October 23, 2016

Bouncer-safety starts with watching the ball

Proper technique is a must. And there are lessons to be learnt from how batsmen of the pre-helmet era negotiated short balls

Ian Chappell: "When you're quickly on to the front foot it's impossible to get inside the line of the delivery to play the shot more safely" © PA Photos

Fast bowlers use the short ball as a legitimate weapon to unsettle any batsman. It is a fair and reasonable tactic that has stood the test of time.

On that terrible day at the SCG in November 2014, Phillip Hughes appeared to misjudge the pace of the ball and looked to be through his hook shot before he was struck in the neck, clear of the protective face of the helmet.

It was a shocking, freak accident and, especially for Phil's family and friends, so terrible in its finality.

In the wake of the Hughes' tragedy there has been a disturbing number of quality batsmen being struck on the helmet. The "hit" list is not dominated by mid- to lower-order batsmen. In recent times players of the calibre of Steven Smith, Shane Watson, Michael Clarke, Chris Rogers and Virat Kohli have copped heavy blows to the helmet.

When looking at footage of the incidents, you see all too clearly that all of the players who were hit were not watching the ball and they were struck on the side of the helmet.

Just a couple of weeks after Hughes' tragic death, Australia played India at the Adelaide Oval. The ground was packed but the silence was deafening the instant Kohli was hit on the helmet from the first ball he faced from Mitchell Johnson.

Kohli, one of the best and most exciting batsmen in the world, was not watching the ball.

If some of the world's best batsmen are taking their eye off the ball, what's happening to batting technique among the young, emerging cricketers?

All parents want their children to be safe, but just sticking a helmet on them is not the only solution here. Youngsters need to learn to watch the ball like a hawk and to play short-pitched bowling.

Junior coaches everywhere must look at what they are doing. Proper technique against short-pitched bowling starts the day the youngster picks up a cricket bat, eager to learn the game. The Chappells were five years old when they did.

Former Test opening batsman Ashley Woodcock coaches juniors and seniors at University Cricket Club in Adelaide. He learnt the rudiments of batting from his older brother Steve.

Greg Chappell: "The two keys to not getting hit are to be on the balls of your feet and to watch the ball" © Getty Images

"Two basic shots are the backward defence and the forward defence," Woodcock said. "With the modern-day forward press, it makes life difficult to get back and across to a short-pitched delivery. In the days before helmets a batsman had no choice. He had to watch the ball."

Long-time South Australian captain Les Favell used to invite a current State player to accompany him on coaching trips to the country areas. He stressed to the youngsters that "all the attacking shots are linked to two basic shots: the forward and back defence."

When a batsman plays back, the movement is back and across. From that position he can cut, pull or hook. Shots developed from the forward defence are the off and the cover drives and shots off the pads.

Among the list of players who accompanied Favell on those trips were Garry Sobers and Barry Richards. Both men had a back-and-across first movement. Those basic movements are important, all done while never taking your eye off the ball.

Against fast bowling a back-and-across first movement allows the batsman to get in behind the line of flight. If the ball is wide he can allow it to pass, but he can hook a short ball that is passing over leg stump if he is back and across his stumps, with his head inside the line of flight. This technique is terrific because even if he makes a mistake and misses the ball, his head is inside the line and out of harm's way.

England's Colin Cowdrey scored centuries against West Indian speedsters Wes Hall and Charlie Griffith in the early 1960s. He likened the challenge of facing a fast bowler to be akin to a boxer moving his feet swiftly, never taking his eyes off his opponent, easily swaying away from danger.

Ian Redpath, a former Australian Test opener, rarely hooked the ball, yet he scored three centuries in 1975-76 against West Indies, whose attack included Andy Roberts and Michael Holding. Redpath's method was make the West Indies bowlers bowl to him. Anything short, shoulder to head high, he swayed out of the way, waiting for a ball of full length to drive for four.

It is folly to think the helmet, however innovative and strong, can fully protect batsmen.

Last Friday, during the elimination final of the Matador Cup at Drummoyne Oval, New South Wales opening batsman Daniel Hughes was struck on the side of his helmet as he attempted to hook a short ball from Victoria's Peter Siddle. Hughes fell to his knees as concerned fieldsmen rushed to his side. The medical officer at the ground, Dr John Orchard, immediately ordered Hughes to take a concussion test. After undergoing the test, Hughes (retired hurt on 23) was ruled out of taking further part in the match. A "concussion substitute" (Nick Larkin) took his place.

