South Africa news March 4, 2014

'He was a youngster but he was a big man'

Three of Graeme Smith's former team-mates, Mark Boucher, Shaun Pollock and Jacques Kallis, remember a brash youngster growing into a statesmanlike captain and scoring a mountain of runs with a rough technqiue
14

#politeenquiries: Will Graeme Smith play for Ireland?

By the time he was 21, Graeme Smith had already done a lot of growing up. He had moved away from the city of his youth and his parent's home in Johannesburg and set himself up 1,400 kilometres away in Cape Town. He had a job as a professional cricketer at Western Province and he was making progress.

After a couple of seasons in the domestic set-up, he was earmarked for higher honours. A month after reaching the adulthood, he was picked to make his international debut. Against Australia. At Newlands.

Glenn McGrath was the first man to dismiss Smith at that level and the Australian seamer was not going to let him forget it. McGrath spent the rest of that series sledging Smith, who took it bravely but was slowly losing patience. He wanted to respond but was not quite sure how. So he asked some of the senior players, including mischief-maker Mark Boucher for some help.

"A couple of us mentioned something he could say back but we did it as a joke," Boucher said. "Graeme went out there and said it. He just came back to us and said he didn't think it went too well."

In a candid interview with the now-defunct South African Sports Illustrated magazine two months later Smith revealed he asked McGrath if he was "constantly on his period," in retaliation. It was exactly the kind of thing that would irritate McGrath and Boucher and co. knew it. They did not know Smith could be ballsy enough to repeat those words. "That was Graeme, he had the character to front up. He walked the walk," Boucher said.

Exactly a year, a month and a double hundred later, Smith was asked to walk a much thornier path. In the aftermath of the 2003 World Cup failure, South Africa wanted to work from a clean slate. "Graeme had a mature cricket brain and a real presence," Shaun Pollock, his predecessor said. "He was a youngster but he was a big man."

He also had a sharp tongue that he was not afraid to use. "People saw him as quite brash because he was a 22-year-old and making big statements and people would ask where the performance was to back that up," Pollock said. Smith had an answer for that too: twin double hundreds against England. From "whatshisname", as Nasser Hussain called him in a press conference, to having his name become headline, Smith had arrived.

Then he had to continue. Captaining in South Africa involved dealing with much more than just sport. A country fractured by segregation was only in its first decade of healing when Smith took over. Democracy was younger than him and a lot had to change to make the game inclusive. He had to understand that and he had to become part of the solution. "We are unique in this country. There are extra challenges that you have to deal with that other countries don't have to," Pollock said.

But there is also the small matter of winning. As a fiercely competitive nation, South Africa never accepted anything but victory and even when Smith racked some up, his failure to win a World Cup, for example, always haunted him and the team. "He is another South African sportsman who just didn't get the credit that he deserves," Jacques Kallis said. "A lot of our sportsmen are like that - rugby players, golfers. Maybe it is a South African thing that we like to keep our guys down on the ground or we like criticising."

Smith dealt with the public dislike and snide remarks for much of his career, which only started to soften when he won in England in 2008 and then won in Australia. That was where he really won hearts. By the time the team went there, they were wisened by memories of being beaten by Australia at home and away. He decided the best way to fight them was not to fight at all. At least, not publicly. "Graeme and Mickey said let's not try and upset the apple cart, let's go there humbly and not get involved in too much media stuff," Boucher said. It worked.

It was quite emotional for guys in the dressing-room. They realised what had happened on that tour. The Australian crowd had come to fall in love with a captain they actually hated. I've never seen it before
Mark Boucher remembers the reception Graeme Smith received in Sydney

South Africa concentrated on themselves and soon led the series 2-0. They stunned an Australian side that had not been beaten in their own backyard for 15 years and so they had earned respect.

Smith earned them a little more when he showed he too could adopt an Australian-style ruthlessness. Even though the series was won he walked out to bat with a broken hand to try and save the final Test. "South Africans and Australians love to hate each other," Boucher explained. "It was quite emotional for guys in the dressing-room. They realised what had happened on that tour. The Australian crowd had come to fall in love with a captain they actually hated. I've never seen it before."

On homecoming South Africa were hailed but then humbled when they lost to Australia in the return series. That was the last time Smith captained a team in a series defeat. It was 14 series ago - an incredible run that includes South Africa's rise to No.1 and another series win in Australia. Even just those two things in isolation would leave many wondering what there is left to achieve.

Smith has decided there is not anything. Combined with an accident to his young daughter and a lean patch personally, he has also decided it is not worth battling on to try and engineer something and Boucher can understand. "When Jacques wasn't quite up to it, his technique took over and he could still score runs. Graeme's technique is not as good as Jacques so he needs a bit of heart, a bit of passion and enthusiasm to get out there and dominate so his technique won't put into a situation when it was questioned.

