Shah endorses Manohar's call for ICC democracy

Former BCCI secretary Niranjan Shah, a long-time administrator and currently secretary of Saurashtra Cricket Association, has endorsed Shashank Manohar's "personal" view that the ICC needs to be more democratic. This comes as important support for possible change in the structure of the ICC, especially considering BCCI secretary Anurag Thakur had essentially opposed Manohar's view.

Shah had told ESPNcricinfo in November that it was not fair that everybody earned equal revenue when India contributed a majority of it. "I remember we fought against the infamous veto rights of England and Australia," he said. "Now it is almost like we have brought back that system, except that we have added ourselves to that list."

Last week, Manohar had said in an interview with the Hindu that the revenue-sharing structure the Big Three had imposed needed changing. "I don't agree with the revenue-sharing formula, because it's nice to say that India [BCCI] will get 22% of the total revenue of the ICC, but you cannot make the poor poorer and the rich richer, only because you have the clout. The ICC runs cricket throughout the world."

This had brought about an opposing view from Thakur. "The [BCCI] president said this in his personal capacity," Thakur told Indian Express. "He made it very clear that it was his personal opinion. The Indian subcontinent contributes close to 70% of the ICC's revenues. To take 21% of that is not much. That was the position with Australia and England earlier, and no one objected to it then. If this happens to India today, we shouldn't object to it."

Shah, who will be a voting power if this issue comes up for discussion in the BCCI, believes the board shouldn't take the view that this becomes right just because somebody else had done it in the past. Shah also compared it with the structure of the BCCI. "In India Tripura and Mumbai have the same voting powers and get the same share of the revenue," he said and reiterated Manohar's view that even if India contributes more to the world cricket financially, it needed good competition to do so.

Shah said that if the ICC was to be restructured, the matter would be brought up in the BCCI first. Asked if he, as a member of the BCCI, would support such a move, he answered in the affirmative, but said that only a majority view was likely to be considered.