Features FeaturesRSS FeedFeeds

Firdose Moonda

South Africa seek to fill Kallis-sized hole

A player of his magnitude cannot exactly be replaced, but South Africa have options to help them rejig their line-up

Firdose Moonda

January 13, 2014

Comments: 95 | Text size: A | A

AB de Villiers and Faf du Plessis put on 205 for the fifth wicket, South Africa v India, 1st Test, Johannesburg, 5th day, December 22, 2013
AB de Villiers and Faf du Plessis are the two leading candidates for the No. 4 slot © Getty Images
Enlarge

For the first time in 18 years, South Africa's selectors will have to pick a Test squad without one of its certainties. Jacques Kallis' retirement has left a gap many have said will be impossible to fill.

While it's understood a player of his magnitude cannot be replaced, South Africa have to, as Shaun Pollock said, find a way to move forward without him as quickly as possible. They have a lot to ponder as they search for a new strategy in the post-Kallis era.

The first consideration is the No. 4 spot. For years, it was thought AB de Villiers was being groomed for that role. De Villiers is the most outrageously talented and adaptable batsman in South Africa's line-up and is capable of switching between the two most important roles in that position: he scores runs under pressure (like at Headingley 2008, and in Hamilton 2012 and Johannesburg 2013) and is the best person to have on hand when there is a platform to take off from (Perth 2012 being a standout illustration).

But de Villiers is not an automatic pick for No. 4 because he is already heavily burdened. He keeps wicket and is also the team's vice-captain; there's also a strong chance he will eventually succeed Graeme Smith, and though that is not imminent, it is something to bear in mind for the long term.

That's why Faf du Plessis is likely to fill the No. 4 spot. Du Plessis' batting style is similar to de Villiers' in that he understands when to attack and when to defend, and has the skills for both. Batting is his only responsibility, although he is also expected to take Kodak-moment catches, so he is a good pick for the crucial role.

Du Plessis also prefers to bat higher up and has openly said so on several occasions. In his 11-Test career, he has already been pushed up three times. The first was against Pakistan in Cape Town last February, when he came in ahead of Kallis, with South Africa in trouble at 50 for 2. The second was in the next match, in Centurion, when Kallis sat out because of injury, and the third, and most telling, was against India in Johannesburg in December 2013.

In that last match Kallis had bowled more than his quota of overs and the team management wanted to give him an extra night's rest. South Africa needed a consolidator and du Plessis was trusted with the job. His century, crafted with patience, took them to the brink of a historic win. It was a performance that underlined his claim to be slotted in at No. 4.

Because Kallis' place in the batting line-up is likely to be occupied by one of de Villiers or du Plessis, the change to the XI will have to happen lower down, at No. 7. That spot has been occupied by an extra specialist batsman since Mark Boucher's retirement in July 2012, and South Africa have always said it is a berth they would like to use creatively, which suggests some experimentation could be in order.

Without Kallis, the only way they can keep a specialist batsman in that position is if JP Duminy becomes their premier allrounder. That would mean forsaking the specialist spinner, a role that has yo-yoed between Imran Tahir and Robin Peterson, though neither has taken ownership of the spot, and tasking Duminy with filling that role in order to include another seamer and maintain the side's balance.

 
 
Du Plessis' batting style is similar to de Villiers' in that he understands when to attack and when to defend. Batting is his only responsibility, although he is also expected to take Kodak-moment catches, so he is a good pick for No. 4
 

Duminy's offspin has developed significantly. He has shown himself capable of holding up an end and he makes timely breakthroughs, but whether he is good enough to operate as the sole spinner is still a matter of debate. South Africa could try him out at home, where spin rarely plays a role, before deciding if he is a viable option for away Tests as well. In that case, Dean Elgar, who has been on the fringes and has played a handful of matches, would slot in as the additional batsmen. South Africa's XI would then look like this:

Smith, Petersen, Amla, du Plessis, de Villiers, Duminy, Elgar, Philander, Steyn, Morkel, extra seamer (Tsotsobe/Abbott/Kleinveldt).

Another, more likely, option for No. 7 is to slot in an allrounder. That person will be more of a bowling two-in-one, as opposed to Kallis, who was seen as a batting allrounder. Even though there appears to be a dearth of these rare cricketers around, South Africa have some options in that regard.