"He probably woke up a couple of mornings ago and realised he was battling to get himself up for this challenge. When that happens he probably gets exposed a bit more than a guy who has a good technique."

Those comments could be seen as a criticism of Smith's methods of slicing and clubbing his runs but Smith will not take that away. By his own admission, he "made a career of looking ugly," and embraced his awkward technique because it worked for him. He does not expect it to be copied.

"If I had a boy, I don't think I'd want to get him to bat the Graeme Smith bats," Pollock joked. "I'd rather go down the Kallis or AB de Villiers route. But that's the nice thing about cricket. You've got different techniques and not all of them are from the MCC coaching manual."

Kallis said Smith's heavy bottom-hand and leg-side preference meant, "you always feel like you can get him out lbw, so he sucks you into it." In-form, Smith could take a delivery from a yard outside off stump and find a way to force it through the on-side. Out of form, he looks clumsy and unsure and that is how he lurched through most of this series.

What he never let slip was the emphasis he placed on team-spirit. South Africa began this series with a bush weekend with Boucher as part of his Save the Rhino campaign. They tried to maintain the same close bonds that they formed over the last 18 months. Smith made sure he led them as best he knew how. "He is very strong on culture and tradition and that's something he set up in his time," Kallis said.

But even the person who held it all together eventually could not hold on anymore. Although the timing of the announcement is awkward, both Pollock and Kallis believed he chose the right moment. "If you had to pick a time, it's probably the right time," Pollock said. "If you look at what's coming, there's a Test series of Sri Lanka, Zimbabwe and then West Indies at home. No disrespect to any of them but it's a bit of honeymoon period now where the new captain can sort out what works for him."

Who that new captain is will be decided in the next few months. For now it is all about Smith, and Kallis has asked for it to stay that way. "I just hope South Africans get behind and appreciate what Graeme has done for South African cricket," he said. Having recently retired himself, Kallis said he "can recommend it," because "it's been nice to do stuff away from the cricket and it will be for Graeme. Rather he retire too early than too late."

Smith is now 33. He has played his last Test. Against Australia. At Newlands. He has grown up completely. He is a husband and a father and he has decided his time as an international cricketer is up. He will celebrated and he deserves to be.

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • sherishahmir on March 6, 2014, 5:43 GMT

    Sad to c Smith is also leaving the game so early as he is only 33, he is great thinking captain and very good batsman who kept the higher standards for keeping the South African the top team in all formats of game regardless the rankings and fact that his team has never won the world cup or T20 title etc. Its really unfortunate to watch game without the greats i.e. Kallis, Smith, Boucher, Hussey, Ponting, Yousif, Tendulkar, Dravid and Swan and many more who quit the international cricket in recent past. Hats off to Grahame Smith for his serving to South African & International cricket and all the best to his life after cricket, wish he can further play for couple of years with the gut feeling which he can . A Pakistani fan.

  • Srikanth048 on March 6, 2014, 5:11 GMT

    Big man, big heart and never saw him get over the line. Always played in the right spirit. When threw a challenge, he is up to it. I always thought he excels under pressure. Sad though, that he couldn't win a world cup or something like it. All the very Best smithy!

  • gwoshmii on March 5, 2014, 23:12 GMT

    Big fan of the man. I'm am Australian but have always liked this bloke - even before the Sydney test. Something about his attitude resonated with me, a back-to-wall, over-the-top type of character; not a strategic leader, poring over plans but a leader of men.

  • St00rt on March 5, 2014, 16:18 GMT

    "I just hope South Africans get behind and appreciate what Graeme has done for South African cricket," - Unfortunately Jacques, that will never happen. Smithy is reviled by more people in this country (wannabe know it all armchair critics more than anything I suspect) than anywhere else. It blows my mind to think that people still harbour ill feelings towards him after what he's done and how he's performed. You only have to to look at polls put up on various sites to see how glad most people are to see the back of him and this is really sad. He took over at a tumultuous time in SA cricket and lead with aplomb. So what if he spoke his mind!?! To the people that only choose to dwell on the negatives, well I feel sorry for you.

    Go well Mr Smith, and thank you

    From a proud supporter...

  • on March 5, 2014, 16:14 GMT

    Everyone forgets his contribution to Rajasthan royals in the first edition where he was one of the highest run scorers in the tournament must have been of great help to Shane Warne.I know its out of topic but I would still prefer a guy like Smith over someone like a KP everyday(no hatred towards him just saying).

  • on March 5, 2014, 10:18 GMT

    One of the best captains i have watched and enjoyed. his leadership qualities are the best among all captains and i dont know of any other captain who could go out and bat to try and save a test match for his nation with a broken thumb/hand. Wishing you all the best Mr.Smith, the world cricket has lost a brave captain.

