England in India 2012-13 December 9, 2012

Ashwin administers CPR

And the Indian hope that lies not in its fields but its stands
19

India had their best session of the series yesterday morning. They sliced through the England tail, then, with Sehwag, reprieved by another slip-clanger in a series amply festooned with them, in increasingly Sehwagian form, and Gambhir, always fidgety outside off stump but positive against the spinners, managing to resist the urge to run out India's key batsman for the second time in the match just to see the look on everyone's faces. At lunch, they were 121 behind, with all their second-innings wickets in hand, and England, as England generally are, defending deep in the field, allowing a comfortable flow of runs.

One more session of Sehwag and the game would have been alive. One more session of both of them, and the game would have been fascinating. Instead, there was one more ball of Sehwag - insufficient time even for a fast-scorer such as the Delhi Now-Intermittent Destroyer to transform a game ‒ and 45 minutes of Gambhir, sufficient time for him to compensate himself for not doing the double on Sehwag by running out India's best batsman of the series instead, flirt with danger a few times, then drive stupidly at a good away-reverse-swinger from the hostile and dangerous Finn.

The game was in the bag. The rest of the Indian batting top seven promptly filled up the bag with bricks and dropped it into a local canal to put it out of its misery. Ravichandran Ashwin bravely dived it to save it, slapped it back into life, shouted "Stay with me, stay with me," desperately at it whilst giving it an unusually elegant bout of CPR, and left the game overnight in a hospital surrounded by its family, all aware that there is no real hope for it, but relieved that they were at least able to pay their last respects to it in a dignified manner.

England's bowling throughout this match has been of the same high class that it was throughout their period of dominance in 2010 and 2011, and even in their difficult winter in Asia early this year. It has been significantly improved by the two changes made since Ahmedabad. Anderson bowled faster than he has for some time, and with all his considerable reserves of skill and craft, and Finn again looked like a bowler who will discomfort and dismiss good players for the next decade. Swann despatched India's two remaining veterans with superb bowling, and Panesar, though not as good as in his previous three innings, continued to threaten and had some chances spurned. It was a searching cross-examination, and India cracked, admitted everything, and turned themselves in.

They were unable to cope technically - Tendulkar, Yuvraj and Dhoni were out playing defensively to probing but not unplayable balls ‒ or temperamentally. Sehwag was lured by a classic perfectly flighted, teasing, come-and-hit-me offbreak by Swann with the first ball after lunch. The batsman was drawn into an injudicious, poorly executed half-drive, and the breach was made. Gambhir and Kohli were the most culpable. Both had played themselves in to an extent, then, like dieting gluttons on day three of yet another new regime, dived for the cookie jar hoping no one would notice, tempted into needless drives at ignorable swinging balls when the situation required stricter control of their attacking urges. It was a woeful display against superb bowling on a testing but playable surface.

Indian top seven batsmen, in the 19 Test matches they have played over the 20 months since their World Cup triumph in April 2011, collectively average 33.99, and have scored 12 centuries in 246 innings (one every 20.5 innings). Over the previous 18 months, they played 18 Tests, jointly average 51.48, and scored 30 hundreds in 202 innings (one every 6.7 innings). Those numbers should be setting selectorial alarm bells clanging. Perhaps they are. Do the selectors know the security code to disable the alarm? Is there such a code lurking in Indian domestic cricket? Or do they like the sound of alarms, and are dancing along happily to its rhythmical honk?

In the stands at the Eden, the mood was exultant amongst the eternally vociferous if not always entirely melodious travelling England support. The home spectators, who had turned out in good numbers again and stayed to the end despite the hopeless match situation, were downcast, but did not turn against their team, and as soon as the Ashwin-Ishant stand began to take shape, there was rapturous acclaim.

When Ishant was out, he received a standing ovation more befitting a centurion than someone who had scored 10 off 55, but the crowd simply appreciated that someone had played with discipline and determination for them. When Ashwin brought up his half-century and spared India an innings defeat, the stadium roared as if there were 25 minutes remaining to save the match, not 25 minutes, dinner, a bedtime story, a snooze, breakfast, then 360 more minutes to save the match (assuming Mr Monsoon does not make an unseasonal one-day-only return to the city to do some media work or Christmas shopping).

