June 21, 2013

The smartest cricketers XI

A team featuring an Oxford graduate, a farm boy from Dungog, and an artistic wicketkeeper. And Shane Warne
17

Jack Russell: the artistic one
Jack Russell: the artistic one © Getty Images

Ranjit Fernando
In the World Cup in 1975, Jeff Thomson was bowling faster than anyone ever had and he sent Sri Lanka's Sunil Wettimuny and Duleep Mendis to hospital after hitting the first on the head and smashing the second's instep with his famous "sandshoe crusher". But opener Fernando decided on a novel approach to self-preservation: "I kept smiling at Thomson, hoping to keep him in a good mood." It might not have worked but Fernando walked off unscathed (though he was bowled by Thomson for 22).

Geoff Boycott
While he could kill entire stadiums with batting more boring than the creep of prehistoric moss, Boycott realised it was impossible to score runs when you weren't at the crease. This, curiously, is not obvious to all batsmen. Boycott, though, learned how to occupy the crease. And occupy it. And continue occupying it until the United Nations needed to send in tanks to remove him. Boycott saw his role as a batsman as being around long enough to ensure his team did not lose. Significantly, of his 108 Tests, only 20 ended in defeat.

Douglas Jardine
With his fingers steepled like those of a cunning, ruthless and evil train baron, Jardine devised field placements and bowling methods so cunning, ruthless and evil that they halved Bradman's batting average and won England the 1932-33 Ashes 4-1. Bodyline - or "fast leg theory" as Jardine called it - was so effective it was outlawed. Yet in 1933, Jardine scored 127 - his only Test century - against a West Indies team that was employing these very tactics. So Jardine proved himself smart enough to employ Bodyline and also beat it. He also went to Oxford and learned things.

Steve Waugh
Stephen Rodger Waugh's knowledge of what makes cricketers tick went a long way to making his Australian team an all-conquering force. When he came into the side in 1985, his fellow players were on edge, not talking to those who might take their place. John Dyson once put a debutant's kit in the toilet when the new guy mistakenly used "his" locker. Waugh ended such bastardry and made new chums feel good. Later he coached Glenn McGrath to a Test highest score of 61. Personally Waugh eliminated certain shots from his game and became a massive run accumulator. He also wrote several books, one of them featuring so many words, scholars are still working their way through it.

Doug Walters
It took a clever cricketer to hide in a cemetery smoking cigarettes while the rest of the Australian World Series Cricket team ran laps of it. Walters also managed to score a hundred in South Africa against Mike Procter after a six-pack of "breakfast beers". Once borrowed a spectator's bicycle to get from third man to third man after Ian Chappell had punished him for sleeping in.

Mike Brearley (c)
Brearley was one of the first players to think of wearing a helmet - or at least a pillow-like thing that poked out under his England cap like the ears of a basset hound - against Lillee and Thomson. With grey hair and a scholarly mien, Brearley even looked smart. But his cleverest trick was that he kept getting picked for England despite not being able to bat. A man picked just for his brain. That's the captain of this XI.

Jack Russell (wk)

He managed to last 235 balls and 274 minutes in scoring 29 runs and save a Test match against South Africa despite having a batting range more limited than Jason Gillespie, without the flamboyance. An eccentric character, Russell still wears a floppy white hat despite being retired from cricket for several years, hence eliminating any chance of skin cancer. This is helped by living in England. But Russell's smartest trick has been selling paintings of cricket grounds to people for actual money.

Waqar Younis and Wasim Akram
Sarfraz Nawaz was the first man to discover "reverse" swing but it was this pair that became its masters. The terrible twosome swung the old ball with such menace that it was thought they must have been cheating. Other bowlers - Terry Alderman was one - occasionally swung it Irish by mistake. Imran Khan also had his Irish moments after wheedling the secret out of Sarfraz, who was at first reluctant to share the love. But it was Waqar and Wasim who were the first to truly exploit it, and they did it at exceptional speed and accuracy. Their late inswinging yorkers made batsmen look like splay-footed fools.

