the visitors' preference for faster surfaces had contributed to a mediocre first innings of 214 for 9 declared.

"Today for them wasn't the best day in terms of how the wicket was playing, they are accustomed to wickets coming on just like in Australia," Baugh said. "This wicket wasn't the best and they struggled a little bit. Hopefully when the Test matches start if we can continue to keep them on that road, eventually we should surprise them.

"Our team is growing in confidence and you can see what we've been putting in and it's paying off, so we're just taking it one step at a time, and hopefully we can be very much competitive, just like the one-day series. They weren't at their best as you can see and they played a few batters short, but at the same time it is the Australian team and I think we bowled pretty well in patches. To restrict them to 214 even though they had declared, we still got nine wickets and that is a plus for us."

Shane Watson, the touring vice-captain, admitted the Australians were "not entirely" happy with how they had gone in their pursuit of a smooth segue to day one of the series.

"We would have liked guys going on to get bigger scores and a bit more consistent batting but the practice matches are here for the guys to adjust to conditions as well as we can and get some time in the middle," Watson said. "It's certainly better than training. It's more to get out of it as much as you can. So far most batters have had enough time in the middle to get their head around their game plans are going to be on these types of wickets."

As for Bishoo, Watson said he was formulating his method to combat the Guyanese legspinner. "I've seen a fair bit of him already because there was a chance he was going to play the one-day series and the Twenty20s," Watson said. "I've already had a fair look at his footage so far and I've seen the way he bowled throughout the World Cup for the West Indies very closely.

"Without playing him I've got an idea of what his skills are and how he's going to bowl, it's moreso until you get out there and see what he's doing and whether the wicket is turning before you know how big a challenge he's going to be. There's no doubt he's got some really good skills. It's going to be a good challenge for our batting group."

Daniel Brettig is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo. He tweets here

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Geoffrey on April 7, 2012, 6:28 GMT

    @RandyOZ "Failing Miserably"- right.. I suggest mate that you get your excuses ready, the windies spinners are about to rock Australian cricket. I'd try the saffy coach or maybe the windies slow wickets. Don't dare try and give the windies any credit. It just wouldn't be the Australian way.

  • Randolph on April 6, 2012, 11:24 GMT

    Australia crushed Sri Lanka, and England are failing miserably, yeh, we are weak aginst spin.

  • Sean on April 5, 2012, 23:56 GMT

    australia are ranked 4th!

  • Michael on April 5, 2012, 12:05 GMT

    @ Reuelsean....Because a man took 4 wickets in a match since January you say he is fit ? What long spells you talking about ? You mean he had LONG breaks between his spells.... even the TnT commentators said that he has put on some weight. Ashley Nurse took a number of wickets in about 4 or five matches and was replaced in a WI called up because he was not fit..all along people thought he was fit.Over the years Rampaul has ALWAYS struggled with his fitness in the tests.Anytime he is given long spells ,you can see him huffing and puffing on the boundary....and to come back after a long layoff and clearly overweight and make the X1 would be a mistake.

  • Marcio on April 5, 2012, 12:00 GMT

    Ponting, Clarke and Hussey are great players of spin. People here are dreaming. AUS accounted for SL easily in the dustbowls of SL, why would they suddenly become inept now?

  • Zaccharia on April 5, 2012, 8:36 GMT

    @Hammond--We played Herath very well in our series win in Sri Lanka just last year.

  • hayden on April 5, 2012, 5:43 GMT

    @landl47 gee with that comment anyone would think aus are as inept as england at playing spin!!! thanking lucky stars??? more like disapointed the 8th team in the world cant even play its strongest XI in a test against them!!! agree west indies have some tallent in the spin department but trying to score freely against a reletivly unknown spinner in a ODI isnt the same as playing a ball on its merit in a test. as mentioned in other comments bellow the pitch at the 3w's oval, it wasnt like the home side showed aus how to bat on it! they got spun out for less, and i susspect the west indies will probably follow suit.

  • John on April 5, 2012, 3:22 GMT

    I'm really amazed, given how well he bowled in the ODIs, that Narine isn't playing in this series alongside Bishoo. The WI seamers are no more than steady, but those two bowling together, one offspin and one legspin, would be a real challenge. It's almost as though the WI don't believe their own eyes; or perhaps they're so obsessed with the notion that West Indians have to be fast bowlers that they haven't considered the possibility that they might have one of the best spin attacks in the world. The Aussie batsmen must be thanking their lucky stars that Narine will be bowling 4-over spells in the IPL instead of playing test cricket.

  • Rohan on April 5, 2012, 0:20 GMT

    I think Baugh's comments are spot on generally, and especially with the current side. The reason is simple. For the number of great spin bowlers we've had, they are still so very rare. Our pitches are generally not helpful, nor are captains, so unlike in India, only the very best spinners will do well. And since they come around so rarely, our batsmen don't learn to play spin well. Only Clarke in the current side uses his feet regularly to come down to the spinners and how many in the side actually sweep? None! Guys like Warner are just stuck to the crease, can barely score and are a fairly easy wicket. Despite India being on the skids as a test nation, I really do think a lot of the Aussie batsmen will struggle there if they don't at least learn to sweep!

  • Prashan on April 5, 2012, 0:18 GMT

    I think Windies have a great chance to win against Australia this time. Come on Sammy. Go all out and score runs with your big bash style. Hope you can score a ton against Aussies. Also, hope Rampaul, Roach and Bishoo deliver in style as bowlers.

  • No featured comments at the moment.