Whither West Indies?

So where do West Indies go from here?

To say 300 kilometres south-west to Multan is the obvious answer, but may not be the one most are looking for in the aftermath of the heavy defeat at Lahore. The deeper, more analytical response, is just as self-evident, except that too many people are seeking solace from umpiring errors and an assortment of other excuses so as not to face up to a fundamental reality.

As well as the Caribbean cricketers have progressed as a unit in one-day internationals during the course of this year, too many of them still don't know how to play Test cricket. It's not just about the results, which are damning enough, but the repetitive manner in which they tend to subside, at home and abroad, which underscore that reality.

They are all capable of individual brilliance, and we have seen several of those flashes in the very recent past from batsmen and bowlers alike. But a Test match, like a cricket team, is the sum of its parts. It's no use dominating opponents for a session if the effort can't be sustained, day in day out, until victory is achieved.

We like to highlight turning points in a match - a key wicket, a brilliant catch or a straight six off the most threatening bowler-because it is easy to hinge a result on one or two incidents. However, in a contest as protracted as this, these are essentially just points along a graph, and the overall effort must be anchored in a solid base of discipline and perseverance, qualities that demand a high level of concentration.

Talking about bowling a consistent line or going back and across is the easy part compared to developing those intangible elements in players, the vast majority of whom are the products of a popular culture of instant gratification.

Just look at what happened yesterday at the Gaddafi Stadium.

Another masterful hundred from Brian Lara, superbly supported by Shivnarine Chanderpaul, finally put some real backbone in the West Indies effort and threatened to give the home team a few worries heading into the final day. Yet from the moment of Lara's demise, the fight went out of the side (Chanderpaul's wild swipe at Danish Kaneria shortly after was immediate confirmation) and the last six wickets tumbled for 53 runs.

Anything new in that? Close your eyes and call a cricket venue anywhere in the world and there is a very good chance that almost the exact scene would have been played out in that arena at some time over the past 11 years.

For Lara, it must be an increasingly deflating experience, never mind the usual empty platitudes about learning from this latest setback and staying positive and focused ahead of the next match. What else can he say at a post-match ceremony, that we should forfeit the remaining Tests and play 12 ODIs instead so that everyone can return to preparing for the World Cup?

Maybe I'm reading too much into it, especially from this distance, but a little exchange with Dwayne Bravo while both were standing in the slips during the formalities of Pakistan's second innings appeared much more revealing of Lara's true feelings. Bravo, who 29 months after his Test debut has not yet experienced what it is like to be in a winning Test team, seemed in the mood for some playful old talk with his fellow countryman, except that Lara wasn't particularly accommodating and at one point in the brief exchange looked as if he was uttering a few stern words.

Again, it may have been nothing, but you never know. It must be galling for Lara to have now scored 5226 runs in vain for West Indies. Vain in the context of at least not losing Test matches (something he has been talking about more and more over the last few months), though clearly not futile in terms of the sheer delight he has brought to fans of the game around the world for the incomparable elegance and style with which he embellishes an insatiable appetite for runs.

Some of Lara's greatest performances - the 688 runs with a double-century and two other hundreds in three Tests in Sri Lanka in 2001 stand out-have come in the midst of comprehensive defeats. In the single-mindedness of youth and the desire to rack up more and more runs and records, the legacy of being a champion batsman in a woeful Test team isn't all that relevant, because the mind says there is still time to make a difference in the winning column.

But time is running out, and even if the evidence of his 33rd Test hundred and third in as many matches against the Pakistanis reaffirms his pre-eminence among contemporary batsmen worldwide, Lara is increasingly haunted by the stark reality that too many of his runs are only of personal statistical value.

Like millions of Indian cricket fans and their obsession with Sachin Tendulkar, many Trinis now don't seem to mind too much that the West Indies have been beaten again, so long as their hero has gotten another hundred.

Those indulging in that short-sighted consolation would do well to appreciate, as Lara certainly does, that his Test career has, maybe, another couple years to run and that the game, and the team, are always bigger than the player, never mind how great that player is.

Click here to send us your thoughts.