The Surfer

New Twenty20 threatens county structure

"Although its architects will deny the charge of plagiarism, the similarities between the radical new Twenty20 competition leaked yesterday and the Indian Premier League (IPL) are so clear that it seems the ground-breaking tournament has simply been

George Binoy
George Binoy
25-Feb-2013
In a different slot, the New T20, as it would be called, is being projected as a complement rather than a rival to the IPL. The organisers will save themselves a lot of tedious politicking with Lalit Modi and his friends on the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) if they can make friends early. But the tone of the early part of the document written by Keith Bradshaw, the MCC chief executive, and David Stewart, the Surrey chairman, is that England must act quickly to ensure that India, already the biggest market for the world game, does not gain a monopoly on the most lucrative staging of the format.
Also in the Times, Christopher Martin-Jenkins writes, "Profits are estimated, with questionable precision, at £7 million a team, but let us have some cricketing honesty here. It should be either this revamped nine-team extravaganza with profits genuinely shared, or a continued county league. In a properly balanced programme there is no realistic place for both."
"The Twenty20 format proposed by the Marylebone Cricket Club, Hampshire, Lancashire and Surrey is imaginative and has some merit but it threatens the fabric of the domestic game in England. Despite what the project team state, the creation would cause an insurmountable split among the 18 first-class counties. It threatens overkill of Twenty20 cricket, a product that has achieved so much good in the six years since its inception," writes Angus Fraser in the Independent.
Full post
Reeve heads to Napier

Dermot Reeve has been appointed the Central Districts coach and talks to Dominion Post 's Sam Worthington about the challenges ahead, as he relocates to New Zealand without his family.

Nishi Narayanan
25-Feb-2013
Dermot Reeve has been appointed the Central Districts coach and talks to Dominion Post's Sam Worthington about the challenges ahead, as he relocates to New Zealand without his family.
Reeve brings to Central a reputation for improvisation that is likely to endear him to the likes of the flamboyant Ross Taylor, though he claimed that was a tag thrust upon him by others. "Innovative is something that someone else puts on you and I just weighed up the pros and the cons of where to put men in the field and what degree of risk you might take with a certain shot. I was lucky to have played and captained at a time at Warwickshire where myself and Bob Woolmer, we did analyse the game and give it the attention I believe it deserves. To me, playing the reverse sweep when the field is set a certain way is just the right thing to do. Other people would describe the shot as innovative, but if you practice it, it's just like playing any other shot."
Full post
England's nearly man shines

Ian Bell came in to the first Test at Lord's under pressure with Andrew Flintoff fit for action against for the next match, writes Derek Pringle in the Telegraph

Nishi Narayanan
25-Feb-2013
Ian Bell came in to the first Test at Lord's under pressure with Andrew Flintoff fit for action against for the next match, writes Derek Pringle in the Telegraph. There have been criticisms that Bell makes hundreds in undemanding situations and that he is too introverted, playing the theory of the game rather than the game itself. His 199 on Friday laid to rest some of these doubts.
To get the ball in the gap behind square leg, Pietersen had to rotate his wrists as if turning a car steering wheel sharp left at the lights. Bell may lack that kind of elasticity in limb but not in mind, and his late cut for four off Ntini, through an empty slip cordon, was like a deadly kiss, delicate but lethal in its effect on South Africa's morale. Before that his finest shot had been a lofted six off his eventual nemesis, Harris, but this came with that delicious cruelty closer to sadism than sport.
In the Guardian, Neil Manthorp catches up with Gulam Bodi, the man KwaZulu Natal picked ahead of Pietersen ten years ago, a selection which turned KP's career for the better.
Full post
Blurred Twenty20 vision?

Reacting to the proposal for an Indian Premier League clone in England, Stephen Moss in the Guardian asks: Do we really want to replace the grand narrative of county cricket with mock dramas starring the Headingley Humdingers.

Reacting to the proposal for an Indian Premier League clone in England, Stephen Moss in the Guardian asks: Do we really want to replace the grand narrative of county cricket with mock dramas starring the Headingley Humdingers.
If and when this English Premier League is launched in 2010, dominating the key cricketing months of June and July, the county championship, which has already been made virtually meaningless by the comings and goings of star players for the odd fortnight, will wither. It will carry on in some form, but in effect it will be a second-eleven competition, a place for the Premier League stars to get some practice and for young players to stake their claim to the big bucks of Twenty20.
...
Cricket is a great game because it lasts long enough for character to express itself. Twenty20 allows for no such niceties. Mock drama replaces narrative; money overwhelms love; celebrity usurps true character.
Full post
Day of mixed emotions and a skip to the loo

Billy Bowden, the umpire, shares his experience of officiating on the first day of the first Test between England and South Africa

