May 14, 2009

West Indies in England, 2009

Test cricket needs Gayle

Andy Zaltzman
Chris Gayle drags on against Stuart Broad, England v West Indies, 1st Test, Lord's, May 7, 2009
 © Getty Images
Enlarge

RELATED LINKS

At last, the waiting is over. Again. A tortuous, seemingly endless five entire days with no Test cricket have finally wended their pointless way into the history books, and the long-awaited England versus West Indies rematch now marches towards its thrillingly decisive climax at the Riverside today. The Wisden Trophy is still literally anyone’s. The two captains have been at each other’s throats like two top surgeons in a one-on-one emergency tracheotomy competition. And the Ashes (not to mention West Indies’ forthcoming home clash with Bangladesh) loom with massively gargantuan enormity as the players strain every conceivable physical and mental sinew to touch the elusive heavens of cricketing immortality. Truly, the eyes of the universe are trained through excited binoculars on the green Durham sward, and it is hard to envisage that this will not prove to be the greatest match cricket has ever seen.

Perhaps I am guilty of talking things up a little. The advance ticket sales suggest I may even be guilty of talking things up more than a little. Following three days of medium-to-low calibre action at Lord’s, and with the West Indian captain essentially proclaiming that he would rather be doing something else somewhere else than spending a long weekend standing outside in the north of England in the middle of May, the cricketing public is showing little appetite for this game. In fact, it is pushing this game around its plate. It may nibble the odd morsel, but it is clearly watching its weight and saving itself for a far more satisfying main course – Ashes pie.

The first Test was an unsatisfying match, despite its nail-biting denouement. Admittedly, it was only nail-biting for the friend with whom I watched the evening session of day 3 – he had tickets for day 4, and would have missed out on his refund if the West Indies had resisted until stumps. The tension in his wallet was unbearable.

England played well enough, but the startling ineptitude of their opponents in the field and with the bat renders judgement largely irrelevant. If the Australians are not quite quaking in their boots, it is at least partially because the Ashes remain sufficiently far away that they have not yet put their boots on.

Here, then, are the official Confectionery Stall Conclusions To Be Drawn From The First Test:

  • England’s main concern will be about Ravi Bopara. He is clearly a good player, and, on the evidence of his last two Test innings, a lucky one. However, questions must be asked about his temperament under pressure. He had a chance to carve himself a unique place in the history books – he could have been the 700th player to be out in the 90s in Test matches. No-one could ever have taken that away from him. Instead, he played himself calmly to a century, the 3281st century in Tests, yet another name on an overfilled honours board. He had the chance to make his mark by throwing his innings away to any one of the 20 balls he faced after passing 90 before reaching three figures. And he blew it.
  • Graham Onions, after perhaps the most inept two-ball start to a Test career (100% bowled out by a full toss, then a long-hop demolished to the boundary), showed himself to be a decent bowler, and his giddy enthusiasm was magnificent to see. He prompted some slightly overexcited comparisons to Glenn McGrath. Other than a good action and a propensity for skittling teams out in Lord’s Tests, this may be a little premature. Onions’ first-class economy rate is 3.7, compared to McGrath’s 2.5. Onions has also thus far shown no capability for unleashing needless barrages of verbal abuse into batsmen’s faces. If he wants to match the Australian’s 563 Test wickets at 21, he will have to work on both of these aspects of his game. The McGrath-style batting is clearly almost there.

    However, the British media clearly do not consider Onions to be a long-term prospect. They blew every conceivable onion-related headline and wordplay at the first available opportunity, rather than pacing themselves over a 70-Test career. Already, journalists and sub-editors will be rifling through their recipe books trying to find more onion-based dishes in case the Gateshead Goliath transpires to be one of England’s greats.

  • Tim Bresnan will never be a Test cricketer. Unless he stops (a) being given out lbw when the ball was not even contemplating hitting the stumps, and (b) not having to bowl very much.
  • Those wickets in the West Indies really did flatter the batsmen and insult the bowlers. A boring five-day Test is much, much more boring than a boring three-day Test.
  • History will never know whether Chris Gayle would have played better or worse had he arrived more than two days before the game began. He would certainly have played in the same way. Arguably, he would have been stroppier for having had to leave the IPL even sooner. In fact, it is possible that Gayle had too much acclimatisation time. If he had arrived just in time for the toss, he might not have had time to remember that he doesn’t like Test cricket much any more.

