West Indies tri-series 2013 June 27, 2013

Sunil Narine a lion in his own den

Shiva Jayaraman
A statistical analysis on Sunil Narine's performance in ODIs, home and away, and how he has become West Indies' leading ODI bowler

West Indies' improved performances at home in ODIs, in the last year or so, has coincided with the emergence of Sunil Narine as their leading spinner in International cricket. By 2000, when the last of their feared breed of fast bowlers retired, and for much of the time since then, spinners were only in the West Indian squads to carry out the perfunctory role of the fifth bowler. Narine has changed all that. With 52 wickets from 31 matches, he has been their leading wicket-taker in ODIs since his debut in December 2011.

Narine has won three Man-of-the-Match awards since then, with two against New Zealand, and one against Australia. He also won the Man-of-the-Series award for his bowling performance against New Zealand in the aforementioned series - the first ODI Man-of-the-Series award by a specialist West Indian spinner since Lance Gibbs won in the Prudential Trophy in England in 1973. Narine earned the award by taking 13 wickets against New Zealand. This is the most a West Indian spinner has ever taken in a bilateral ODI series.

Top-five West Indian bowlers since Narine's debut
Bowler Mat Overs Mdns Runs Wkts BBI Avg Econ SR 5 wkts
SP Narine 31 289.5 20 1,149 52 5/27 22.09 3.96 33.4 1
KAJ Roach 20 170.3 14 918 30 5/56 30.60 5.38 34.1 1
DJ Bravo 23 151.3 4 864 27 6/43 32.00 5.70 33.6 1
AD Russell 21 142.0 1 818 22 4/45 37.18 5.76 38.7 0
DJG Sammy 27 170.1 5 801 20 3/28 40.05 4.70 51.0 0

In home matches, Narine has provided the West Indies attack with much needed penetration. With Narine applying pressure at one end, the West Indian bowlers have been far more effective. In 13 ODI matches at home, their average, strike rate and economy have all improved significantly, as the table shows below.

West Indies at home since Narine's debut and 5 years before
West Indies Mat Overs Mdns Runs Wkts BBI Avg Econ SR 5 Wkt
Since Narine's debut 13 225.5 14 868 41 5/27 21.17 3.84 33.0 1
5-yr (before debut) 51 621.2 27 2,857 78 4/36 36.62 4.59 47.7 0

Narine's performances against New Zealand in the bilateral ODI series at home was clearly his best. He captured 13 wickets at an average of 11.23 from five games against them. This included a five-wicket haul in the last game of the series at Basseterre. The first such haul by a West Indian spinner in almost ten years, and the best bowling returns by a West Indian spinner in ODIs.

Narine's contribution in the series against Australia was telling. West Indies managed to draw an ODI series at home against Australia for the first time since 1999. Narine's four-wicket haul in the second game of the series helped his team beat Australia for the first time in eight matches at home.

Sunil Narine v teams, in the West Indies
Opposition Mat Overs Mdns Runs Wkts BBI Avg Econ SR 5 wkt
New Zealand 5 50.0 4 146 13 5/27 11.23 2.92 23.0 1
Australia 5 47.5 2 159 11 4/27 14.45 3.32 26.0 0
Zimbabwe 3 30.0 5 124 5 3/28 24.80 4.13 36.0 0

Statistically, Narine has clearly been the best spinner West Indies has produced. His average of 22.09 and economy of 3.96 are the best among West Indian spinners who have bowled at least 50 overs in ODIs. In home games, he is clearly ahead of the next best West Indian spinner in terms of bowling average. His average of 14.79 is much better than Jimmy Adams' 20.15, which is the second best.

Sunil Narine has also been the best spin bowler in ODIs, among all teams, in the West Indies. He has taken 29 wickets in 13 matches at an average of 14.79. His economy of 3.35 and strike rate of 26.4 are also the best among spinners who have played at least ten matches in the West Indies.

However, Narine loses some of his incisiveness in alien conditions. His average and strike rate come down to 31.30 (14.79 at home) and 42.2 (26.4 at home), respectively. His record against Australia - who are the only team he has played both home and away - shows that his effectiveness as an attacking bowler is greatly reduced in away matches. His strike rate doubles when he plays Australia in Australia, while his average goes up to 34.4, as opposed to a brilliant 14.5 when playing at home. He has managed to keep the Australian batsmen in check, though, with an economy of 4.0.

Sunil Narine v Australia, in away and home matches
Venue Mat Wkts Overs Econ Runs conc Avg SR
Australia 5 5 43.0 4.0 172 34.4 51.6
West Indies 5 11 47.5 3.3 156 14.5 26.1

That he has been less lethal bowling in Australia than at home, can be seen by his performance against Australian batsmen who have played him both home and away. Matthew Wade has found Narine difficult irrespective of the conditions, while Shane Watson and George Bailey have negotiated him better in Australia.

