Essays, reflections and more

A spinner's flight plan

The great spinners visualised their wickets and deceived the batsmen in the air. But why are today's bowling coaches almost always fast men?

Ashley Mallett

July 24, 2011

Comments: 23 | Text size: A | A

Clarrie Grimmett bowls, February 5, 1937
Clarrie Grimmett stressed the need to spin on a trajectory just above the eye line of the batsman so he's unsure of where the ball will bounce © PA Photos
Related Links

In my first over in Test cricket, to Colin Cowdrey at The Oval in August 1968, I appealed for lbw decisions for the first four balls. The fifth ball was the decider. Cowdrey went well back and the ball cannoned into his pads halfway up middle stump. Umpire Charlie Elliott raised his index finger, and "Kipper" touched the peak of his England cap and said to me, "Well bowled, master."

In hindsight Cowdrey was a pretty good wicket, given that he had conquered the spin of Sonny Ramadhin and Alf Valentine at a time when I was trying to track down an ice-cold Paddle Pop in Perth.

Test cricket is the ultimate challenge for the spin bowler. Sadly Twenty20s and ODIs bring mug spinners to the fore. They skip through their overs and bowl "dot" balls, which their legion of hangers-on believe to be something akin to heaven. Test spinners are all about getting people out. After all, the best way to cut the run rate is to take wickets.

Before getting into big cricket I felt the need to have a coaching session with Clarrie Grimmett. I was 21, living in Perth, and Clarrie, a sprightly 76, was based in Adelaide. To my mind a spinner cannot be doing things all that brilliantly if he thinks he is a pretty good bowler but doesn't get many wickets. That was my lot, and I sought Clarrie's advice. Two days in the train from Perth to Adelaide, then a short bus ride to the suburb of Firle, found Clarrie at home. He was up the top of an ancient pepper tree.

There he had hung a ball in a stocking. He handed me a Jack Hobbs-autographed bat, and having dismissed my protestations that I wanted to learn spin bowling, not batting, he said with a broad grin: "Well, son, there was a youngster I taught to play the square cut on the voyage to England in 1930 and… Don Bradman was a fast learner."

Clarrie swung one ball towards me and I met it in the middle of his bat. We then went to the nets. Clarrie had a full-sized turf wicket in his backyard. He wandered to the batting end. He wore no protective equipment - no box, no pads or gloves. Just his Jack Hobbs bat. "Bowl up, son," he cried.

My first ball met the middle of his bat. He called me down the track. "Son," he said, "Give up bowling and become a batsman… I could play you blindfolded."

As it happened I had a handkerchief in my pocket. He put that over his horn-rimmed glasses and my second ball met the middle of his bat. When he had stopped laughing he proceeded to give me the best possible lesson on spin bowling. He talked about spinning on a trajectory just above the eye line of the batsman.

Eighteen months later I was playing a Test match in India. The Nawab of Pataudi was facing, and while he was not smashing my bowling all over the park, he was clearly in control. I had to find a way to arrest the situation, so I thought of Grimmett and the necessity of getting the ball to dip acutely from just above the eye line.

It worked. The dipping flight fooled him to the extent that he wasn't sure exactly where the ball would bounce. Pataudi pushed forward in hope rather than conviction, and within four balls Ian Chappell had grabbed another bat-pad chance at forward short leg.

A spinner needs a plan to get wickets at the top level. Even a bad plan is better than no plan at all, but it is not about reinventing the wheel.

Grimmett had many a plan. He told me that he often saw the image of a batsman he was about to dismiss in his mind's eye. When the wicket fell, he was nonchalant, for this was the action replay. Nowadays visualisation is an official part of cricket coaching.

The key to spin bowling is how the ball arrives. If the ball is spun hard and the bowler gets lots of energy up and over his braced front leg, he will achieve a dipping flight path that starts just above the eye line and drops quickly.

Grimmett firmly believed, as does Shane Warne, that a batsman had to be deceived in the air. Warne's strategy at the start of a spell was to bowl his fiercely spun stock legbreak with subtle changes of pace. Similarly my idea was to stay in the attack. There is nothing worse for a bowler than to go for 10 or 12 runs in his first over. Psychologically you are then playing catch-up to make your figures look reasonable.

If a spinner doesn't plan he doesn't change his pace and thus does not break the rhythm of the batsman. It is crucial to a Test spin bowler's success that he attacks with subtle changes of pace

As an offspinner I found if my off-side field was in order the rest fell into place. My basic plan against a right-hander was to have the ball arriving in a dangerous manner: spin hard and drive up and over the braced front leg. And I wanted to lure the batsman into trying to hit to the off side, against the spin, to look at the huge gap between point and my very straight short cover. When a batsman hit against the spin and was done in flight, the spin would take the ball to the on side - a potential catch to bat-pad or short midwicket. Sometimes this plan doesn't work - the batsman might be clean-bowled, or if the ball skipped on straight, caught at slip, or it would cannon into his front pad for no result.

