India XI
ESPNcricinfo picks the best Test teams of all time


Two skills, four men

In Indian cricket, the term allrounder has often been used with a disclaimer. But not for these players

Suresh Menon

August 17, 2010

Comments: 167 | Text size: A | A

Vinoo Mankad batting against England on India's 1946 tour
Vinoo Mankad: The quickest to 1000 runs and 100 wickets till Ian Botham broke the record © Wisden
Related Links

The true allrounder comprises two roughly equal halves. Specifically, he ought to be able to make a century and claim five wickets. Indian allrounders, with few exceptions, have had their skills in somewhat different proportions, sometimes a third and two-thirds making up the whole, or a quarter and three quarters.

The smaller fraction has often enabled those deemed allrounders to make it to the national side ahead of specialists. The bits-and-pieces allrounders sometimes switched roles - becoming batsmen when they were expected to be bowlers and vice versa. Often the term allrounder in Indian cricket has had to appear within inverted commas to denote embarrassment.

This was partly political. For years a top-class offspinner like Venkataraghavan was passed off as an "allrounder" to give him a more impressive CV than his rival Erapalli Prasanna. It suited the powers that controlled Indian cricket then. At other times it was merely about convenience or desperation. Suru Nayak went on a tour of England in 1982 as a mystery cricketer - was he batsman or bowler? - and returned with the mystery unsolved. Sachin Tendulkar is probably a better allrounder than many who played within those inverted commas.

Many have had dual personalities, as it were. Roger Binny, for example, opened the batting for Karnataka and scored a double-century in a 451-run partnership, but in international cricket he was a medium-pacer. Chandu Sarwate went to England as a spinner but was an opening batsman against Bradman's Australians. Wicketkeeper Budhi Kunderan opened India's bowling after telling his skipper, who asked him what kind of bowler he was: "I'll have to bowl to find out."

Lala Amarnath, India's first centurion, also opened the bowling, once dismissing Denis Compton first ball. He also kept wicket as substitute and finished with five victims. His bowling (off the wrong foot after just a few paces) improved as his batting declined in the latter part of his career, justifying the call made by many players to have more than one arrow in their quiver to extend their careers.

Amarnath was, in fact, the first Indian allrounder to claim five in an innings and score a half-century in the same Test, at Lord's in 1946. Amar Singh had come close a little over a decade earlier, with his 7 for 86 and a second-innings 48 in the Madras Test against England.

The candidates

Kapil Dev
Quite the most remarkable thing about him - apart from his 5248 runs and 434 wickets - was how he kept himself fit over 131 Tests without missing one through injury. A natural athlete, he brought to the game a sense of joy that communicated itself to those watching. With the last man at the crease, he once hit four sixes in a row to avert the follow-on. In the land of spinners, he led the medium-pacer revolution.

Dattu Phadkar
To those who worshipped him on the Kolkata maidans, he was not so much a prototype of Kapil Dev as the original from which a lesser version emerged. Phadkar was not only a fine medium-pacer, he was one of the finest players of medium pace in the team. A century against Bradman's Australia gave him a series average of 52. His eight wickets included those of Bradman, Morris and Miller.

Vinoo Mankad
Was the quickest to the double till Ian Botham broke the record. Held the record of India's highest individual score and most wickets in an innings, extending that to most in career till a new generation of spinners took over. At Lord's in 1952 he scored 72 and 184 and claimed 5 for 196 in the first innings, bowling 97 overs in the match.

Manoj Prabhakar
One Test century and 96 wickets in 39 Tests do not tell the story of Prabhakar's value to the team. The first Indian medium-pacer to master reverse swing during a tour of Pakistan, he made up in variation what he lacked in pace. He opened the batting too, making 95 in a Test in New Zealand from that position.