Ryan McLaren is first name that pops up. He established himself as the first-choice allrounder in the ODI team when Kallis was unavailable for bilateral series, and blossomed once given a regular run. McLaren has only played one Test, against England in 2010, but more than 100 first-class matches. He has a batting average of over 30, with three centuries and 20 fifties, and has taken 329 wickets at 25.47.

Wayne Parnell is the other option. After falling by the wayside, following an impressive start that included three Tests, he has made a full recovery from a serious groin injury, plays regularly for his franchise, and is performing well. Parnell has racked up two List A hundreds, has even opened the batting for the Warriors, and is in good form with the ball. So far in the 2013-14 season he has eight wickets at 12.75 from one match.

South Africa could also look for the allrounder within the group they already have, where three candidates emerge. Rory Kleinveldt is a regular member of the squad and someone who is considered front of the queue. Kleinveldt has scored one first-class hundred and nine fifties and has been one of the most consistent wicket-takers in the domestic game.

The other two options are already part of the team. Both Vernon Philander and Robin Peterson are capable of batting at No. 7. They have three Test fifties each and have batted South Africa out of difficult positions in the recent past - Philander at Lord's in August 2012, Peterson in Durban in December 2013.

If South Africa make use of one of them, they will have a free spot to toy with in the XI, which can be used for either an extra bowler or batsman. The team would look something like this, with the unallocated role able to move anywhere in the order:

Smith, Petersen, Amla, du Plessis, de Villiers, Duminy, No. 7, Philander, Peterson, Steyn, Morkel


Vernon Philander drives down the ground
Vernon Philander has shown he is capable of shoring up the batting from No. 7 © Associated Press
Enlarge

Mike Procter, the former convenor of selectors, who admits his panel "never thought of a team without Kallis", is in favour of this approach. He would use the gap to bring in a specialist wicketkeeper, because even though de Villiers' batting average has increased since he took over from Boucher, Procter thinks he is better off as a batsman only. "His batting will progress even more if he does not keep." Some may wonder how much better de Villiers can get but Procter believes he can score match-winning double-hundreds if freed from the gloves.

Should South Africa go this way, they will have to bring in one of the reserve glovemen - Thami Tsolekile or his Lions team-mate Quinton de Kock. Tsolekile is probably the first choice. His issue has also become political because of the lack of black African players in the team. South Africa's Test side has gone more than three years without a member of the country's biggest demographic group and it is understood CSA board members are pushing for Tsolekile's inclusion.

But there is a wave of public support for de Kock, who went from a promising youngster to proven international in the space of a week in which he scored three consecutive ODI hundreds against India. De Kock has played 19 first-class matches, averages 51.96, and has scored four centuries. He is only in his second season as a franchise cricketer and the selectors are wary of rushing him, as current convenor Andrew Hudson confirmed when the squad for India was announced. They also believe his glovework could do with some improvement. De Kock will definitely come into the picture in the future but the Australia series may be a little soon to expect his inclusion.

What all this highlights is that South Africa have options. There is depth, they have different players who offer different skills, and several capable candidates. Kallis' absence will require a rethinking of strategy, but that is not an insurmountable task. Nobody can fill in for the sun but if the stars band together in the correct combinations they can produce something that could be just as good.

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

RSS Feeds: Firdose Moonda

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by charles1968 on (January 16, 2014, 20:55 GMT)

Peterson is a good player. no doubt but not in the league of a really top class opener. de Kock can't open and keep in the longer format so he either bats 7 or doesn't play, Elgar at 7 but the aussies have already sorted him out the last time these two sides met.

Posted by   on (January 16, 2014, 14:14 GMT)

If I were Australia, I would be really happy to see Duminy, Mclaren and Robbie P batting at 6,7 and 8, all with batting averages of 30. Those averages are most probably in the low 20's if you exclude Zim, Bangladesh and NZ.

Posted by   on (January 15, 2014, 17:45 GMT)

King Kallis cant be replaced but S A should bring in decock and play mcleran in place of duminny but in spinning conditions thy shud play wth Tahir and peterson

Posted by JimmySA on (January 15, 2014, 10:14 GMT)

@Ralf Foley I agree with you completely. We should not be aiming to contain if we don't require that. We have more than capable fast bowlers to make any opposition sweat beneath their helmets. If you have a forth fast bowler, there will be sustained pressure leading to more breakthroughs.

