The Surfer

India's cricket journalism marred by jingoism

In a scathing indictment of the cricket media in India, Peter Roebuck writes in the Outlook that individual glorification and jingoism have blinded the bulk of the media to what should be its chief job, being the eyes and ears of the nation.

In a scathing indictment of the cricket media in India, Peter Roebuck writes in the Outlook that individual glorification and jingoism have blinded the bulk of the media to what should be its chief job, being the eyes and ears of the nation.
At such times, the only hope lies with the newspapers. As far as cricket is concerned, though, they too are rapidly losing ground. Capable and intrepid reporters continue to uncover stories and publish hard truths. That is the stuff of journalism. Left to their own devices, they could provide a sound critique of Indian cricket. But, unfortunately, they are not. Instead, they are undermined by a board that doesn't feel the need to hire a media manager, disdained by a captain who didn't feel obliged to attend a press conference after the Mohali Test, overwhelmed by the sound and fury and hemmed in by experts.
Full post
Hayden and Warne go for the <i>naans</i>

Venkat Ananth and Akshay Sawai of the Open magazine go behind the scenes to find what cricketers do, speak, and most importantly, eat, during the lunch break.

Nitin Sundar
Nitin Sundar
25-Feb-2013
Venkat Ananth and Akshay Sawai of the Open magazine go behind the scenes to find what cricketers do, speak, and most importantly, eat, during the lunch break.
Asked to name the big eaters in the current dressing room, Rohit Sharma says, “In the Ranji Trophy team, it would be Abhishek Nayar, and in the Indian team, Irfan Pathan.” Sharma himself is known to be a food enthusiast.
Nayar also figures in Agarkar’s list of dining table heavy-hitters. Vengsarkar names Shastri and Sachin Tendulkar. Bevan says, “The big fast bowlers were the best eaters. Glenn McGrath, Jason Gillespie... they didn’t mind a feed.”
Full post
Why Tendulkar's bat looks big

Writing in the Sydney Morning Herald , David Sygall tries to analyse what makes Sachin Tendulakar's bat look bigger than normal.

Akhila Ranganna
Akhila Ranganna
25-Feb-2013
Writing in the Sydney Morning Herald, David Sygall tries to analyse what makes Sachin Tendulakar's bat look bigger than normal.
''I was having lunch two days ago with the guy who makes his bat,'' said cricket-supply guru, Harry Solomons, who owns Kingsgrove Sports Centre, which once employed the Waugh brothers. ''Sachin's bats look wide, but they are regulation width. It's the thick edges that make it look bigger.
Full post
Time to save domestic cricket

Cricket Australia's AGM is approaching, and Robert Craddock writes in the Courier-Mail that it's time for some firm decisions on the country's new Twenty20 competition.

Brydon Coverdale
Brydon Coverdale
25-Feb-2013
Cricket Australia's AGM is approaching, and Robert Craddock writes in the Courier-Mail that it's time for some firm decisions on the country's new Twenty20 competition.
Endless meetings have failed to resolve key aspects of the competition: when it starts, how many teams it has, how players are chosen for it, whether franchises are privately owned. You cannot blame Australia for being cautious, the game's future is at stake here, but the time has arrived for tough, firm decision making. If the competition is to start next season, as most officials hope it will, Friday's CA board meeting is seen as the one which should produce the rubber stamp.
Full post
India's rotation policy robbing cricket fans

The rotation policy of venues for international cricket in India is impractical, says Anand Vasu in the Hindustan Times

Siddhartha Talya
Siddhartha Talya
25-Feb-2013
The problem, however, is that such sensible and practical scheduling is impossible because the BCCI allots matches on the basis of its much-pilloried (occasionally deservedly) rotation policy. While this automatically means that the best matches are not necessarily played at the best venues, it also means that a state association could get a match when it was least prepared for it.
Only recently, the Uttar Pradesh Cricket Association gave up a Test and an ODI, nominally because one stand at the Green Park in Kanpur was not ready, but also because the municipal authorities, who own the ground, and the UPCA, are constantly at loggerheads. For some time now, the BCCI has stressed the importance of state associations acquiring land and building their own stadia, and set up the necessary funding to make this possible. But this is a time consuming process, and at the moment cricket is still being played at grounds not owned by the state association.
Full post
NZ have a a mountain to climb

Writing in the New Zealand Herald , Adam Parore says that for all of the praise we must send the way of Bangladesh, following their 4-0 ODI series win over New Zealand, there is one word which best sums up this result: embarrassing.