Shane Warne
Now, now, none of your cheek. Sure, Warnie's private life hasn't been the neatest. And he's probably made some decisions he'd take back given the location of the hidden cameras. And sharing love-sick tweets with millions of people is sort of naff. Shane the man, like all of us, is not perfect. But Shane the legspinner is a genius, up there with theoretical physicist Albert Einstein. Hey, you try rolling the ball out the back of the hand 40,705 times and taking 708 Test wickets at an average of 25.41. You try beating the world's best batters with deliveries that come at them slowly. You try drifting one in and jagging it past Mike Gatting and nipping off his off bail with your first ball in the country Gatting grew up in. All of these things are incredibly difficult; perhaps even impossible. Yet Warnie conjured them all. A dinkum shaman.

Sarfraz Nawaz
It might not really have been quite cricket, wot? But it was certainly quick-witted to think of appealing against Andrew Hilditch for handled the ball when the Australian opener caught an outfield throw on the first bounce and tossed it back to Sarfraz. How was he? Out, as it turned out.

Terry Alderman
Learned about getting close to the stumps off Dennis Lillee. Mastered English conditions on two record-breaking Ashes tours; taking over 40 wickets apiece in '81 and '89. His outswingers and offcutters so upset Graham Gooch that he changed his phone's answering machine message to: "Please leave a message because I'm out, probably lbw Alderman." The Western Australian was also astute enough to take the money for the rebel tour of South Africa and hence avoid one of Australian cricket's worst periods. It might not have been smart to chase the English skinhead who invaded the WACA ground, but it certainly gave Alderman something people will still pay him to hear him speak about. He also earns a crust in a radio role best described as, "be Terry Alderman. And talk about cricket."

Matt Cleary writes for several Australian sports and travel magazines. He tweets here

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • sportofpain on June 23, 2013, 10:44 GMT

    What about Dwayne Leverock Matt? Warnie might have bowled the ball of the century but Dwayne took the catch of the century

  • on June 23, 2013, 6:56 GMT

    Excellent article. Pity only the Clever readers got most it :) Nice one Matt

  • Viv-Viru on June 22, 2013, 14:58 GMT

    Sarfraz Nawaz's appeal "might not really have been quite cricket", but for that he makes it to your The smartest cricketers XI list? Geoff Boycott makes it to your list just for occupying the crease, but what about players like Rahul Dravid who could not only occupy the crease, but also be a Wall to the bowlers, and still score a lot of runs? And Ranjit Fernando makes it to your list for scoring 22 without getting hurt? Are you serious?

  • RogerC on June 22, 2013, 13:21 GMT

    Is Mike Gatting such an impossible batsman to dismiss of spin that dismissing him becomes the ball of the century? Warne is a great bowler, but he also got wickets with freak deliveries like the one he bowled to Gatting. Even Ashwin bowled such a ball recently to Kulasekara in the Commonwealth trophy.

  • on June 22, 2013, 8:10 GMT

    There are many that should come above shane warne...warne had the fortune to play against a team that was very very weak against spin in playing the ashes. What if sri lanka had such a series instead of playing india all the time? Murali would have easily taken 1000 test wickets.... also murali's cunning at the bowling crease was hard to beat.

  • on June 22, 2013, 5:16 GMT

    Cant believe MSD isnt here

  • Emancipator007 on June 22, 2013, 4:51 GMT

    Ranatunga was one of the shrewdest, psychological cricket player/captains around. Yes agree,Gavaskar was one of the greatest thinkers of the game; the excellence that he brought to the art of technical proficiency against express pace bowling is unprecedented in cricket history. Miandad was certainly quick-witted about his game. Gooch for all his fallibilities against Alderman was actually a smart cookie. McGrath was the smartest bowler after Marshall and Hadlee. Whoa and the over-hype about Warney continues. Not a single magic ball or outwitting of the really great batters of spin throughout his career: SRT,Azhar,Laxman,Sidhu,Sehwag,Ganguly,Dravid,De Silva,Arjuna,Malik.Hell, even Kambli, Shastri tonked him.

  • KiwiRocker- on June 22, 2013, 3:37 GMT

    Interesting choices but there is an obvious and glaring omission- Javed Miandad. Javed Miandad mastered the art of mental disintegration long before Steve Waugh even started to play the cricket. It is an utter shame that Shane Warne did not bowl against Javed Miandad or that would have been a superb sight. Javed Miandad had a unique thing against spinner. He did not considered them bowlers and especially the leg spinner. It is well known that he told one Indian spinner to hit him out of the ground and ball will land in bowler's room. Javed Miandad was always thinking of a cheeky single while batting, he kept wickets and even scored stumpings, then he also bowled occasion leg spinners to rub some salt and while fielding he was a true class. How can anyone forget run out of Jeff Crowe when poor Crowe was out of crease. Javed Miandad had a thing about him and his last ball six against India was a huge psychological blow resulting in India losing against Pakistan until 2003!