  • arunsubbu on March 5, 2014, 10:11 GMT

    He led his team to No1 in test cricket and thats a BIG thing.Leadinga side when u are 22 is no less mean a feat.Wish he had remanied till WC and led them to victory..

  • on March 5, 2014, 4:59 GMT

    He was an outstanding captain - intuitive, resourceful, sympathetic and clear-thinking not a pleasing batsmen though but kind of similar to Mike Brearley of England

  • Rufus_Fuddleduck on March 5, 2014, 4:25 GMT

    @nareshgb1 - McGrath has been the kind of bully who gives bullies a bad name. Can only dish out but not take it. Would have loved to see McGrath have his place in England or New Zealand teams. Definitely not likely to make a career by shaping the corners of history like Smith did. Anyways, many thanks for the two articles Firdose and also for updating our general knowledge.

  • Rufus_Fuddleduck on March 5, 2014, 3:01 GMT

    Smith's body of work can never be forgotten. Output combines Border- Waugh, even Worrell-Lloyd. Took over a premier team in disarray at 21 (21!) after the match fixing scandal. Let totally from front, battled numerous fractures and played brilliant knocks. Many with injuries - Gladiator style. Aggressive thinking captaincy has systematically improved record. South Africa is the team not to have lost a Test series in India since 1997. Beat Australia in Australia too. Three England tours and all times their captain resigned immediately afterwards. Not to discuss other sides. No rumbling ever about biases and favourites in team. Totally honest about weaknesses - immortal summation about World Cup "monkey on the back is now a gorilla." After that defeat, systematically working up South Africa to No 1 Test position. They look like being there for a while. All this at 34 ... this man has journeyed a lifetime and by corporate standards he's got 2 decades. Any company would love him as CEO!!

  • sherishahmir on March 6, 2014, 5:43 GMT

    Sad to c Smith is also leaving the game so early as he is only 33, he is great thinking captain and very good batsman who kept the higher standards for keeping the South African the top team in all formats of game regardless the rankings and fact that his team has never won the world cup or T20 title etc. Its really unfortunate to watch game without the greats i.e. Kallis, Smith, Boucher, Hussey, Ponting, Yousif, Tendulkar, Dravid and Swan and many more who quit the international cricket in recent past. Hats off to Grahame Smith for his serving to South African & International cricket and all the best to his life after cricket, wish he can further play for couple of years with the gut feeling which he can . A Pakistani fan.

  • Srikanth048 on March 6, 2014, 5:11 GMT

    Big man, big heart and never saw him get over the line. Always played in the right spirit. When threw a challenge, he is up to it. I always thought he excels under pressure. Sad though, that he couldn't win a world cup or something like it. All the very Best smithy!

  • gwoshmii on March 5, 2014, 23:12 GMT

    Big fan of the man. I'm am Australian but have always liked this bloke - even before the Sydney test. Something about his attitude resonated with me, a back-to-wall, over-the-top type of character; not a strategic leader, poring over plans but a leader of men.

  • St00rt on March 5, 2014, 16:18 GMT

    "I just hope South Africans get behind and appreciate what Graeme has done for South African cricket," - Unfortunately Jacques, that will never happen. Smithy is reviled by more people in this country (wannabe know it all armchair critics more than anything I suspect) than anywhere else. It blows my mind to think that people still harbour ill feelings towards him after what he's done and how he's performed. You only have to to look at polls put up on various sites to see how glad most people are to see the back of him and this is really sad. He took over at a tumultuous time in SA cricket and lead with aplomb. So what if he spoke his mind!?! To the people that only choose to dwell on the negatives, well I feel sorry for you.

    Go well Mr Smith, and thank you

    From a proud supporter...

  • on March 5, 2014, 16:14 GMT

    Everyone forgets his contribution to Rajasthan royals in the first edition where he was one of the highest run scorers in the tournament must have been of great help to Shane Warne.I know its out of topic but I would still prefer a guy like Smith over someone like a KP everyday(no hatred towards him just saying).

  • on March 5, 2014, 10:18 GMT

    One of the best captains i have watched and enjoyed. his leadership qualities are the best among all captains and i dont know of any other captain who could go out and bat to try and save a test match for his nation with a broken thumb/hand. Wishing you all the best Mr.Smith, the world cricket has lost a brave captain.

  • arunsubbu on March 5, 2014, 10:11 GMT

    He led his team to No1 in test cricket and thats a BIG thing.Leadinga side when u are 22 is no less mean a feat.Wish he had remanied till WC and led them to victory..