Akhila Ranganna
Akhila Ranganna
25-Feb-2013
Writing in the New Zealand Herald, Adam Parore says that for all of the praise we must send the way of Bangladesh, following their 4-0 ODI series win over New Zealand, there is one word which best sums up this result: embarrassing.
New Zealand's cricket reputation has been seriously dented and the game is heading for major problems in this country if the Black Caps' fortunes cannot be quickly turned around. Cricket will lose its audience and suffer commercially. Bangladesh have clearly improved but this does not explain such an incredible turnaround in fortunes for the two sides.
Writing in the same newspaper, Mark Richardson says that he did not see the same level of desperation in New Zealand that he saw in the Bangladesh players.
Do our top players desperately need to succeed any more for New Zealand? I'm not sure they do. They may want to succeed but do they need to succeed? With the distraction of the IPL and Champions League, performing on low-profile New Zealand tours is not the priority.
Full post
Ray of hope for West Indies cricket

Hartley Anderson, in the Jamaica Observer , is optimistic about the future of West Indies cricket

Hartley Anderson, in the Jamaica Observer, is optimistic about the future of West Indies cricket. He points to the emergence of young talent like Adrian Barath and Andre Russell, and believes that the relieving of Chris Gayle's captaincy burden and the end of Dwayne Bravo's injury woes make it possible for West Indies to turn the corner.
Finally, the truth is that all is not lost with West Indies cricket, and in fact, just when we thought we could sink no further, the dangling carrot is the chance to move up the Test rankings -- ahead of Pakistan -- if indeed we perform creditably in the upcoming series.
Full post
Dhoni's Jharkhand experiencing change

Cricket in the Indian state of Jharkhand, which has produced MS Dhoni and Saurabh Tiwary, has remained mired in the shackles of mediocrity

While the bleached-blond-long-haired men have brought national interest to the region, the pair still remain unable to inspire their fellow state players to raise the bar on the domestic field.
Setting up nurseries of cricket is the unanimous answer.
Full post
Cricket and consolation

Walking towards the government headquarters in Bangalore, to catch a glimpse of the unfolding political drama, Ramachandra Guha instead chose to go to the Chinnaswamy stadium to watch, as he writes in the Telegraph another, and indubitably more

Akhila Ranganna
Akhila Ranganna
25-Feb-2013
In the first over of the third day, Tendulkar played two late leg-glances to get to his half-century. Then he hit two lusty pulls off Mitchell Johnson, Australia’s fastest bowler, and a man reckless enough to announce before the series began that the Indians were suspect against the short ball
I learnt from the next day’s papers that the last stages of his innings had been watched by, among others, the leader of the Opposition in the Karnataka state assembly, the Congress politician, A. Siddaramiah. That morning, Siddaramiah had gone to work hoping that the BJP government would be voted out, and that he would stake a claim to be chief minister. The plan was foiled when, with the aid of the police, the speaker enforced his decision to disqualify the defecting legislators.The thwarted leader now chose to leave for the Chinnaswamy Stadium, where, since Tendulkar was still at the crease, he knew he would find pleasure — and consolation.
Full post
Agnew remembers Johnston

At a time when cricket commentary has degenerated into loud and cliched utterances set to the monotonous frenzy of Twenty20 cricket, Jonathan Agnew of Test Match Special looks back at the magical era of his predecessor as BBC's cricket

Nitin Sundar
Nitin Sundar
25-Feb-2013
Johnston was describing a curious dismissal in which Ian Botham’s inner thigh had brushed his stumps, dislodging a bail. ‘He just didn’t quite get his leg over,’ chipped in Agnew mischievously. Cue Johnston, a lover of schoolboy innuendo to rival Frankie Howerd, erupting in a Krakatoa of snorts, whimpers, sneezes and, finally, uncontrollable laughter. Listeners were similarly afflicted; motorists had to pull on to the hard shoulder to wipe away the tears.
The ‘Leg Over’ has since become a commentary classic. But, at the time, Johnston was aghast. ‘He thought he’d been unprofessional,’ says Agnew. ‘It was only the next day when we listened to it that we realised it was very funny.’
Full post

Showing 3191 - 3200 of 9201