  • cloudmess on June 22, 2013, 3:33 GMT

    FunFunyyc and cleverFuWitty and astute. Good cricketers are always given credit for their talent and/or temperament, but rarely for their brains. Those of us who are England supporters used to truly dread the sight of Steve Waugh - not because he was the most talented Australian, or even the toughest, but simply because he had worked out the game of cricket better than almost anyone else of his generation.

  • cricketconnoisseur27 on June 22, 2013, 3:32 GMT

    No Anil Kumble!!! The man got close to 1000 international wickets basically foxing batsman with right arm gentle medium...

  • sportofpain on June 23, 2013, 10:44 GMT

    What about Dwayne Leverock Matt? Warnie might have bowled the ball of the century but Dwayne took the catch of the century

  • on June 23, 2013, 6:56 GMT

    Excellent article. Pity only the Clever readers got most it :) Nice one Matt

  • Viv-Viru on June 22, 2013, 14:58 GMT

    Sarfraz Nawaz's appeal "might not really have been quite cricket", but for that he makes it to your The smartest cricketers XI list? Geoff Boycott makes it to your list just for occupying the crease, but what about players like Rahul Dravid who could not only occupy the crease, but also be a Wall to the bowlers, and still score a lot of runs? And Ranjit Fernando makes it to your list for scoring 22 without getting hurt? Are you serious?

  • RogerC on June 22, 2013, 13:21 GMT

    Is Mike Gatting such an impossible batsman to dismiss of spin that dismissing him becomes the ball of the century? Warne is a great bowler, but he also got wickets with freak deliveries like the one he bowled to Gatting. Even Ashwin bowled such a ball recently to Kulasekara in the Commonwealth trophy.

  • on June 22, 2013, 8:10 GMT

    There are many that should come above shane warne...warne had the fortune to play against a team that was very very weak against spin in playing the ashes. What if sri lanka had such a series instead of playing india all the time? Murali would have easily taken 1000 test wickets.... also murali's cunning at the bowling crease was hard to beat.

  • on June 22, 2013, 5:16 GMT

    Cant believe MSD isnt here

  • Emancipator007 on June 22, 2013, 4:51 GMT

    Ranatunga was one of the shrewdest, psychological cricket player/captains around. Yes agree,Gavaskar was one of the greatest thinkers of the game; the excellence that he brought to the art of technical proficiency against express pace bowling is unprecedented in cricket history. Miandad was certainly quick-witted about his game. Gooch for all his fallibilities against Alderman was actually a smart cookie. McGrath was the smartest bowler after Marshall and Hadlee. Whoa and the over-hype about Warney continues. Not a single magic ball or outwitting of the really great batters of spin throughout his career: SRT,Azhar,Laxman,Sidhu,Sehwag,Ganguly,Dravid,De Silva,Arjuna,Malik.Hell, even Kambli, Shastri tonked him.

  • KiwiRocker- on June 22, 2013, 3:37 GMT

    Interesting choices but there is an obvious and glaring omission- Javed Miandad. Javed Miandad mastered the art of mental disintegration long before Steve Waugh even started to play the cricket. It is an utter shame that Shane Warne did not bowl against Javed Miandad or that would have been a superb sight. Javed Miandad had a unique thing against spinner. He did not considered them bowlers and especially the leg spinner. It is well known that he told one Indian spinner to hit him out of the ground and ball will land in bowler's room. Javed Miandad was always thinking of a cheeky single while batting, he kept wickets and even scored stumpings, then he also bowled occasion leg spinners to rub some salt and while fielding he was a true class. How can anyone forget run out of Jeff Crowe when poor Crowe was out of crease. Javed Miandad had a thing about him and his last ball six against India was a huge psychological blow resulting in India losing against Pakistan until 2003!

  • cloudmess on June 22, 2013, 3:33 GMT

    FunFunyyc and cleverFuWitty and astute. Good cricketers are always given credit for their talent and/or temperament, but rarely for their brains. Those of us who are England supporters used to truly dread the sight of Steve Waugh - not because he was the most talented Australian, or even the toughest, but simply because he had worked out the game of cricket better than almost anyone else of his generation.