If a spinner doesn't plan he doesn't change his pace and thus does not break the rhythm of the batsman. It is crucial to a Test spin bowler's success that he attacks with subtle changes of pace.

I had played 10 Test matches and taken 46 wickets when Bob Simpson, the former Australia opening batsman and Test captain, sidled up to me and said: "You need a straight one."

I eyeballed Bob and said that some of my offbreaks went dead straight and "they don't pick them". He went on to say that I needed a ball that, to all intent and purpose, looked as if it would turn from the off but would skip off straight. I could "bowl" what they call a doosra today, but when I played, offspinners did not have ICC carte blanche to throw the ball. I felt it was wrong to throw, so I discarded the whole thing.

In Tests a batsman is challenged by pace and spin. My aim was to take 100 Test wickets in 20 Tests. But I got there in my 23rd - the same as Shane Warne, Glenn McGrath and Garth McKenzie - after which circumstances changed. Dennis Lillee and Jeff Thomson joined forces, and man, you tried to grab a wicket anyhow while those two were on the hunt. My next 15 Tests brought little in way of wickets, but my experience helped me in a coaching sense. I knew how unloved and untried spinners felt.

Somehow the cricket world brought forth a bunch of national coaches who didn't know the difference between an offbreak and a toothpick. Some were celebrated ones, like South Africa's Bob Woolmer. His idea of combating spin was ludicrous. He had blokes trying to hit sixes against Shane Warne's legspin. As splendid as he was against any opposition, no wonder Warne excelled against Woolmer-coached sides.

It is amazing that all national sides pick ex-fast bowlers as their bowling coaches. At least in England, Andy Flower, easily the best coach in world cricket, recognises the role of the spin coach. Mushtaq Ahmed, the former Pakistan legspinner, teams with David Saker, the fast-bowling coach, to help the England bowlers.

For years Australia have floundered in the spin department. Troy Cooley, the bowling coach, is a fast-bowling man, not one for spin. Australia has suffered; a lot of the blame can be attributed to the stupid stuff going on at the so-called Centre of Excellence in Brisbane.

Australia have had three great spinners: Grimmett, Bill O'Reilly and Warne. If Grimmett had played 145 Tests, the same as Warne, he would have taken 870 wickets. Different eras, of course, but you get the idea of how good Grimmett was. However, the best offie I ever saw - by a mile - was the little Indian Erapalli Prasanna. Now there was a bowler.

Offspinner Ashley Mallett played 38 Tests for Australia

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by ygkd on (July 27, 2011, 9:58 GMT)

Spinners spinning the ball? That's so last century! Drift? Isn't that what betting-odds do? Eye-line? Isn't that where a player focuses on his endorsement during an ad-shoot? Bracing your leg? Is that perchance a catwalk pose? Flight? Is that what you get on to go to the IPL? Planning? Now, I know this one - that's what your financial agent does for you with all the money you make dropping it on a spot, quickly, before anyone realises how rubbish you are and remembers how honest toilers like Peter Taylor were so much better in years gone by. Oh, and yes, one Ashley Mallett too.

Posted by BillyCC on (July 25, 2011, 21:49 GMT)

This is an excellent article. I especially like Mallett's dismissal of current T20 and ODI specialist spinners. Bowlers such as Botha, Hauritz, Harbhajan, Mendis etc. are kidding themselves and all have terrible Test records. And to all those Murali fans out there, stop complaining. Half the cricketing world believes Murali chucks and so that is why he is not rated the greatest by everyone's standards.

Posted by Markus971 on (July 25, 2011, 5:20 GMT)

When saying pace, I meant a change of pace, oooh & he was an Off-Spinner!

Posted by Markus971 on (July 25, 2011, 5:17 GMT)

I like your writings, generally they are mostly unbiased & knowledgeable. Although our views are, knowingly or not, influenced from our experiences & in this case 1st hand, from the 'Gnome' himself. In so, I believe Mr.A.Mallett, you missed a pre-war Great in your summation. H.Trumble should be included! & I think, perhaps in front of C.Grimmett. Remember the views of C.Grimmetts career are divided, both with his contemporaries & those in retrospect. G.Armstrong left him out of his top 100 (A.Mailey was preferred) & I think A.Narayanan has him at no.1... Anyway H.Trumble had spin, flight, pace & bounce!!

