Sri Lanka v South Africa, 2nd Test, SSC, 4th day July 27, 2014

SA sweat on underperforming Petersen, Tahir

The SSC Test has emphasised why South Africa may have to spring clean and find opening batsmen with more mettle and spinners with more control
11

Spring cleaning usually includes two stages. First, throw out all the things you absolutely cannot hang on to, like clothes that no longer fit and food that has grown mould. For a South African Test team which had just lost Graeme Smith and Jacques Kallis those discardables were abstract concepts like insecurity and doubt. They got rid of them as they showed with their victory in Galle.

Then look at everything else and decide what is nearing the end of its run and is better replaced sooner than later. For this South Africa Test team Alviro Petersen and Imran Tahir fit that category. The SSC Test has showed them why they need opening batsmen with more mettle and spinners with more control. Day four emphasised it.

Petersen's is probably the more pressing concern because South Africa put on hold considering his position as they dealt with the aftermath of Smith's retirement. The reality is that there was always more than one vacancy in the top two. Before this tour, Petersen had gone 17 innings without a Test hundred. That run has extended to 21.

In that time, he has scored more than fifty on three occasions, all at home. He has also not managed more than 30 runs in 15 innings. His struggles gave come against what are considered unconventional for a South African player: subcontinental conditions, Pakistan's left-arm arsenal or Sri Lanka's strangling spin. He also struggled against himself and the certainty that comes with being assured enough to convert starts into something more substantial.

In Galle, Petersen was both caught on the back foot against spin and drawn forward by it. Both times he was beaten by deliveries that did not turn. Both times he asked for a review and both times he was unsuccessful. In Colombo, the pressure had increased. He was out to a nothing shot in the first innings when he handed Rangana Herath a return catch which meant he had to view the second innings as the one that would save his career.

Petersen is a patient man by nature. He waited seasons to get his chance opening the batting for South Africa and when he was dropped after not doing much wrong in favour of Jacques Rudolph, he went back, scored runs and waited again to get recalled. For four overs of this second innings he showed his willingness for that kind of wait when he needed it most.

But it was the wait that undid him. Petersen and Dean Elgar took just four runs off the first eight overs and made it clear they were each going to attach themselves to one end and stay there. Petersen would face Herath, Elgar would face the offspinner Dilruwan Perera, who had dismissed Petersen both times in Galle. Herath had lured him forward in the first innings and was threatening to do it again.

Herath tossed it up and turned it away and Petersen was lured further and further forward. After 25 balls, he leaned too far and pushed the ball into silly point's hands.

Petersen walked back to the changeroom. Quinton de Kock walked out. There will still have to be a debate about whether de Kock can keep wicket and bat higher up, even though he is a top-order batsman in the domestic game, but there is no question over Petersen. Even if de Kock is not the man to take his place, South Africa have other options. Stiaan van Zyl, a No.3, was the leading run-scorer in last season's first-class competition and could be promoted to open. He is part of the touring squad so Petersen would have known he was on notice. And there have also been other signs Petersen may be ready to hand over the reins.

He is 33 and seems to have realised if there is a lengthening to his career it needs to be done on the county circuit. Petersen has spent the last two seasons at Somerset and there is talk of him signing a Kolpak deal once his international career is over.

He indicated that may not be far away on his blog on alviropetersen.com when he wrote about the difficulties of his family not traveling with him. "Family is the most important thing to me and if I am honest cricket is second, so in the future we will have to look at what is best for all of us."

Contrastingly Tahir is not ready to give up. Although he is 35, Tahir has only had tastes of international cricket but he has failed to take them through a lack of control. He was used ineffectively on the fourth day and allowed to continue bowling even when he was leaking runs and South Africa should have been creating pressure. In trying to show confidence in Tahir, Hashim Amla held back on using JP Duminy, who may have been the better tactical option.