We'll be publishing an all-time India XI based on readers' votes to go with our jury's XI. To pick your allrounder click here

Suresh Menon is a writer based in Bangalore

RSS Feeds: Suresh Menon

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by   on (August 20, 2010, 23:09 GMT)

Sehwag, Sunny, Dravid, Sachin, Laxman, Kapil, Dhoni, Kumble, Bedi, Srinath, Binny

Posted by   on (August 20, 2010, 17:10 GMT)

Kapil Dev absolutely. This was no brainer.................. I genuinely think that Ravi shastri should have been picked ahead of Manoj Prabhakar. I found some1 suggesting Ravindra Jadeja's name.......... lol Ravindra Jadeja havent played a single test match till date, how can you suggest his name for India's All time great XI?

Posted by kushur on (August 20, 2010, 12:19 GMT)

yeah, how come Manioj Prabhakar can be nominated aheda of Ravi Shashtri?? Though not to suggest that Ravi Shastri a deserving candidate for all time XI, but miles ahead of Prabhakar..

Posted by RayShaumik on (August 19, 2010, 18:16 GMT)

TO Featherbed_Champ

Very well said.... I absolutely agree with every word you said. from the current generation batsmen ONLY SACHIN and DRAVID and maybe Sehwag should be in the batting order. THERE IS NO PLACE FOR ANYONE ELSE... Gavaskar, Amarnath, Viswhawant,Hazare should make up the rest ....

Posted by   on (August 19, 2010, 16:59 GMT)

No discussion on this, Kapil dev, and I want to say something regarding choices for allrounder. Its a shmae for Indian Cricket that the name of Manoj Prabhakar is mentioned in this list ahead of many others better than him???????

Posted by buntyj on (August 19, 2010, 16:18 GMT)

as for mentions apart from baloo i believe spinners vv kumar, shivalkar, goel, kanwaljit singh, kripal singh rate a mention and pacers shute banerjee n t a shekar all of whom were unlucky not to play tests or played too few tests, n batsman d b deodhar

Posted by buntyj on (August 19, 2010, 16:14 GMT)

batting- after double checking viru's record on the few not so flat decks he played on i could agree to risk viru in place of merchant as opener instead of mid order if the fact that both sunny and viru (superstition?) prefer to bat at no 1 and not at no 2 is reconciled; in that case a mid order position opens up in my xi and i could accept any 1 of merchant, hazare or vvs at no 3 - vvs having the safest pair of hands close in of the 3, none of the 3 was a good fielder in the deep) with jimmy amarnath shifting to no 5; i stick to kapil as the all rounder, sunny n sachin as certainties and nissar n amar singh as the 2 other opening bowlers and engineer as wicketkeeper.

Posted by buntyj on (August 19, 2010, 16:05 GMT)

the only certainties are sunny, sachin n kapil; if we select the 2 spinners with the best away records it would be chandra n gupte- which is possible as they were very different types of leggies; but gupte had only 3 away series (of which pakistan was on matting wickets); while i've no doubt personally that he was by far the best traditional leggie produced by india and 1 of the all time best anywhere with warne oreilly etc i am not sure if his away record is sufficiently representative- and india didnt win an away test in his time; bedi adds variety, made a good pair with chandra, took a 5 for almost every country he toured (10 for in narrow loss at spinners grave perth 77) was a success at county level and was selected (with gavaskar n engineer for the 71-72 world xi tour of oz; earlier pataudi was -a bit lucky- selected for the world xi tour of england in 65); but i could accept gupte as the 2nd spinner (chandra 1st) ahead of bedi;

Posted by Bhavyang29 on (August 19, 2010, 10:51 GMT)

I certainly think so Kapil Dev is the best all rounder India has ever produced. How can you put Manoj Prabhakar ahead of Ravi Shashtri? Apart from his batting , bowlong and fielding skills he posees a very good cricketing brain which is very useful for a captain in tight situations.

Posted by sanj1981 on (August 19, 2010, 10:37 GMT)

how about Ravindra Jadeja? top all rounder............

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Suresh MenonClose
Suresh Menon Suresh Menon went from being a promising cricketer to a has-been, without the intervening period of a major career. He played league cricket in three cities with a group of overgrown enthusiasts who had the reverse of amnesia - they could remember things that never happened. For example, taking incredible catches at slip, or scoring centuries. Somehow Menon found the time to be the sports editor of the Pioneer and the Indian Express in New Delhi, Gulf News in Dubai, and the editor of the New Indian Express in Chennai. Currently he is a columnist with publications in India and abroad, and is beginning to think he might never play for India.