On then, to the Riverside, the mostly empty Riverside. During his entertaining to-and-fro with Gayle, Andrew Strauss said: “The important thing is that Test cricket gets the attention it deserves. And that means that people prepare themselves properly for any Test match you play. You don’t want Test cricket to be devalued in any way, shape or form.”

These are noble thoughts, which all Test fans would support. But these words ring a little hollow before a Test at a ludicrous time of year against a team that had not been planning to be involved. Test cricket is the pinnacle of the game, but it is not always treated as such by its authorities. Teams (both home and away) are habitually underprepared, some are depopulated by the tedious political squabbling over the ICL, series are raced through at breakneck speed, and pitches are often designed to provide time-span rather than contest. Test cricket is increasingly often devalued in many ways, shapes and forms.

Gayle’s recent mutterings to the media also proved what a phenomenal entertainer the man is, both on and off the pitch. After encouraging Strauss not to “sleep with Chris on his mind” (sage advice at any time, unless the Chris to whom he was referring was Chris Tavare, who was often prescribed as an insomnia cure by the NHS in the 1980s), Gayle bemoaned how the demands of captaincy force him to go through innumerable onerous tasks. “There’s always something you have to go and do, you know, extra,” said the Kingston Cavalier. “Lunch or dinner, some other thing.” These, of course, are meals of which Gayle would normally steer well clear. He is very much a breakfast, elevenses, teatime nibbles and bedtime snack man. The fact that he is prepared to alter his dietary timetable for the needs of the team is a mark of the man.

England should win this game – they have beaten West Indies in 11 of the past 13 Tests in this country, and it seems unlikely that Gayle’s comments about wanting to give up the captaincy and not being particularly fussed about the future of Test cricket will serve to inspire his troops to follow their captain in a Test match. Let us hope it is a better game than Lord’s, however, and that Captain Chris enjoys it. He might not need Test cricket, but Test cricket needs him.

Andy Zaltzman is a stand-up comedian, a regular on the BBC Radio 4, and a writer

RSS Feeds: Andy Zaltzman

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by safwan on (May 16, 2009, 16:35 GMT)

well dun andy.....u make us smile.....the humour is very subtle and witty...n test cricket does need gayle more then he needs it, he is amongst the last few remaining beacons of hope and excitement left in the game!!!

Posted by jogesh99 on (May 16, 2009, 9:04 GMT)

So now know the identity of the secret KKR blogger - it's Gurveer Singh Kaller - the only man in Buchanan's stable with a sense of humour.

Posted by girlie on (May 15, 2009, 21:47 GMT)

frankly i am sick of this entire fiasco. whether west indies had nine days to prepare or not the fact is this is a young side who had to fight for the trophy over 5 gruelling test matches and yet the value of that is being demorilised by a 2 match series. I frind this rediculous.Yes the pitches were flat in the WI but our bowlers had to bowl on it as well not just the english. I think Chris is frustrated with the fact that this seroies was just shoed in and i personally believe its just a sad, low and pathetic attempt to gain back the trophy quickly and painlessly. lets be fair here. even the english that live in this weather 24/7 are freezing down at chester lee street. what does that say about our Caribbean boys who have been there a mere few weeks. Franly if my boys do lose this series i wont be disappointed and i know that our win in the west indies was hard fought on grueling batsman friendly pitches, whilst this one was just over a period of 2 matches.

Posted by waterbuffalo on (May 15, 2009, 14:25 GMT)

Yes, the windies had nine days of preparation but they were in England as replacements and one can see why Gayle was more than a little miffed at Strauss' remarks. I remember when England last won the Ashes, their next opponent was Pakistan, and Mr. Strauss did not make the tour because his wife was giving birth. Evidently Strauss thought holding a video camera and giving out cigars and drinks was more important than the sanctity of Test Cricket at the time. Pakistan won that Series 2-0 but it did not matter to Strauss because they had just won the ashes, just like this two test series does not matter to Gayle because the Windies had just beaten England in the Carribean. Changing tack, I hope the pitches for the Ashes will not be as bland and lifeless as the track for this test. Hope to see a lot of ducking, weaving and plonking on the head in the Ashes. Something that you will never ever see in the batsman's paradise that is 20/20.