There is a young offspinner who can replace Tahir. Dane Piedt led the wicket-taking charts in last summer's first-class competition and maintained an economy rate under three an over. The Cobras spinner is known for both variation and control.

If Tahir battles on subcontinental pitches in the latter stages of matches, there will be questions about whether he is going to be a threat anywhere else except in limited-overs where he has proved his worth. There is every chance if they play against Zimbabwe next month and West Indies at home later this year, with no disrespect to either team, both Tahir and Petersen will be able to regain form but it is also possible that it would allow the successor a gentler introduction to Test cricket than they might have had against a team like Australia. Next year, South Africa have Test series in Bangladesh and India and they need to use the matches they have left this season to spring clean.

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • jgoogly on July 28, 2014, 6:41 GMT

    South Africa never had a quality spinner but had been successful with pace an d medium fast bowlers. Their formula is working!

  • on July 28, 2014, 3:43 GMT

    Tahir is one of the worst spinners playing the game at the moment, Amla's captaincy in doubt after he gave many amount of overs to him even he keep on bowling loose balls, hes a burden to the SA team

  • Sexysteven on July 28, 2014, 3:28 GMT

    I think tahirs career should be over at test level at least he's not upto it I would prob leave him out of white ball cricket he is getting on in age time to develop young spinners and bring them through I think as for Peterson I would keep for abit a longer just to see if Elgar is the right man at the other end ideally you want to get Elgar settled in to openers role before you think about getting rid of Peterson I think keep Peterson for another year for the good of the team cos you don't want to be searching for two new openers at the same time so I think the selectors should ask him if he has another year or two at most left in him just to get Elgar settled in hopefully cos I'm sure Peterson will find some form and his experience will help his opening partner I'm sure

  • jimbond on July 28, 2014, 2:57 GMT

    attilathecricketer: Fine if it is inclusion we want, it safe to replace Tahir with Phangiso- who doesn't leak runs at least. And De Kock is more or less opening now so he can take up that job permanently- this also reduces the pressure on ABD. I am sure there are many coloured batsman who are good enough to play in the top six. But for the moment it is best to focus only on cricket (and SA and Zimbabwe are very different in so many ways). Just imagine how stronger SA would have been if deKock had opened- with someone like Miller at No. 6, and Piedt instead of Tahir.

  • attilathecricketer on July 27, 2014, 22:53 GMT

    The changes may be fair enough on form but what does that do towards having a representative side? Ok there would be Amla, Duminy and Philander but surely some consideration should be given to the wider picture (if for no other reason that it might stop politicians from interfering a la Zimbabwe)

  • TommytuckerSaffa on July 27, 2014, 21:24 GMT

    We all predicted it would happen before it did. Tahir failure in the First Test was a sign of things to come. And now, with a Test average of 47, it should be glaringly obvious he is not a Test player. Petersen has been under-performing for the last 2 years.

    There needs to be quick promotion of the Top performing players from Domestic Cricket to Test cricket. Dane Piedt and Van Zyl are those players. They both should have been playing in this Test. CSA needs to cut loose the deadwood.

  • Herath-UK on July 27, 2014, 19:35 GMT

    You can't expect Tahir to be in the same league as Herath or Perera but he seemed to suffer from the lack of confidence placed on him by the captain & the team.He is SA's front line spinner but called on to serve his duty sometimes after the part timers which is not good to boost his form.

  • MeTalHeD69 on July 27, 2014, 19:35 GMT

    Tahir had a spinner's paradise to work on and barely took any wickets. I think Hashim Amla was right to have faith in him - he has to have faith in his players - but Tahir is not right for test match cricket. He is a T20 and ODI player. Alviro should have been dropped a long time ago, but they persisted with him. He is a naturally attacking player and is classy, but he seems to have no clue about what to do in international cricket. They should have dropped him down the order first, with Amla opening, to see if that would have helped. I believe it's a bit late now because there are other players who can do the job that are ready to play.

