The Surfer

PCB, Younis need to show maturity

The PCB has to find a way of addressing issues leading to dissent within the Pakistan team and try to restore Younis Khan as captain, while Younis himself has to come out with a direct response to end any speculation surrounding his stepping down,

Siddhartha Talya
Siddhartha Talya
25-Feb-2013
Unfortunately, on many occasions the authorities shattered all hopes of tens of millions of Pakistani fans. The present management is no exception.
The glaring proof is the casual manner with which the board coped with Younis’ break from the game, accepting his plea without any queries or concern. Rather than backing the captain fully at this crucial juncture of his career, the Ijaz Butt-led PCB gave the senior batsman the impression that they were too eager to see him go off the scene.
Amid reports of differences with some of the players, a tough competitor like Younis was left out in the cold by the authorities who perhaps didn’t realise the gravity of the situation that had been developing quietly for several months.
Full post
Blame the players, not UDRS

The Umpire Decision Review System is not to be blamed for the criticisms associated with it, but the players, who have misused it and to some extent, the TV umpires, who haven't yet come to grips with their job description, writes Lawrence Booth in

Siddhartha Talya
Siddhartha Talya
25-Feb-2013
The truth is, it couldn’t be simpler. A quick reminder: if a player thinks he’s been done an injustice and his side has one or both of its challenges per innings in hand, he can refer the decision to the TV umpire. And if the TV umpire sees clear evidence that the original decision was wrong, he can over-rule. Where, gentlemen, is the difficulty?
Problems have arisen not because – as romantics such as Dickie Bird believe – the on-field umpires have been stripped of their authority, but because both the players and the TV umpires have exceeded their brief. The ICC, in trying to deal with the kind of umpiring-induced bad blood that marred India’s tour of Australia in 2007-08, have made it clear all along that the UDRS is there to get rid of the howlers. And that is it.
Full post
Vote for Strauss

James Lawton, writing in the Independent , makes a case for Andrew Strauss to be voted the BBC's Sports Personality of the Year

Siddhartha Talya
Siddhartha Talya
25-Feb-2013
James Lawton, writing in the Independent, makes a case for Andrew Strauss to be voted the BBC's Sports Personality of the Year. He points out the turmoil in which Strauss inherited the England captaincy and the turnaround he wrought by regaining the Ashes.
Ryan Giggs is considered an infinitely stronger contender than Strauss at 5-2 and there is no question that he is a candidate of great merit, his evergreen, biting performances reminding us of all the quality that he has brought to a career which has seen him outstrip in character and consistency all of his Old Trafford contemporaries except the equally phenomenal Paul Scholes, the best English midfielder of his generation.
Yet Strauss's position in the odds table remains both an oddity and a scandal. Above anything else, it suggests a profound failure in the sports public to muster even the rudiments of proper analysis; a sweeping assessment perhaps but then what other conclusion survives even the barest examination of quite what Strauss achieved in the wake of the embarrassing denouement of Kevin Pietersen's ill-starred captaincy.
Full post
Decline in quality of offspinners in India

G Viswanath, writing in the Hindu , says the BCCI's clampdown on bowlers with suspect actions in the current domestic season has contributed to the below-par performance of offspinners.

Siddhartha Talya
Siddhartha Talya
25-Feb-2013
G Viswanath, writing in the Hindu, says the BCCI's clampdown on bowlers with suspect actions in the current domestic season has contributed to the below-par performance of offspinners.
This ought to be seen as an unhappy development in a country for which this type of finger spinners — with the ball breaking into the batsman’s body allied with flight and line and length variations with a high intelligence quotient of the practioners — have played a distinguished part and has been regarded as an important cog in the wheel of India’s bowling arrangement.
The decline of quality off-break bowlers has been a gradual feature in the last two decades and in this season the sheer anxiety of being called for illegal action has eliminated this particular facet of the game in India.
Full post
The new Rahul Dravid?

Suresh Menon is mighty impressed with M Vijay's turn as opener in the Brabourne Test

Cricinfo
25-Feb-2013
Suresh Menon is mighty impressed with M Vijay's turn as opener in the Brabourne Test. He suggests on dreamcricket.com that Vijay might be "the Rahul Dravid of the next generation."
Vijay played the medium pacers comfortably, getting out of the way of the short-pitched deliveries both easily and elegantly, and when Muttiah Muralidaran came on, drove him past cover with the minimum of effort. He brought up his fifty with a six, and at no point in the 200-plus partnership with Sehwag did he look like a man playing in only his second Test. It was a confident, professional innings that was aesthetically pleasing as well, and that is a combination of virtues few young Indian batsmen bring to their efforts.
Full post
Dermott, a legend who cannot be replaced

Dermott Monteith, Ireland's all-time highest wicket-taker, died yesterday at the age of 66

Siddhartha Talya
Siddhartha Talya
25-Feb-2013
Nowadays, Ireland cricketers can chalk up 76 appearances in barely two years. It took Dermott 19 summers. He missed 25 matches including Ireland’s most famous at the time, at Sion Mills when the West Indies were dismissed for 25. Although his bowling would not have been needed in that match, no one has bowled more overs for Ireland.
Full post
India's remarkable climb

There have been plenty of factors at play in India's rise to the No.1 ranking in Tests, including MS Dhoni's captaincy, but foremost among them is their adherence to the "process" put in place by coach Gary Kirsten, writes Lokendra Pratap Sahi in the

Siddhartha Talya
Siddhartha Talya
25-Feb-2013
When Chappell talked of “process,” it would be seen as a means of keeping Sourav Ganguly out of the dressing room and getting Sachin to bat down the order in ODIs, instead of opening the innings.
Kirsten, Chappell’s full-time successor, did away with a lot of things fancied by the Australian legend. However, he kept faith in the basic principles of any “process” and wasn’t wary of saying so in public.
Full post
A ground for the ages

Peter English
Peter English
25-Feb-2013
Mike Coward, writing in the Australian, gets nostalgic about South Australia’s home ground, which is undergoing a major redevelopment.
Unlike most mainland grounds, Adelaide Oval evokes a sense of place and the good folk of this fair if conservative city gather each year to share their knowledge and celebrate the joys of the traditional game.
Full post
Axe hovers over New Zealand batsmen

Depending on which batsmen have most raised the selectors' hackles, three players are in line for the axe from the New Zealand third test team to face Pakistan in Napier this week, writes David Leggat in the New Zealand Herald .

George Binoy
George Binoy
25-Feb-2013
Among the top six, Ross Taylor is the exception; opener Martin Guptill will stay, although he's only managed 75 runs at 18.7 in four innings. So too Daniel Flynn, who at least grafted 5h 8min over 29 and 20 at the Basin Reserve - solid stuff in this context. However lefthander Tim McIntosh (37 runs at 9.5), and middle-order pair Peter Fulton (42 at 10.5).and Grant Elliott (59 at 14.7) all in four innings are on a knife edge. At least one must go.
In the same paper, Leggat also says New Zealand are operating as two distinct halves, and their bowlers are being badly let down.
Full post

Showing 4001 - 4010 of 9201