South Africa news

Smith considered resigning Test captaincy

Firdose Moonda

June 29, 2012

Comments: 20 | Text size: A | A

Graeme Smith during practice, Wellington, March 22, 2012
Graeme Smith considered quitting the Test captaincy to work on his form as a batsman © Getty Images
Enlarge

Graeme Smith has revealed that he considered stepping down from all forms of leadership last year but was talked out of quitting the Test captaincy by Gary Kirsten. Smith led South Africa in all three formats for eight years but relinquished captaincy of the Twenty20 and ODI teams in August 2010 and April 2011 respectively. The latter was timed to coincide with the end of the fifty-over World Cup and it was then that Smith also considered giving up the Test captaincy.

"After the World Cup, when things were tough, it certainly was something that was on my mind," Smith told ESPNcricinfo ahead of the team's departure to England. "Gary played a role in me keeping the captaincy. He talked me into doing it for longer and he was the reason I decided to carry on."

The World Cup was a massive turning point in Smith's career. It seemed to change him on many levels. South Africa were knocked out in the quarter-finals, after failing to chase down a modest total against New Zealand in Dhaka. Having chosen a squad suited to subcontinental conditions, beaten India in a thriller in Nagpur to top their group, and been the only team to bowl out their opposition in all six matches, South Africa appeared set for a run to the final. With expectations growing, they were on track to finally lift an ICC trophy for the first time since 1998, only to run into a tenacious New Zealand, who forced a choke out of South Africa.

The whole squad was shell-shocked by the defeat but Smith was particularly affected. He addressed the media almost in tears as he explained how he had wanted his last act as one-day captain to be a victory. He did not return home with the rest of the team but flew to Ireland to propose to the woman who is now his wife, Morgan Deane. A fickle public rejected him and his profile nosedived. Smith was criticised in many forums, for his lack of both leadership and form.

When he eventually returned home in June, he apologised to fans for the World Cup defeat and his subsequent no-show. It was only through his match-winning century against Australia in the Newlands Test in November that Smith began to win back hearts and minds, although negative sentiment still surrounded his inclusion in the one-day team. Again, it was through a gritty innings, a century against Sri Lanka in January, that Smith regained the faith of the cricketing masses.

He described the period that followed the World Cup as "the most difficult" of his career, because he was also going through a run drought. He thought reducing his load would allow him to concentrate on batting.

However, without any clear replacement available, even though AB de Villiers was appointed limited-overs captain, Smith was asked to stay on and provide continuity at a time when everything, including the coaching staff, was changing. "Gary was a big instigator in me carrying on captaining the Test side," Smith said. "I've certainly enjoyed working with him and the management team, which has also helped. As long as I can keep enjoying it and keep adding value then I will captain."

It is not a job Smith wants to do forever, though. "I don't know if I will captain the Test side for as long as I play. I've only just turned 31 and I feel I still have a lot to offer from a batting perspective but I certainly don't see myself captaining until the time I retire."

Retirement, however, is not in Smith's current plans. "In the long run, I'm going to concentrate on performance. I'm still hungry, I've got a lot of things that I want to achieve."

First on his list of things to do, is captain the side successfully on the tour to England. With South Africa competing for the No.1 ranking in Tests, Smith said he will be required to contribute both with the bat and as a leader if they hope to topple England. He feels he has matured since his first visit to the country in 2003, as a 23-year-old novice captain.

"In the early days I didn't know who I needed to be and what was important from a leadership role. I wanted to come across as a strong leader," Smith said, explaining why he was sometimes perceived as cocky. "But now I'm at peace with things and I think that comes through. I'm more relaxed in showing my personality and how I feel, and I'm much more at peace with understanding what I need to do."

Firdose Moonda is ESPNcricinfo's South Africa correspondent

RSS Feeds: Firdose Moonda

© ESPN EMEA Ltd.

Posted by 5wombats on (July 2, 2012, 20:11 GMT)

Inclined to agree with @landl47. Smith isn't so great. There are undoubtedly problems of the "mental" kind in the SA set up - why? Where does that come from?

Posted by JG2704 on (July 2, 2012, 19:34 GMT)

@Fidel Damons on (July 02 2012, 10:17 AM GMT) Is it possible that a man can be a great leader of men without being a great tactical captain?