Fellow NSW batsman Nic Maddinson replaced Hughes in the order. He too was struck a blow on the helmet and was assessed under Cricket Australia's new Concussion and Head Trauma Policy by medical staff on the ground and allowed to bat on. He played on and belted a match-winning 86.

NSW batsman Daniel Hughes had to retire hurt from a one-day game after being hit on the helmet © Getty Images

These incidents further highlight how dangerous the game has become mainly because of poor technique against short-pitched bowling and batsmen taking their eye off the ball.

Former Test captain Ian Chappell was a good hooker and I can't remember him being hit in the head at any stage of his first-class career.

"When you're quickly on to the front foot it's impossible to get inside the line of the delivery to play the shot more safely," he said.

"I can't believe they [Cricket Australia] held a review of safety and it didn't include the technique of playing the short ball."

Bob Simpson, a former Australian Test opener and captain, was adamant that technique against fast bowling generally seemed to be lacking.

"I think the helmet gives a batsman a false sense of security," he said.

Don Bradman reckoned the most important aspect of batting was to watch the ball. Arguably Australia's best batsman since Bradman, Greg Chappell, nowadays Cricket Australia's talent manager, said the bigger issue is that the helmets are now heavier and cause players to stand more upright to manage that weight.

"This puts their weight back on their heels more than the players of the past who were more on the balls of their feet," Greg said. "They find it harder to change position quickly so they are more prone to get hit than a nimble-footed player.

"The fact that they know that they are less likely to get badly hurt, there is not the same incentive to develop a good method to deal with short balls. We didn't have that luxury so we had to get into a better position.

"The two keys to not getting hit are to be on the balls of your feet and to watch the ball."

In relation to coaching youngsters in the art of batting, Greg suggested starting with a soft ball. "Unlike our father [Martin Chappell], I wouldn't recommend using a hard ball from the start.

"Use a soft ball and include short balls early by getting a youngster to hit to areas. What I mean by hitting to areas is to set the session up anywhere but a net. A tennis court is ideal so the kid has a feeling of space around them, but the ball can't go too far. Apart from ensuring that the grip and stance are comfortable, relaxed and efficient, I wouldn't 'teach' the kid anything else."

Greg advocated setting three "scoring zones" - square of the wicket on the off-side, square of the wicket on the leg side and straight back past the bowler.

"If one can cut, pull and drive, one can be a great player. Think Graeme Pollock - those three shots were all he needed. Every other shot is a derivative of those three anyway."

Greg sets up a coaching session by bowling from the net of a tennis court to the youngster batting on the base line. Scoring zones are from the back corner of the net to mid-pitch both sides. He lobs the ball to the batsman and direct them to a target. For example, if the ball is lobbed full and straight, Greg will say, "Okay son, I want you to hit it to the net straight past me".

If a cut shot to the point boundary is required, the ball is lobbed short and wide of the off stump.

"I include balls bouncing up to chest and head height very early so it becomes part of the whole rather than a separate part of the learning," Greg said.

"Most kids quickly work out that if they shift their body to the off side of the short ball they can hit it hard through the leg-side target area. As they get more proficient, I cramp them for room with more speed to see how they cope. If they have a problem, I ask them what they think the solution is rather than telling them what to do. It generally works extremely well and the kids progress quickly."

Martin Chappell gave his three boys this advice: "You have a bat in your hand for one reason and one reason only and that is to score runs. Learn to use the bat properly and you will never get hit."

Greg believes good footwork is nothing more than developing the ability to shift one's body from one position to another to free one's arms to hit the ball to the intended target area.

"This is what Bradman did better than the rest of us," he said.

For the sake of the health of our international and emerging batsmen, let's hope the administrators take heed of the sound advice from three of Australia's batting legends.

By all means, let's have lighter, stronger batting helmets, but the very first step in safety for batsmen against any bowler is to watch the ball.

The ICC can't afford to take its eye off the ball over this safety issue. Safety for batsmen is a global priority. Batsman getting hit on the head - whether while wearing a helmet or not - are vulnerable to serious injury.