Sriram Veera
25-Feb-2013
I thought the fact that my mother was not at Lord's to watch me - she died three weeks ago - would hit me hard when I took the field yesterday .. The one intervention that I needed to make came when I picked up Pietersen's necklace when he was hit on the helmet.
Telegraph's Martin Johnson writes that the Lord's Test was a welcome dose of Twenty20 antidote.
There were 41 dot balls in the first six overs of this game, but it didn't mean it was any less intriguing than the instant biff-bang-wallop of Twenty20. Did those spectators who turned up to see whether the self-proclaimed South African mean machine would live up to their arrogant pre-match propaganda feel disappointed when it turned out their fast bowlers couldn't hit a cow's arse with a banjo?
Full post
Azeem Rafiq 'just wants to play cricket'

Azeem Rafiq, the 17-year-old at the centre of Yorkshire's Twenty20 eligibility furore, is gutted and just wants to play cricket

Sriram Veera
25-Feb-2013
As far as we are concerned, there is no reason for him to feel upset," said the club's development officer David Clayton ... "He's absolutely gutted. He just wants to play cricket. He is obsessed by cricket, so driven. He loves the game. I offered him a game with our Under-17s (last night) and he said he'd better not – that was the first time I've ever seen him turn down a game. I remember when he first moved over here with his family. He was so keen. He practised every night. If there was no one to practise with, he would practise on his own. Even though he's been playing with the Yorkshire Academy for the last two seasons, he's still down here all the time.You could tell he was good right from the start – he's the best I've seen at that age. He's also a top lad. I'm sure he'll bounce back from this."
Yorkshire Post cricket writer Sam Wheeler gives his views on the ECB's decision. Listen to the audio programme CricketTalk.
Full post
Mendis creates magic but ICC mess up big time

In the Indian Express , Harsha Bhogle writes how Ajantha Mendis' marvellous bowling performance was the only silver lining in a week that saw the game suffering grievous wounds at the ICC meeting.

Sriram Veera
25-Feb-2013
In the Indian Express, Harsha Bhogle writes how Ajantha Mendis' marvellous bowling performance was the only silver lining in a week that saw the game suffering grievous wounds at the ICC meeting.
The funny thing is that every country got what it wanted and the game suffered. Zimbabwe got the best deal. They wanted money, they got it; they didn’t want cricket, now they don’t need to provide it. And England got what they wanted; the money that will flow in from organizing the next world T20 and a political victory by denying Zimbabwean players a world stage. It has very dangerous implications ... Worse still is the decision to change the result of the Oval Test between England and Pakistan.
Full post
A highly anticipated clash

Michael Atherton previews the upcoming Test series between England and South Africa, and is happy that the home side is going to play a new opponent after a while

Not since the beginning of the Ashes series three years ago has there been such anticipation about the start of a Test series. Yesterday, Michael Vaughan suggested that a series against South Africa is “nearly up there with the Ashes” and if the England captain overstated the case a touch, it was partly in recognition of the fact that the bland fare offered up by 19 consecutive matches against New Zealand will be replaced by something much richer and more varied for the palate.
The Guardian's Mike Selvey says it will be series that "defines England's progress" since Peter Moores took over last year.
The Times' Ivo Tennant talks to the eccentric Billy Bowden ahead of his maiden appearance as an umpire at Lord's.
Full post
How safe are helmets?

The Telegraph's Simon Hughes writes about the Loughborough University's scientific study on helmets

The Telegraph's Simon Hughes writes about the Loughborough University's scientific study on helmets.
In a project financed in part by the government, in part by the ECB, Loughborough's sports technology institute - an organisation that works with sporting bodies and manufacturers to produce cutting edge equipment - has been subjecting various helmets and gloves to a severe assault. In a transparent box a typical betting helmet is positioned on the head of a mannequin which is screwed onto a steel post. Balls are fired at the helmet from close range using a bowling machine.
The speed is about 65mph, similar to that of James Anderson bouncer once it has reached the batsman. The process is recorded by cameras filming at 10,000 frames per second. Once slowed down the images are similar to those ads featuring crash-test dummies. A similar process is used to test a glove on the hand of a prosthetic arm.
Full post
Cricket Australia's AFL-style mediation plan

Chloe Saltau, in the Sydney Morning Herald , says Cricket Australia (CA) is lobbying for an AFL-style mediation plan to resolve racial disputes before the ICC.

Chloe Saltau, in the Sydney Morning Herald, says Cricket Australia (CA) is lobbying for an AFL-style mediation plan to resolve racial disputes before the ICC.
The AFL is considered a world leader in confronting racial vilification, and won a United Nations award for the code established after Essendon champion Michael Long reacted to Collingwood's Damian Monkhorst racially abusing him in 1995. Since then, the first step in resolving incidents of racial abuse has been for the two players to attend a mediation session. If that fails, the matter proceeds to the AFL Tribunal.
Cricket Australia is advocating a similar system, in which mediation would ideally be confidential, and prosecution a last resort. The ICC is understood to have been unconvinced, but CA is determined to keep pushing for a less combative process that, in the first instance, aims for the offender to understand why a particular remark is unacceptable.
Full post

Showing 6191 - 6200 of 9201