Mixed reactions from players, officials to CBI report
So finally the report is out and has been made public
AC Ganesh
01-Nov-2000
So finally the report is out and has been made public. The Central
Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has unearthed perhaps the most shameful
chapter in the history of cricket. Off the field, Indian cricket has
hit a new low over the past six months. On the field, things have been
no better and the team reached a nadir in Sharjah just the other day.
In a damning expose, the CBI report has ripped apart the reputation of
many Indian and foreign players. The 162-page report has alleged that
former Indian captain Md Azharuddin along with Ajay Jadeja and Nayan
Mongia fixed some games for money. Another Indian players who is said
to have a nexus with the bookies is former Indian player Ajay Sharma.
The man who first blew the siren and talked of cleansing the game
Manoj Prabhakar has also been named in the report of wrong doing.
Azharuddin has named his former teammates Jadeja and Mongia as being
involved with him in fixing matches, according to the report submitted
by the agency to the government.
Another name which may surprise many is that of former Indian physio
Ali Irani who is said to have been a conduit of Azharuddin. The report
said that Irani has been named by the investigating agency as having
"acted as a conduit for receiving payments on behalf of Azharuddin
from MK and his associates." Azhar is alleged to have paid Irani money
on each occasion he received payments on the former's behalf, the
report said.
But perhaps the most shocking aspect of the report is that match
fixing is not only a virus in India or confined to Indian cricketers.
The report has it that the menace has spread its venom to other
cricketing nations too.
The Union Sports Minister SS Dhindsa said on Tuesday that apart from
the Indian players, former England captain Alec Stewart and former
West Indies captain Brian Lara along with seven other foreign
cricketers have been named by bookies. He also added that Australian
player Dean Jones has also been named in the report.
The report does not specify whether the foreign players accepted or
turned down the request made by Mukesh Gupta, an alleged bookie, to
throw matches. The players named in the report are former England
captain Alec Stewart, West Indian batting stalwart Brian Lara,
Australians Mark Waugh and Dean Jones, Sri Lanka's Aravinda de Silva
and Arjuna Ranatunga, former South African skipper Hansie Cronje,
former New Zealand captain Martin Crowe and former Pakistan skipper
Salim Malik.
The immediate reaction from various quarters of the world has been one
of shock and disbelief.
Former New Zealand captain Martin Crowe strongly denied that he was
linked to match-fixing in India. Talking to AFP on Wednesday, Crowe
said "I'm shattered that my name is mentioned when you don't know what
it's for. I'll be more than interested to see what this report says.
The only incident I've ever had is with a so-called journalist in
1992. That was this guy Gupta who did a couple of articles with me
over the phone and then revealed he was a bookie, at which time I told
him to leave me alone. That was about the only contact I've ever had
with that part of the world and the first time I've heard of it
since.'' He added I've never had any contact with these dudes
(bookmakers). It certainly never came into direct contact with the New
Zealand team at the time, but we did hear whispers of things from the
sub-continent."
New Zealand Cricket chief executive Chris Doig said he was unaware of
the content of the report, and would make no comment until he knew the
full details.
Former Australian batsman Dean Jones was quick to deny the
allegations. "I'm obviously surprised about this. In what way has my
name been brought up?" Jones told ABC radio, quotes AFP. Jones said
"In 1992, there was the well-documented situation where I was
approached by a bookmaker and by an Indian player - most of the
Australian players know who that guy was -- so whether they used me to
throw a bit of dirt around, I don't know. All my books are open,
anyone can go through my place. There is one player throwing a lot of
dirt over there trying to protect his backside at the moment."
English cricket officials remained silent on Wednesday after former
captain Alec Stewart was named in the agency's report which claims
that bookmaker Mukesh Gupta paid Stewart 5,000 pounds for pitch,
weather and team information. The official team spokesman Andrew
Walpole said in Rawalpindi "We are in constant touch with the England
and Wales Cricket Board in London and Stewart or any other official
will not make any comment until the report is made public."
The West Indies Cricket Board (WICB) chief Pat Rousseau said he would
not comment on an Indian government report that allegedly accuses
former West Indies captain Brian Lara and others of involvement in a
match-fixing scandal. Rousseau said "So far all we can hear is sources
saying this and that without a shred of evidence." The Observer quoted
him as saying that "Until we do, it is unfair to fuel the rumour
mill."
PTI, quoting an AP report said that the WICB chief executive Gregory
Shillingford on Tuesday said that the British investigators had
interviewed Lara. Shillingford said he believed they were seeking
evidence against an alleged bookmaker. "It was simply a matter of
Brian verifying that he had been approached by an Indian bookmaker
during one of his stopovers in London and that he had told the man he
wanted nothing to do him," Shillingford said. Lara has denied any
involvement. He was scheduled to leave Jamaica Monday night with the
West Indies for their tour in Australia.
Finally, the Sri Lankan officials cricket were dismayed over the
allegations against their two super stars Arjuna Ranatunga and his
deputy Aravinda de Silva on the report that they accepted bribes to
fix matches. Mukesh Gupta had claimed in the CBI report that the two
cricketers helped him fix an Indian victory in the Lucknow Test in
1994. He also said that de Silva was paid 15,000 dollars. A Lankan
Board official said "Both players are now seeking legal advice and a
statement will be issued later. The allegations, coming from a
questionable character, lack credibility."