The Surfer

Boot-camp experience just not cricket

Steve James, writing in the Daily Telegraph , says pre-series excursions like boot camps to get the players to gel better may not achieve the desired results

Siddhartha Talya
Siddhartha Talya
25-Feb-2013
Steve James, writing in the Daily Telegraph, says pre-series excursions like boot camps to get the players to gel better may not achieve the desired results. Cricket, he says, is an individual sport played in a team environment and the togetherness that such exercises try to achieve is seen more in rugby.
Team spirit, eh? Generally I’m with former Tottenham striker Steve Archibald on this one, even if his description – “an illusion glimpsed in the aftermath of victory”– has become a hackneyed cliché. But then cricket is essentially an individual sport played in a team environment. Selfishness often sits comfortably within its dressing rooms. The Australians spout their propaganda about mateship, that machismo forged by miners and bushmen in the harsh conditions of the late 19th century, whereby a man had to do everything within his powers to stand by his mate. But I have only really seen that tightness in rugby dressing rooms.
Full post
Franchise-based model the way forward for India

At a time when India's premier domestic competition, the Ranji Trophy, fields as many as 26 regional sides in two leagues, Venkat Ananth makes a strong case for a franchise-based system with fewer teams to foster excellence

Nitin Sundar
Nitin Sundar
25-Feb-2013
At a time when India's premier domestic competition, the Ranji Trophy, fields as many as 26 regional sides in two leagues, Venkat Ananth makes a strong case for a franchise-based system with fewer teams to foster excellence. In his Yahoo blog, he draws parallels with the South African model where 11 provincial teams were shortened to six franchises in a bid to narrow the gap between international and domestic standards.
From a cricketing point of view, firstly, there is likelier to be a heavy competition for places, a larger responsibility towards your side, a professional dressing-room and franchise atmosphere and since corporate ideology is largely result-oriented, it could assist incentivize performances, which is in stark contrast to the existing system, which almost presents itself as a formula a captain needs to rehearse, rinse and repeat to win the Ranji Trophy.
Full post
First the Ashes, then the World Cup

Onward then and upward

George Binoy
George Binoy
25-Feb-2013
For reasons best known to themselves, England have gone on a bonding session for four days. Apparently they are not fed up with the sight of each other after a season which began in April, or February if you count the Bangladesh tour. If it helps to devise plans to ensnare terracotta urns, all well and good. England have their best chance for decades of retaining the Ashes in Australia. They last did so in 1986-87 when Mike Gatting's side were not tipped to keep the prize won in 1985 by David Gower's side.
This will not be easy because Australia being Australia, they are developing a new team of their own. They may spring on England some new fast bowlers like Josh Hazlewood, only 19, and Peter George. Hazlewood's cause for a dramatic debut has been diminished by having to withdraw from the squad to tour India because of a stress fracture to his back.
In the Observer, Vic Marks says: "Sport's most captivating contest cannot be renewed soon enough after the havoc wreaked during a summer spent hosting Pakistan."
Full post
Amir in the eye of the storm

Masud Alam visits Changa Bangal, Mohammad Amir's village in Pakistan, and speaks to family and friends about one of their very own at the centre of the spot-fixing controversy

Siddhartha Talya
Siddhartha Talya
25-Feb-2013
We take the dirt track and stop in a square that is the entrance to the enclave. Two narrow, winding streets lead off at a right angle. All the houses have low boundary walls and identical name plates stuck to them. The streets are paved and clean. No open sewers and no stench of cow dung. Many of houses are single-storied and all are small but neat and well presented. Amir's house is at the far edge of the enclave with open fields on two sides. A Pakistani flag embellished with golden border is flying on a pole fixed on the rooftop — a symbol of pride for Amir's father, Mohammed Fayyaz, for having served in the Pakistan army. He retired as a sepoy.
Full post
Drop Cook, play Morgan

England are taking Eoin Morgan to Australia and Duncan Fletcher, writing in the Guardian , says its critical that they fit him into the team at No

George Binoy
George Binoy
25-Feb-2013
England are taking Eoin Morgan to Australia and Duncan Fletcher, writing in the Guardian, says its critical that they fit him into the team at No. 6 for the first Test.
If England are going to fit Morgan in, obviously someone else will have to make way. The men to look at here are the No2 and No3 in the order, Alastair Cook and Jonathan Trott. I think Cook should be the man who is dropped. I have written before about the qualities Cook brings to the team apart from his ability as a batsman. The management clearly like him as a character and see him as a good influence on the team. But the runs Trott has scored in international cricket since he came into the team outweigh those criteria. On top of that the one major concern I would have about the English batting is their propensity for sudden collapses. They have not managed to shake off this habit, as we saw again and again in both the recent Test and one-day series. Trott, like Morgan, seems to be a cool player in a crisis, with a steady temperament and an ability to handle pressure.
In his analysis of England's Ashes squad for the Telegraph, Shane Warne says the visitors' success could hinge on how Graeme Swann performs. He also throws light on why Chris Tremlett could prove crucial for England if he bowls with the right attitude.
Graeme Swann is the No 1 spinner. He is the most improved cricketer in the world and has had another good summer. For me he is the key to the Ashes. If Swann is successful, England will do well in Australia. I believe that because when it is hot and sunny in Australia and England are bowling on flat wickets, he is going to bowl a lot of overs. Australians sometimes struggle against good off-spinners, so he will play a massive part ...
Full post
What next for Pakistan?

