Wisden Asia Cricket

Six of the best

How does India's top and middle order compare to the great line-ups from the past

David Frith

February 2, 2004

Text size: A | A

VVS Laxman, Sachin Tendulkar and Rahul Dravid: are they part of the greatest top six ever?

As India handsomely worked their way to a record score, spoiling Steve Waugh's farewell Test match in the process, it dawned on some of us that this might be as strong a top six in the batting order as ever visited Australia - or perhaps even as strong a top six as the world has seen.

At first it seemed a slightly far-fetched conjecture. However, we are here not just talking about a top three (Hobbs, Sutcliffe, Hammond, or Barnes, Morris, Bradman, or Greenidge, Haynes, Richards) but a complete specialist batting order, No.1 to No.6. The manner in which this Indian side toyed with the bowling of the world champions (who helped by grassing 15 catches in the four Tests) suggests that it deserves a very high rating indeed. Australia were admittedly without Glenn McGrath and Shane Warne, but the legspinner's record against India (29 wickets at 55.44) has been moderate, while the injury-stricken McGrath is nearing the end of his prolific career. One of the startling achievements of this series was that India's highest individual scores at the four Test venues played have all just been raised (by Ganguly - 144 at Brisbane; Dravid - 233 at Adelaide; Sehwag - 195 at Melbourne; and Tendulkar - 241 not out at Sydney).

When one digs into the annals of Test cricket one finds, of course, several extremely impressive line-ups. Legendary England offspinner Jim Laker wondered what he had done to deserve a couple of days under a baking Caribbean sun, bowling on a shiny surface to Everton Weekes, Frank Worrell and Clyde Walcott. There have been few to match that West Indies line-up, which also featured the elegant Jeff Stollmeyer and solid Allan Rae opening the innings.

Think, too, of Australia's top orders - Victor Trumper, Reg Duff, Clem Hill, Joe Darling. Bill Woodfull, Bill Ponsford, Don Bradman, Stan McCabe. And more recently, Matt Hayden, Justin Langer, Ricky Ponting, Damien Martyn, and the Waughs.

Statistics can mean everything, or nothing. Pitch and weather conditions, opposition strength, freshness or fatigue, the luck of dropped catches, players just past their best or with their best still to come: mix all this into a computer and still there is only the next ball, which could be fatal, or be hit for four, or let go through to the keeper. What really counts is the inherent worth of a player. And in the case of these Indian batsmen, the high quality of Dravid, Tendulkar and Laxman is patently obvious.

It is preposterous to suggest that the Sehwag-Chopra partnership rates (as yet) anywhere near the likes of Hobbs and Sutcliffe, Greenidge and Haynes, Simpson and Lawry, and other pairings. But taken on recent evidence, their potential is quite apparent. I was particularly impressed with the way Chopra, in an inconsequential period of play near the end of the tour match in Hobart, fine-tuned his defensive armoury for over an hour before bothering to open his score. With great mental strength he cocooned himself exactly as Geoff Boycott or Sunil Gavaskar might have done.

Sourav Ganguly, Sachin Tendulkar and Virender Sehwag try another sport

We are not merely looking at an outstanding Indian top six. We are seeing a combination which may yet become even more formidable - abroad as well as at home. Australia may uncharacteristically have given India's batsmen many reprieves in the field, but what if Tendulkar had not been the victim of a bad lbw decision in the opening Test at Brisbane? He may have found his stride much sooner.

The best top six? How can it be proved, even by those confounded statistics? If that is to be the chosen means of deciding, then given another year or two Ganguly's current top six may erase all doubts. I saw the signs on India's last tour of England. Dravid and Ganguly, the young newcomers who had taken Lord's by storm in 1996, were now fully developed. And I recall with great pleasure Tendulkar's maiden Test hundred, at Old Trafford so many years ago. Then, he had the voice of a child and the batting technique of a veteran. He is now comfortably assured of immortality in cricket terms and is recognised as the nearest thing to Bradman since The Great One hung up his bat.

For my money VVS is the most pleasing to watch. Then, controlling the middle order, comes Ganguly, with his penchant for taking the ball on the helmet and for displaying an aloofness that would have delighted England's Golden Age aristocrat AC MacLaren. Of the six, Sehwag is the most daring and unpredictable, and therefore exciting. And then there is "Boycott" Chopra.

Some six. Maybe as good as any in the past. I don't really care. They were simply wonderful to watch in this Australian summer, when the balance of power began to shift.

David Frith was editor of Wisden Cricket Monthly from 1979 to 1996.

This article was first published in the February 2004 issue of Wisden Asia Cricket. Click here for further details.

© Wisden Asia Cricket

Email Feedback Print
Related Links

Walking up the down escalator

2014 in review: Player strikes, defeats against fellow minnows, and mountains of debt for the board marked another grim year for Zimbabwe

    The first Boxing Day classic

Ashley Mallett: Nearly 150 years ago, the MCG saw the start of a much-loved tradition, with a match starring Aboriginal players

Hangovers and headaches

2014 in review: Embarrassing defeats, a beleaguered captain, a bitter former star, alienating administrators - England's year was gloomy. By George Dobell

Ten years later

Gallery: Efforts by Surrey have helped transform a coastal village in Sri Lanka devastated by the December 26 tsunami

Going for glory and falling just short

Anantha Narayanan: An anecdotal account of close finishes similar to the recent Adelaide Test

News | Features Last 7 days

Watson's merry-go-round decade

In January 2005, Shane Watson made his Test debut. What does he have to show for a decade in the game?

Power to Smithy, trouble for Dhoni

Australia's new captain admirably turned things around for his side in Brisbane, leading in more departments than one

Why punish the West Indies players when the administration is to blame?

As ever, the West Indies board has taken the short-term view and removed supposedly troublesome players instead of recognising its own incompetence

Gilchrist's conscientious moment

In the semi-final against Sri Lanka in 2003, Adam Gilchrist walked back to the pavilion despite being given not out by the on-field umpire

Australia's 50-50 lifelines

Three Australia players made half-centuries on day one at the MCG; for each of them, the innings' meant different things

News | Features Last 7 days