  • on July 27, 2014, 19:09 GMT

    Tahir was worth a try, but has failed unfortunately. It's time to get Stiaan van Zyl and Dane Piedt into the mix.

  • BellCurve on July 27, 2014, 17:40 GMT

    I just wish the changes were made before this Test. Neither Petersen nor Tahir made any contribution whatsoever. Just about all the commentators on this site predicted just that.

  • jgoogly on July 28, 2014, 6:41 GMT

    South Africa never had a quality spinner but had been successful with pace an d medium fast bowlers. Their formula is working!

  • on July 28, 2014, 3:43 GMT

    Tahir is one of the worst spinners playing the game at the moment, Amla's captaincy in doubt after he gave many amount of overs to him even he keep on bowling loose balls, hes a burden to the SA team

  • Sexysteven on July 28, 2014, 3:28 GMT

    I think tahirs career should be over at test level at least he's not upto it I would prob leave him out of white ball cricket he is getting on in age time to develop young spinners and bring them through I think as for Peterson I would keep for abit a longer just to see if Elgar is the right man at the other end ideally you want to get Elgar settled in to openers role before you think about getting rid of Peterson I think keep Peterson for another year for the good of the team cos you don't want to be searching for two new openers at the same time so I think the selectors should ask him if he has another year or two at most left in him just to get Elgar settled in hopefully cos I'm sure Peterson will find some form and his experience will help his opening partner I'm sure

  • jimbond on July 28, 2014, 2:57 GMT

    attilathecricketer: Fine if it is inclusion we want, it safe to replace Tahir with Phangiso- who doesn't leak runs at least. And De Kock is more or less opening now so he can take up that job permanently- this also reduces the pressure on ABD. I am sure there are many coloured batsman who are good enough to play in the top six. But for the moment it is best to focus only on cricket (and SA and Zimbabwe are very different in so many ways). Just imagine how stronger SA would have been if deKock had opened- with someone like Miller at No. 6, and Piedt instead of Tahir.

  • attilathecricketer on July 27, 2014, 22:53 GMT

    The changes may be fair enough on form but what does that do towards having a representative side? Ok there would be Amla, Duminy and Philander but surely some consideration should be given to the wider picture (if for no other reason that it might stop politicians from interfering a la Zimbabwe)

  • TommytuckerSaffa on July 27, 2014, 21:24 GMT

    We all predicted it would happen before it did. Tahir failure in the First Test was a sign of things to come. And now, with a Test average of 47, it should be glaringly obvious he is not a Test player. Petersen has been under-performing for the last 2 years.

    There needs to be quick promotion of the Top performing players from Domestic Cricket to Test cricket. Dane Piedt and Van Zyl are those players. They both should have been playing in this Test. CSA needs to cut loose the deadwood.

  • Herath-UK on July 27, 2014, 19:35 GMT

    You can't expect Tahir to be in the same league as Herath or Perera but he seemed to suffer from the lack of confidence placed on him by the captain & the team.He is SA's front line spinner but called on to serve his duty sometimes after the part timers which is not good to boost his form.

  • MeTalHeD69 on July 27, 2014, 19:35 GMT

    Tahir had a spinner's paradise to work on and barely took any wickets. I think Hashim Amla was right to have faith in him - he has to have faith in his players - but Tahir is not right for test match cricket. He is a T20 and ODI player. Alviro should have been dropped a long time ago, but they persisted with him. He is a naturally attacking player and is classy, but he seems to have no clue about what to do in international cricket. They should have dropped him down the order first, with Amla opening, to see if that would have helped. I believe it's a bit late now because there are other players who can do the job that are ready to play.

  • on July 27, 2014, 19:09 GMT

    Tahir was worth a try, but has failed unfortunately. It's time to get Stiaan van Zyl and Dane Piedt into the mix.

  • BellCurve on July 27, 2014, 17:40 GMT

    I just wish the changes were made before this Test. Neither Petersen nor Tahir made any contribution whatsoever. Just about all the commentators on this site predicted just that.