The crowd in Kolkata has been predominantly young, generous to the opposition, and desperate for Indian Test competitiveness. At times when they have been given that competitiveness, they have been loud. I can only imagine what Eden Gardens can have been like with three times as many people watching India beat Australia 12 years ago in one of the greatest cricket matches of all time. There has been little hope for Indian cricket on the field, but plenty in the stands.

SOME STATS

● Graeme Swann has now taken 70 wickets in 12 Tests in Asia, at an average of 26 - the third best average of the 16 non-Asian spinners to have taken 30 or more wickets in Asia, behind Richie Benaud (71 at 19) and Lance Gibbs (54 at 24). Of all the non-Asian bowlers to have taken 30-plus wickets on the continent, 16 of the lowest 17 averages are by pace bowlers, with Benaud, in third behind fellow Australians Alan Davidson and Graham McKenzie, the only exception.

● As of the start of play on the fifth day, Pragyan Ojha has been dismissed five times in the 406 balls he has faced in Tests ‒ once every 89 deliveries. Which makes him 46% harder to dismiss than Virender Sehwag (average balls per dismissal: 61). Albeit that he scores at 18 runs per 100 balls, which is a little less threatening to the opposition than Sehwag's strike rate of 82. Jacques Kallis' average innings length is 124 balls, Shiv Chanderpaul's 120 balls, and Chris Martin's 12.

● James Anderson in overseas Tests since the start of the 2010-11 Ashes: 13 Tests, 49 wickets, average 27, strike rate 59. In away Tests before 2010-11: 19 Tests, 52 wickets, average 43, strike rate 74.

● This was the sixth time that India have lost two top-three batsmen run out in the same match, and the 13th Test in which three top-three wickets have fallen to run-outs.

Andy Zaltzman is a stand-up comedian, a regular on the BBC Radio 4, and a writer

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Orang on December 10, 2012, 2:35 GMT

    The chickens have come home to roost for India . Many of their Test wins over the last few years have been lucky ones, they struck a purple patch to win the 2011 World Cup but that was definitely their swansong (perhaps the fat lady will sing the swansong for ODIs anyway), and as for T20s, despite the IPL, India can be beaten by just about every other team in the top 10.

  • CricGod on December 9, 2012, 19:11 GMT

    Ashwin just showed the entire team how they should have played the game. There was still nothing much in that wicket, but top order showed no application. I like Dhoni, but it is high time that he steps down so that someone like Dinesh Kartik can take his place. Tendulkar, please, please, please, please, RETIRE. You are going to go down so bad like Ponting did against SA. Do not do that. You had a great career. Please do not listen to Kapil and others, just simply RETIRE. That is the best thing you can do for this team now.

  • Abhigyan on December 9, 2012, 17:30 GMT

    Benaud averages only 19 in Asia. Thats partly because bastmen played more defensively in 1960s.

  • Jagaraj on December 9, 2012, 15:03 GMT

    Indian fans should not be surprised with the result. the BCCI has successfully killed the ICL, yes the money power attained during that period was put to kill the ICL and new monster was unveiled in the name of IPL. Now the IPL has killed the cricket and the BCCI has decided to focus on building fortune out of cricket. IPL or ICL, the future of Indian cricket has reached back where it was in the 1980s. Now the best solution is to have separate board for IPL, and BCCI should only be involved with the basic cricket as before and leave the IPL to the business establishment. Also let us stop being emotional idiots and ask Tendulkar to go back to Parliament. Politics as such bad for any sports, and then politician in sports, the result can be as good as what we see today.

  • natarajan on December 9, 2012, 14:36 GMT

    We are not able to understand why Sachin is still holding on to his no.4 spot. It very evident that he is now a pale shadow of his old self. It brings tears in our eyes to see the great man trying to put bat to the ball. He should have retired with his head held high. Now every body world over is asking why he still playing. It is a pity to see Sachin in this situation. He should have hanged his shoes soon after his 100th 100.At least now Sandeep Patil must talk to him?,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

  • Anonymous on December 9, 2012, 14:15 GMT

    india dont play cricket on tv. play it on the grounds.

  • Lee on December 9, 2012, 13:10 GMT

    Why isn't Andy writing all of the official Wisden match reports?