  • cricketconnoisseur27 on June 22, 2013, 3:32 GMT

    No Anil Kumble!!! The man got close to 1000 international wickets basically foxing batsman with right arm gentle medium...

  • on June 21, 2013, 23:58 GMT

    Ah yes - Crafty Javed Miandad. You could make a good case for his inclusion in the middle-order of this XI

  • 777aditya on June 21, 2013, 23:02 GMT

    Miandad, Ganguly, Sunil Gavaskar, Dhoni should all feature in this list, agreed. But if there was ever a list of made of the not so smart cricketers, I think Vinod Kambli should be the captain!

  • on June 21, 2013, 22:32 GMT

    awsm post .... really feeling good aftr read all about masters of the game ... Name is Cricket ...

  • on June 21, 2013, 17:11 GMT

    Great piece but in my book probably no one was more street smarter than Miandad.

  • HansonKoch on June 21, 2013, 11:14 GMT

    What, no Dave Warner? Skipped first class and went straight to top of the class. Warney's protege.

  • on June 21, 2013, 10:51 GMT

    The bit on Geoff Boycott was downright amusing! Loved the article.

  • MJ1234 on June 21, 2013, 10:12 GMT

    Among the modern gen. Shane Warne is the smartest. His commentary is wonderful and he picks up the minutest of things. Also, he is a world class poker player.

    Sunil Gavaskar was a smart thinker until he was drafted into the propaganda machinery of the BCCI.:-)

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • MJ1234 on June 21, 2013, 10:12 GMT

    Among the modern gen. Shane Warne is the smartest. His commentary is wonderful and he picks up the minutest of things. Also, he is a world class poker player.

    Sunil Gavaskar was a smart thinker until he was drafted into the propaganda machinery of the BCCI.:-)

  • on June 21, 2013, 10:51 GMT

    The bit on Geoff Boycott was downright amusing! Loved the article.

  • HansonKoch on June 21, 2013, 11:14 GMT

    What, no Dave Warner? Skipped first class and went straight to top of the class. Warney's protege.

  • on June 21, 2013, 17:11 GMT

    Great piece but in my book probably no one was more street smarter than Miandad.

  • on June 21, 2013, 22:32 GMT

    awsm post .... really feeling good aftr read all about masters of the game ... Name is Cricket ...

  • 777aditya on June 21, 2013, 23:02 GMT

    Miandad, Ganguly, Sunil Gavaskar, Dhoni should all feature in this list, agreed. But if there was ever a list of made of the not so smart cricketers, I think Vinod Kambli should be the captain!

  • on June 21, 2013, 23:58 GMT

    Ah yes - Crafty Javed Miandad. You could make a good case for his inclusion in the middle-order of this XI

  • cricketconnoisseur27 on June 22, 2013, 3:32 GMT

    No Anil Kumble!!! The man got close to 1000 international wickets basically foxing batsman with right arm gentle medium...

  • cloudmess on June 22, 2013, 3:33 GMT

    FunFunyyc and cleverFuWitty and astute. Good cricketers are always given credit for their talent and/or temperament, but rarely for their brains. Those of us who are England supporters used to truly dread the sight of Steve Waugh - not because he was the most talented Australian, or even the toughest, but simply because he had worked out the game of cricket better than almost anyone else of his generation.

  • KiwiRocker- on June 22, 2013, 3:37 GMT

    Interesting choices but there is an obvious and glaring omission- Javed Miandad. Javed Miandad mastered the art of mental disintegration long before Steve Waugh even started to play the cricket. It is an utter shame that Shane Warne did not bowl against Javed Miandad or that would have been a superb sight. Javed Miandad had a unique thing against spinner. He did not considered them bowlers and especially the leg spinner. It is well known that he told one Indian spinner to hit him out of the ground and ball will land in bowler's room. Javed Miandad was always thinking of a cheeky single while batting, he kept wickets and even scored stumpings, then he also bowled occasion leg spinners to rub some salt and while fielding he was a true class. How can anyone forget run out of Jeff Crowe when poor Crowe was out of crease. Javed Miandad had a thing about him and his last ball six against India was a huge psychological blow resulting in India losing against Pakistan until 2003!