May 6, 2007


Government at loggerheads over Bermuda's pitches

Will Luke
Tom Moody inspects the pitch while ICC grounds consultant Andy Atkinson looks on, Sri Lanka v New Zealand, 5th match, Champions Trophy, Mumbai, October 20, 2006
 © AFP


The long-running saga of Bermuda's sub-standard pitch at the National Sports Centre, which has prevented the country hosting internationals, continues to rumble on - and is now in the hands of the government.

The main concern surrounds the quality of the soil which was last year described by Andy Atkinson, the ICC's pitch expert, as "only suitable for growing carrots". His solution is to import better quality foreign soil, an idea supported by Bermuda's sports minister, Randy Horton, but roundly condemned by the acting Environment Minister, John Barritt who called it a "reckless" proposal.

"The United Bermuda Party disagrees in the strongest possible terms with Sports Minister Randy Horton's plan to change long-standing regulations against the importation of soil," he said on Sunday. "Most Bermudians understand the dangers of introducing alien species to this country. The cedar blight that hit our shores in the late 1940s was caused by an imported scale insect that dramatically and speedily altered the look of the island, killing off forests of our national tree."

Tests conducted on soils from different parts of the island have shown that local clay is not good enough to produce wickets of international class. The problem isn't new, either: the issue was first raised during the Americas Championship in 2004 when teams complained of the quite chronic uneven bounce of the square. Barritt is insistent that whatever measure are taken must be in the interest not only of the sport, but the environment.

"Like everyone else, I would love to have the cricket pitch at the National Sports Centre to be of the highest quality, but we do not think the government needs to endanger the flora and fauna of Bermuda to do so," he said. "The danger is too great, and our posture on this issue must be firm, with absolutely no exceptions. In this age of mass transportation, we have to be doubly vigilant to the threat from lethal species.

"The minister's out-of-the-blue proposal is reckless in its intent, and quite frightening considering the potential consequences for the country."

Will Luke is assistant editor of ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Will Luke

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by Ralph on (May 7, 2007, 19:47 GMT)

Classic story - the Environment Minister has got a bloomin' good knowledge of the history of his island! Some might say that most of the world had rather more serious issues to deal with than a cedar tree blight in the later 1940s, but perhaps that's digressing too much!

Anyway, I have absolutely no idea whether the soil of Bermuda can produce a decent pitch - you would surely think that it can't be that hard, especially for however many hundreds of thousands of dollars that Andy Atkinson gets paid, but what do I know?!

Posted by Mikey Brown on (May 7, 2007, 13:17 GMT)

The environment ministers needs to stop being an obstinent fool

Posted by Prakatheesh on (May 6, 2007, 19:18 GMT)

I guess they should, but you can't criticise a country that has worked so hard to come to international standards, making it to the world Cup is an example.

Posted by Nafi Karim on (May 6, 2007, 17:57 GMT)

I kind of see what the Environment Minister is saying, although I don't think that is a big deal. Can't the Environment Minister just make sure the imported soil is examined to exclude any alien species; though that might be hard, I'm pretty sure it can be done.

Comments have now been closed for this article


Will Luke
Assistant editor Will opted against a lifetime of head-bangingly dull administration in the NHS, where he had served for two years. In 2005 came a break at Cricinfo where he slotted right in as a ferociously enthusiastic tea drinker and maker, with a penchant for using "frankly" and "marvellous". He also runs The Corridor, a cricket blog where he can be found ranting and raving about all things - some even involving the sport. He is a great-great nephew of Sir Jack Newman, the former Wellingtonian bowler who took two wickets at 127 apiece for New Zealand.

All articles by this writer