  • Ali Jaddy on December 9, 2012, 12:55 GMT

    Fantastic article Andy!! The heart burns but there was a smile all the way reading it. The statistics are damning! Actually, the selection committee is dancing along to the sound of alarms and are nowhere near stopping and taking notice of the fire raging!! Hope sanity prevails!

  • Sunder Mirchandani on December 9, 2012, 11:27 GMT

    Pathetic show by Indian team, especially the top players. Totally irresponsible attitude displayed without a grain of fighting spirit. A shame.

  • h n s mani on December 9, 2012, 11:19 GMT

    After two successive clinical demolitions By England bowlers wisdom doesnt seem to have dawned on the Indian selectors!For how many more tests would they expect Sachin to "perform"? Okay he has scored 100 centuries? how many of them have won a match/saved a match for India?It is high time for a change of captain? will our selectors take a lesson from what happened to NZ skipper Ross Taylor?No! they will never learn!

  • Orang on December 10, 2012, 2:35 GMT

    The chickens have come home to roost for India . Many of their Test wins over the last few years have been lucky ones, they struck a purple patch to win the 2011 World Cup but that was definitely their swansong (perhaps the fat lady will sing the swansong for ODIs anyway), and as for T20s, despite the IPL, India can be beaten by just about every other team in the top 10.

  • CricGod on December 9, 2012, 19:11 GMT

    Ashwin just showed the entire team how they should have played the game. There was still nothing much in that wicket, but top order showed no application. I like Dhoni, but it is high time that he steps down so that someone like Dinesh Kartik can take his place. Tendulkar, please, please, please, please, RETIRE. You are going to go down so bad like Ponting did against SA. Do not do that. You had a great career. Please do not listen to Kapil and others, just simply RETIRE. That is the best thing you can do for this team now.

  • Abhigyan on December 9, 2012, 17:30 GMT

    Benaud averages only 19 in Asia. Thats partly because bastmen played more defensively in 1960s.

  • Jagaraj on December 9, 2012, 15:03 GMT

    Indian fans should not be surprised with the result. the BCCI has successfully killed the ICL, yes the money power attained during that period was put to kill the ICL and new monster was unveiled in the name of IPL. Now the IPL has killed the cricket and the BCCI has decided to focus on building fortune out of cricket. IPL or ICL, the future of Indian cricket has reached back where it was in the 1980s. Now the best solution is to have separate board for IPL, and BCCI should only be involved with the basic cricket as before and leave the IPL to the business establishment. Also let us stop being emotional idiots and ask Tendulkar to go back to Parliament. Politics as such bad for any sports, and then politician in sports, the result can be as good as what we see today.

  • natarajan on December 9, 2012, 14:36 GMT

    We are not able to understand why Sachin is still holding on to his no.4 spot. It very evident that he is now a pale shadow of his old self. It brings tears in our eyes to see the great man trying to put bat to the ball. He should have retired with his head held high. Now every body world over is asking why he still playing. It is a pity to see Sachin in this situation. He should have hanged his shoes soon after his 100th 100.At least now Sandeep Patil must talk to him?,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

  • Anonymous on December 9, 2012, 14:15 GMT

    india dont play cricket on tv. play it on the grounds.

  • Lee on December 9, 2012, 13:10 GMT

    Why isn't Andy writing all of the official Wisden match reports?

  • Ali Jaddy on December 9, 2012, 12:55 GMT

    Fantastic article Andy!! The heart burns but there was a smile all the way reading it. The statistics are damning! Actually, the selection committee is dancing along to the sound of alarms and are nowhere near stopping and taking notice of the fire raging!! Hope sanity prevails!

  • Sunder Mirchandani on December 9, 2012, 11:27 GMT

    Pathetic show by Indian team, especially the top players. Totally irresponsible attitude displayed without a grain of fighting spirit. A shame.

  • h n s mani on December 9, 2012, 11:19 GMT

    After two successive clinical demolitions By England bowlers wisdom doesnt seem to have dawned on the Indian selectors!For how many more tests would they expect Sachin to "perform"? Okay he has scored 100 centuries? how many of them have won a match/saved a match for India?It is high time for a change of captain? will our selectors take a lesson from what happened to NZ skipper Ross Taylor?No! they will never learn!