Narine v Australian batsmen, at home and away
  In Australia In West Indies
Batsman Runs BF SR Dis Avg Runs BF SR Dis Avg
GJ Bailey 38 38 100.0 1 38.00 16 41 39.0 0 -
SR Watson 32 41 78.0 0 - 17 32 53.0 0 -
MS Wade 8 18 44.33 1 8.00 2 20 10.0 3 0.66

The West Indies tri-series will be the first time Narine bowls to Sri Lankan batsmen in ODIs, while his record against Indian batsmen, who are also featuring in the series, should give him confidence. He has taken five wickets against these Indian batsmen at an average of 17.4 and a strike rate of 26.8. Both Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma have been dismissed by Narine twice in three matches.

Narine v batsmen in the current India squad
Batsman Inns Runs BF SR Dis Avg
S Dhawan 1 24 28 85.7 0 -
V Kohli 3 22 30 73.3 2 11.00
RG Sharma 3 21 35 60.0 2 10.50
KD Karthik 1 9 15 60.0 0 -
SK Raina 2 6 6 100.0 0 -
R Ashwin 1 4 16 25.0 1 4.00
RA Jadeja 1 1 4 25.0 0 -

During this series, Narine will be bowling against some of the better players of spin bowling. Some notable performances will only enhance his reputation as a leading spinner in the ODIs, for the subcontinent batsmen will not be discouraged by the local pitches, which are similar to home. To Narine's advantage, he will be playing in conditions he has produced his best in.

Shiva Jayaraman is a sub-editor (stats) at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Ahilan on July 1, 2013, 2:59 GMT

    WI 5yr before Narine debut - 51 matches, 621.2 overs, 78 wickets. approx 12 overs bowled and 1.5 wickets per match. what does this mean. are these wickets taken by WI spinners before Narine.

  • perry on June 29, 2013, 23:56 GMT

    shillingford will not see the night of day once narine is there.narine is in a class by himself,that is worldwide

  • Dummy4 on June 29, 2013, 13:54 GMT

    I believe that it's time the Windies try two spinners in ODi. Add Shillingford, drop Ramdin and have Charles keep. We have to maximize Shillingford playing since he's over 30 years old already and has proved a handful against opposition, especially in the West Indies. This would demand more from the batsmen but they need the pressure to develop their game. The batsmen, especially Charles, need to understand that ODI is not T20. He threw his wicket needlessly yesterday. Hope he does a better job next game. Overall, each batsman must have their role specified in the team which I assume has been clearly defined by team management. My view is Darren Bravo and Samuels - consolidators to bat through; Capt. Bravo, Pollard and Sammy play defense, offense or counter-attack based on the situation at hand. The pace bowling can be tweaked depending on performance since I believe that we should not always automatically rule out Best. Overall the team has great potential.

  • Dummy4 on June 29, 2013, 3:17 GMT

    learn to read J.adams who was an accomplished middle order batsman hav the 2nd best AVERAGE he was not our second best spinner (behind narine) narine hav a long way b4 he could be the best anyhow......." His average of 14.79 is much better than Jimmy Adams' 20.15, which is the second best."

  • Dummy4 on June 29, 2013, 2:58 GMT

    Why would anyone be wondering about Devon Smith ? What are his test and odibaverages again ?

  • Dummy4 on June 28, 2013, 10:28 GMT

    Jimmy Adams was a more of a batsman?

    Come on... He was wicket keeper!!! I still remember high maiden hundred against India. He was popularly known as "Padams", because he used Pads (feet) against spinners effectively.

    It is surprising that he was the best spinner for WI in WI before Narine!!!

  • Asker on June 28, 2013, 6:17 GMT

    Jimmy Adams was more of a 6/7 th batsman who can round his arms a bit more like sehwag, raina, Clarke, dilshan, sachin, ganguly etc but if he is the second best after Narine in the land which produced guys like Gibbs, Hooper, Vallentine, Jumadin etc etc it is a pity, now WI's do not have even the fearsome foursome to bank on and nor the spinners and not the towering presence of Haynes, Greenidge,Fredricks, Richards, LLoyd. I believe one guy named Devon Smith can add much value to the side, I am not sure why he is being sidelined or is he is unfit these days. If they groom Jason Holder and a couple of guys who were in the U19 team who were pretty decent looking fast bowlers, they can still hope to have that battery of fast bowlers again in the company of Roach,Rampaul, Edwards,Best these youngsters can flourish and carry on the mantle in the future. One last word, all the commentators in IPL or CT have produced his name wrongly it should be na-ri-ne not Narain they should get it right

  • sampath on June 28, 2013, 6:05 GMT

    "His strike rate has halved when he has played Australia in Australia." This is wrong. It has 'doubled' not 'halved'. please correct.

  • Shipu on June 27, 2013, 22:06 GMT

    Its funny the writer of the article didn't mention Narine stats against minnows Bangladesh which they happened to won 3-2 in that last year interesting :)

  • No featured comments at the moment.