Posted by Saravanan.NB on (May 15, 2009, 5:46 GMT)

Andy, I was expecting some of your own "Onion" catch phrases.

Posted by redneck on (May 15, 2009, 5:30 GMT)

love the diatry requirments and mcgraths batting avg. bloody funny mate! @ giri you have to be kidding me or either watching the ashes on mute! the barmy army dont shut up long enough for us aussies to cheer or do anything when the ashes are here! and in england in 05 the manchester test the atmosphere was electric i even picked up on that from here in australia! in contrast the nagpur test last year i could here the groundsman fart through the ground microphone the stadium was that empty! i think you could knock any other country for poor test crowds except australia and england. the ashes are between australia and england who cares if no other nation cares no ones making you watch it, just like the last pak v ind series it didnt even get shown on cable tv here in australia!

Posted by Marcus on (May 15, 2009, 2:46 GMT)

The West Indies should have put up a better showing in the first Test, I agree, but who'd have thought that all of Gayle, Sarwan and Chanderpaul would get failing scores?

Posted by davo on (May 15, 2009, 2:39 GMT)

the ashes the ashes the ashes...............thats all you here ENGLAND talk about everytime they play a team other than AUSTRALIA........it was SO DEGRADING TO ALL WEST INDIAN FANS(IM A WEST INDIAN) TO ACTUALY HEAR THAT AT THE START OF THE RECENT SERIES IN THE CARIBBEAN W.I vs ENG WAS BEING USED BY ENGLAND AS PREPARATION FOR THE "ASHES"........how can a team that ruled cricket for such a long period of time be used as preparation?it was good to see ENGLAND get a beating & i hope they get a 5-0 in the ashes because they thats all they're concerned with

Posted by davo on (May 15, 2009, 2:32 GMT)

personally,& i mean PERSONALLY, i simply hate the IPL. i dnt mind ICC T20 matches but the IPL is destroying the greatest test of all, TEST CRICKET. lets face it, can someone like ANDREW STRAUSS play T20?i dont think so but yet he is an outstanding test cricketer & has made his name not by hitting it out the park but by playing proper cricket shots.BRENDON NASH has been a great find for WINDIES in test cricket but will he ever play T20?dont tink so....but yet wit only a couple test matches under his belt he has already transformed from a domestic AUSSIE cicketer to a reliable WINDIES middle order batsman & he is already internationally recognized...did IPL or ICC T20 do it for him?I think the IPL should either be squashed or be a reduced tournament that fits in the ICC FTP because SRI LANKA has already chosen it over THE GOD OF CRICKET, TEST CRICKET. something needs to be done urgently because in order to be called a great cricketer, YOU MUST BE A GREAT TEST CRICKETER!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Andrew on (May 14, 2009, 22:36 GMT)

I liked your article Andy. The way i see it those who like to be challenged and challenge themselves would rpefer test, the others who want a bludge and a paycheck will choose T20. To all those people talking about the ashes being over-rated etc. I do get the feeling that neither of you guys are Australian or English so i understand. But from our point of view this is more than just a test series. The ashes is a rivalry that goes beyond just cricket and money etc. It is the complete opposite to what the IPL is about.It is about pride and tradition.Its about not letting the other guys have bragging rights as all sports in Australia there is a Aus-Eng rivalry and we don't want to let the poms claim bragging rights in any of them

Comments have now been closed for this article

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Andy Zaltzman
Andy Zaltzman was born in obscurity in 1974. He has been a sporadically-acclaimed stand-up comedian since 1999, and has appeared regularly on BBC Radio 4. Zaltzman's love of cricket outshone his aptitude for the game by a humiliating margin. He once scored 6 in 75 minutes in an Under-15 match, and failed to hit a six between the ages of 9 and 23. He would have been ideally suited to Tests, had not a congenital defect left him unable to play the game to anything above genuine village standard. He writes the Confectionery Stall blog on ESPNcricinfo.

All articles by this writer