  • Rajendra Hardikar on December 9, 2012, 10:34 GMT

    It is more than borrowed time that Tendulkar should be axed from now on as he is not the player what is supposed to be from last 03 years. It is quite baffling that if selectors can drop Yuvraj-Zaheer-Harbhajan with diligence, then why not drop Tendulkar. From now, Virat Kohli ought to learn value of discretion in Test cricket as he is still young and must optimumly utilise the chance to prove himself. Also everyone must avoid comparing Pujara to Dravid as he is very new to cricket and still there is lots to prove.

    Of course, we cannot take credit away from England team, where almost every member is contributing some bits to make it a collective team effort, if not in great proportions.

    It is time that Sandeep must wake up and accept reality that Sachin is not indispensable and he is human after all (not a God) and he too requires to be dropped after pathetic displays in Test cricket in past few years

  • P.Vasanth on December 9, 2012, 10:12 GMT

    R.Ashwin has shown his potential as proper batsman. He should be promoted to No.6 in the batting order and P.Chaula to be drafted in for variety in spin dept. S.Tendulkar should be dropped and Ajenkia Ranhyae to be included in his place if we are to win the test at Nagpur. There is no place for sentiment

  • Rehan Faruqi on December 9, 2012, 9:22 GMT

    I fail to understand why Mr. SR Tendulkar can’t call it a day.....his diehard fans would like to see him bat at the age of 99 even on a wheel chair but the truth is that he has to go now...no wonder he is a great player but time has come for him to take a bow and exit with pride and self respect. His batting average this calendar year is just 22 which is poor by any standards. He has aged, his reflexes are fraction of a second slow and that only proves that he is just a human....even playing on Indian wkts he could not get more than two test 50s this year. For heaven’s sake Mr. SR Tendulkar make way for the new comers, you have most records in the history of batting, what else do you need? As far as Dhoni is concerned I think it’s time for India to change the captain. India also have to look at their bowling department "you ve got to take 20 wkts within a decent total" if you cant you are doomed. BCCI has to show some spine otherwise things will go from bad to worse for Team India

  • Kannan Sundar Rajan,Dubai on December 9, 2012, 8:23 GMT

    Can someone coach Gautam how not to run in the middle and how not to run out a co batsman.

  • Kannan Sundar Rajan,Dubai on December 9, 2012, 8:21 GMT

    Seven World Class Batsmen back in the pavilion and watching a spinner out in the middle and trying to extend the lead,very pathetic to watch.Indian Batsmen especially dhoni and tendulkar should be made accountable.Winning and losing are part of the game but the way it has happened for india today is really difficult to digest.BTW we are waiting for a word from BCCI on the future of master batsman.

  • V.Ramakrishnan on December 9, 2012, 8:02 GMT

    Dhoni was acclaimed to be the best captain when he had the services of hard core fighters like Dravid and Laxman. I wonder whether England would have been as successful if the above players had replaced Kohli and Yuvaraj. Zaheer is a spent force and the case of Sachin is no differant. Again,Dhoni has to be shown the door . Unless BCCI and the Indian selectors shelve their sentimental approach and take some bold decisions,it will not be long before India's test ranking falls below West indies,Newzeland abd Bangladesh. It is too painful for the ardent Indian fans to watch this agony while the so called great cricketers are more concerned about filling their pockets,

  • Shahzad Ahmad on December 9, 2012, 7:41 GMT

    Indian bowlers are below par.... After each wicket they were celebrating like they were near to won. ridiculous...

  • R.Narayan on December 9, 2012, 6:47 GMT

    Wish, u were my stats teacher in college, u have a way of making them fun! But you didn't mention that R. Aswin is one of only three players in the history of Test matches to score 500+ runs and take 50+ wickets by his eleventh match, the others being Jack Gregory and Ian Botham. If you want to be churlish, you might say Gregory and Botham were marginally better fielders...

  • Bassel on December 9, 2012, 6:45 GMT

    Analogies, metaphors, similes - very, very enjoyable. Quality writeup.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • Bassel on December 9, 2012, 6:45 GMT

    Analogies, metaphors, similes - very, very enjoyable. Quality writeup.

