In six tours of Australia, India have played 25 Tests and
the overall record makes for pretty dismal reading. Four
rubbers have been lost and on two occasions the series has
been shared. Out of the 25 Tests, India have won just three
and lost as many as 16.
Past record has proved that faulty team selection has
played its part in this sorry showing. The team in 1947-48
for example was selected along provincial lines and in fact
Anthony De Mello, the president of the Board of Control for
Cricket in India was quoted proudly as saying that the entire
map of India had been represented in the team selection. But
then this was immediately after independence and so there must
have been other considerations.
Twenty years later, there were some shock omissions. Among
those who did not make the tour were Hanumant Singh,
S.Venkatraghavan, BK Kunderan, Salim Durrani and ML
Jaisimha (though he was sent later as a replacement). For the
1980-81 tour, Surinder Amarnath and Madan Lal were the
notable players who missed out. The 1991-92 squad was top
heavy in pace bowling and weak in the spin department and
lost the five Test series 0-4.
If anything, it would appear that the selectors have not
learnt any lessons from the reverses sustained on the
previous tour. This time also there are five fast bowlers
and only two spinners. Spin has been our traditional strength
and the best tweakers have succeeded in any country and
under any wicket and weather conditions. In Australia,
Prasanna in 1967-68, Bedi and Chandrasekhar in 1977-78, Dilip
Doshi and Shivlal Yadav in 1980-81, Yadav in 1985-86 and
Ravi Shastri in 1991-92 have either really excelled or at
least been among the wickets. With the exception of the
peerless Kapil Dev on all his three visits, Indian
medium pacers have rarely done well in Australia.
The Indian team picked for the Australian tour is again
top heavy in pace bowling and weak in the spin department.
Never has an Indian team for Australia contained as many as
five pace bowlers (and a sixth in Ganguly who can also use the
seam upright) and only two spin bowlers. Australian batsmen
are traditionally weak against off spin but one cannot see
a bowler like Harbhajan Singh troubling Steve Waugh and
company, except perhaps at Sydney. And Anil Kumble's record
away from home is not at all an encouraging factor. Which
means it will be up to the seam attack to pick up most of
the wickets and as I pointed out, Indian medium pacers have
hardly ever come off in Australia. Here though one must
applaud the selection of Tamil Nadu's Thirunavukarasu Kumaran.
Whether he comes off or not, his selection is certainly
a bold step.
The one considerable silver lining is that the batting is
extremely strong. Never has an Indian batting line up
in cricket history seen its top five batsmen in the
order - Ramesh, Gandhi, Dravid, Tendulkar and Ganguly - all
have a Test career average of 50 plus. The reserve batting -
Ajay Jadeja, Vijay Bharadwaj and VVS Laxman - just about
passes muster and taking only one wicketkeeper on a three
month tour is foolhardy. The pressure on young MSK Prasad
is going to be too much and this will in turn affect
his overall performance. All in all, it would have been
better if the side had a third spinner and a second
wicketkeeper at the expense of one of the extra batsmen
and a seam bowler.
Under the circumstances, the best the Indians can hope for
against a pretty strong Australian outfit - particularly
formidable at home - is that the batsmen come off every
time to at least ensure a draw for the bowling does not
inspire confidence.
The squad: Sachin Tendulkar (captain), Saurav Ganguly
(vice captain), Ajay Jadeja, S.Ramesh, VVS Laxman, Devang
Gandhi, Vijay Bharadwaj, Rahul Dravid, J.Srinath, Venkatesh
Prasad, D.Mohanty, A.Agarkar, T.Kumaran, MSK Prasad,
A.Kumble and Harbhajan Singh. Coach: Kapil Dev.