Posted by JG2704 on (July 2, 2012, 19:30 GMT)

@Randy_Wilson on (June 29 2012, 21:15 PM GMT) - Sammy and Gibson get the flak for everything that goes wrong in WI cricket. When WI lose , they're to blame but I bet if I went on the NZ/WI thread now there would not be one comment giving credit to either

Posted by   on (July 2, 2012, 10:17 GMT)

@timtom and Landl47 Oh so winning the 1st away series in Eng and Aus since return from isolation is not much success in your eyes. I guess your precious Hansie and Polock did all that with their eyes closed. Yes the great Dhoni did it all too... Give credit where credit is due. He is an inspirational captain that always leads from the front. No matter how much virtol is directed at him he always bounces back. You have to admire that kind of determination and courage. Lesser men would crack under much less.

Posted by timtom on (July 1, 2012, 4:16 GMT)

Success of a captain is always gauged by his achievements.... Smith had the best or second best team at his disposal for last 10 yrs..What are his achievements ?? A brief stint at No:1 test ranking and beating Aus in Aus....end of it...Now compare Dhoni with perennial sub par bowling .. T20WC, One dayWC, 20 month Test No 1 test ranking[not counting the 2 DLF and ChT20 cups ].....Smith just like Ganguly has always been high underachiever with the kind of team possessed...And it definitely has a lot to do with attitude... @Randy :: If current WI sticks together and performs the way are now, Sammy will have more cups than Smith at the end of his career....

Posted by Xolile on (June 30, 2012, 12:48 GMT)

@land47 - De Villiers and Amla will play for 8 more years. Smith, Rudolph and Petersen each have 4-5 years left. Kallis will probably retire in 2015. Faf looks ready to compete at the highest level. Plus there are youngsters coming through such as De Kock. I'd say SA is in very good shape until at least 2020.

Posted by landl47 on (June 30, 2012, 4:26 GMT)

How successful a captain has been is measured by how much success the side has had relative to the strength of its players and based on that Smith hasn't been that successful. He's had some extremely talented players, led by the great Jacques Kallis, but hasn't really achieved the level of success the ability of those players warranted. This is probably his last chance, as Kallis is now 36 and SA doesn't appear to have many top-class batsmen coming through. The seam bowling is great, but Tahir's a very ordinary spinner. Smith himself might have a struggle in England; he plays with his bat face very closed and it's hard to play the ball moving away with that bat position. Expect to see him caught by the keeper or the slips off Anderson a good deal. It should be a good tight series; I just wish it was 5 tests instead of 3.

Posted by   on (June 30, 2012, 4:22 GMT)

Looks like Smith's #1 critic at it again... claiming "the masses" didn't support Smith... complete nonsense... he is a true champion, SA's most successful ever leader and opening batsman in both forms of the game. South Africans are loyal to their champions and rightly so. He wasn't even out of form for that long, and now he's back to something like his best, so look out England, one of his favourite hunting grounds :)

Posted by Randy_Wilson on (June 29, 2012, 21:15 GMT)

sorry for out of Topic. Sammy should learn from these great Captain Ponting and Smith. He should step down and At least try to cement his place in de WI. Instead of been in the team because of captaincy.

Posted by   on (June 29, 2012, 19:45 GMT)

I, somehow, have mixed feelings about Smith's leadership. He can be astute enough at times particularly while working out a particular batsman. While, in the next moment one is always likely to watch tactical blunders, some of which are fundamental indeed, such as leaving vital cordons vacant while his bowlers are fuming and bowling their heart out. However, as a batsman, who knows how to get going when it really is tough to get through, he is peerless reminding dogged perseverance of another tough customer: Steve Waugh. Anyway, I seriously wish him to be overcoming English frontier...and many more.

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Firdose MoondaClose
Country Fixtures Country Results
Only ODI: South Africa v Netherlands at Amstelveen
May 31, 2013 (10:45 local | 08:45 GMT | 04:45 EDT | 03:45 CDT | 01:45 PDT)
Pakistan v South Africa at The Oval
Jun 3, 2013 (10:30 local | 09:30 GMT | 05:30 EDT | 04:30 CDT | 02:30 PDT)
1st Match, Group B: India v South Africa at Cardiff
Jun 6, 2013 (10:30 local | 09:30 GMT | 05:30 EDT | 04:30 CDT | 02:30 PDT)
5th Match, Group B: Pakistan v South Africa at Birmingham
Jun 10, 2013 (13:00 local | 12:00 GMT | 08:00 EDT | 07:00 CDT | 05:00 PDT)
9th Match, Group B: South Africa v West Indies at Cardiff
Jun 14, 2013 (10:30 local | 09:30 GMT | 05:30 EDT | 04:30 CDT | 02:30 PDT)
Complete fixtures » | Download Fixtures »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days
Sponsored Links

Safe & simple online money transfer. Apply Now!

Available now at Cricshop