As Pakistan depart England after a tour besieged by grave controversy, James Lawton, writing in the Independent , says cricket must not cast them into the wilderness.

George Binoy
George Binoy
25-Feb-2013
What cricket cannot afford to do is write off Pakistan as a lost cause before properly recognising that it is not in a position to hand down such arbitrary moral judgement; not, at least, without acknowledging that the richest part of its empire, India, is also beset by terrible doubts about its freedom from spot- and match-fixing and that even such a sturdy sports nation as South Africa was unable to escape one of the worst examples of corruption in the history of any sport.
None of this is likely to sweep away the great mountain of doubt and dismay that has accumulated in England this summer – or diminish the challenge of attempting to reform a Pakistani game that operates in a society where corruption is not so much a threat as the norm and the legitimate rewards of the most successful Pakistani cricketers are dwarfed by those of their chief rivals.
While Nasser Hussain isn't condoning the controversies that marred the English summer, writing in the Daily Mail, he says "you've got to admit that watching Pakistan is never dull."
Full post
Who will defend the Ashes for England?

England will take an official party of 16, but in effect this will be doubled by the performance squad that will be in Australia not just to provide players who are match-fit and can be called up in case of injury, but to give alternatives should

George Binoy
George Binoy
25-Feb-2013
However, unless there is a catastrophic absence of form during the three warm-up matches in Perth, Adelaide and Hobart we can name the XI for the first Test in Brisbane as those who played the last Test of the summer at Lord's, with the inclusion of Ian Bell in place of Eoin Morgan, who will nonetheless be in the party.
That strategy for the first Test has been clear all summer and is spot on (it is the balance England should have fielded in Brisbane last time). However, for the rest of the series it will vary according to venue, pitch, weather and circumstance, as of course it should. Previous stereotyping of Australian pitches should not be taken as the norm now: Perth is no longer the fastest pitch in the world and Sydney is not the sand pit it once was. There is talk, too, of attempting to tickle pitches to suit Australia's attack and negate Graeme Swann, though this would only help England's seamers, while Swann gets wickets in all conditions.
In the Independent, Stephen Brenkley says: "Gone are the days when a batsman could make a late run on the rails by having a fertile August, or a fast bowler could emerge suddenly and force the selectors' hands. Continuity is the modern mantra and England have constantly demonstrated its value in the past 18 months."
Full post
James Anderson does cricket proud

James Anderson's appearance in the new issue of the gay magazine Attitude has confirmed his status as one of our most admirable sportsmen: clever, charming and – above all – courageous, writes Simon Briggs in the Telegraph .

George Binoy
George Binoy
25-Feb-2013
While same-sex marriages have become routine events across the civilised world, homosexuality in professional sport remains a forbidden frontier ...
"If there are any gay cricketers," Anderson told Attitude, "they should feel confident enough to come out, because I don't think there is homophobia in cricket. Football fans can be quite abusive and quite harsh, [but] cricket fans are generally quite placid."
This is probably right, even if one can imagine the beery hordes at the Melbourne Cricket Ground coming out with a few ugly chants. Yet most people are less worried about the fans than they are about their own peers.
Full post
Theatre of the absurd

The Champions League Twenty20 is a tournament searching for an identity

Tariq Engineer
25-Feb-2013
My problem with the Champions League begins with the concept. Memory being notoriously short, here's a quick history lesson: In 2000-'01, you had a tournament in Perth called the "Champions Cup" played towards the end of the Australian domestic season, which was loosely modeled on the FIFA World Club Championship, and was meant to discover the best domestic one-day side in the world. Mumbai, Kwazulu-Natal, Central Districts and hosts Western Australia featured in the tournament, but soon after its debut it was sadly disbanded. My guess is it didn't work as well as the organizers hoped it would, and the whole 'international domestic cricket' schtick wasn't as commercially viable or capable of generating as much spectator interest as the organizers believed.
Full post
The time may come to remove Pakistan

There may come a point sometime soon when temporarily removing Pakistan from world cricket may be the only way to preserve the game's dignity

George Binoy
George Binoy
25-Feb-2013
I've generally agreed with Imran Khan on this: You can't kick out a team just because of two or three bad apples. But we're seeing now what happens when accusations are bandied around with no thought for their consequences. Would Jonathan Trott and Wahab Riaz have had their dust-up before the start of play yesterday if Butt hadn't accused England of throwing the Oval one-dayer? Possibly.
But it's no surprise that tempers are fraying at the end of a summer in which England have had to put up with so much.
In the Daily Telegraph, Derek Pringle says, "Charity and sympathy are deserved by the millions ruined and damaged by the monsoon floodwaters, but Pakistan cricket is rapidly becoming a monster only a mother could love."
Full post

Showing 3251 - 3260 of 9201