Proper technique when playing the short stuff is paramount and every batting coach from the grassroots to the Test arena needs to take heed.

Ashley Mallett took 132 wickets in 38 Tests for Australia. He has written biographies of Clarrie Grimmett, Doug Walters, Jeff Thomson, Ian Chappell, and most recently of Dr Donald Beard, The Diggers' Doctor

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Richard on October 29, 2016, 13:15 GMT

    @RKUMAR06 - I don't think such an accomplished cricket writer would want to make a point supporting bumpers by referencing a batsman from India. India having such fast, bouncy wickets and all...

  • Rajesh Kumar on October 28, 2016, 13:57 GMT

    Decent article, but it is a bit disappointing that the author did not interview Gavaskar for the article. He scored 13 hundreds in 27 tests against the famed Windies pace quartet and scored it everywhere not just in India...that too without a helmet!! I would think, he would know a thing or two about that.

  • carl on October 26, 2016, 18:42 GMT

    aus off spinner who took 132 wickets in 38 tests, how to play short pitched bowling safely, is it just me, or is this article mainly hot air, maybe an analyses of saqlain mustaq's bowling style would have been more interesting

  • Joe on October 26, 2016, 0:55 GMT

    CRICFAN75259648, yep, and they sure done good recently vs ENG, NZ, Australia and SA of late, the teams with the best quicks. I do believe it is one test win, one ODI won in the past five years.

  • ncs2th2070085 on October 25, 2016, 13:31 GMT

    only Indians were adept in facing bouncers, especially Gavaskar, Vengsarkar, Amarnath, Gavaskar tackled it by playing late, Amarnath took them head on by hooking, Vengsarkar used to play square of the wicket, i.e why among them scored 23 hundreds against West Indies

  • Geoffrey on October 25, 2016, 11:29 GMT

    Heavier bats have a lot to do with it as well. The bats today are harder to swing through a horizontal arc, they are designed primarily for the big pendulum swing.

  • Alex on October 25, 2016, 7:21 GMT

    The way i see is that you have to be able move out of the line of ball. For that feet can not freeze and if feet is spread , you can only crouch , if feet is closer you can not bend but you can dodge side way. Bowlers try to center batsman by making him move right or left side of the ball. You should watch the ball but that is not enough , you have to be able to move away , that is only possible where feets are pointing. if it is 45 Degree from each other you can move anywhere.

  • Paul on October 24, 2016, 20:12 GMT

    @PACELIKEFIRE generally the pull/ hook is pre-meditated because you decide that if you see it short, you will attack it. Presumably this is what Hughes did but it didn't come through as quickly as he thought. Infamously, Andy Roberts used to have a slow and a fast bouncer. The first would be slower and lull the batsman into thinking he was safe to hook anything dropped short. The next would be much faster and could cause serious damage. I recall a photo from around 1973 of Colin Cowdrey, bent over having just been hit on the arm or jaw by by the faster one, a few balls after pulling the slower one for four. It was a county match in England. His technique was pretty flawless but undone by the bowler's skill. On the whole, I agree that technique in the modern era has suffered for the advent of helmets and must be addressed. I'm not sure poor technique was the reason Hughes missed this delivery, though.

  • peter on October 24, 2016, 13:26 GMT

    In response to modernumpiresplz, with respect, I never said he turned his head away. I said he took his eye off the ball. Had he kept his eye on the ball, he would have realised the ball was not coming through as quickly as he expected, and his reflexes would have allowed him to either check the shot, or get out of the way. Of course he went through with the shot, hence his eye coming off the ball. Which brings me back to possible pre-meditation. And its not as if bowlers who possess two different paces for their bouncers are unknown - Malcolm Marshall a past master. Of course we'll never know what was in Phil Hughe's mind at the time - poor lad - but the point, drummed into me when I was a young cricketer by my seniors, whether batting, fielding, or even between deliveries - NEVER take your eye off the ball.

  • Xiong on October 24, 2016, 12:23 GMT

    @pacelikefire Did you actually see the footage of Phil Hughes? I'm not going to get into an argument about his technique against the short ball in general, but that incident was not him turning his head away. He was actually through his shot too early, and his momentum turned him and exposed the side/back of his head to the delivery. I get what you're trying to say, but if you're going to tread on a sensitive subject accuracy is paramount.