South Africa v England, 1st ODI, Johannesburg January 30, 2005

The mystery of the missing man

Where was he? AB de Villiers wasn't selected for the first one-dayer © Getty Images

The bad weather which followed the Tests around doesn't seem to have left South Africa along with the Barmy Army. England were well on the way to a convincing victory at Johannesburg when there was a repeat of the storms that blighted the early part of the Centurion Test.

With Kevin Pietersen managing to block out the catcalls of the crowd and the brickbats of the fielders, the second part of England's innings should have been a walk in the Wanderers. We'll never know, but it did seem that the onfield storm had been ridden. Duckworth and Lewis were also on England's side, which was what mattered once the outfield was turned into a paddling pool.

When South Africa dipped to 90 for 7 earlier, though, Duckworth and Lewis were the last names on most people's minds. If Michael Vaughan had gone for the jugular, and brought back his strike bowlers rather than filling in with 15 overs from Paul Collingwood and Marcus Trescothick, then Shaun Pollock and Nicky Boje might never have made a game of it with their eighth-wicket rescue act of 58.

But the real mystery happened even before the first stumps were rattled. South Africa's selectors left out AB de Villiers, the one shining discovery of the recent Test series - and a man in ripping form after making 92 and 109 in the final Test last week. Instead Adam Bacher came back, for the first time in half a decade, and looked out of his depth in scoring 4 from 18 balls. With the ball doing a bit on a helpful pitch - the top-notch trio of Graeme Smith, Herschelle Gibbs and Jacques Kallis went cheaply too - it's fair to say that de Villiers might have struggled as well. But barring accidents he will be a key member of South Africa's team at the next World Cup in 2007. Barring accidents, Bacher won't be.

It took the South African selectors more than half the Test series to get their side right. England will be highly delighted if it takes them as long to work out what their best one-day line-up is as well.

Steven Lynch is the editor of Cricinfo.