India Jury

Sambit Bal
Sambit Bal
Editor, Cricinfo
XI: Gavaskar, Sehwag, Dravid, Tendulkar, Mohinder Amarnath, Mankad, Kapil Dev, Dhoni, Srinath, Anil Kumble, Prasanna
Harsha Bhogle
Harsha Bhogle
Cricket commentator, presenter and writer. Has covered nearly 100 Tests and over 400 ODIs
XI: Gavaskar, Sehwag, Dravid, Tendulkar, Viswanath, Umrigar, Mankad, Kapil Dev, Kirmani, Kumble, Srinath
Ramachandra Guha
Ramachandra Guha
Historian and cricket writer. Author of A Corner of a Foreign Field, Wickets in the East, Spin and Other Turns, and editor of the Picador Book of Cricket
XI: Gavaskar, Sehwag, Dravid, Tendulkar, CK Nayudu, Mankad, Kapil Dev, Kirmani, Kumble, Prasanna, Nissar
Arun Lal
Arun Lal
Played 16 Tests and 13 ODIs for India between 1982 and 1989. Currently a cricket commentator
XI: Gavaskar, Sehwag, Dravid, Tendulkar, Hazare, Dhoni, Kapil Dev, Mankad, Lala Amarnath, Kumble, Srinath
Pradeep Magazine
Pradeep Magazine
Has written on cricket for the last three decades for various Indian newspapers. Author of the book Not Quite Cricket. Currently advisor, sports with the Hindustan Times
XI: Gavaskar, Sehwag, Dravid, Tendulkar, Mohinder Amarnath, Mankad, Kapil Dev, Kirmani, Kumble, Srinath, Prasanna
Sanjay Manjrekar
Sanjay Manjrekar
Played 37 Tests and 74 ODIs for India between 1987 and 1996. Now a cricket commentator and presenter for ESPN Star
XI: Sehwag, Gavaskar, Dravid, Tendulkar, Hazare, Mankad, Dhoni, Kapil Dev, Prasanna, Gupte, Srinath
Ayaz Memon
Ayaz Memon
Sportswriter for 30 years. Former editor of Sportsweek and former sports editor of the Independent and the Times of India. Has covered over 100 Tests, more than 250 ODIs, and six World Cups
XI: Gavaskar, Sehwag, Dravid, Tendulkar, Hazare, Mankad, Kapil Dev, Dhoni, Kumble, Zaheer, Nissar
Suresh Menon
Suresh Menon
Former sports editor of the Pioneer and the Indian Express in New Delhi, Gulf News in Dubai, and former editor of the New Indian Express in Chennai. Currently a columnist with publications in India and abroad
XI: Gavaskar, Sehwag, Dravid, Tendulkar, Hazare, Mankad, Kapil Dev, Dhoni, Srinath, Prasanna, Kumble
R Mohan
R Mohan
Resident Editor of the Deccan Chronicle, Chennai. Formerly cricket correspondent of the Hindu and The Sportstar for nearly two decades. Has reported live close to 150 Test matches and more than 300 ODIs, including five World Cups.
XI: Gavaskar, Sehwag, Merchant, Tendulkar, Hazare, Kapil Dev, Dhoni, Mankad, Srinath, Kumble, Prasanna
Vasu Paranjape
Former Mumbai and Baroda player, and former coach of Mumbai and of the National Cricket Academy
XI: Gavaskar, Merchant, Tendulkar, Hazare, MAK Pataudi, Phadkar, Kapil Dev, Mankad, Tamhane, Gupte, Prasanna
Sharda Ugra
Sharda Ugra
Senior editor, Cricinfo. Cricket writer for two decades with Mid-Day, the Hindu and India Today magazine
XI: Gavaskar, Sehwag, Dravid, Tendulkar, Laxman, Mankad, Dhoni, Kapil Dev, Kumble, Srinath, Zaheer