Reserve players who made good
They were picked as reserve batsman and reserve opening bowler
Partab Ramchand
01-Dec-1999
They were picked as reserve batsman and reserve opening bowler.
But at the end of the opening first class fixture of the
Australian tour, VVS Laxman and T Kumaran have virtually made
their places certain in the Indian team for the first Test
against Australia commencing at Adelaide on December 10. They
continue the tradition of lesser known players doing better than
the stars and gaining a regular place in the team.
Probably the earliest such example of a player making good when
it was least expected of him was Dattu Phadkar. He was picked
for the 1947-48 tour of Australia as a promising fast bowler
who could bat a bit. But with Sohoni, Amarnath, Hazare and
Rangachari around, it was doubtful whether he would get enough
bowling even in the first class games. And with Mankad, Adhikari, Amarnath, Hazare, Rangnekar, Sarwate and Gul Mohammed in the
side, there would be no chance for the 22-year-old from Bombay
to display his batting skills.
But Phadkar, besides being gifted, was also pluck and confidence personified. By the second Test, he had forced his way into the
team, got a half century besides picking up three wickets,
scored another half century in the third Test, got a hundred
in the fourth Test and ended the series with another half century
in the final Test. He headed the batting averages and remained
India's utility man for the next decade.
Twenty years later also on a tour of Australia, it was the turn
of another gutsy cricketer to show his mettle. Like Phadkar,
Abid Ali too was picked as a reserve opening bowler who could
bat a bit. But with Desai, Kulkarni and Surti in the side,
one reckoned that the 26-year-old Hyderabadi was destined to
play a minor role on the tour. However the doughty cricketer that
he always was, Abid Ali made his way into the team for the first
Test, picked up six wickets for 55 - the best figures by an
Indian bowler on debut - scored a valuable 33 and showed that he
had it in him to become a fine utility player. Indeed, his last
three innings in the series brought him scores of 47, 78 and 81
while opening the innings with Engineer. He virtually remained
a regular member of the team till 1975.
One of the most famous episodes concerning a reserve player
revolves around Dilip Sardesai. He was picked for the 1971 tour
of the West Indies, despite having a chequered Test career.
His selection was severely criticised and the experts said it
was bad policy to take a 31-year-old veteran, whose fielding
was mediocre, as a reserve batsman. Indeed, it looked that
Sardesai would be a tourist on the trip for the batting, in the
hands of Gavaskar, Mankad, Jayantilal, Durrani, Jaisimha,
Viswanath and Wadekar seemed in safe hands. But an injury to
Viswanath gave Sardesai his big opening. He got 97 in the
opening fixture of the tour, made his place in the team for
the first Test secure and of course the rest is history.
Playing what Vijay Merchant called ``the innings that was the
turning point in Indian cricket'' Sardesai scored 212, added
two more hundreds in the second and fourth Test matches and
finished the triumphant series with 642 runs at an average
of 80.25. Not bad for a reserve batsman.
It may be difficult to believe Md Azharuddin as a reserve batsman
but on the eve of the 1989 tour of Pakistan, he seemed to have
been reduced to just that. A disastrous tour of West Indies
earlier that year, during which he showed a distinct dislike of
pace bowling, made his place in the Indian team uncertain. When
the team for the first Test at Karachi was announced, Raman Lamba
was in and Azharuddin out. It was only an injury to Lamba that
opened the doors for Azharuddin. He scored 35 in each innings
but more importantly equalled the world record by holding five
catches in the Pakistan first innings. He stayed on in the team,
got a hundred in the next Test and within a month was leading
the Indian team on its tour of New Zealand. Indeed, a story
book finish for a player who was doubtful of his place in
the eleven at Karachi.
Three years later, it was the turn of Pravin Amre to display
his fighting qualities. The Indian team for the tour of Zimbabwe
and South Africa in 1992-93 was chockful with batsman - Shastri,
Raman, Jadeja, Manjrekar, Azharuddin, Tendulkar and the
indications were that Amre's role on the tour would be restricted
to a couple of opportunities in the minor games. He did well
enough to merit selection in the team which played the first
Test and made it a memorable debut by getting a fighting 103.
In the face of a South African total of 254, India were reduced
to 146 for seven. With Kiran More, Amre added 101 runs for the
eighth wicket, playing an innings of class and character. He kept
his place throughout the four match series, finished second in
the averages, made runs consistently for some time before he
was inexplicably dropped, never to be considered again.
The latest fairy tale story of reserve players making good is
perhaps Saurav Ganguly. Few cricketers have faced the barrage
of criticism that greeted his selection for the 1996 tour of
England. Various allegations were made and almost unanimously
everyone seemed to agree that he did not deserve a place in the
side. But it was obvious that his role would be that of a tourist
for the batsmen in the side included Azharuddin, Tendulkar,
Manjrekar, Sidhu, Rathore, Jadeja and Dravid. How he made his
way into the Test team, how he got a hundred on debut at Lord's,
how he followed it up with another century and how he headed
both the Test and tour averages has since been so well documented
that it does not need any repeating here.