Posted by CricSamraat on (July 25, 2011, 2:41 GMT)

Prasanna vs Harbhajan: Harbhajan needs to reinvent himself, otherwise, his days as a stock Indian spinner can be counted on fingers. With immense exposure of test cricket Harbhajan has had, he should have been an offspinner. Unfortunately, Harbhajan looks like a spinner who is taken lightly by almost any batsman he bowls against. Prasnnas guiles spread fear in the hearts of even the greatest batsmen at the time. What a sharp contrast! Where is that spinner Erapalli Prasanna? Why is Indian Cricket Establishment not begging services of spin legends like Prasanna, Bedi, Chandrsekhar and Venkatraghvan? What a terrible waste!!!

Posted by CricSamraat on (July 25, 2011, 2:29 GMT)

I remember Ashley Mallett as an effective offspinner. Good grace, he mentioned Erapalli Prasanna. I remember Prasanna as a great offspinner. Legendary Prasanna and legendary legspinner Bishen Singh Bedi worked as a lethal duo. Every team was terribly afraid of facing this duo. To top it all, S. Chandrasekhar, another legendary legspinner, added third leg to this duo. Then, another legendary offspinner Venkatraghvan emerged on the scene. Indian bowling attack basically consisted of these spinners - there was hardly any pace attack of note on the Indian side those heady days for Indian spinners. What a golden age that was! I do not know what has been going on with Harbhajan Singh. He does not seem to induce any fear in any batsman's heart these days - Graeme Swan seems to be far more intimidating and effective than Harbhajan Singh. India needs to rediscover world-beating spinners once again.

Posted by   on (July 25, 2011, 2:27 GMT)

good article mate, well written and better thought out than most. Will pass onto my spinning mates here in Peru

Posted by   on (July 24, 2011, 22:43 GMT)

Wonderful article, informative and entertaining! "When I played, offspinners did not have ICC carte blanche to throw the ball", how very true but there is no need to introduce this fact into the discussion about who the three greatest Test spinners were. Bradman says O'Reilly and Grimmett, which leaves us to fill in a third. Statistics, especially if you exclude home tests, prove conclusively that Warne is the superior of the two modern contenders. But oh to be able to watch Bedi, Chandrasekhar, Venkatarahvan and Prasanna again!

Posted by   on (July 24, 2011, 21:49 GMT)

Recently bhajji claimed that he would add anothr 400wickets to his tally by the time he retires. But after watching his horrendous show at Lord's i am really afraid that can he even take anothr 40wickets. He even bowled flatter ones from round the stump when ian bell started his innings. What a shame!!!! He must take some steps to get back to his wicket taking best. So asking anyone may b prasanna ,venkata r evn murali for help is a good idea for him.Recently bhajji claimed that he would add anothr 400wickets to his tally by the time he retires. But after watching his horrendous show at Lord's i am really afraid that can he even take anothr 40wickets. He even bowled flatter ones from round the stump when ian bell started his innings. What a shame!!!! He must take some steps to get back to his wicket taking best. So asking anyone may b prasanna ,venkata r evn murali for help is a good idea for him.

Posted by MENDIS_Forever on (July 24, 2011, 19:43 GMT)

Mr .....WHO? Malit or is it Mallet? sorry sir .. I don't remember anyone in the history of spin bowling.sorry...

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print

    Ronchi's blitz, and remarkable ODI recoveries

Ask Steven: Also, the fastest ODI 150s, and the highest Test totals without a half-century

    Penalty runs the best punishment for slow over rates

Ashley Mallett: Fines and suspensions have had no effect. Awarding the opposition runs for every over a team falls short in a Test innings will definitely bite harder

    Pietersen stars in his own muppet show

David Hopps: KP's rubbishing of many aspiring English county professionals brings to mind the belief of Miss Piggy that "there is no one in the world to compare with moi"

    How to construct an ODI chase

Michael Bevan: Focus on targets smaller than winning the match, and back your tailenders to deliver for you

The many crickets of an Indian boyhood

Sankaran Krishna: Growing up in India, you play a number of varieties of the game, each developing a certain skill

News | Features Last 7 days

Kohli at No. 4 - defensive or practical?

It seems Virat Kohli is to not bat before the 12th or 13th over to strengthen the middle and the lower middle order. It suggests a lack of confidence in what was supposed to be India's strength in their title defence: their batting

Open with Rohit and Binny, with Kohli at No. 3

India's batting is going the way of their bowling in Australia, and they need get their order sorted before the World Cup

Off-stump blues leave Dhawan flailing

The out-of-form Shikhar Dhawan still has the backing of his captain, but there's no denying his slump has arrived at an inconvenient time for India and his technical issues have to be sorted out before they attempt to defend the World Cup

On TV it looks uglier than it actually is

Often reasonable arguments on the field look nasty beyond the boundary and on camera

'Teams can't have set formula' - Dravid

In the first episode of Contenders, a special ten-part buildup to the 2015 World Cup, Rahul Dravid and Graeme Smith discuss the impact of local conditions on team compositions and the issues surrounding the format of the tournament

News | Features Last 7 days