India news

BCCI defers decision on Azhar

ESPNcricinfo staff

November 23, 2012

Comments: 1 | Text size: A | A

Mohammad Azharuddin addresses the press after a court struck down his life ban, Delhi, November 8, 2012
The BCCI's life ban on Mohammad Azharuddin was termed 'unsustainable' in a court order recently © Associated Press

The BCCI was forced to "defer" its decision regarding former India captain Mohammad Azharuddin's life ban due to the complications in the Andhra Pradesh High Court's order.

After the court termed the BCCI's life ban on Azharuddin as "unsustainable" in its order on November 8, the BCCI's working committee discussed the issue during its meeting in Mumbai on November 21. But rather than deciding the future course of action, the committee deferred the matter till the next meeting.

A BCCI insider, who attended the meeting, said the deferment was primarily due to "complications in the judgment order."

"Nowhere does the judgment mention that he [Azharuddin] did not indulge in match-fixing. At the same time, the honourable court has lashed out at the then BCCI president [AC Muthiah] for unilaterally conducting the enquiry and imposing a ban. So it's a tough call for the board as to how to perceive the verdict," the member told ESPNcricinfo. "The board will take as much time as it takes before arriving at a conclusion."

The insider added that the major bone of contention from the court's perspective was the lack of provision for an enquiry committee in the then BCCI constitution. "Such a provision was added during an amendment to the constitution after the match-fixing episode."

In 2000, after the Central Bureau of Investigation, India's central investigative agency, exposed the nexus between some of the high-profile cricketers, including Azharuddin, and bookies. It resulted in former South Africa captain Hansie Cronje being banned for life. The BCCI also acted swiftly and on the basis of the CBI report and an inquiry conducted by K Madhavan, it banned Azharuddin and former Test player Ajay Sharma for life, while imposed a five-year ban on two other Test cricketers - Ajay Jadeja and Manoj Prabhakar - besides physiotherapist Ali Irani.

While Jadeja returned to first-class cricket after the Delhi High Court quashed the ban in January 2003, Azharuddin has been fighting the case for over a decade. It remains to be seen if the BCCI decides to appeal against the high court verdict in the Supreme Court, India's apex court.

Meanwhile, hours after Thursday's working committee meeting, Azharuddin, now a member of parliament of the ruling Congress party, made an appearance at the annual BCCI awards after a gap of six years. Though he clarified that he had been getting invites all these years and he couldn't attend the function due to other commitments, his presence suggested that he could have met some of the top brass of the BCCI.

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by Nampally on (November 23, 2012, 20:38 GMT)

BCCI cannot overrule the A.P. High Court's decision. If they do they will be charged with contempt of the court. They can appeal to Supreme court & after that they have no more options. But in majority of the cases, High court decisions are of a pretty high standards & Supreme court will generally support it. So BCCI shoud think twice before lashing out some of its money for an expensive appeal. Also it is better for BCCI to focus on the tasks ahead of them in getting the game of Cricket the funding support it needs rather than think that their decisions are always sound even when High court overrules it!.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Country Fixtures Country Results
Group A: Baroda v J + K at Vadodara - Dec 21-24
J + K 497 Baroda 156/1
Group B: Delhi v Rajasthan at Delhi - Dec 21-24
Rajasthan 141 Delhi 201/3
Group C: Goa v H. Pradesh at Porvorim - Dec 21-24
Goa 357 H. Pradesh 172/3
Group B: Haryana v Vidarbha at Rohtak - Dec 21-24
Vidarbha 154 Haryana 60/2
Group C: Jharkhand v Tripura at Dhanbad - Dec 21-24
Jharkhand 142 Tripura 285/6
Group C: Kerala v Hyderabad at Wayanad - Dec 21-24
Hyderabad 270 Kerala 179/6
Group B: Maharashtra v Punjab at Pune - Dec 21-24
Maharashtra 210 Punjab 391
Group A: Railways v Karnataka at Delhi - Dec 21-24
Karnataka 247 Railways 105/4
Group B: Saurashtra v Gujarat at Rajkot - Dec 21-24
Saurashtra 207 & 34/1 Gujarat 248
Group C: Services v Andhra at Delhi - Dec 21-24
Andhra 234 Services 53/1
Group A: Tamil Nadu v M. Pradesh at Chennai - Dec 21-24
M. Pradesh 432 Tamil Nadu 157/5
Group A: U. Pradesh v Mumbai at Kanpur - Dec 21-24
U. Pradesh 206 Mumbai 42/3
Complete fixtures » | Download Fixtures »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days