  • SurlyCynic on July 27, 2014, 16:58 GMT

    Both need to go. Now. Surely Piedt would add more to the team than Tahir, as many of us on here were pointing out before this test. Tahir should be a limited overs specialist.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • SurlyCynic on July 27, 2014, 16:58 GMT

    Both need to go. Now. Surely Piedt would add more to the team than Tahir, as many of us on here were pointing out before this test. Tahir should be a limited overs specialist.

  • BellCurve on July 27, 2014, 17:40 GMT

    I just wish the changes were made before this Test. Neither Petersen nor Tahir made any contribution whatsoever. Just about all the commentators on this site predicted just that.

  • on July 27, 2014, 19:09 GMT

    Tahir was worth a try, but has failed unfortunately. It's time to get Stiaan van Zyl and Dane Piedt into the mix.

  • MeTalHeD69 on July 27, 2014, 19:35 GMT

    Tahir had a spinner's paradise to work on and barely took any wickets. I think Hashim Amla was right to have faith in him - he has to have faith in his players - but Tahir is not right for test match cricket. He is a T20 and ODI player. Alviro should have been dropped a long time ago, but they persisted with him. He is a naturally attacking player and is classy, but he seems to have no clue about what to do in international cricket. They should have dropped him down the order first, with Amla opening, to see if that would have helped. I believe it's a bit late now because there are other players who can do the job that are ready to play.

  • Herath-UK on July 27, 2014, 19:35 GMT

    You can't expect Tahir to be in the same league as Herath or Perera but he seemed to suffer from the lack of confidence placed on him by the captain & the team.He is SA's front line spinner but called on to serve his duty sometimes after the part timers which is not good to boost his form.

  • TommytuckerSaffa on July 27, 2014, 21:24 GMT

    We all predicted it would happen before it did. Tahir failure in the First Test was a sign of things to come. And now, with a Test average of 47, it should be glaringly obvious he is not a Test player. Petersen has been under-performing for the last 2 years.

    There needs to be quick promotion of the Top performing players from Domestic Cricket to Test cricket. Dane Piedt and Van Zyl are those players. They both should have been playing in this Test. CSA needs to cut loose the deadwood.

  • attilathecricketer on July 27, 2014, 22:53 GMT

    The changes may be fair enough on form but what does that do towards having a representative side? Ok there would be Amla, Duminy and Philander but surely some consideration should be given to the wider picture (if for no other reason that it might stop politicians from interfering a la Zimbabwe)

  • jimbond on July 28, 2014, 2:57 GMT

    attilathecricketer: Fine if it is inclusion we want, it safe to replace Tahir with Phangiso- who doesn't leak runs at least. And De Kock is more or less opening now so he can take up that job permanently- this also reduces the pressure on ABD. I am sure there are many coloured batsman who are good enough to play in the top six. But for the moment it is best to focus only on cricket (and SA and Zimbabwe are very different in so many ways). Just imagine how stronger SA would have been if deKock had opened- with someone like Miller at No. 6, and Piedt instead of Tahir.

  • Sexysteven on July 28, 2014, 3:28 GMT

    I think tahirs career should be over at test level at least he's not upto it I would prob leave him out of white ball cricket he is getting on in age time to develop young spinners and bring them through I think as for Peterson I would keep for abit a longer just to see if Elgar is the right man at the other end ideally you want to get Elgar settled in to openers role before you think about getting rid of Peterson I think keep Peterson for another year for the good of the team cos you don't want to be searching for two new openers at the same time so I think the selectors should ask him if he has another year or two at most left in him just to get Elgar settled in hopefully cos I'm sure Peterson will find some form and his experience will help his opening partner I'm sure

  • on July 28, 2014, 3:43 GMT

    Tahir is one of the worst spinners playing the game at the moment, Amla's captaincy in doubt after he gave many amount of overs to him even he keep on bowling loose balls, hes a burden to the SA team