Posted by BokkeForever on (January 14, 2014, 20:31 GMT)

I remember seeing Kallis play at Newlands for the Western Provance B side - I think he was just out of high school then. A mate of mine leant over to me and said "watch this boy bat - he's going to be a great". That was 20 years ago, how right he proved to be. No-one is ever going to replace King Kallis. Long live the King.

Posted by   on (January 14, 2014, 19:26 GMT)

Why play a spinner for the sake of it? The fast bowlers build up the pressure, and the spinner comes on and immediately releases it. This happens most times. Rather give Abbot another chance as the 4th bowler. He took a bundle of wickets in his one and only test. Let's play to our strength, which is fast bowling.

Duminy can play the holding role if needed. He spins the ball as much or little as Robbie P.

Posted by B.C.G on (January 14, 2014, 18:03 GMT)

Both the Peterson's may be unpopular,but they have made crucial contributions.At the WACA,Perth 2012,our top order was blown away by Starc & MITCH yeah the same demonic Mitch.Robbie held the fort with Faf & regained the initiative.He also saved the day against Ajmal & co. in CT.In the last series he conceded 3-4 runs per over v/s the world's best spin players unlike Tahir who gets belted on any non-Asian pitch for 6-8 rpo.And no don't say chuck the spinner,because to keep up with over rates,bring variation we do need one.JP is a useless batsman as well as a useless bowler.JP out,Mclaren or Van Zyl in.

The 12 should be: Smith, Petersen, Amla, du Plessis, de Villiers, Van Zyl, Peterson, Philander, McLaren, Steyn, Morkel.

Posted by   on (January 14, 2014, 17:13 GMT)

SA have many options to fill that one spot, i think it is fairly obvious to pick elgar at no 7 in asia because he is a part time spinner too, but parnell or McLaren are better options on fast pitches. other 10 members should be same,those who played against india last test. it is when a fast pitch has something for spinners too, but if there is nothing for spinners then it should be elgar instead of peterson(left arm spinner).

Posted by creebo777 on (January 14, 2014, 14:43 GMT)

alviro petersen always gets starts but never kicks on ..he doesnt even avrg 40

Posted by Xolile on (January 14, 2014, 14:36 GMT)

I feel sorry for Tsolekile. He had a good season in 2009/10 and in 20011/12 - but inbetween he averaged 25 and 29. As a result he was not asked to take over from Boucher. Now he is 33 years old and counting. Batsmen peak between 28 and 34. Time is not on Thami's side. Selecting him would be a mistake. I also feel sorry for Van Zyl. What more can he do? Every time Faf or Petersen gets close to getting dropped, they score a hundred. There are really very limited opportunities available for a potential Test specialist like Van Zyl. At 26 he is approaching his prime. He could be of great service to SA over the next 10 years.

Comments have now been closed for this article

FeedbackTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Firdose MoondaClose

    The cricket tragic who bowled Bradman

Former Australian PM Bob Hawke loved cricket. And he once left the Don speechless with the force of his political convictions

    'The worst thing about being a keeper is stinky hands'

Chris Read talks about how unprepared he was for Tests, and that slower ball from Chris Cairns

    Everybody deserves a second chance?

Switch Hit: Mark Butcher joins our team to discuss the new England coaches, KP, and a potential England XI

    England's Pietersen folly

Martin Crowe: Not getting rid of Kevin Pietersen after the texting saga in 2012 cost them greatly

Fizz, flight and loop

V Ramnarayan: Erapalli Prasanna was a masterful conjurer and perhaps the shrewdest of India's great spin quartet

News | Features Last 7 days

UAE all set to host lavish welcoming party

The controversy surrounding the IPL has done little to deter fans in UAE from flocking the stadiums, as they gear up to watch the Indian stars in action for the first time since 2006

The watch breaker, and Malinga specials

Plays of the day from the IPL match between Kolkata Knight Riders and Mumbai Indians in Abu Dhabi

The world record that nearly wasn't

Twenty years ago this week, Brian Lara became Test cricket's highest scorer, but he almost didn't make it

'Sri Lankan fans embrace the team, not just icon players'

Mahela Jayawardene and Kumar Sangakkara go over their World T20 win, and feel grateful to have fans whose support remains unwavering in victory and defeat

Crunch time for Sehwag and Gambhir

The former Indian openers haven't been shining lately, but the IPL presents an opportunity for them to show their class

News | Features Last 7 days