  • R.Narayan on December 9, 2012, 6:47 GMT

    Wish, u were my stats teacher in college, u have a way of making them fun! But you didn't mention that R. Aswin is one of only three players in the history of Test matches to score 500+ runs and take 50+ wickets by his eleventh match, the others being Jack Gregory and Ian Botham. If you want to be churlish, you might say Gregory and Botham were marginally better fielders...

  • Shahzad Ahmad on December 9, 2012, 7:41 GMT

    Indian bowlers are below par.... After each wicket they were celebrating like they were near to won. ridiculous...

  • V.Ramakrishnan on December 9, 2012, 8:02 GMT

    Dhoni was acclaimed to be the best captain when he had the services of hard core fighters like Dravid and Laxman. I wonder whether England would have been as successful if the above players had replaced Kohli and Yuvaraj. Zaheer is a spent force and the case of Sachin is no differant. Again,Dhoni has to be shown the door . Unless BCCI and the Indian selectors shelve their sentimental approach and take some bold decisions,it will not be long before India's test ranking falls below West indies,Newzeland abd Bangladesh. It is too painful for the ardent Indian fans to watch this agony while the so called great cricketers are more concerned about filling their pockets,

  • Kannan Sundar Rajan,Dubai on December 9, 2012, 8:21 GMT

    Seven World Class Batsmen back in the pavilion and watching a spinner out in the middle and trying to extend the lead,very pathetic to watch.Indian Batsmen especially dhoni and tendulkar should be made accountable.Winning and losing are part of the game but the way it has happened for india today is really difficult to digest.BTW we are waiting for a word from BCCI on the future of master batsman.

  • Kannan Sundar Rajan,Dubai on December 9, 2012, 8:23 GMT

    Can someone coach Gautam how not to run in the middle and how not to run out a co batsman.

  • Rehan Faruqi on December 9, 2012, 9:22 GMT

    I fail to understand why Mr. SR Tendulkar can’t call it a day.....his diehard fans would like to see him bat at the age of 99 even on a wheel chair but the truth is that he has to go now...no wonder he is a great player but time has come for him to take a bow and exit with pride and self respect. His batting average this calendar year is just 22 which is poor by any standards. He has aged, his reflexes are fraction of a second slow and that only proves that he is just a human....even playing on Indian wkts he could not get more than two test 50s this year. For heaven’s sake Mr. SR Tendulkar make way for the new comers, you have most records in the history of batting, what else do you need? As far as Dhoni is concerned I think it’s time for India to change the captain. India also have to look at their bowling department "you ve got to take 20 wkts within a decent total" if you cant you are doomed. BCCI has to show some spine otherwise things will go from bad to worse for Team India

  • P.Vasanth on December 9, 2012, 10:12 GMT

    R.Ashwin has shown his potential as proper batsman. He should be promoted to No.6 in the batting order and P.Chaula to be drafted in for variety in spin dept. S.Tendulkar should be dropped and Ajenkia Ranhyae to be included in his place if we are to win the test at Nagpur. There is no place for sentiment

  • Rajendra Hardikar on December 9, 2012, 10:34 GMT

    It is more than borrowed time that Tendulkar should be axed from now on as he is not the player what is supposed to be from last 03 years. It is quite baffling that if selectors can drop Yuvraj-Zaheer-Harbhajan with diligence, then why not drop Tendulkar. From now, Virat Kohli ought to learn value of discretion in Test cricket as he is still young and must optimumly utilise the chance to prove himself. Also everyone must avoid comparing Pujara to Dravid as he is very new to cricket and still there is lots to prove.

    Of course, we cannot take credit away from England team, where almost every member is contributing some bits to make it a collective team effort, if not in great proportions.

    It is time that Sandeep must wake up and accept reality that Sachin is not indispensable and he is human after all (not a God) and he too requires to be dropped after pathetic displays in Test cricket in past few years

  • h n s mani on December 9, 2012, 11:19 GMT

    After two successive clinical demolitions By England bowlers wisdom doesnt seem to have dawned on the Indian selectors!For how many more tests would they expect Sachin to "perform"? Okay he has scored 100 centuries? how many of them have won a match/saved a match for India?It is high time for a change of captain? will our selectors take a lesson from what happened to NZ skipper Ross Taylor?No! they will never learn!