The consensus when John Bracewell stood down this month after five
years as New Zealand's coach was that he had only done half the job.
They had established themselves as a consistently threatening one-day
side during his reign, but in the Test arena their poor results had
become as predictable as Chris Martin's batting. Never was that
frustrating split more apparent than in Bracewell's last year at the
helm.
New Zealand's Test schedule had been light in recent seasons; they
played only ten Tests in 2006 and 2007 combined. In 2008 they played
14 Tests and won four but three of those victories came against
Bangladesh. The most revealing moment came when they lost to Australia
in Adelaide and slipped to eighth on the ICC's Test rankings -
effectively last, as only Bangladesh were below them.
In the limited-overs format they thrived, with 10 wins from
15 ODIs.
They didn't lose a series, beating England at home and away and
expectedly triumphing against Ireland, Scotland and Bangladesh. The
new coach, Andy Moles, faces the task of developing a team that can
perform in both versions. At least he has some of the building blocks.
After a year of change in 2007, when they lost Nathan Astle, Craig
McMillan and Hamish Marshall to the ICL, there were a couple of even
more important departures in 2008. Within the first few weeks of the
year, Shane Bond had headed for the ICL and his New Zealand career was
over. Stephen Fleming also retired after the home series against
England, although his exit was as inevitable as the prime minister,
Helen Clark, losing office.
Jesse Ryder, Daniel Flynn, Tim Southee and Tim McIntosh all debuted
and showed promise. Iain O'Brien went from a battling trundler to the
world's No. 11 wicket-taker for the year. He also turned into a
highly
entertaining blogger. Ross Taylor consolidated his reputation with the
first two centuries of his Test career.
But for all the potential that their emerging men displayed, far too
much was left up to the new captain Daniel Vettori. That he was their
leading Test wicket-taker by a considerable margin was not surprising
- he collected 54 at 26.12 - but that he was
third on their batting
List with 672 runs at 35.36 was a sad reflection of their top-order
woes.
The incessant chopping and changing with the opening roles continued.
Craig Cumming and Matthew Bell began as the first-choice pair, Bell
and Jamie How were tried, then How and Aaron Redmond, and finally How
and McIntosh. And now How is struggling, so who knows how long the
current combination will last. It has created instability for the
middle order - hardly ideal with young batsmen trying to find their
feet at Nos. 3, 4 and 5. Flynn, Taylor and Ryder could provide New
Zealand with a firm batting core in the future, although 2008 was hit
and miss for the trio.
When Flynn arrived on the scene during the tour of England, he would
have preferred miss than the hit he received. In his second Test,
at
Old Trafford, he was struck in the face by a James Anderson bouncer
and lost a couple of teeth. Flynn walking off the ground with a
bloodied mouth was one of the enduring images of the year in New
Zealand cricket, but the way he returned to perform solidly for the
remainder of the year proved the team had found a fighter.
The tour of England provided another memorable image when
Vettori and Brendon McCullum shouted their disapproval from the
players' balcony
at The Oval after England's ODI captain, Paul Collingwood, declined to recall Grant Elliott, who had been run out after colliding with the bowler, Ryan Sidebottom. New Zealand went on
to win the series 3-1.
At Test level they struggled to match England; they won the first home
Test,
in Hamilton, and drew
at Lord's, but lost the other four Tests in the home-and-away tours. They were not helped by the absence of senior
men like Vettori and McCullum for the start of the tour after
they were given permission to stay longer in the IPL, where McCullum's
incredible 158 in the opening match had set the tone for the tournament.
A visit to Bangladesh brought more concerns than it should have; they
lost the
first ODI and only won the
Chittagong Test because Vettori
carried the side with bat and ball. The signs were not good ahead of a
tour to Australia and the comprehensive
2-0 loss to the No. 1 team was not a major surprise, although Southee continued to show his potential as a dangerous swing bowler after bursting onto the scene
with a five-wicket haul on debut against England
in Napier.
A more closely-fought
home series against West Indies followed, but a 0-0 draw was not the ideal result. It was the first time Moles had been in charge of the side; the coaching role was one of several
management positions that altered during the year. And so a period of
changes on field and off ended with New Zealand at the bottom of the
Test table. The only way is up.
New man on the block
Jesse Ryder. Happily for New Zealand there were options in this
category. Flynn and Southee in particular could be cornerstones of the
line-up for the next few years. Ryder has the potential to be not only
a key player but a cult hero. Unconventionally proportioned for a
top-level cricketer, his international career got off to a
smashing start in February when he slammed 79 from 62 balls in his
second ODI, against England
in Hamilton, and then it threatened to
crash and burn when he put his fist through a bar-room window in
Christchurch after a late night of drinking. He hurt his hand so badly
that he could not make the tour of England, but on his return he showed
promise in Tests against
Bangladesh, and
West Indies.
Fading star
Stephen Fleming. It was strange that one of the most respected
captains of the modern era farewelled the game not leading his side
but as one of 10 men playing under the new skipper, Vettori.
New Zealand fans knew at the start of the year the end was nigh for
Fleming, although he surprised many by bowing out after the Napier
Test against Michael Vaughan's men instead of kicking on for one last
tour of England. He left the game with scores of 59 and 66 in his
final Test and it was somehow appropriate for a man who, for all his
talent, should have made more than nine Test centuries, having passed
50 on 55 occasions.
High point
In Tests there were precious few; three of their four victories came
against Bangladesh. Beating England in the first Test at home was the
standout, but it was followed by a pair of defeats. The other high
point for New Zealand in 2008 was coming back from 1-0 down after two
games to beat England 3-1 in the
one-day series in England. That arguably their best achievement came in an inconsequential
limited-overs series says much about the state of cricket in New Zealand.
Low point
Losing to Australia was not unexpected but the consequences of New Zealand's defeat in the second Test
in Adelaide made the outcome particularly disappointing. That game nudged them down the ICC rankings to below West Indies and Martin Crowe thought that was such a galling position to be in that it was quite possibly the country's
worst moment in Test cricket.
What 2009 holds
For a team that clearly prefers the coloured clothing, next year
thankfully features a less hectic Test schedule. They host India for
two Tests in March-April and then head to Sri Lanka for three Tests in
August. At least expectations will not be high in either series; India
are one of the world's best sides and Sri Lanka at home have beaten
India, South Africa and England in the past couple of years. A trip to
Pakistan later in the year may or may not go ahead; the same for the
Champions Trophy. The reality is that 2009 will be another development
year for an evolving side. It will also start to show whether Moles
can simultaneously run two successful sides instead of one, like his
predecessor.