  • on March 5, 2014, 4:59 GMT

    He was an outstanding captain - intuitive, resourceful, sympathetic and clear-thinking not a pleasing batsmen though but kind of similar to Mike Brearley of England

  • Rufus_Fuddleduck on March 5, 2014, 4:25 GMT

    @nareshgb1 - McGrath has been the kind of bully who gives bullies a bad name. Can only dish out but not take it. Would have loved to see McGrath have his place in England or New Zealand teams. Definitely not likely to make a career by shaping the corners of history like Smith did. Anyways, many thanks for the two articles Firdose and also for updating our general knowledge.

  • Rufus_Fuddleduck on March 5, 2014, 3:01 GMT

    Smith's body of work can never be forgotten. Output combines Border- Waugh, even Worrell-Lloyd. Took over a premier team in disarray at 21 (21!) after the match fixing scandal. Let totally from front, battled numerous fractures and played brilliant knocks. Many with injuries - Gladiator style. Aggressive thinking captaincy has systematically improved record. South Africa is the team not to have lost a Test series in India since 1997. Beat Australia in Australia too. Three England tours and all times their captain resigned immediately afterwards. Not to discuss other sides. No rumbling ever about biases and favourites in team. Totally honest about weaknesses - immortal summation about World Cup "monkey on the back is now a gorilla." After that defeat, systematically working up South Africa to No 1 Test position. They look like being there for a while. All this at 34 ... this man has journeyed a lifetime and by corporate standards he's got 2 decades. Any company would love him as CEO!!

  • on March 5, 2014, 0:04 GMT

    Nicely written, thank you Firdose. And thank you Graeme Smith.

  • nareshgb1 on March 5, 2014, 0:03 GMT

    LOL....darn funny - so Sarwan was not the only one that made McGrath look like a real pidgeon witha counter sledge. Why did "pidge" even bother at all really?

  • on March 4, 2014, 21:52 GMT

    Really nice written article about a great cricketer

  • on March 4, 2014, 21:43 GMT

    One of the greatest captains of all time. Like his batting, not always pretty- but usually very effective! Thanks for the last decade plus Biff!

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • on March 4, 2014, 21:43 GMT

    One of the greatest captains of all time. Like his batting, not always pretty- but usually very effective! Thanks for the last decade plus Biff!

  • on March 4, 2014, 21:52 GMT

    Really nice written article about a great cricketer

  • nareshgb1 on March 5, 2014, 0:03 GMT

    LOL....darn funny - so Sarwan was not the only one that made McGrath look like a real pidgeon witha counter sledge. Why did "pidge" even bother at all really?

  • on March 5, 2014, 0:04 GMT

    Nicely written, thank you Firdose. And thank you Graeme Smith.

  • Rufus_Fuddleduck on March 5, 2014, 3:01 GMT

    Smith's body of work can never be forgotten. Output combines Border- Waugh, even Worrell-Lloyd. Took over a premier team in disarray at 21 (21!) after the match fixing scandal. Let totally from front, battled numerous fractures and played brilliant knocks. Many with injuries - Gladiator style. Aggressive thinking captaincy has systematically improved record. South Africa is the team not to have lost a Test series in India since 1997. Beat Australia in Australia too. Three England tours and all times their captain resigned immediately afterwards. Not to discuss other sides. No rumbling ever about biases and favourites in team. Totally honest about weaknesses - immortal summation about World Cup "monkey on the back is now a gorilla." After that defeat, systematically working up South Africa to No 1 Test position. They look like being there for a while. All this at 34 ... this man has journeyed a lifetime and by corporate standards he's got 2 decades. Any company would love him as CEO!!

  • Rufus_Fuddleduck on March 5, 2014, 4:25 GMT

    @nareshgb1 - McGrath has been the kind of bully who gives bullies a bad name. Can only dish out but not take it. Would have loved to see McGrath have his place in England or New Zealand teams. Definitely not likely to make a career by shaping the corners of history like Smith did. Anyways, many thanks for the two articles Firdose and also for updating our general knowledge.

  • on March 5, 2014, 4:59 GMT

    He was an outstanding captain - intuitive, resourceful, sympathetic and clear-thinking not a pleasing batsmen though but kind of similar to Mike Brearley of England

  • arunsubbu on March 5, 2014, 10:11 GMT

    He led his team to No1 in test cricket and thats a BIG thing.Leadinga side when u are 22 is no less mean a feat.Wish he had remanied till WC and led them to victory..

  • on March 5, 2014, 10:18 GMT

    One of the best captains i have watched and enjoyed. his leadership qualities are the best among all captains and i dont know of any other captain who could go out and bat to try and save a test match for his nation with a broken thumb/hand. Wishing you all the best Mr.Smith, the world cricket has lost a brave captain.

  • on March 5, 2014, 16:14 GMT

    Everyone forgets his contribution to Rajasthan royals in the first edition where he was one of the highest run scorers in the tournament must have been of great help to Shane Warne.I know its out of topic but I would still prefer a guy like Smith over someone like a KP everyday(no hatred towards him just saying).